Sunday, 22 November 2026
Trending
ExplainersHistory

November 22 in New Hampshire History: A 79-Cent Ping-Pong Ball Tests the State’s New Annulment Law

Photograph by Carol M. Highsmith, 2017. Library of Congress.
Independent New Hampshire Journalism · Northfield, NH
This Day in New Hampshire History · November 22
November 22 in New Hampshire History: A 79-Cent Ping-Pong Ball Tests the State’s New Annulment Law

The state Supreme Court opened record annulment to a man convicted before the 1973 criminal code, a Farmington-born vice president died inside the U.S. Capitol, and Dartmouth College came to a stop after Dallas.

Listen to this article · 8 min

Audio edition (8:23): a synthetic voice reads the article. The images, fact check and sources are on this page.

A ping-pong ball worth 79 cents reached the New Hampshire Supreme Court in 1974, and the opinion that came back opened the state’s new record-annulment law to people convicted before it took effect. November 22 carries other New Hampshire marks too: a Farmington farm boy who rose to the vice presidency and died at the Capitol, a State House memorial that began with a family’s offer, a Nashua mayor who became governor, and a college that went quiet on the day a president was killed.

The court that would not punish a fine harder than a jail term

Related coverage: GSR’s The Eraser That Does Not Erase covers how annulment works for dismissed cases under current law, a different question from the 1971 conviction below. In His Own Words: What John F. Kennedy Told New Hampshire collects his 1960 campaign speeches in the state, background for the 1963 entry.

On September 27, 1971, an 18-year-old pleaded guilty in Keene District Court to willfully concealing a ping-pong ball valued at 79 cents. The court fined him $25 and suspended $10 of it. The court refers to him, by agreement, as John Doe.

New Hampshire’s new criminal code took effect on November 1, 1973. One of its sections, RSA 651:5, let a person with a qualifying record ask the court to annul the conviction. Doe applied on January 28, 1974. The county attorney and the state probation officer both agreed. The attorney general’s office doubted that the law reached a conviction entered before the code existed, and the district court sent the question to the Supreme Court without ruling.

The state pressed two more arguments. A fine, it said, was not one of the sentences the annulment section listed, so Doe could not use it at all. In a supplemental brief, it argued that letting judges annul records invaded the governor’s pardon power under Part II, Article 52 of the state constitution.

In an opinion by Justice Griffith dated November 22, 1974, the court ruled for Doe. It found nothing in the statute denying its benefit to people convicted before November 1, 1973. On the fine, the court conceded that a literal reading favored the state and that the argument would have been hard to answer on the day Doe applied. By late 1974, though, three years had run since his sentence, which brought him under the section for offenders under 21 who had been sentenced to imprisonment. The court read a fine as a smaller penalty contained within a jail sentence, so it qualified too. Any other reading, it said, would leave a defendant who drew the lighter sentence worse off than one sent to jail.

The court also quoted Senator Nixon, who in 1971 urged the Senate to adopt the annulment sections and spoke of giving an offender “the chance to start anew without this stigma in his records.” On the pardon question, the court drew a line: a pardon wipes out the consequences of a conviction but leaves the record, while annulment acts on the public record and falls within the legislature’s power to give the courts. The case was remanded. All justices concurred. The citation is Doe v. State, 114 N.H. 714 (1974).

For how annulment works for a dismissed case under current law, see the GSR report The Eraser That Does Not Erase.

The Natick Shoemaker from Farmington dies at the Capitol

Henry Wilson was born Jeremiah Jones Colbath in Farmington on February 16, 1812, according to the University of Virginia’s Miller Center. When he was 10, his father bound him to a nearby farmer as an apprentice. He changed his name at 21, left New Hampshire for Natick, Massachusetts, learned the shoemaker’s trade and eventually ran a shoe factory of his own.

The Massachusetts legislature elected him to the U.S. Senate in 1855. A U.S. Senate biography says Wilson drafted the original version of the District of Columbia emancipation act passed in April 1862 and introduced the first civil rights bill after the war, in 1865. In the 1872 campaign, Republicans billed Grant and Wilson as the “Galena Tanner” and the “Natick Shoemaker.” Wilson took office as vice president in 1873.

Wilson died on November 22, 1875. A Senate art record says he died in the Vice President’s Room of the Capitol. In 1885 the Senate commissioned a marble bust of him from Daniel Chester French, a work the Senate biography calls the beginning of its Vice Presidential Bust Collection.

