Independent New Hampshire Journalism · Northfield, NH
Robert Greene’s thirty-fifth law says to wait for the right moment and then move. New Hampshire reopens the governor’s office every two years. A Democrat, a Republican and a senator who changed his mind show what the calendar rewards.
On July 19, 2023, Gov. Chris Sununu said he would not seek a fifth term. Chuck Morse, the former state Senate president, declared for the job within minutes, New Hampshire Public Radio reported. Kelly Ayotte waited five days. On Monday, July 24, she went on “Fox and Friends” and announced she was running. She had been out of office since 2016, when she lost her U.S. Senate seat by one-tenth of a percentage point.
Fifteen months later she was governor-elect. The candidate who moved first was not the Republican on the November ballot.
Robert Greene’s thirty-fifth law says to master the art of timing: watch how power is shifting, be patient, and move when the conditions favor you. New Hampshire gives that law more to work with than most states. It elects its governor every two years and opens a short legal window for candidates each June. The record holds a Democrat who waited six years for a different electorate, a Republican who waited seven for an open seat, and a Republican senator who said yes to a president and then took it back. In all three, the calendar did as much work as the candidate.
The window
Greene’s law, as summaries of the book put it, is about patience and the right moment. Track how power moves. Act when conditions are favorable. Poor timing, the summaries warn, can derail a career.
New Hampshire builds timing into its law. The state constitution says the governor “shall be chosen biennially,” so the top office comes open, at least in theory, every 24 months. And a statute fixes the days on which a candidate has to commit.
That is a window of ten days, give or take, once every two years. Everything before it is positioning. A candidate can announce a year early or a week early, and the law does not care. But the short cycle changes the arithmetic of waiting. In a state with four-year terms, sitting out a race costs four years. Here it costs two years, and the next opening is already on the calendar.
The 2024 race shows how far ahead of the window the real contest runs. Sununu’s announcement came almost a year before the filing period opened. By the end of that July, two Republicans and two Democrats were in, and NHPR reported that the state’s education commissioner, Frank Edelblut, was considering it. The ten days in June were a formality by the time they arrived. The decision that mattered was when to step into a field that was forming in public.
The state applies the same logic to itself. Its presidential primary date is set by a statute that lets one official wait until other states have moved, a fight Granite State Report covered in its account of the Dec. 2 vote for secretary of state.
Six years
Jeanne Shaheen’s first run for the U.S. Senate came in 2002. She was the state’s first elected female governor, and she was unopposed in the Democratic primary. John Sununu had beaten a sitting senator, Bob Smith, in the Republican one. Sununu won in November by 4 points. President George W. Bush was still popular that year, The Associated Press later noted.
She ran again in 2008 against the same man, and the ground had moved under both of them. A University of New Hampshire study estimated that about a quarter of the electorate had changed since 2002, the AP reported in a story carried by NH Business Review. Young voters and newcomers to the state were more likely to call themselves Democrats. Bush was now unpopular, and Shaheen spent the campaign tying Sununu, by then a 44-year-old incumbent, to him. Barack Obama was at the top of the ticket.
An American Research Group poll on Oct. 31 had her ahead 53 percent to 41, The Dartmouth reported. She won all but three of the state’s 10 counties, according to Roll Call. She became New Hampshire’s first female U.S. senator and its first Democratic senator since 1975. In her victory speech she said she wanted “to end this misguided war in Iraq.”

Shaheen in 2008 was the same candidate with the same resume, running against the same opponent. What she had done was let six years pass and then file in the year the electorate had turned over. Carol Shea-Porter won a rematch of her own the same night, for a U.S. House seat, against the Republican she had narrowly beaten two years earlier.
Five days
Ayotte’s version of the law ran in two speeds. The slow one took seven years. She had been attorney general from 2004 to 2009 and won the Senate seat in 2010. In 2016 she lost it to Maggie Hassan, then the governor, by a tenth of a point, Roll Call reported. She did not run for anything in 2018, 2020 or 2022, years when a Republican incumbent held the governor’s office. She helped guide Neil Gorsuch through his Supreme Court confirmation in 2017 and sat on corporate boards, among them BAE Systems, Caterpillar, the Blackstone Group and News Corp, according to NHPR.
The fast one took five days. Sununu’s announcement on July 19 opened the seat. Morse was in within minutes. Two Democrats, Joyce Craig and Cinde Warmington, had already launched. Ayotte let the first news cycle belong to Sununu and to Morse, then took the following Monday for herself with a line built to travel: “we are one election away from becoming Massachusetts.”
Sununu endorsed her in the September 2024 primary, the AP reported. She ran on a slogan aimed south, “Don’t Mass it up,” and on her five years as attorney general. On Nov. 5 she beat Craig, a former mayor of Manchester. With roughly 75 percent of ballots counted late that night, she led 53 percent to 46, NHPR reported.

