Independent New Hampshire Journalism · Northfield, NH
Newsroom · Podcast
The GSR Podcast

AI hosts talk through Granite State Report’s reporting. Every episode links to the articles it discusses.

Each episode takes one or more Granite State Report articles and turns them into a short conversation between two synthetic hosts. It is the quick version: what the reporting found, why it matters, and where to read the rest.

Made by AI, checked by the newsroom. Most episodes here are generated by WordPress.com’s experimental AI podcast tool from articles published here; Pip and Mara are synthetic voices, not people, and the script is written by the tool, not by the editor. Episodes marked “Scripted from the articles” are written by Claude, an AI model made by Anthropic, from the articles they discuss, and read by synthetic voices; nothing goes into those scripts that the articles do not say. Before any episode goes on this page, every factual claim in it is checked against the articles it draws on, and a listener’s note under the episode records anywhere the hosts’ wording drifts from the record. The articles are the record. The episode is a conversation about them.

Episodes

AI, Minds, And Public Records

Made November 11, 2026 · AI hosts · 5:57

Four pieces in one episode: the column that reads Ill Bill’s “War Is My Destiny” against New Hampshire’s constitution and the Right-to-Know Law, the research on which minds gain most from AI, the essay that runs from the oldest stone tools to the Dartmouth summer study and Voyager 1, and the launch of Your Voice, the polling desk that asks verified residents what happened within five business days of their last records request.

Articles discussed in this episode

Listener’s note.

  • The hosts say the column “draws a line from that image straight to civic accountability: ‘Government, therefore, should be open, accessible, accountable and responsive.’” Those are not the column’s words. The column quotes them from the state constitution: “New Hampshire wrote its answer into Part First, Article 8 of the state constitution.”
  • The hosts call “A door stops opening, one unposted job at a time” the column’s phrase. The column has the two halves in different sentences: “A door stops opening, and the share of the harvest that goes to the people who did the work keeps shrinking,” and, two sentences later, “If owners keep all of it, the song’s first scene plays out slowly and legally, one unposted job at a time.”
  • The hosts say people with “an idea surplus and a finishing deficit, the profile the ADHD research describes, have the exact gap these tools fill.” The article is more careful: “I have found no randomized trial that tests AI tools on adults with ADHD specifically. The ADHD case is a strong lead resting on a small pile of evidence.”
  • The hosts say a UNH poll “found” the AI-use figures. The article gives the numbers as the UNH Survey Center’s results as reported by NHPR and the New Hampshire Bulletin, and marks them ATTRIBUTED.

Checked and holding: all four articles are bylined Dexter Dow; the song is the eighth track on Ill Bill’s 2008 album, and in the column’s telling the boy is five when raiders burn his village and spends his life walking back toward the man who gave the order; the column’s disclosure that it was drafted with Claude; software that “will sit with you at 11 p.m.,” and the instruction to check every claim against the document; the Bureau of Labor Statistics’ labor share of 52.8 percent in the second quarter of 2026, the lowest in data beginning in 1947; the Stanford finding of a 19 percent gap for workers 22 to 25 in AI-exposed occupations, mostly from reduced hiring; 59 percent of New Hampshire workers using AI on the job, up from 44 percent the previous October, and more than half of them reporting little or no difference; the largest gains going to the least experienced or weakest performers in the customer support, consultant and writing studies; the article’s heading “The trait that decides it: hard to fool”; stone tools at Lomekwi 3 about 3.3 million years old, older than the oldest Homo fossil at about 2.8 million; the 1956 Dartmouth summer study in Hanover, which Dartmouth marks as the event where the term was coined; Voyager 1; I.J. Good’s 1965 condition that the machine be docile enough to tell us how to keep it under control; RSA 5-D:4, I, which requires human review before an irreversible AI recommendation or decision by a state agency takes effect; the Your Voice quotation, verbatim; the desk’s single question about the five business days; no result until five verified residents answer, because in a small county two or three answers can tell a neighbor how someone voted.

Read the transcript

Pip: Granite State Report is covering artificial intelligence, civic records law, and the deep history of toolmaking — which, as it turns out, is the same argument told three different ways.

Mara: Dexter Dow is the author behind all of it. Today we are looking at who wins with AI, what the constitution already arms you with, why the species builds tools at all, and how New Hampshire tracks — or mostly does not track — its own records law. Let’s start with AI and human creativity.

AI, the Constitution, and Who the Tools Actually Serve

Pip: The question running through these pieces is not whether AI is coming — it is who it comes for, and whether ordinary people end up with any of it.

Mara: The anchor post opens with a song and a constitutional argument. The setup is Ill Bill’s “War Is My Destiny,” a track about a five-year-old who watches his village burn and spends his life walking back toward the man who gave the order. The column draws a line from that image straight to civic accountability: “Government, therefore, should be open, accessible, accountable and responsive.”

Pip: So the war song is not actually about war. It is about being the one who saw it and kept the record.

Mara: Exactly — and that is where AI enters. The column argues that the research and drafting work once limited to paid staffs is now available to any resident at eleven at night. File a Right-to-Know request, read the response with an AI model at your elbow, check every claim against the document.

Pip: The column is also transparent that it was drafted with Claude, which is either a disclosure or a demonstration — probably both.

Mara: The economic backdrop matters here. Bureau of Labor Statistics data cited in the piece put the labor share of nonfarm business output at 52.8 percent in the second quarter of 2026, the lowest ever recorded in data going back to 1947. Stanford researchers found employment of workers ages 22 to 25 in AI-exposed occupations running 19 percent behind their less-exposed peers, driven mainly by reduced hiring.

Pip: A door stops opening, one unposted job at a time. That is the column’s phrase, and it is doing real work.

Mara: The piece “Which Minds Win With AI?” puts numbers to who gains most from the tools. A UNH poll found 59 percent of New Hampshire workers already use AI on the job — up from 44 percent the previous October — but more than half of those users report little or no productivity difference.

Pip: Most workplaces have the tool. Most people are getting nothing from it. That gap is the whole story.

Mara: The research points somewhere specific. Across multiple studies — customer support agents, consultants, writers — the largest gains went to whoever started furthest behind. People with an idea surplus and a finishing deficit, the profile the ADHD research describes, have the exact gap these tools fill. The trait that decides outcomes for every group, though, is skepticism: the ability to check what the machine hands back.

Pip: And the third piece, “We Are the Animal That Builds Tools,” pulls the camera all the way back — to stone tools older than the genus Homo, to the 1956 Dartmouth summer study in Hanover where the term artificial intelligence was coined, and eventually to Voyager 1 as the furthest thing human hands have ever sent anywhere.

Mara: The argument there is that building a tool smarter than its makers is the most natural thing this species has ever done — and possibly the only insurance policy a planet-bound animal gets. But it comes with I.J. Good’s 1965 condition attached: the policy pays only if the machine is, as Good wrote, “docile enough to tell us how to keep it under control.”

Pip: New Hampshire has already written a small version of that condition into state law — human review before any irreversible AI decision by a state agency takes effect.

Mara: Which brings the argument back to the same place the war-song column lands: the tools are arriving regardless, ownership of the gains is a live decision, and a human hand stays on the switch for anything that cannot be undone.

Mara: The records side of that argument has its own infrastructure — and its own gap in the data.

New Hampshire’s Five-Day Promise, and Who Is Counting

Pip: RSA 91-A gives every New Hampshire resident the right to inspect government records. It also gives public bodies five business days to respond. What it does not do is require anyone to track whether that deadline is met.

