Independent New Hampshire Journalism · Northfield, NHA chain with 29 daily papers plans to rebuild itself around software and sites that sell products. This one-person newsroom uses the same kind of software for one job: reading the public record.
On Nov. 6, the people who run a 169-year-old newspaper company put their staff on a video call and described the future. Nieman Lab obtained audio of the meeting and published its account on Nov. 18. By that account, McClatchy’s chief executive, Tony Hunter, told employees the company is working to “agentify the entire enterprise.”
The plan has a name, Project Catalyst. Nieman Lab reports that it would rebuild the company’s operations around artificial intelligence, with software agents placed inside daily work and repeated tasks moved off people. It arrives with four new lifestyle websites that sell consumer products, and two months after McClatchy cut more than 90 journalists.
I run a newsroom that uses the same class of software, so I have no standing to blame the machine. My quarrel is with where McClatchy is aiming it, and with who is left to answer when it gets something wrong. On both counts, Granite State Report made the opposite bet.
Related coverage. Three examples of the records-first work this piece describes: A New Hampshire House Recount Costs $10. Sixteen Candidates Asked for One., on the recount fee; Fourteen Months to Answer a Five-Day Law, on a Right-to-Know delay; and The Attorney General’s Right-to-Know Manual Leaves Out the Part Where You Get the Records, on the state’s own guidance.
Disclosure. I founded, own and edit Granite State Report, so this is an argument about my own shop and you should weigh it that way. It was produced under the method published on How This Is Made, which includes software assistance from large language models. I checked every claim against the sources listed below, and I answer for all of it.
What McClatchy told its own people
Everything I know about the meeting comes from Nieman Lab reporter Mark Keierleber’s story. He writes that the town hall was held online, was described to staff as off the record, and reached him as an audio recording. I have not heard the audio. Treat what follows as his reporting, credited to him.
McClatchy owns 29 daily newspapers in 14 states, among them the Miami Herald, The Kansas City Star and The Sacramento Bee. A New Jersey hedge fund, Chatham Asset Management, has owned the company since 2020.
Nieman Lab reports that executives told employees local journalism is no longer a workable business and that the company survives only by rebuilding around AI. Chief operating officer Jeff Dorsey described Project Catalyst as automating both core and non-core functions and cutting work that no longer adds value. The story counts about a dozen AI tools already in use at McClatchy, for jobs that run from spotting trends and writing to predicting which subscribers will cancel.
Then there are the new sites: Crime Hunter, Saltwater South, Camp & Country and Student Section. Nieman Lab reports all four run on Trend Hunter, a company McClatchy bought in 2024 that uses AI to find consumer trends and sell goods. One product the story cites is a $249 red light therapy cap. A newly hired video executive, Ariel Storch, told staff the company makes entertainment and that information comes along as a byproduct.
The executives also said things in their own defense, and those belong here. Hunter said the company is not abandoning its standards. Rajiv Pant, the chief product and engineering officer, said people stay in control of AI-assisted work. A person close to the decisions told The New York Times that the September layoffs were about business performance and not about AI. All three statements come from the same Nieman Lab story, which also says McClatchy did not answer its requests for comment.
I did not ask McClatchy for comment before writing this. It is commentary on what the company’s executives told their own staff, as Nieman Lab reported it, and it accuses no one of wrongdoing. If McClatchy answers, GSR will publish what it says.
The readers already voted
The most useful numbers in the story came from the executives themselves. Over the past year, they told staff, McClatchy’s papers lost 17 percent of their paid digital subscribers. Unique visitors fell 39 percent.
McClatchy has company. Northwestern University’s Medill School released its State of Local News report on Oct. 13. It counted 238 counties it classifies as news deserts, 26 more than a year earlier and the largest one-year rise in at least five years. Newspapers are closing at about three a week. The same release counted 75 local news startups launched in the past year.
McClatchy’s leadership reads numbers like these as proof that reporting no longer pays. I read them as what happens after the reporters are gone. Kristine Sherred, who chairs the Washington State NewsGuild and covers food for McClatchy’s News Tribune in Tacoma, told Nieman Lab that Tacoma no longer has a city reporter. A reader who cannot find city hall in the paper has little reason to keep paying for the paper.