Being first was not the skill. Morse was first. The skill was having stayed out of three cycles that offered her nothing and being ready, within a week, for the one that did.
The yes that became a no
The third case is the law broken. In early 2009 Judd Gregg, a Republican in the U.S. Senate, agreed to become commerce secretary for a new Democratic president. He had set a condition, the AP reported: his leaving could not hand his seat to the Democrats. Gov. John Lynch pledged to appoint Bonnie Newman, a former interim president of the University of New Hampshire, who agreed not to run for a full term in 2010. The arrangement would have kept the seat out of Democratic hands until 2010 and left it open after that.
The pieces were in place, and the moment was wrong. Gregg and the White House were at odds over the economic stimulus and over the handling of the 2010 census. On Feb. 12 Gregg withdrew, citing conflicts over both that he called irresolvable. He had told the White House early that week. “This is more of a question of just being me,” he said. The White House said it had not asked him to go. Lynch said he respected the decision.
The White House press secretary, Robert Gibbs, said Gregg had put his own name forward for the job. Gregg himself said the two sides were working from different views on many critical items of policy. That was as true on the day he accepted as on the day he withdrew. He had misjudged how long he could hold a position between the two parties, and the cost was a public reversal.
A clock that waited
The photograph that accompanies this piece is a clock tower in downtown Concord, and it has a timing story of its own. According to the Library of Congress record for the image, the clock stood atop the Board of Trade Building from 1872. In 1950 a renovation took off the building’s top two floors, and the tower and its parts were lost. In 1984 an architect, Duncan McGowan, began tracking the components down. The bell turned up at a flea market in Michigan. After a fundraising drive the tower was reassembled and put back in service at street level.
It was gone for more than three decades and came back when someone was ready to do the work. That is the patient half of Greene’s law, in brick.
What the three cases share
None of these people changed much about themselves. Shaheen did not become a different politician between 2002 and 2008, and Ayotte’s record in 2024 was the one she had in 2016. What changed was the field: who else was in it, who had left it, and who was voting.
Each of the two winners also let time go by. Shaheen waited six years between tries. Ayotte skipped three cycles. Greene’s law treats that kind of waiting as work, and New Hampshire’s calendar makes it cheap. The next window is always two years off.
Gregg’s case is the mirror. He moved when an offer appeared, not when the conditions for accepting it existed. The state’s short clock did nothing for him, because the timing that mattered was Washington’s.
A fair objection
The first objection is that this is luck dressed up as skill. Shaheen did not make 2008 a Democratic year. Obama, an unpopular president and a changing electorate did, and any competent Democrat might have won. That is fair. The claim here is narrower: she was the one who had waited for it and filed.
The second is survivorship. For each candidate who waited and won, there are others who waited and were forgotten, and nobody writes them into a series on power. Also fair. Two wins and one stumble are examples, and they prove nothing about the candidates this piece did not look at.
The third is that Gregg’s reversal may have cost him little. Nothing read for this piece says what it did to his standing at home. The piece does not claim it ended anything.
The verdict
Greene’s thirty-fifth law holds in New Hampshire, and the state’s own rules are part of the reason. A two-year term and a ten-day filing window mean that the question in front of an ambitious person is rarely whether to run. It is which June. Shaheen picked the one after the electorate had changed. Ayotte picked the one after the incumbent stepped aside. Gregg said yes in a month when yes could not last.
The law has a limit the record also shows. Timing chooses the field. It does not win the race. Both winners still had to campaign, and both had lost before.
Part Thirty-Four showed front-runners who arrived with the crown and were made to ask. Part Thirty-Three showed attackers who found a weak point and gained little. Part Thirty-Five shows the quieter move: in a state that reopens the door every two years, the people who last are the ones who can stand to wait for the right one.
Next: Law 36, on disdaining what you cannot have, tested against the New Hampshire record.