Mara: The piece on Your Voice, GSR’s polling desk for verified residents, opens with exactly that gap: “I located no state agency that keeps a running count of how the Right-to-Know Law is obeyed, and no statute that requires one.” The desk asks one question — what happened within five business days the last time you filed a records request — and holds results until five verified residents answer, a privacy floor designed for small-county data.

Pip: A count from the people who actually filed. It is a start the state has not made.

Mara: And that connects directly back to the AI columns — the same RSA 91-A request the war-song piece asks readers to file is the behavior this desk is trying to measure.

Pip: Stone tools, a rap song, a five-day deadline, and a Dartmouth summer study — same argument, different entry points.

Mara: The throughline is who holds the record and who answers for it. More of that next time.

Transcript as generated by the tool, minus one divider line that carries no speech. The listener’s note above records where it differs from the articles.

Ghosts, UFOs, And Newsmaking

Made November 10, 2026 · AI hosts · 7:00

Six pieces in one episode: the Ocean-Born Mary record in Henniker, the recruiting call to the generation locked out of the first job, and four reports from GSR’s UFO Data Analysis Engine: the editor’s own Northfield sighting, the engine’s technical account, the seven beach clips and the second look at the Rochester lights. The tool made a second episode from the same six articles earlier the same day; it follows this one.

Articles discussed in this episode

Listener’s note.

  • The hosts open with “Dexter Dow is behind all of it.” Five of the six articles carry his byline. “Second Look at the Rochester Lights” is bylined GSR Staff.
  • The hosts say the post traces Mary Wallace’s life “through two 19th-century town histories and finds that she spent her final sixteen years at her son William’s farm.” The town histories supply her birth, marriage and death and Cogswell’s line on her last years. The sixteen years at William’s farm come from later sources, which the article marks ATTRIBUTED: the Henniker Historical Society’s December 2017 newsletter and Yankee Magazine.
  • The hosts say AI “is narrowing the entry-level jobs that remain” and “The door isn’t closing on everyone — it’s closing on the youngest workers first.” The article reports the Stanford authors’ own caution: “They call these early descriptive indicators, not causal estimates, and they report the pattern weakens when they control for education.”
  • The hosts say U-2 testing “in the late 1950s” set off the surge. The article puts the plane’s building and high-altitude testing in the mid-1950s. The late 1950s is the period of the CIA history’s own estimate that U-2 and later OXCART flights “accounted for more than half of all UFO reports in the late 1950s and most of the 1960s,” a figure the article notes UFO researcher Stanton Friedman disputed.

Checked and holding: Mary Wallace died in 1814; Cogswell’s 1880 History of the Town of Henniker describes a tall, resolute woman and says “her last years were sunny and happy,” verbatim; a search of both digitized town histories for “ghost” and “haunt” returns nothing about Mary or either Wallace house; Mary lived about a mile from the house that bears her name; Louis Roy bought the Robert Wallace mansion in 1916, by the Henniker Historical Society’s account (other accounts give 1917), and marketed it as haunted; the phantom carriage, the pirate under the hearth and the 50-cent treasure digs came later; Martha Taylor’s “He was a showman” to the Concord Monitor, verbatim; the article calls the case the first file for the ghost software GSR is building; the New York Fed’s June figures of 5.7 percent for recent graduates and 4.1 percent for all workers, higher for graduates every month since January 2021; underemployment of 42 percent; a statewide median rent of $2,011 that takes $80,440 a year to afford, as NHPR reported New Hampshire Housing’s figures; the 19 percent Stanford gap; employment held flat or rose where AI mostly helps people do their jobs; the October 25 sighting over Northfield; the quotation on the crossing lines of sight, verbatim; the stop and the remembered direction did not survive the record; GoJet 4527 climbing through about 27,000 feet beside the contrail of Condor 114; the engine’s score for the white object was a tie between contrail and bird, and the flight archive settled it; AARO’s 319 reports, 114 resolved to ordinary objects and 191 archived for lack of data; GSR asks for the original file; the first Rochester story said the September 10 light did not flash, and the second look counted 16 flares in 13 seconds, one every 0.86 seconds, with a correction at the top of the first story; seven beach clips, one phone, one hand; a red light on a 1.08-second beat for 21 seconds; “The shapes were real. The camera drew them.”; the CIA’s 1992 history says the U-2’s high-altitude testing set off a tremendous increase in UFO reports, and that Project Blue Book investigators checked sightings against U-2 flight logs and could not tell the letter writers what they had seen.

Read the transcript

Pip: Granite State Report covers New Hampshire — ghosts, job markets, and UFOs — which, honestly, is the correct order of priorities for any state with this many old farmhouses and this many overcast skies.

Mara: Dexter Dow is behind all of it. Today we’re looking at a haunted house that wasn’t, a generation locked out of entry-level work, and a newsroom building software to check what people film in the sky.

Pip: Let’s start with the ghost that arrived a century late.

The House That Wasn’t Haunted

Mara: The question here is whether one of New Hampshire’s most famous ghost stories holds up against the town’s own historical record — and specifically whether Ocean-Born Mary ever set foot in the house that carries her name.

Pip: She did not. The post traces Mary Wallace’s life through two 19th-century town histories and finds that she spent her final sixteen years at her son William’s farm, about a mile from the house tourists associate with her.

Mara: Cogswell’s 1880 history puts it plainly, describing a tall, resolute woman and writing that “her last years were sunny and happy.” No ghost. A search of both digitized town histories for the words ghost and haunt returns nothing connected to Mary or either Wallace house.

Pip: The haunting has a start date, which is not a quality ghosts are supposed to have.

Mara: That date is 1916, when a photographer named Louis Roy bought the deteriorating Robert Wallace mansion and, according to the Henniker Historical Society, began marketing it as haunted. The phantom carriage, the buried pirate, the treasure hunts with shovels at fifty cents a dig — all of it came later. Town historian Martha Taylor’s verdict to the Concord Monitor: “He was a showman.”

Pip: The software GSR is building to check ghost evidence will run the same paper-trail test on every submission — and this case is where that work starts, because the record is complete enough to close it before a camera comes out.

The Generation Locked Out

Mara: The tension here is structural: recent college graduates are now more likely to be unemployed than the workforce as a whole, AI is narrowing the entry-level jobs that remain, and young adults trust social media about as much as they trust newsrooms.

Pip: The post opens as a recruiting call, which is a disarming way to deliver labor-market data.

Mara: The numbers are from the Federal Reserve Bank of New York. In June, 5.7 percent of Americans ages 22 to 27 with a bachelor’s degree were out of work, against 4.1 percent for all workers. That gap has held every month since January 2021. Beyond unemployment, 42 percent of recent graduates hold jobs that never required a degree.

Pip: And New Hampshire’s low headline unemployment rate does not make it easier to start out here — median rent requires over eighty thousand dollars a year to afford.

Mara: The Stanford payroll research adds a specific wrinkle: employment of 22- to 25-year-olds in AI-exposed occupations sits 19 percent below where it would be had it kept pace with less-exposed peers. The door isn’t closing on everyone — it’s closing on the youngest workers first. Where AI complements rather than substitutes, employment held.

Mara: That’s the opening the post is pointing toward: work that keeps a person on the judgment is the work that’s holding up, which is the argument for building a records-based newsroom with people the squeeze hits first.

Pip: From ghost software to job markets — both segments circle back to what the record actually shows, which is where the UFO coverage lives too.