I cannot prove the cuts caused the losses. The executives cannot prove the reverse. What the record shows is the order of events: the layoffs came in September, and the town hall describing Project Catalyst came in November.
Yes, this newsroom uses the machine
Granite State Report is one person. The About page says so. One person cannot read every bill, every set of minutes and every budget line in a state with 400 House members, so I use software to help, and the site says that too.

The method page, How This Is Made, lists where: research, building and formatting the fact-check table, checking drafts against the style rules, and editorial review. It also states the limit in a sentence I wrote to be held to: “No claim reaches publication because a machine produced it.” GSR’s constitution, signed in October, puts the same rule in Article XIII. Tools are named in public, a tool is never a source, and the editor answers for an error however it got in.
So McClatchy and I want the same thing from the software, which is hours. Where we part is what the hours are for. In McClatchy’s account, as Nieman Lab reports it, they are for cash to keep the business running and for sites built to sell things. Here they go to more records.
What software cannot fetch
A language model reads what already exists somewhere it can reach. The New Hampshire records worth reading mostly do not. They sit in a clerk’s cabinet or on an agency server until a person asks for them under RSA 91-A, the Right-to-Know Law, and keeps asking.
Here is one from this week. InDepthNH reported on Nov. 18 that 499 New Hampshire police officers had not completed a required fitness test due Dec. 31, according to the director of the Police Standards and Training Council, and that officers who miss the deadline are suspended from duty on Jan. 1. The story names no departments. Which towns stand to lose officers is a question with an answer, and the answer is in records that someone has to request, one agency at a time. No model can summarize a list nobody has pried loose.
That work is the whole of what GSR does. The mission statement says it in one line: “We answer to readers, never to the people we cover.” The site also hands readers the same tools, free: a 91-A Request Builder, the Granite State Archive of public documents, and a Noncompliance List. A resident who never reads another word I write can still use them to get a record out of town hall.
Follow the money, including mine
McClatchy’s chief financial officer, Joe Settineri, told staff the company carries a sizable debt and that most of its profit is committed to paying it down, Nieman Lab reports. I do not envy him. When debt service comes first, every reporter is a cost and every product page is a hope.
GSR’s money rules are public, and readers can check me against them. The About page says the site is owned and operated by its editor, is backed by no corporation, party, political action committee or candidate, and carries no advertising inside its reporting. Paid local listings appear on the Community Board and are labeled. The home page promises no paywall on the reporting. The constitution adds the rule that matters most when someone pays for a records request: “Payment buys reporting work. It never buys a conclusion, a preview, or a veto.” It also requires a public accounting of reader support at the end of each year.
None of that makes GSR a business that has proved itself. McClatchy has 29 dailies. I have a desk in Northfield. I have not shown that records-first reporting pays its own way, and nobody should take my word that it will. What I can show is the rulebook, in public, and the work.
The test
Both of these are bets, and both can be checked. Watch whether Tacoma gets a city reporter back. Watch whether McClatchy’s subscriber numbers turn once the agents are running. Then hold this newsroom to the table below, where every claim in this piece is listed with its source, and to the corrections register, where GSR’s corrections are logged.
McClatchy’s plan, as its own executives described it, points the software at what sells. Mine points it at what is on file at town hall. One of these bets is wrong, and readers will be the ones to say which.
— Dexter Dow, Granite State Report
Your Turn
You tell me: What is one record from your town or school district that you have never been able to get? Send it to granitestatereport@gmail.com, or vote and comment at Your Voice.