Full-length studio portrait of Henry Wilson standing beside a column and a carved armchair, wearing a long dark coat.
Henry Wilson, circa 1861. Carte de visite of the Farmington-born senator from Massachusetts, Mathew B. Brady, photographer; Edward Anthony, contributor. Credit: Library of Congress, World Digital Library collection; no known restrictions.

A widow and a daughter offer the state a statue

Commodore George Hamilton Perkins, a Hopkinton native, died in Boston on October 28, 1899. Twenty-five days later, on November 22, Isabel Weld Anderson of Brookline, Massachusetts, acting for her mother, Anna Weld Perkins, and herself, offered the State of New Hampshire a statue of her father through Gov. Frank West Rollins. That account comes from the official proceedings the state printed in 1903.

The governor and council thanked the family and reserved a site on the Capitol grounds for the memorial. Daniel Chester French, a Chester native, sculpted the 7.5-foot bronze. Henry Bacon designed the granite setting, 42 feet long. The memorial was dedicated on April 25, 1902, before more than 10,000 people, with a Navy commander standing in for President Theodore Roosevelt. Its inscription credits Perkins, commanding the Chickasaw at Mobile Bay, with forcing the surrender of the Tennessee.

Bronze statue of a naval officer in dress uniform standing in a white stone niche carved with winged figures, in front of a granite government building.
The Perkins memorial, Concord. Daniel Chester French’s statue of Commodore George Hamilton Perkins on the State House grounds, dedicated April 25, 1902. Photograph by Carol M. Highsmith, 2017. Credit: Library of Congress, Carol M. Highsmith Archive; no known restrictions on publication.

Hugh Gregg is born in Nashua

Hugh Gregg was born in Nashua on November 22, 1917, according to the National Governors Association. He attended Phillips Exeter Academy, graduated from Yale in 1939 and earned a Harvard law degree in 1942. His service in World War II and Korea was as an Army Counterintelligence Corps special agent.

Gregg won a seat as alderman-at-large in 1947 and served as mayor of Nashua in 1950. Voters elected him governor in 1952, and he served from January 1, 1953, to January 6, 1955. He ran for governor three more times without winning. He later founded the Library and Archives of New Hampshire Political Tradition and stood up for the state’s first-in-the-nation primary. He died on September 24, 2003.

Hanover goes silent

President John F. Kennedy was assassinated in Dallas on November 22, 1963, a Friday. Dartmouth College, with 3,000 students in residence, reacted within hours, according to the December 1963 Dartmouth Alumni Magazine. President Dickey of Dartmouth and President Goheen of Princeton jointly called off the next day’s Dartmouth-Princeton football game, later moved to November 30. Every public event on the calendar for the next three days was scrapped, a Friday night musical program at Hopkins Center among them.

On Sunday, November 24, a memorial service drew hundreds of students into Rollins Chapel. Monday, the national day of mourning, brought no classes and closed offices. Palaeopitus, writing for the undergraduates, mailed condolences to the president’s widow along with a $250 gift to the National Association of Mental Health. The magazine said the college, while in session, came “to a virtual standstill.”

GSR collected Kennedy’s 1960 New Hampshire campaign speeches in In His Own Words: What John F. Kennedy Told New Hampshire.

Your Turn

Tell us. Do you have a family story, letter or photograph from Hanover, Concord or Nashua tied to any of these dates? Did an annulment change a door that had been closed to you or someone you know? Write to granitestatereport@gmail.com or call (603) 931-9264. We read everything and will ask before quoting anyone.