The Engine That Checks the Sky

Mara: The core question across these pieces is whether a disciplined process — hash the file, replay the flight record, measure every frame — can clear the sky of ordinary explanations and leave only what genuinely can’t be accounted for.

Pip: The editor built the software, then pointed it at his own footage and got humbled by a regional jet. That is the correct order of operations.

Mara: The post on the UFO Data Analysis Engine describes what happened over Northfield on October 25: an elongated white object that seemed to stop and jump sides. The flight archive resolved it. “The two lines of sight crossed. A smaller, closer jet sliding past a bigger, higher one looks, to an eye locked on one of them, as if the other one stopped and jumped sides.”

Mara: So the upshot is that two parts of the eyewitness account — the stop, and the direction faced — didn’t survive the record. GoJet 4527, a regional jet climbing through 27,000 feet, beside the contrail of Condor 114. The engine itself had called it a tie. The archive settled it.

Pip: The federal ledger puts this in context: the All-domain Anomaly Resolution Office received 319 reports in one year, resolved 114 — every one to something ordinary — and shelved 191 because the files lacked enough data to judge.

Mara: Which is why the engine asks for original files, not screenshots. The Rochester follow-up, Second Look at the Rochester Lights, shows what re-measurement does: GSR’s first pass said the September 10 light showed no flashing rhythm. Wrong. Frame by frame, it flares sixteen times in thirteen seconds, once every 0.86 seconds — the beat of an aircraft anticollision strobe. The correction sits at the top of that story.

Pip: And the beach clips — seven videos of “weird shapes” over the ocean — turned out to be one phone, one hand, and a camera that draws shapes when it moves. One red light kept an airplane beacon’s beat for twenty-one seconds. The shapes were real. The camera drew them.

Mara: The engine also covers the history: CIA records show U-2 spy plane testing in the late 1950s generated a surge of UFO reports that investigators couldn’t explain publicly. An unexplained light can be a real government secret. The cure is records.

Pip: The same cure the ghost software is being built to apply — which means all of this is really one project wearing different hats.

Mara: A paper trail that closes a haunting, a labor market that closes a door, a flight archive that closes a sighting — the through-line is the same discipline applied to very different questions.

Pip: Next time: whatever New Hampshire sends in that the engine can’t explain on the first pass.

Transcript as generated by the tool, minus one divider line that carries no speech. The listener’s note above records where it differs from the articles.

Ghosts And UFOs In New Hampshire

Made November 10, 2026 · AI hosts · 7:45

The same six pieces as the episode above, in the tool’s first take that day: the Ocean-Born Mary record in Henniker, the editor’s own Northfield sighting, the engine that checks sky video, the seven beach clips, the second look at the Rochester lights, and the recruiting call to the generation locked out of the first job. This one spends more time on the engine and the beach clips.

Articles discussed in this episode

Listener’s note.

  • The hosts open with “Dexter Dow has been busy.” Five of the six articles carry his byline. “Second Look at the Rochester Lights” is bylined GSR Staff.
  • The hosts say “The Henniker Historical Society’s verdict is blunt: Cogswell’s 1880 town history says ‘her last years were sunny and happy’ — no ghost, no haunting, no pirate under the hearthstone.” The quotation is Cogswell’s, from 1880, not the society’s. The society’s verdict, from its newsletters, is the one the article reports: “no stories of ghosts were heard before Roy’s years in the house, and Mary never lived there.” Cogswell does tell the pirate story of her birth at sea, introduced with “Tradition says.”
  • The hosts say “The historical society calls the whole production a hoax.” The article attributes that word to SeacoastNH.com, whose account it cites as “The Ocean Born Mary House Hoax.” The society’s finding is the one quoted above.
  • The hosts place the haunted-house research at Hampton Court Palace. The article describes two experiments, one at Hampton Court Palace and one in Edinburgh’s South Bridge Vaults.
  • The hosts say of the Stanford payroll study, “The door just doesn’t open.” The article reports the authors’ own caution: “They call these early descriptive indicators, not causal estimates, and they report the pattern weakens when they control for education.”

Checked and holding: Mary died in 1814 and the haunting dates to Louis Roy’s purchase of the Robert Wallace mansion in 1916 (other accounts give 1917), a house she never lived in; Cogswell’s “her last years were sunny and happy,” verbatim; Roy’s 50-cent digs in his orchard, by Yankee Magazine’s price; Roy’s mother, Flora, played the elderly Mary for tourists; Martha Taylor’s “He was a showman,” verbatim; the Wiseman experiments tied reports of unusual experiences to reputedly haunted areas whether or not people knew the reputation, and to lighting and magnetic variation; the ghost software starts with the paper trail; the editor’s opening quotation in “I Built Software to Check UFO Videos,” verbatim apart from the quotation marks around “the plane”; the crossing lines of sight; the stop and the remembered direction did not survive the record; the engine is just over 3,000 lines of Python, hashes each file, reads its metadata, tracks every moving point, scores the ordinary explanations with the evidence printed and never gives a verdict; the second clip’s point of light, visible about a fifth of the time on no fixed beat, which the editor reads as foil and the engine cannot tell from a bird’s wings at two pixels; AARO’s 319 reports, 114 resolved and 191 archived; most open cases stay open because nobody kept the original file; seven beach clips whose shapes the moving phone drew; a red light on a 1.08-second beat that moved against the stars, with no location tag in the files; the first Rochester story said the September 10 light did not flash; 16 flares in 13 seconds, 0.86 seconds apart, 70 a minute, inside the federal range for anticollision lights; the September 22 lights matched to stars of the Big Dipper with the Yale Bright Star Catalog; the New York Fed quotation, verbatim; graduates’ jobless rate above the all-worker rate every month since January 2021; the 19 percent Stanford gap and no comparable gap for experienced workers; Pew’s trust figures for adults under 30, 51 percent for national news and 50 percent for social media; the application is to check one claim about New Hampshire against the record.

Read the transcript

Pip: Granite State Report covers New Hampshire — ghosts, UFOs, and the job market — which is either the broadest beat in local journalism or proof that the state contains multitudes.

Mara: Dexter Dow has been busy. Today we’re looking at a haunted house that wasn’t, a homemade engine that checks sky footage frame by frame, and a recruiting call aimed at the generation the economy is currently leaving on the porch.

Pip: Let’s start with the ghost that showed up a century late.

Ocean-Born Mary and the Paper Trail

Mara: The question here is simple: did Ocean-Born Mary, one of New Hampshire’s most famous ghosts, ever actually live in the house that carries her name?

Pip: The Henniker Historical Society’s verdict is blunt: Cogswell’s 1880 town history says “her last years were sunny and happy” — no ghost, no haunting, no pirate under the hearthstone.

Mara: What that means in practice is that the haunting has a start date and an author. Mary died in 1814. The ghost arrived in 1916, when a photographer named Louis Roy bought the decaying Robert Wallace mansion — a house Mary never lived in — and began marketing it as haunted.

Pip: Roy charged fifty cents to let treasure hunters dig in his orchard. His mother played elderly Mary for tourists. The historical society calls the whole production a hoax, and town historian Martha Taylor told the Concord Monitor simply: “He was a showman.”

Mara: The post also walks through why honest people still feel things in old buildings — psychology research on Hampton Court Palace found that people reported more unusual experiences in reputedly haunted areas regardless of whether they knew the reputation, correlated with ordinary room features like lighting and magnetic variation.

Pip: Which is why the software GSR is building to check ghost recordings starts with the paper trail, not the camera — run Henniker through that check and it’s over before you unpack the equipment.