Fact check
| # | Claim | Status | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | RSA 655:14: party membership, qualifications and a declaration of candidacy filed “between the first Wednesday in June and the Friday of the following week”; source notes 1979, 436:1 through 2011, 150:3 | VERIFIED | gc.nh.gov, RSA 655:14 |
| 2 | Part Second, Article 42: “The governor shall be chosen biennially in the month of November” | VERIFIED | New Hampshire Constitution, executive articles, as published at nh.gov |
| 3 | Sununu announced July 19, 2023, that he would not seek a fifth term; Ayotte announced Monday, July 24; lost reelection in 2016 by 0.1 percentage points; helped guide Gorsuch through confirmation in 2017; Morse, Craig and Warmington in the race | ATTRIBUTED | Mary Ellen McIntire, Roll Call, July 24, 2023 |
| 4 | Announcement on “Fox and Friends”; Morse declared within minutes of Sununu’s announcement; Craig and Warmington had already launched; attorney general 2004 to 2009; elected to the Senate in 2010; lost in 2016 to then-Gov. Maggie Hassan; corporate boards named; Edelblut reported to be considering a run; “we are one election away from becoming Massachusetts” | ATTRIBUTED | Josh Rogers, New Hampshire Public Radio, July 24, 2023 |
| 5 | Ayotte beat Joyce Craig on Nov. 5, 2024; Craig a former Manchester mayor; Sununu declined a fifth two-year term and endorsed her in the September primary; “Don’t Mass it up”; five years as attorney general | ATTRIBUTED | Holly Ramer, The Associated Press, Nov. 6, 2024 (as published by Boston.com) |
| 6 | With roughly 75 percent of ballots counted at 11:30 p.m., Ayotte led 53 percent to 46 | ATTRIBUTED | Josh Rogers, New Hampshire Public Radio, Nov. 5, 2024 |
| 7 | Sununu beat Shaheen by 4 points in 2002; Bush still popular then; UNH study, about a quarter of the electorate changed since 2002; young voters and newcomers more Democratic; Shaheen linked Sununu to Bush; Obama’s coattails; Sununu, 44, the incumbent | ATTRIBUTED | The Associated Press, as published by NH Business Review, Nov. 4, 2008 |
| 8 | Shaheen the first elected female governor, first female senator from New Hampshire and first Democratic senator since 1975; American Research Group poll of Oct. 31, 53 to 41; “to end this misguided war in Iraq” | ATTRIBUTED | Turia Lahlou, The Dartmouth, Nov. 5, 2008 |
| 9 | Shaheen won all but three of 10 counties; in 2002 Sununu beat Sen. Bob Smith in the primary and Shaheen was unopposed; Shea-Porter won a rematch against Jeb Bradley after narrowly beating him in 2006 | ATTRIBUTED | Tricia Miller, Roll Call, Nov. 5, 2008 |
| 10 | Gregg withdrew Feb. 12, 2009; conflicts over the stimulus and the 2010 census that he called irresolvable; the two sides held different views on many critical items of policy; told the White House early that week; his condition on the seat; Lynch’s pledge to appoint Bonnie Newman, who agreed not to run in 2010; Gibbs said Gregg had offered his own name; Gibbs said the White House did not request the withdrawal; Lynch respected the decision; “This is more of a question of just being me” | ATTRIBUTED | The Associated Press, Feb. 12, 2009 (as published by MPR News) |
| 11 | Featured photograph: a clock tower in Concord, Carol M. Highsmith, LC-DIG-highsm-48269, no known restrictions; atop the Board of Trade Building from 1872, lost in a 1950 renovation, reassembled at street level after a search begun in 1984 by architect Duncan McGowan; bell found at a flea market in Michigan; fundraising drive | VERIFIED | Library of Congress catalog record 2017884899 |
| 12 | Robert Greene’s Law 35 is “Master the Art of Timing,” and Law 36 is “Disdain Things You Cannot Have: Ignoring Them Is the Best Revenge,” from The 48 Laws of Power, Viking, 1998 | VERIFIED | Shortform summary of the book, read this session |
| 13 | GSR Power Index scores for Laws 1 through 35 | EDITORIAL | Granite State Report’s own rating, not a measurement. Method stated in the chart |
Your voice
Poll. Should New Hampshire keep electing its governor every two years?
Yes, keep two years · Move to four years · Four years with a two-term limit · Not sure
Survey: the comeback candidate. Five questions: your town; whether you have voted for a candidate who had lost an earlier race; whether a past loss makes you more or less likely to vote for someone; how much it matters to you when a candidate gets into a race; and why. Granite State Report asks before using your name or story.
Discuss. Is waiting for the right year good judgment or just opportunism? And does a two-year term keep governors accountable or keep them campaigning?
Verified New Hampshire residents vote and answer at granitestatereport.com. Or write to granitestatereport@gmail.com with your town in the subject line.
Granite State Report wants to hear from candidates, campaign staff and local officials about how they chose their year. granitestatereport@gmail.com, 603-931-9264. Confidentiality on request.
Editor’s note: Commentary and analysis, not legal advice. The statute and the constitutional article were read on the state’s websites. Accounts of the 2002, 2008, 2016 and 2024 races and of the 2009 nomination come from contemporary reporting and are attributed. The 2008 figures in the first chart are a pre-election poll, and the 2024 figures in the second are partial returns; neither is the official canvass. The GSR Power Index is editorial, not data.

