Monday, 16 November 2026
Trending
CourtsRight to KnowSpecial Series

The Eraser That Does Not Erase

The New Hampshire State House in Concord. Photo: Warren LeMay via Wikimedia Commons, CC0. Cropped.
Independent New Hampshire Journalism · Northfield, NH
Punished First · Part 6 of 8
The Eraser That Does Not Erase

New Hampshire law says a dismissed case shall be annulled. Every official set of instructions I read says to file a petition, and the courts say they cannot count how many people do.

Listen to this article · 9 min

In August I told readers of this site that if their case ended in a dismissal or an acquittal on or after Jan. 1, 2019, the record had already been annulled, free, with no petition, whether anyone told them or not. I wrote that because the statute reads that way. I cannot support it as a description of what happens, and this piece explains why.

The sentence in question is RSA 651:5, II-a. It says a person whose arrest ended in a finding of not guilty on all charges, or whose case was dismissed or not prosecuted, shall have the arrest record and court record annulled, 30 days after the finding if nobody appeals. The paragraph does not mention a petition.

Everything built around that sentence does. The Judicial Branch publishes a petition form for these cases. The State Police tell people the process begins with a petition. And in 2026 the Legislature passed a law about the filing fee for petitions brought under that same paragraph. I looked for a published count of how many non-conviction records have been annulled since 2019 and located none. The courts told lawmakers why: they cannot reliably track it.

Disclosure: The editor of Granite State Report has been named in New Hampshire police records and has requested those records under RSA 91-A. Those matters are not part of this series.

Related coverage: This is Part 6 of Punished First. It follows up on GSR’s Aug. 27 guide, How to Annul a Criminal Record in New Hampshire, and Why the Police File Never Goes Away, which covers waiting periods, fees and what police keep. Part 1, The Accusation Is the Sentence, makes the series argument. Part 2, The Report, covers the arrest record. Part 3, The Booking, covers fingerprints and photographs. Part 4, The Hearing, covers bail conditions. Part 5, The Court File, covers who can read the case. This piece reports only what is new.

What the statute says

The annulment law has two tracks for people who were never convicted. For a case that ended before 2019, paragraph II says the person may petition. For a case that ended on or after Jan. 1, 2019, paragraph II-a drops the word petition and says shall.

RSA 651:5, II-a(a). For an offense disposed of on or after Jan. 1, 2019, a person whose arrest resulted in a finding of not guilty on all charges, or whose case was dismissed or not prosecuted, shall have the arrest record and court record annulled: 30 days after the finding if no appeal is taken, or when an appeal affirming a dismissal is finally decided. Read RSA 651:5 →

The paragraph names no one who has to do the annulling. It gives the clerk no instruction, sets no deadline for the court to act, and requires no notice to the person. It says what shall be true 30 days after a case ends and stops.

What the instructions say

The Judicial Branch’s annulment page for the Circuit Court lists five forms. One is numbered 3056-DSe and titled Petition of Eligibility for Annulment of Record Non-Conviction. A forms publisher that carries it gives the full title as covering offenses resolved Jan. 1, 2019, or later, and a release date of Aug. 6, 2019. That is a petition form for exactly the cases paragraph II-a covers.

The State Police page on annulments opens by saying the process begins by filing a Petition to Annul with the court. It tells people to pull their full record first. It says that after the court approves a petition, a dismissed, dropped or not-guilty charge comes off the state criminal history in one to two business days. Nothing on the page says any record is annulled without a petition.

The court rule on annulments, Rule 31 of the Rules of Criminal Procedure, describes an application the person files and signs under oath. It says the same procedure may be used for an arrest that ended in a dismissal, a dropped charge or a not-guilty finding, and that granting it is within the court’s discretion. It has no provision for the court to act on its own.

An outside reader reached the same conclusion. The Collateral Consequences Resource Center, a national nonprofit that tracks record-clearing law, describes paragraph II-a this way: the person shall have the records annulled “upon filing of a petition.”

Table titled One sentence, four readings. RSA 651:5, II-a: the record shall be annulled 30 days after the case ends; petition not mentioned. Judicial Branch forms: form 3056-DSe, Petition of Eligibility for Annulment of Record Non-Conviction; petition yes. State Police: the process begins by filing a Petition to Annul; petition yes. 2026 law, Chapter 105: no filing fee for any petition to annul brought under II-a(a), effective Jan. 1, 2027; petition yes.
What four official sources say about annulling a case that ended without a conviction. Chart: Granite State Report. Sources: RSA 651:5; N.H. Judicial Branch annulment forms; N.H. State Police; 2026 Laws, Chapter 105.