Mara: From haunted houses to haunted skies — the same analytical discipline shows up in GSR’s UFO work.

What the Sky Engine Found Over Northfield

Pip: The central tension in this segment is whether a homemade tool built by a self-described UFO believer can actually hold its own footage to account — and what the federal record says about how often sky mysteries stay mysterious.

Mara: The piece “I Built Software to Check UFO Videos” opens with a direct answer. After filming something he couldn’t name over Northfield, the editor writes: “It was a regional jet. The public flight record for that minute puts GoJet 4527, a Bombardier CRJ550 climbing through about 27,000 feet, on the same line of sight as Condor 114, an Airbus A330 cruising near 39,000 feet and laying the contrail I took for the plane.”

Pip: So the thing that seemed to stop and jump sides was a smaller, closer jet sliding past a bigger, higher one — a geometry trick, not an anomaly. Two parts of his own account didn’t survive the record: the stop, and the direction he remembered facing.

Mara: The engine itself — described in the technical piece “GSR Built a Machine That Checks UFO Videos” — is about three thousand lines of Python. It fingerprints every file, reads camera metadata, tracks every moving point, and scores ordinary explanations with the evidence printed beside each one. It never announces a verdict.

Pip: A second blinking point from the same afternoon stayed genuinely open. The engine found a small sunlit object crossing the sky steadily, visible about a fifth of the time, on no fixed beat. The editor’s own read is tumbling foil. The engine’s read is that it cannot tell foil from a bird’s wings at two pixels with one camera.

Mara: That honesty about limits is the design. The federal numbers back it up. The All-domain Anomaly Resolution Office received 319 reports in one year, resolved 114 — every one to something ordinary — and shelved 191 because the files lacked enough data to judge. Most of what stays open stays open because no one kept the original recording.

Pip: A reader then sent seven beach clips of what they called “weird shapes in the sky.” The piece “Seven Beach Clips of Weird Shapes in the Sky, Checked Frame by Frame” found that every shape was a point of light dragged into a streak by a moving hand — the camera drew the shapes. One red light, though, flashed on a 1.08-second beat and moved against the stars: an airplane’s anticollision beacon, by timing and motion, even without a flight record because the files carried no location tag.

Mara: And the “Second Look at the Rochester Lights” corrected GSR’s own earlier story, which had said a September 10 light showed no flash. Measured again frame by frame, it flares sixteen times in thirteen seconds, once every 0.86 seconds — seventy times a minute, inside the federal range for aircraft anticollision lights. The September 22 lights turned out to be five stars of the Big Dipper, identified by matching positions against the Yale Bright Star Catalog.

Pip: A newsroom that corrects its own frame-by-frame measurements is either very honest or very embarrassed. Probably both, which is the right combination.

Mara: The same instinct — check the record, show the work — drives the next piece, which is less about the sky and more about who builds what comes next.

The Generation That Should Build the Next Newsroom

Pip: The argument here is that the people the economy is squeezing hardest are also the people best positioned to rebuild local journalism — and GSR is making a direct ask.

Mara: The numbers are stark. The piece cites the Federal Reserve Bank of New York: “In June, 5.7 percent of Americans ages 22 to 27 with a bachelor’s degree were out of work and looking. Among all workers ages 16 to 65, the rate was 4.1 percent.”

Pip: A degree used to buy you a lower jobless rate than the national average. That relationship has been inverted every single month since January 2021.

Mara: A Stanford study on ADP payroll records adds the AI dimension: employment of workers ages 22 to 25 in AI-exposed occupations sits 19 percent below where it would be had it kept pace with less-exposed peers. Experienced workers in the same jobs show no comparable gap. The door just doesn’t open.

Pip: Meanwhile, Pew found that trust in national news and trust in social media are now one percentage point apart among adults under 30. That’s not apathy — that’s an audience that stopped finding the old product useful.

Mara: GSR’s response is a recruiting call: coders, fact-checkers, records filers, reporters who live in New Hampshire and know a beat. The application is to pick one claim you’ve seen online about New Hampshire, check it against the record, and report back what you found.

Pip: Which is also, conveniently, the job description.

Mara: A ghost story with a paper trail, sky footage checked frame by frame, and a generation asked to build the newsroom that covers both — the thread running through all of it is the same: original file, primary source, show the work.

Pip: Next time, we’ll see what else New Hampshire has that deserves that treatment. There’s always something.

Transcript as generated by the tool, minus one divider line that carries no speech. The listener’s note above records where it differs from the articles.

November 10 In History

Made November 10, 2026 · AI hosts · 6:20

Three pieces in one episode, all from the November 10 almanac: Nigeria’s 1995 execution of Ken Saro-Wiwa after a tribunal with no appeal, the Webster-Ashburton Treaty line at Hall’s Stream, and the 1898 Wilmington coup, with the other entries each edition carries.

Articles discussed in this episode

Listener’s note.

  • The hosts say “Dexter Dow covers the ground across all three.” All three articles are bylined GSR Staff.
  • The hosts call it “Khrushchev’s 1958 ultimatum over Berlin.” The November 10, 1958 entry is a speech in Moscow; the article says the ultimatum followed: “Two weeks later Moscow demanded that West Berlin be demilitarized within six months and declared it a free city.”
  • The hosts say the treaty “settled what a small armed standoff could not.” In the article’s account the standoff was over first: “the British gave up their claim in January 1838, residents accepted New Hampshire’s authority that May, and the legislature incorporated Pittsburg in its November 1840 session.” The 1842 treaty fixed the line.
  • The hosts promise “four other November 10 dates in New Hampshire” and name three: Lyman’s 1761 charter, Fitz John Porter’s removal in 1862, and the Portsmouth firemen’s run to Boston in 1872. The fourth in the article is two New Hampshire Supreme Court rulings on November 10, 2010: Allianz Global Risks U.S. Insurance Co. v. State, on a Seabrook flood, and City of Manchester v. Secretary of State, on a charter amendment.
  • The hosts state flatly that Henry Wirz was “the only Confederate soldier charged with war crimes.” The article attributes it: “A Library of Congress research guide says he was the only Confederate soldier charged with war crimes during the Civil War.”

Checked and holding: Saro-Wiwa and eight other Ogoni activists were hanged at Port Harcourt Prison on November 10, 1995, “executed in secret” three days after the Provisional Ruling Council confirmed the sentences, verbatim from the African Commission; Section 8(1) of the decree barred any court from inquiring into the tribunal’s decisions, and the confirming council’s members were exclusively from the armed forces; the commission’s 1998 decision at Banjul found violations of Articles 4, 7 and 26 and called carrying out such sentences an arbitrary deprivation of life; the $15.5 million settlement announced in 2009, with Shell admitting no fault; Resolution 3379 adopted in 1975 and revoked in 1991, sixteen years apart; Article I runs the line “to the head of Hall’s Stream,” verbatim, then down the stream to the Valentine and Collins line of the 45th parallel; Canada had pressed for the Connecticut Lakes, by a Quebec heritage guide’s account; about 300 residents declared the Indian Stream republic in 1832, and the state militia occupied the territory in 1835; the treaty was proclaimed November 10, 1842; Article VIII’s naval squadrons against the slave trade; the telegram text, verbatim; the engine loaded at the Dover Street side track and unloaded at Causeway Street two hours later; Mayor Silas P. Wright “resigned under pressure,” verbatim, with council members and other officers, Black and white, and Alfred Moore Waddell took office as mayor; the election passed quietly two days earlier; as many as 60 dead by the state’s 2006 report, all reported victims Black; the commission created in 2000 and its final report in May 2006, with the recommendation to repair the moral, economic, civic and political damage; the 1775 resolution raising the Marines; 41 pickets, each carrying a five-foot banner; the Edmund Fitzgerald lost with all 29 aboard, and the safety board’s report on hatch covers and on freeboard reductions under the Great Lakes load line amendments.