Fact check
| # | Claim | Status | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | McClatchy held a staff town hall on Nov. 6, 2026; it was online and described as off the record; Nieman Lab obtained audio and published Nov. 18. | ATTRIBUTED | Nieman Lab, Mark Keierleber, Nov. 18, 2026. GSR has not heard the audio. |
| 2 | CEO Tony Hunter described an effort to “agentify the entire enterprise.” | ATTRIBUTED | Nieman Lab, quoting the audio. |
| 3 | Project Catalyst would rebuild operations around AI, with agents in daily work and repeated tasks moved off people; COO Jeff Dorsey said it automates core and non-core functions. | ATTRIBUTED | Nieman Lab. |
| 4 | McClatchy is 169 years old, owns 29 daily newspapers in 14 states, and has been owned since 2020 by Chatham Asset Management, a New Jersey hedge fund. | ATTRIBUTED | Nieman Lab. |
| 5 | McClatchy cut more than 90 journalists in September 2026. | ATTRIBUTED | Nieman Lab. |
| 6 | Executives told employees local journalism is no longer a workable business model. | ATTRIBUTED | Nieman Lab’s account of the meeting. |
| 7 | About a dozen AI tools are in use, including for trend detection, writing and churn prediction. | ATTRIBUTED | Nieman Lab. |
| 8 | Four lifestyle sites (Crime Hunter, Saltwater South, Camp & Country, Student Section) run on Trend Hunter, acquired in 2024; a $249 red light therapy cap is among products cited. | ATTRIBUTED | Nieman Lab. |
| 9 | Ariel Storch told staff the company makes entertainment, with information as a byproduct. | ATTRIBUTED | Nieman Lab, paraphrased. |
| 10 | Hunter said the company is not abandoning its standards; Rajiv Pant said people remain in control of AI-assisted work; a person close to the decisions told The New York Times the layoffs were about business performance; McClatchy did not answer Nieman Lab’s requests for comment. | ATTRIBUTED | Nieman Lab. |
| 11 | Paid digital subscribers fell 17 percent and unique visitors 39 percent in a year. | ATTRIBUTED | McClatchy executives, as reported by Nieman Lab. |
| 12 | Medill counted 238 news-desert counties, up 26 in a year, the largest one-year rise in at least five years; about three newspaper closures a week; 75 startups in the past year. | ATTRIBUTED | Medill’s Oct. 13, 2026 release, as published by Editor & Publisher. |
| 13 | Kristine Sherred chairs the Washington State NewsGuild, reports for The News Tribune, and said Tacoma no longer has a city reporter. | ATTRIBUTED | Nieman Lab. |
| 14 | CFO Joe Settineri said the company has sizable debt and most profit goes to paying it down. | ATTRIBUTED | Nieman Lab. |
| 15 | GSR is a one-person newsroom, owned and operated by its editor, with no advertising inside its reporting and labeled paid listings on the Community Board only. | VERIFIED | GSR About page, read Nov. 19, 2026. |
| 16 | GSR uses software, including large language models, in research, the fact-check table, style checks and editorial review; the quoted sentence appears on the page. | VERIFIED | GSR How This Is Made, v1.2. |
| 17 | Article XIII of the GSR constitution: tools are named, no tool is a source, the editor answers for errors. The quoted payment rule and the year-end accounting rule are in Articles V and XI. | VERIFIED | GSR constitution, signed Oct. 15, 2026. |
| 18 | The mission statement line quoted; the home page’s no-paywall promise; the three reader tools named. | VERIFIED | GSR mission page and home page, read Nov. 19, 2026. |
| 19 | 499 officers had not completed the fitness test due Dec. 31; suspensions begin Jan. 1; the story names no departments. | ATTRIBUTED | InDepthNH, Damien Fisher, Nov. 18, 2026, citing the Police Standards and Training Council director. |
| 20 | The New Hampshire House has 400 members. | VERIFIED | NHPR, Nov. 17, 2026 (“400-member New Hampshire House”). |
Reach the editor directly. Confidentiality respected where possible.
granitestatereport@gmail.com · 603-931-9264
Editor’s note. This is a signed opinion piece. Its account of the McClatchy meeting rests on Nieman Lab’s reporting; GSR has not heard the recording, and those rows are marked ATTRIBUTED in the fact-check table. The Medill figures are taken from Medill’s release, not from the full report. Claims about GSR were checked against GSR’s published pages. The audio and video editions use a synthetic voice. Corrections: Granite State Report corrects verified errors promptly and appends a note identifying what changed and when.