What the Legislature did about it in 2026

Senate Bill 512 settles how the people who write the law read it. As introduced, the bill would have made courts waive the filing fee for a petitioner who showed a not-guilty finding, a dismissal or a decision not to prosecute. As passed, it adds one sentence to paragraph II-a: “No filing fee shall be charged for any petition to annul brought under subparagraph II-a(a).” The governor approved it on May 28, 2026, as Chapter 105. It takes effect Jan. 1, 2027.

A paragraph that annulled records by itself would have no petitions to exempt. The Legislature has now written the petition into the one paragraph that did not have it.

The bill’s fiscal note is the closest thing to data I found. The Judicial Branch told the Legislature’s budget office that the filing fee is $125 and that it collected $221,425 in annulment filing fees in calendar year 2024. It assumed that 10 to 40 percent of annulment petitions involve charges that ended without a conviction, and estimated the lost revenue at more than $10,000 and less than $100,000 a year.

Run the arithmetic and $221,425 is the equivalent of about 1,771 filings at $125 each. Ten to 40 percent of that is roughly 177 to 709. Those are my divisions, not counts; the note gives no number of petitions, and waived fees would not show up in it. But the direction is plain. By the courts’ own assumption, people who were never convicted have been paying $125 to clear their records, and for cases since 2019 the statute says those records shall be annulled.

The count that cannot be made

I looked for a published count of annulments, by year or by kind, from the Judicial Branch and from the State Police. I located none.

The fiscal note explains the courts’ half of that. The Branch said it could not give a more precise estimate because annulled case information is expunged from its case management system and “cannot be reliably tracked.” The eraser removes the evidence of whether the eraser is working.

The eraser removes the evidence of whether the eraser is working.

That leaves the question in this piece’s headline without a number. New Hampshire reported 36,488 arrests in 2022, the figure Part 1 of this series cited. I have found no public count of how many cases since 2019 ended without a conviction, how many of those people filed a petition, and how many records sit in the State Police file and the court’s public search because nobody told the person a form existed.

What I have not established

I have not established that no court ever annuls a record under paragraph II-a without a petition. A clerk somewhere may do it. What I can say is that no official source I read describes that happening, and four of them describe a petition.

I have not read form 3056-DSe itself. Its number and title come from the Judicial Branch’s forms list, and its full title and release date from a forms publisher. I have not established how often the $125 fee is waived for non-conviction petitions under the current rule, which allows a waiver.

The case for a petition

There are reasons a court would want one. Paragraph II-a applies only when every charge from an arrest ended without a conviction, and a clerk has to check that. An arrest can produce cases in two courts. The State Police, the arresting agency and the prosecutor all have to be told, and a petition names them. A system that annulled the wrong record, or half of one, would do its own damage.

Those are arguments for a careful process. They do not explain why the burden of starting it falls on the person the state failed to convict, or why that person is not told.

What would fix it

  • Name who acts. Amend paragraph II-a to say the clerk of the court enters the annulment on the 31st day and notifies the State Police, the arresting agency and the prosecutor, with no petition.
  • Tell the person. Require the court to mail a notice that the record has been annulled, or, if a petition stays, a notice at disposition that the form exists and costs nothing.
  • Count before erasing. Require the Judicial Branch to keep and publish yearly totals of non-conviction dispositions and annulments, stripped of names.
  • Look back. Direct the courts to identify cases since Jan. 1, 2019, that ended without a conviction and were never annulled, and annul them.

If your case ended without a conviction since 2019

  • Do not assume it was annulled. Ask the State Police Criminal Records Unit for your own record and ask for arrests as well as convictions.
  • If the charge is there, ask the clerk of the court that had the case for form 3056-DSe, the non-conviction petition.
  • Ask for a fee waiver. The court rule allows one when a case ended in a dismissal or a not-guilty finding. From Jan. 1, 2027, the statute bars the filing fee.
  • After the court acts, order a fresh record to confirm the entry is gone.

This is reporting, not legal advice. Part 7 follows the copies no court order reaches: background checks, data brokers and the search result.

— Dexter Dow, Granite State Report

Your Turn

Poll: Who should have to start the annulment of a case that ended without a conviction?
A) The court, automatically  ·  B) The prosecutor who dropped it  ·  C) The person, by petition

Survey, six questions: 1) What town were you in? 2) Which court had the case, and in what year did it end? 3) How did it end: dismissal, not guilty, or never prosecuted? 4) Did anyone tell you about annulment when the case ended? 5) Did you file a petition, and were you charged a fee? 6) Does the charge still show on your State Police record or in a court search?