Read the transcript

Pip: Granite State Report runs a date through three lenses — world, state, and nation — and November 10 turns out to be one of those dates that history kept very busy.

Mara: Dexter Dow covers the ground across all three: a military tribunal with no appeal in Nigeria, a treaty that finally drew New Hampshire’s northern border, and a mob that removed an elected city government two days after the polls closed.

Pip: Let’s start with the world history, and with a courtroom door that a decree shut permanently.

When a Decree Closes the Courtroom

Mara: The post frames this as a question of who holds the last word — and in Nigeria in 1995, a military council did. The African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights later found that Ken Saro-Wiwa and eight other Ogoni activists were “executed in secret” three days after the Provisional Ruling Council confirmed their death sentences.

Pip: What that quote means in practice: no independent court ever reviewed the verdict. Section 8(1) of the decree barred any court from examining the tribunal’s decisions, and the confirming authority was composed exclusively of military officers.

Mara: The commission’s 1998 ruling at Banjul found violations of Articles 4, 7, and 26 of the African Charter — arbitrary deprivation of life. By then, three years had passed since the executions. The post also tracks the legal aftermath to New York: a 2009 settlement of $15.5 million against Royal Dutch Shell, with no admission of fault.

Pip: The commission got the last word on paper. The nine were still dead.

Mara: The post places this alongside Khrushchev’s 1958 ultimatum over Berlin — another attempt to claim the last word, defused by negotiation — and the General Assembly’s Resolution 3379 in 1975, which determined that Zionism was a form of racism, then reversed itself sixteen years later in 1991.

Pip: From a military courtroom in Port Harcourt to the U.N. General Assembly floor — the through line is who gets to decide, and whether that decision holds.

Mara: That question travels north, to a border that New Hampshire once had to settle by force.

The Line at Hall’s Stream

Pip: New Hampshire’s northern border wasn’t always a line on a map — it was a live dispute with a militia backing it up. The Webster-Ashburton Treaty post opens with that tension directly.

Mara: Article I of the treaty ran the boundary, in the treaty’s own words, “to the head of Hall’s Stream,” then down the middle of that stream to the old Valentine and Collins survey of the 45th parallel. Canada had pressed for the Connecticut Lakes as the line. Hall’s Stream won.

Pip: The stakes were real: roughly 300 residents of the Indian Stream country had declared an independent republic in 1832, complete with a legislature, courts, and a militia, before New Hampshire’s own militia moved in three years later.

Mara: The treaty proclaimed on November 10, 1842, settled what a small armed standoff could not. It also did more than draw a line — Article VIII committed both nations to naval squadrons off Africa against the slave trade.

Pip: The post covers four other November 10 dates in New Hampshire: the 1761 charter of Lyman, Portsmouth-born General Fitz John Porter losing his Civil War command, and Portsmouth’s fire companies loading a steam engine onto a train to answer Boston’s 1872 call for help.

Mara: The telegram they received read: “Fire in Boston beyond control. Come immediately to our aid.” Two hours after loading at the Dover Street side track, the crew was on Causeway Street, working through the North End.

Pip: From a border fixed by treaty to a government removed by force — that’s the next date.

Wilmington, 1898: The Coup the Record Names

Pip: The post on U.S. history leads with a direct challenge to what an election actually settles: on November 10, 1898, in Wilmington, North Carolina, a mob answered that question with force.

Mara: The post quotes North Carolina’s own account: Mayor Silas P. Wright, a white Republican, “resigned under pressure,” as did city council members and other officers, Black and white. Alfred Moore Waddell then took office as mayor — two days after an election the state’s records say passed quietly.

Pip: The upshot is that a legally elected government was physically removed and replaced. The death toll is still disputed — the state’s 2006 commission settled on as many as 60; all reported victims were Black.

Mara: North Carolina took more than a century to examine it officially. The General Assembly created the 1898 Wilmington Race Riot Commission in 2000, and the final report came in May 2006, recommending efforts to repair what it called the moral, economic, civic, and political damage.

Pip: The post also covers the 1775 Continental Congress resolution raising the Marines, the 1865 hanging of Andersonville commandant Henry Wirz — the only Confederate soldier charged with war crimes — and the 1917 arrest of 41 suffrage pickets at the White House gates, each carrying a five-foot banner.

Mara: And the Edmund Fitzgerald, lost November 10, 1975, with all 29 aboard — the safety board’s report pointed at hatch covers and at freeboard reductions the federal load line amendments had permitted.

Pip: Government action, government failure, government force — the date keeps returning to the same question.

Mara: Across all three posts, the thread is accountability — who decided, under what authority, and whether the record caught up with them.

Pip: Sometimes in three years, sometimes in a century, sometimes never. Same date next week.

Transcript as generated by the tool, minus one divider line that carries no speech. The listener’s note above records where it differs from the articles.

Wealth, Work, And Morality

Made November 10, 2026 · AI hosts · 5:24

Two columns in one episode: the research on whether being rich feels better when everyone else is poor, and the editor’s column on investor money, Pascal’s wager and who owns what AI makes.

Articles discussed in this episode

Listener’s note.

  • The hosts say the lottery study used “postal codes averaging thirteen households.” The article says the median postal code holds 13 households: “in postal codes so small that the median one holds 13 households.”
  • The hosts say Firebaugh and Schroeder “found people were happier in poorer counties, but only when their own block was well-off.” The study found the county result with each person’s own income and their neighborhood’s income held constant, not only on well-off blocks: “People who lived in poorer counties were happier, again with their own income and their neighborhood’s income held constant.” Pairing the two findings is the article’s reading: “Put the two together and the happiest arrangement in the data is a well-off block inside a poorer county.”
  • The hosts say New Hampshire holds “the lowest official poverty rate in the country at 5.4 percent.” The article gives that figure as the Census Bureau’s 2023-to-2025 average and notes the bureau labels the measure “official+.”
  • The hosts say Sullivan County “runs more than double Rockingham County’s rate,” in the present tense. The article’s figures, about 11.7 percent and 4.8 percent, are from the 2018-to-2022 data, and the article notes that “More than double” is its own division.
  • The hosts call “In most scenarios, AI will likely worsen overall inequality” the post’s conclusion. Those are IMF chief Kristalina Georgieva’s words, which the column quotes: “Her summary: ‘In most scenarios, AI will likely worsen overall inequality.’”

Checked and holding: both columns are bylined Dexter Dow; the Census Bureau ranks New Hampshire’s poverty rate the lowest of any state; the 1995 Harvard survey; the three-sentence quotation beginning “Money does raise well-being,” verbatim; a C$100,000 win followed by an 11 percent rise in neighbors’ bankruptcies, in visible assets such as houses and cars and not in furniture; Norway’s tax records went online in 2001 and the happiness gap grew 29 percent with no paycheck changing; the article’s line that the premium for being on top appears only when the people at the bottom are far enough away to be a number; the Supplemental Poverty Measure rate of 8.0 percent; Moving to Opportunity, where a 13 percentage point drop in neighborhood poverty raised well-being as much as a $13,000 income gap; investors have asked about the newsroom and the author lives in poverty; Pascal’s wager; the Small Business Administration’s “an ownership share and active role in the company,” verbatim, and its note that almost all venture capitalists want a board seat; the IMF’s January 2024 estimate of almost 40 percent of jobs exposed worldwide and about 60 percent in advanced economies; the state’s signature business tax runs on wages, from GSR’s July 24 article; Alaska’s $1,200 Permanent Fund payment in 2026; GSR’s earlier reporting found nobody in Concord measuring the gap.

