Independent New Hampshire Journalism · Northfield, NHThe Rev. Dr. Guy Collins of Hanover answered an atheist’s column about the camel, the needle and artificial intelligence. He agrees about wealth. He pushes back on work.
On November 9 I published a column about money, belief and artificial intelligence. I wrote it as an atheist who keeps Christian rules, and it leaned on the verse about a camel and the eye of a needle. A verse belongs to the people who believe it, so I asked the Episcopal Church of New Hampshire to answer three questions on the record.
The diocese’s bishop, Rob Hirschfeld, was not available. His office said his time is limited through the end of his episcopate in March 2027. His executive assistant, Kathy Traynor, pointed me instead to the Rev. Dr. Guy Collins, rector of St. Thomas Church in Hanover and Episcopal chaplain to Dartmouth College. Collins answered in writing. He speaks here for himself, not for the diocese.
Related coverage: this piece follows My Religion Says Don’t Take the Money. I’m an Atheist. I Flinch Anyway. The author wrote that column and is an atheist.
The camel and the needle
I asked how a New Hampshire reader should understand the verse when it comes to owning wealth rather than simply having money. Collins answered with history. In the ancient world, he wrote, wealth was often seen as a barrier to living the good life. The medieval church saw it as a major barrier to living a faithful life. People who put their trust in wealth rather than God risked forgetting the commandments to love their neighbor and give alms to the needy, and medieval Christians took the camel verse seriously. As society grew wealthier, he wrote, the church worked for just and equitable access to that wealth.
He shares the column’s worry that a small number of very rich people will take the gains of the AI build-out while many people will not. Wealth, he wrote, “is not always an unmerited good.” It can create division, inequity and a lack of accountability. Look at how the super-wealthy behave, he wrote, and you see how “enormous wealth can be anti-democratic.”
His prescription is a public conversation. A society, he wrote, needs to talk about how to manage wealth so it does not gather in the hands of an elite who think themselves above the democratic process.
The atheist who keeps the rules
My third question asked what he would say to someone who keeps the commandments without the belief. Collins wrote that the faithful have a lot in common with atheists who are determined to live compassionate, kind and generous lives.
He has written a book on the subject. Faithful Doubt: The Wisdom of Uncertainty argues that atheists have a lot to teach Christians. In his pastoral work, he wrote, much of what atheists reject turns out to be close to what Christians reject about certain models of God. He described theology as the work of testing those models: are they idols “that hold us in thrall,” or visions that draw people into a community of faith, hope and love?
He wants atheists, agnostics and people of faith to look again at what counts as virtue, and to work together toward more equal societies.
The work
The column said I find it hard to mourn “the end of jobs that were never worth a whole human life.” Collins sent a follow-up that pushes on that line.
Christians have long believed work is part of who we are, he wrote. St. Benedict’s Rule told monks to give their time to work and treated it as just as important as the regular cycle of shared prayer. What distresses him is that society lost sight of “the moral, ethical and spiritual value of work,” and he dates that loss back well over a hundred years.
As artificial intelligence changes society, he wrote, everyone has a duty to make sure people have work that rewards them spiritually as well as financially. People whose labor machines replace should be given new and meaningful ways to share their labor. He sees every person as gifted, and in Christian terms created, to labor. Society, he wrote, has to stop treating the reward for work as only money and count a wider set of social goods, for workers and for the web of relationships around them.
He would move the question. Instead of asking only who gets paid for what, he wrote, ask what kind of society would be a “good and worthwhile society.”
Where that leaves the question
The column and the answer agree on the first part. Wealth gathered in a few hands is a danger, and artificial intelligence makes the danger larger.
They part on the second. The column treats the end of paid work as a release and asks who will own the machine. Collins treats work as part of a person’s worth and asks what a good society would give people to do once the machine does the paid part. Neither answer settles who holds the machine. Both leave New Hampshire with the question the column asked.
Readers who believe, readers who don’t, and readers somewhere in between can answer below. I will read every reply.
— Dexter Dow, Granite State Report
Your Turn
Poll: If machines take over much of paid work, how should the people they replace share in what the machines produce?
A) A public dividend, like Alaska’s · B) Ownership stakes in the companies · C) New public work that pays · D) They shouldn’t
Short survey: (1) What town do you live in? (2) Has artificial intelligence changed your job or a family member’s job yet? (3) If a machine could do your paid work tomorrow, what work would you still want to do? (4) Does your faith, or your lack of one, shape how you think about wealth? Answer as much as you like. (5) May GSR contact you to follow up, and may we use your name? Send answers to granitestatereport@gmail.com. GSR keeps survey answers only for its reporting, does not sell them, and deletes contact details on request.
Talk about it: Is work valuable for its own sake, or only for what it pays? And: can a person keep a religion’s rules without believing its God, and does it matter if they do?
Fact check
| # | Claim | Status | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | GSR published the column on Nov. 9, 2026; it cites the camel-and-needle verse and contains the line about jobs “never worth a whole human life.” | VERIFIED | GSR, Nov. 9, 2026 |
| 2 | Bishop Hirschfeld was not available, with limited availability through the end of his episcopate in March 2027; Kathy Traynor is executive assistant to the bishop and referred GSR to Collins. | ATTRIBUTED | Kathy Traynor, Episcopal Church of New Hampshire, emails to GSR, Nov. 10 and Nov. 11, 2026 |
| 3 | Collins is rector of St. Thomas Church, Hanover, and Episcopal chaplain to Dartmouth College; he speaks for himself. | VERIFIED | Lutterworth Press author note; Collins confirmed identification by email, Nov. 19, 2026 |
| 4 | Collins wrote Faithful Doubt: The Wisdom of Uncertainty. | VERIFIED | Lutterworth Press |
| 5 | Collins’s views on wealth in the ancient and medieval church, wealth as anti-democratic, atheists and models of God, and virtue. | ATTRIBUTED | Guy Collins, written reply to GSR, Nov. 16, 2026 |
| 6 | Collins’s views on work, St. Benedict’s Rule, replaced labor and a “good and worthwhile society.” | ATTRIBUTED | Guy Collins, written reply to GSR, Nov. 19, 2026 |
Reach the editor directly, with confidentiality respected where possible.
granitestatereport@gmail.com · (603) 931-9264
Editor’s note. Collins’s words are quoted or paraphrased from his two written replies; he confirmed how he is identified. GSR sent the same questions to the diocese first; its bishop was not available, his office said. The author wrote the column this piece follows and is an atheist. Corrections: Granite State Report corrects verified errors promptly and appends a note identifying what changed and when.