Consent: GSR may contact me about my answers. Nothing I submit is published with my name without my written permission. Responses are kept for 24 months, then deleted or stripped of identifying details.

Discuss: If the law says a record shall be annulled, should anyone have to ask? Should the courts have to count annulments before the records disappear?

You tell me: If your case was dismissed or you were found not guilty since 2019 and the charge is still on your record, send the survey answers to granitestatereport@gmail.com

Fact check

#ClaimStatusSource
1GSR’s Aug. 27, 2026 guide said post-2019 dismissals and acquittals were annulled automatically, free, with no petitionVERIFIEDGSR, Aug. 27, 2026 article text
2RSA 651:5, II-a(a): shall have the arrest record and court record annulled, 30 days after the finding absent an appeal; no petition mentioned; paragraph II says may petitionVERIFIEDRSA 651:5, II and II-a, gc.nh.gov
3Paragraph II-a names no actor, clerk duty, court deadline or notice to the personATTRIBUTEDGSR reading of the paragraph. An absence in the text, not a ruling
4The Judicial Branch’s Circuit Court annulment page lists five forms, including 3056-DSe, Petition of Eligibility for Annulment of Record Non-ConvictionVERIFIEDN.H. Judicial Branch, Annulment, District Division forms page
5Form 3056-DSe covers offenses resolved Jan. 1, 2019, or later and was released Aug. 6, 2019ATTRIBUTEDTemplateRoller listing for the form. GSR has not read the form
6The State Police say the process begins by filing a Petition to Annul; after court approval a dismissed, nol prossed or not-guilty charge is removed in one to two business days; the page does not describe annulment without a petitionVERIFIEDN.H. State Police, Criminal Record Annulments page
7Rule 31 describes a sworn application, applies the same procedure to non-conviction arrests, leaves the decision to the court’s discretion, and allows a fee waiver for not-guilty and dismissed casesATTRIBUTEDN.H. R. Crim. P. 31 as published by CourtRules.net, which notes its text may not reflect the latest amendments
8The Collateral Consequences Resource Center describes II-a annulment as occurring “upon filing of a petition”ATTRIBUTEDCollateral Consequences Resource Center, New Hampshire profile, updated April 13, 2026
9SB 512 as introduced would have required a fee waiver on a showing of a non-conviction; as passed it adds: “No filing fee shall be charged for any petition to annul brought under subparagraph II-a(a)”; approved May 28, 2026, Chapter 105, effective Jan. 1, 2027VERIFIEDSB 512-FN as introduced, New Hampshire Liberty Alliance bill archive; SB 512-FN final version, gc.nh.gov
10Fiscal note: $125 filing fee; $221,425 in annulment filing fees collected in calendar 2024; 10 to 40 percent of petitions assumed to be non-conviction; revenue loss of $10,000 to $100,000 a yearVERIFIEDSB 512-FN fiscal note, Oct. 21, 2025, citing the Judicial Branch
11$221,425 divided by $125 is about 1,771; 10 to 40 percent of that is about 177 to 709VERIFIEDGSR arithmetic on the fiscal note figures, recomputed in code. Not a count of petitions
12The Branch said annulled case information is expunged from its case management system and “cannot be reliably tracked”VERIFIEDSB 512-FN fiscal note
13No published count of annulments was locatedATTRIBUTEDGSR search of Judicial Branch and State Police public pages. An absence of located evidence, not proof none exists
1436,488 arrests reported in New Hampshire in 2022ATTRIBUTEDN.H. Employment Security, Vital Signs 2024, citing FBI data (see Part 1)
Have a document, a tip, or a correction?
Reach the editor directly. Confidentiality respected where possible.
granitestatereport@gmail.com · 603-931-9264

Editor’s note. Sources for this piece are RSA 651:5, the 2026 session law and its fiscal note, the Judicial Branch’s annulment forms page, the State Police annulments page, a published copy of Criminal Rule 31, and the Collateral Consequences Resource Center; see the fact-check table. What the author has not established is listed in the article. No on-the-record interview was conducted for this part. Corrections: Granite State Report corrects verified errors promptly and appends a note identifying what changed and when.

Granite State Report · Northfield, New Hampshire · granitestatereport.com
Next in the series: Part 7, The Afterlife · All eight parts
NH Wire
Board