Read the transcript

Pip: Granite State Report covers New Hampshire, which the Census Bureau has ranked the least-poor state in the country — a fact that turns out to carry more weight than it sounds.

Mara: It does, and Dexter Dow is the writer behind everything in this episode. He traces the research on wealth, neighbors, and well-being, then turns the same ownership question on his own newsroom and on AI. Let’s start with what the data actually say about being rich when everyone else isn’t.

Does Being Rich Feel Better When Everyone Else Is Poor?

Pip: The setup here is a famous 1995 survey that got retold as proof people would rather be on top than be comfortable — and thirty years of research since then complicating that story considerably.

Mara: The post frames it this way: “Money does raise well-being, and it keeps raising it far up the income scale. Falling behind the people around you lowers well-being, and the damage shows up in surveys, in job searches and in bankruptcy filings. Standing above the people around you pays very little.”

Pip: So the scoreboard matters enormously when you’re losing, and almost not at all when you’re winning. That asymmetry is the core of the whole piece.

Mara: The lottery evidence makes it concrete. Canadian researchers tracked wins in postal codes averaging thirteen households and found a C$100,000 win next door drove an eleven percent rise in neighbors’ bankruptcies — only in visible assets, houses and cars, not furniture. Norway went nationwide accidentally: when tax records went online in 2001, the happiness gap between richer and poorer Norwegians widened twenty-nine percent, with no paychecks changing.

Pip: Just knowing the scoreboard exists made people feel worse. Visibility as a hazard — not exactly the argument for radical income transparency.

Mara: The one exception is genuinely unflattering. Firebaugh and Schroeder found people were happier in poorer counties, but only when their own block was well-off. The post’s summary: the on-top premium appears only when poverty is far enough away to be a statistic rather than a neighbor.

Mara: New Hampshire’s stake in all this is direct. The state holds the lowest official poverty rate in the country at 5.4 percent, but the Supplemental Poverty Measure puts it at 8.0 percent, and Sullivan County runs more than double Rockingham County’s rate. The post connects those numbers to the Moving to Opportunity finding — a thirteen-point drop in neighborhood poverty raised well-being as much as a $13,000 income difference.

Pip: Which is a selfish argument for caring about your neighbors’ poverty, dressed up as altruism — and apparently backed by three decades of data. That framing carries into the ownership question next.

Who Owns the Machine — and Who Gets Paid

Pip: The second piece starts with a personal disclosure and turns into a policy argument: investors have approached this newsroom, the writer lives in poverty, and the reason he’s hesitating is a religion he doesn’t actually believe in.

Mara: He describes keeping Christian rules as an atheist on Pascal’s logic, then pivots to what the money would actually cost. The SBA’s definition of venture capital, he notes, is equity offered for “an ownership share and active role in the company,” with almost all venture capitalists wanting a board seat — and a newsroom’s whole product is its judgment about what to print.

Pip: Selling a piece of that judgment to fund the judgment. The tension is real, even if the framing is unusually candid for a publisher talking about his own finances.

Mara: The ownership question then scales up. The IMF estimated in January 2024 that roughly forty percent of jobs worldwide are exposed to AI, with exposure running to about sixty percent in advanced economies. The post’s conclusion: “In most scenarios, AI will likely worsen overall inequality.” For New Hampshire specifically, the state’s main business tax runs on wages, and wages are what automation removes.

Mara: The post points to Alaska’s Permanent Fund as a working model — a $1,200 dividend paid to every resident in 2026, drawn from shared resource wealth. The argument is that machine labor could be treated the same way, and that New Hampshire hasn’t started measuring the gap, let alone closing it.

Pip: Alaska has oil. New Hampshire has low poverty rates and a payroll tax. The analogy is imperfect, but the underlying question — who owns what the machine produces — is the same one the happiness research raised about neighborhoods. Proximity and ownership, all the way down.

Mara: And that’s where the two pieces land together: the data on well-being and the argument about AI both point at the same structural question of who holds the asset and who lives beside the consequences.

Pip: Wealth, neighbors, machines, ownership — it’s the same question at every scale.

Mara: And New Hampshire, sitting at the low-poverty end of the national table, has more riding on how it answers than most places. More next episode.

Transcript as generated by the tool, minus one divider line that carries no speech. The listener’s note above records where it differs from the articles.

Taxes on Business Income Brought In a Third of New Hampshire’s State Tax Collections in Fiscal 2025. The Next-Highest State Was Alaska, at About a Fifth.

Made October 11, 2026 · AI hosts · 4:34

One piece: the Census Bureau’s count of New Hampshire’s fiscal 2025 state tax collections, the third of it that came from taxes on business income, ten straight annual counts with the largest such share of any state, and the individual income line that fell by half in the year the Interest and Dividends Tax repeal took effect.

Articles discussed in this episode

Listener’s note.

  • The hosts say “Dexter Dow decided to find out exactly how.” The article is bylined GSR Staff.
  • The hosts open with “no income tax, no sales tax, and somehow a state budget that still works.” The article does not say New Hampshire has no income tax. It reports collections on the bureau’s individual income line, “where the bureau places taxes on interest and dividends,” of about $183 million in fiscal 2024 and about $91 million in fiscal 2025. The Interest and Dividends Tax was repealed “for tax periods beginning on or after Jan. 1, 2025.” The article counts tax collections. It says nothing about whether the state budget works.
  • The hosts say “The national average was 10.7 percent.” The article says “the figure for the 50 states together was 10.7 percent.” That is the share of all 50 states’ collections combined, not an average of the states’ shares.
  • The hosts call it “a ten-year streak that no other state has matched” and “first place, every year, for a decade.” The article covers the bureau’s counts from “fiscal 2016 through fiscal 2025, the 10 years in this analysis.” It did not look before fiscal 2016, so it does not say when the run began.
  • The hosts conclude that the business income share is “structural, not a one-year blip.” The article draws no such conclusion. It quotes the bureau’s warning about reading rankings and adds: “A large share on one line also reflects how little a state collects on others.”
  • In closing, the hosts describe “A state that funds itself mostly through business income.” The article’s figure is 32.9 percent of state tax collections, a third and not most, and it covers state taxes only: “Local governments are left out, so the property taxes that towns, cities, school districts and counties raise on their own are not in these figures.”
  • The hosts say the bureau’s next annual count “will be the first to show a full year without the Interest and Dividends Tax.” The article says “Fiscal 2026, which began July 1, 2025, is the first state fiscal year to fall entirely after the repeal took effect.” It does not predict what that count will show, and it notes that returns for the 2024 tax year were still due after the repeal.