Fact check

#ClaimStatusSource
1Doe v. State, 114 N.H. 714, was decided November 22, 1974; opinion by Justice Griffith; all concurred; remandedVERIFIEDCourtListener opinion record and text, Doe v. State, 114 N.H. 714, 328 A.2d 784 (date filed 1974-11-22)
2Guilty plea Sept. 27, 1971, Keene District Court, concealment of a 79-cent ping-pong ball under RSA 582:15; fined $25 with $10 suspended; defendant was 18VERIFIEDDoe v. State opinion text
3Criminal code, including RSA 651:5, effective Nov. 1, 1973; application filed Jan. 28, 1974; county attorney and probation officer assented; attorney general doubted; question transferred without rulingVERIFIEDDoe v. State opinion text
4Court held annulment available for pre-code convictions; conceded literal reading favored the State on fines, but granted relief because three years had passed under RSA 651:5 III, treating a fine as included in imprisonment; annulment does not infringe pardon power (Pt. II, Art. 52)VERIFIEDDoe v. State opinion text
5Senator Nixon quote from N.H. Senate Journal 1643 (1971), as quoted by the courtATTRIBUTEDQuoted within the Doe v. State opinion; Senate Journal not opened directly
6Henry Wilson born Jeremiah Jones Colbath in Farmington, N.H., Feb. 16, 1812; changed name at 21; apprenticed at 10; shoemaker in NatickVERIFIEDMiller Center, University of Virginia, Henry Wilson (1873–1875)
7Wilson elected to Senate by Massachusetts legislature 1855; DC emancipation act (April 1862) originally written by him; first postwar civil rights bill 1865; billed as the “Natick Shoemaker” in the 1872 campaign; took office 1873; died Nov. 22, 1875VERIFIEDU.S. Senate, Henry Wilson: A Featured Biography; Miller Center (ticket and nickname)
8Wilson died in the Vice President’s Room; Senate commissioned French bust in 1885, which the Senate featured biography calls the beginning of the Vice Presidential Bust CollectionATTRIBUTEDU.S. Senate bust record (22.00018.000) for the room and commission; the “beginning” characterization is the featured biography’s, and the bust record describes the 1886 set of five busts as the collection’s initial core
9Perkins born in Hopkinton, died in Boston Oct. 28, 1899; on Nov. 22, 1899 Isabel Weld Anderson tendered the statue through Gov. Frank West RollinsVERIFIEDOfficial Proceedings at the Dedication of the Statue of Commodore George Hamilton Perkins (1903), pp. 3 and inscription
10Governor and council expressed appreciation and set apart Capitol grounds; French (born Chester, N.H.) sculptor; Bacon architect; statue 7.5 ft; structure 42 ft long; dedicated April 25, 1902; over 10,000 present; Cowles represented RooseveltVERIFIEDOfficial Proceedings (1903), pp. 3–6. The date of the council action is not stated; the article does not date it
11Inscription: Perkins commanded the Chickasaw at Mobile Bay and compelled the surrender of the TennesseeVERIFIEDMemorial inscription as transcribed in Official Proceedings (1903)
12Hugh Gregg born Nashua Nov. 22, 1917; Exeter, Yale 1939, Harvard law 1942; Army CIC in WWII and Korea; alderman 1947; mayor 1950; elected 1952; term Jan. 1, 1953–Jan. 6, 1955; three later bids; founded Library and Archives of N.H. Political Tradition; died Sept. 24, 2003VERIFIEDNational Governors Association, Gov. Hugh Gregg
13Kennedy assassinated in Dallas on Nov. 22, 1963 (a Friday)VERIFIEDNHPR/NPR, Walter Cronkite on the Assassination of John F. Kennedy; weekday computed
14Dartmouth: 3,000 students in residence; Dickey and Goheen canceled next day’s game, moved to Nov. 30; events canceled three days incl. Hopkins Center program; Rollins Chapel service Nov. 24; classes off Monday; Palaeopitus letter and $250VERIFIEDDartmouth Alumni Magazine, “The College,” December 1963
Have a document, a tip, or a correction?
Write to the editor. Confidentiality is respected where possible.
granitestatereport@gmail.com
Sources.

Primary and official: Doe v. State, 114 N.H. 714, 328 A.2d 784 (1974), opinion text via CourtListener (courtlistener.com/opinion/1517639/doe-v-state/). Official Proceedings at the Dedication of the Statue of Commodore George Hamilton Perkins (Concord, 1903), Internet Archive. U.S. Senate, Henry Wilson: A Featured Biography and Henry Wilson bust record. National Governors Association, Gov. Hugh Gregg. “The College,” Dartmouth Alumni Magazine, December 1963. Library of Congress, Carol M. Highsmith Archive, item 2017883955; Library of Congress, World Digital Library collection (original held by the National Library of Brazil), item 2021669521.

Secondary: Miller Center, University of Virginia, Henry Wilson (1873–1875). NHPR/NPR, Walter Cronkite on the Assassination of John F. Kennedy.

Related GSR coverage: The Eraser That Does Not Erase; In His Own Words: What John F. Kennedy Told New Hampshire.

Editor’s note. This edition draws on the New Hampshire Supreme Court’s opinion in Doe v. State (1974), the State of New Hampshire’s 1903 official proceedings for the Perkins statue, the U.S. Senate, the National Governors Association, the University of Virginia’s Miller Center, the Dartmouth Alumni Magazine of December 1963, NHPR, and the Library of Congress.

Corrections: Granite State Report corrects verified errors promptly and appends a dated note identifying what changed and when. The corrections policy and the corrections register are public, and correction notes are never removed.

Granite State Report · Northfield, New Hampshire · granitestatereport.com
Board