Checked and holding: the quotation that “In each of the bureau’s 10 annual counts from fiscal 2016 through fiscal 2025, no state had a larger share there,” verbatim; $1.11 billion of $3.37 billion in fiscal 2025 state tax collections, 32.9 percent, on the line the bureau calls corporation net income taxes; Alaska next at 21.7 percent; the general sales tax and the individual income tax brought in 64.6 percent of all state tax collections nationally and are zero or small in New Hampshire; the business income line was $700.2 million in fiscal 2016, 25.4 percent of the total; it peaked at $1,271.6 million in fiscal 2023, 36.7 percent; it fell 8.8 percent from fiscal 2024 to fiscal 2025; it was about 59 percent larger in fiscal 2025 than in fiscal 2016, while total collections were about 22 percent larger; the bureau’s methodology warning on rankings and per capita statistics, verbatim; the individual income line fell by half, from about $183 million to about $91 million; the repeal took effect for tax periods beginning on or after Jan. 1, 2025, and fiscal 2025 straddled the change; the other five New England states collected from 26.9 percent to 53.0 percent of their state taxes on the individual income line, and all five had a general sales tax; New Hampshire’s individual income line was 2.7 percent of its collections; the count leaves out local property taxes, and the article points to the property tax explainer linked above.

Read the transcript

Pip: New Hampshire has always done taxes its own way — no income tax, no sales tax, and somehow a state budget that still works. Dexter Dow decided to find out exactly how, and the Census Bureau's numbers are pretty clarifying.

Mara: The episode is built around one big data story: where New Hampshire's state tax money actually comes from, and what a decade of Census Bureau figures reveal about how unusual that mix really is.

Pip: Let's start with the business income numbers, because they are genuinely striking.

New Hampshire's Business Income Dominance

Mara: The question here is straightforward: when New Hampshire doesn't have a broad income tax or a sales tax, what fills the gap — and how does that look compared to every other state?

Pip: The Census Bureau's own count answers that directly. The setup is a ten-year streak that no other state has matched, and the figure for fiscal 2025 puts it plainly: "In each of the bureau's 10 annual counts from fiscal 2016 through fiscal 2025, no state had a larger share there."

Mara: What that means in practice is that nearly a third of every dollar New Hampshire's state government collected in taxes came from business income — $1.11 billion out of $3.37 billion total. Alaska was the next-closest state at 21.7 percent. The national average was 10.7 percent.

Pip: And part of why the share looks so large is what's missing from the denominator. The two lines that drove 64.6 percent of all state tax collections nationally — the general sales tax and the broad individual income tax — are zero or negligible in New Hampshire. So business income doesn't just lead; it leads in a field where the usual frontrunners didn't show up.

Mara: The business income line has also grown faster than collections overall. In fiscal 2016 it was $700 million, about 25 percent of the total. By fiscal 2023 it peaked at $1.27 billion and 36.7 percent. It pulled back in fiscal 2025, down 8.8 percent from the prior year, but the ten-year trend is still up roughly 59 percent while total collections rose about 22 percent.

Pip: The Census Bureau is careful to say rankings can mislead — its methodology notes that "analysis based on rankings or per capita statistics can be misleading and misinterpreted because of subtle yet important differences in state government organization and economic structure." Fair enough. But first place, every year, for a decade, is still first place.

Mara: One other shift shows up in the fiscal 2025 data: the individual income line, where the bureau places taxes on interest and dividends, fell by half — from $183 million in fiscal 2024 to $91 million. That's the year New Hampshire's Interest and Dividends Tax repeal took effect for periods beginning January 1, 2025. Fiscal 2025 straddled the change, so the drop is partial; fiscal 2026 will be the first full year without it.

Pip: New England context makes the picture even sharper. Every other New England state collected between 27 and 53 percent of its state taxes on the individual income line, and all five had a general sales tax. New Hampshire had neither in any meaningful amount — its individual income line was 2.7 percent of collections.

Mara: The broader picture — what these numbers don't capture, including local property taxes raised by towns and school districts — is territory the piece flags explicitly, pointing to earlier Granite State Report coverage on why New Hampshire property tax bills look the way they do.

Pip: So the state's tax mix is genuinely unusual, not just by New England standards but nationally — and the business income dominance is structural, not a one-year blip.

Mara: That's the decade of data in one sentence.

Pip: A state that funds itself mostly through business income, with no sales tax and a shrinking income line — that's a fiscal structure worth watching closely.

Mara: The Census Bureau's next annual count will be the first to show a full year without the Interest and Dividends Tax. That'll be the real test of what the mix looks like going forward.

Transcript as generated by the tool, minus two divider lines that carry no speech. The listener’s note above records where it differs from the articles.

New Hampshire Policy And Change

Made October 11, 2026 · AI hosts · 8:17

Four pieces in one episode: the House Consent Calendar and the ten members who can pull a bill off it, New Hampshire’s union membership rate, Lake Winnipesaukee’s ice-out record since 1887, and the 170,000 online sign-ins to House hearings that no rule requires a committee to answer.

Articles discussed in this episode

Listener’s note.

  • The hosts open with what “Dexter Dow keeps finding.” Two of the four articles carry his byline: “Win Through Actions, Not Argument” and the online testimony piece. The union membership and ice-out articles are bylined GSR Staff.
  • The hosts say the House “has essentially institutionalized” Robert Greene’s ninth law in Rule 52. The article is more guarded: “What the record shows is not quite what Greene predicts, though, and the difference is the whole story.” Its point is that a consent vote certifies an argument that already took place in committee.
  • The hosts say that in March 2026 “seventy-four bills died that way,” right after describing a bill pulled off the Consent Calendar and sent to the end of the Regular Calendar. The article does not say those 74 bills had been removed from the Consent Calendar. It says “in March 2026 the House faced hundreds of bills against a deadline, ordered the calendar so favored bills went first, and adjourned with 74 bills never voted on. They died of time.”
  • The hosts say New Hampshire’s union membership rate was “lowest in New England both years measured.” The two years are 2024 and 2025, the years in the state table the bureau released Feb. 18, 2026. It was not the lowest in every year the article covers: “Maine’s rate was 9.2 percent in both 2022 and 2023, below New Hampshire’s both years, and then 13.1 percent in 2024.”
  • The hosts say “since, at least four in sixteen springs.” The article says “In the springs since, the lake was declared open in March at least four times.” It does not count the springs, and 2010 through 2026 is 17. The sixteen belongs to a different sentence: “NHPR wrote that the four earliest ice-out days had all come in the previous sixteen years.”
  • The hosts say House Bill 1114 “died on a 123-207 vote.” The article says “The House laid it on the table by voice vote on March 5, 2026, refused to take it back up 123-207 a week later, and let it die when the session ended.” The 123-207 vote was on taking the bill off the table, not on the bill.
  • The hosts say the 2023 law “explicitly excluded the Legislature and left towns to their own discretion.” The article says of paragraph IV, “It excludes the General Court, either house and their committees.” Towns are not named there. On local boards, the article says Granite State Report “found nothing in the section that requires a town, city or school board to let the public join remotely.”
  • In closing, the hosts say three of the episode’s threads “land in the same place,” a system that collects input “without guaranteeing anyone has to respond to it,” and they count “a union membership count” among them. The union article makes no such argument. It is an explainer on a federal survey. The point about input that nobody is obliged to answer belongs to the online testimony piece.

Checked and holding: the quotation on consent as “a certificate that the argument already ended,” verbatim; a bill reaches the Consent Calendar only if every committee member present in executive session voted the same way, Republicans and Democrats alike; ten members can remove a bill, and a removed bill is taken up at the conclusion of the Regular Calendar; 60,000 of New Hampshire’s 676,000 employed wage and salary workers were union members in 2025, 8.9 percent; the 2024 rate was 9.2 percent, with Maine next lowest at 13.1 percent; the bureau’s caution that “state union membership estimates for 2025 should be interpreted with caution,” verbatim, and the 11-month year after the October 2025 survey was not collected during the federal shutdown; the rate fell from 10.1 percent in 2022 to 9.3, 9.2 and 8.9 percent; the state table has no public-private split, and the 2025 national rates were 32.9 percent for public-sector workers and 5.9 percent for private-sector workers; the ice-out record goes back to 1887 and the USGS compilation covers 122 years; the average fell near April 20; the only two March ice-outs in the federal table were 1921 and 1946; the lake has been declared open in March at least four times since 2010; the earliest on record is March 17, 2024, called by Matthew Gianunzio, one day earlier than the 2016 mark; Dave Emerson told NHPR he called ice-in on Feb. 9 that winter and the ice began melting 24 hours later; Lake Sunapee’s records begin in 1869, and its average moved about seven days against about five for Winnipesaukee over the same two 30-year windows; both USGS caveats on ice-out definitions, verbatim; NHPR’s April 2026 line that the four earliest ice-out days had all come in the previous sixteen years; the link to “Warming Winters, Rising Waters”; more than 170,000 online sign-ins in 2025 and Citizens Count’s comparison across 963 hearings; the passage on 64 percent, a coin flip and one in three, verbatim from the article’s summary of Citizens Count’s analysis; the article’s caution that the number “does not prove anyone ignored anyone”; House rules require committee minutes to note the important points witnesses make, not what the committee made of them; House Bill 1114 would have required committees to preserve written public comment and report how it shaped their recommendations; the 2023 law requires state boards that meet remotely to let the public take part remotely; NHMA counsel Jonathan Cowal’s “entirely the choice of the municipality”; the closing quotation that “A click is not organizing, and a sign-in is not power,” verbatim.

Read the transcript

Pip: Granite State Report covers the kind of New Hampshire politics that happens before anyone gets to argue — which, as Dexter Dow keeps finding, is most of it.

Mara: Today we're moving through four territories: how the House disposes of bills in silence, where New Hampshire sits on union membership, what Lake Winnipesaukee's ice-out record is telling us, and what 170,000 online sign-ins actually buy a citizen.

Pip: Let's start with the silence — and the ten people who can break it.

The Consent Calendar's Quiet Power

Mara: The New Hampshire House moves hundreds of bills a year through a single motion with no debate allowed. The post frames it around Robert Greene's ninth law — win through actions, not argument — and the House has essentially institutionalized that principle in Rule 52.

Pip: The post puts it directly: "Consent is not the absence of argument. It is a certificate that the argument already ended, unanimously, in a room most people never enter."

Mara: That's the key design detail. A bill reaches the Consent Calendar only after every committee member present voted the same way — not a majority, everyone. Republicans and Democrats together.

Pip: So the floor debate everyone pictures is mostly theater for a decision already laminated in committee. The action happened days earlier.

Mara: And the escape hatch is unusually cheap — ten members can pull a bill off. But the post flags the hidden cost: a removed bill goes last on the Regular Calendar, and on a heavy session day, last is where the clock runs out. In March 2026, seventy-four bills died that way.

Pip: Ten signatures to force a debate, and the reward might be watching your bill expire in the parking lot.

Mara: Which lands us on labor — a different kind of record that's also been quietly moving in one direction.

New Hampshire's Union Membership Floor

Mara: The Bureau of Labor Statistics estimated sixty thousand of New Hampshire's six hundred seventy-six thousand employed wage and salary workers belonged to a union in 2025 — a rate of 8.9 percent, lowest in New England both years measured.

Pip: Maine, the next lowest in 2024, sat at 13.1 percent. New Hampshire wasn't close to the regional pack.

Mara: The BLS itself flags a caution here. Its release states that "state union membership estimates for 2025 should be interpreted with caution" because October data were lost to a federal government shutdown, leaving annual figures built from eleven months instead of twelve.

Pip: A federal data gap, inside a labor story, about a state at the bottom of a regional table. The irony practically footnotes itself.

Mara: The fourteen-year table shows the rate fell three consecutive years, from 10.1 percent in 2022 to 8.9 percent in 2025. The post also covers what the state figures can't show — there's no public-private split for New Hampshire, though nationally the gap is enormous: 32.9 percent for public-sector workers versus 5.9 percent for private.

Pip: From a labor floor to a literal waterline — the ice is moving too.

Winnipesaukee's Shrinking Winter

Pip: Lake Winnipesaukee has an ice-out record stretching back to 1887, and the post uses a USGS compilation of 122 years to establish what "normal" looked like before asking what's changed since.

Mara: Across those 122 years, the average ice-out fell around April 20. The USGS report found only two March ice-outs in that entire span — 1921 and 1946.

Pip: Two March calls in a century and a quarter. That's the baseline.

Mara: Since 2010, the lake has been declared open in March at least four times. The record fell on March 17, 2024, when pilot Matthew Gianunzio made the call — one day earlier than the previous record set in 2016. Dave Emerson, who owns Emerson Aviation, told NHPR he had called ice-in on February 9 that winter and that the ice began melting just twenty-four hours later, something he said he had never seen.

Pip: The federal table also covers Lake Sunapee, records going back to 1869. Over matching thirty-year windows, Sunapee's average ice-out moved about seven days earlier. Winnipesaukee shifted about five.

Mara: The post is careful about what a single date can prove. The USGS notes that ice-out definitions "can vary over time and between observers" and that the exact definition "is not known with confidence in most cases." But the direction is hard to argue with: before 2010, two March calls in 122 years; since, at least four in sixteen springs.

Pip: NHPR's April 2026 report put it plainly — the four earliest ice-out days on record have all come in the last sixteen years. The post connects this to a wider Granite State Report series on climate, "Warming Winters, Rising Waters."

Mara: From a lake that can't hold its ice to a legislature that can't quite hold its testimony — the access question is next.

170,000 Sign-Ins, No Required Answer

Pip: New Hampshire built an online portal for House testimony, logged more than 170,000 sign-ins in 2025 across 963 hearings, and has never written down what committees owe the people who used it.

Mara: Citizens Count analyzed every sign-in from the 2025 session and compared each hearing's online majority with the committee's recommendation. The finding runs backward: "When fewer than 10 people signed in, committees matched the online majority 64 percent of the time. From 10 to 99, it was close to a coin flip. At 100 or more, about one in three."

Pip: So more people showing up in the portal correlated with less agreement from the committee. Turnout as anti-signal.

Mara: The post is careful not to call that ignoring anyone — committees weigh bill text, fiscal notes, caucus positions, their own judgment. But the gap in the rules is real. House rules require committee minutes to note important points witnesses make. They don't require any account of what the committee did with the online record.

Pip: House Bill 1114 would have fixed exactly that — required committees to preserve written public comment and explain how it shaped their recommendations. It died on a 123-207 vote.

Mara: The access gap extends to local meetings too. State law makes remote public participation entirely optional for selectboards and school boards. A 2023 law required state boards meeting remotely to let the public participate remotely — but explicitly excluded the Legislature and left towns to their own discretion. The post quotes NHMA counsel Jonathan Cowal: continuing remote public access is "entirely the choice of the municipality."

Pip: The post's conclusion is blunt: "A click is not organizing, and a sign-in is not power. Input carries weight when someone is obliged to answer it, and New Hampshire has not written that obligation."

Mara: Three of today's threads land in the same place — a system that collects input, whether it's committee testimony, a consent calendar removal, or a union membership count, without guaranteeing anyone has to respond to it.

Pip: The ice-out record doesn't wait for a response. Next episode, we'll see what else isn't waiting.

Transcript as generated by the tool, unedited. The listener’s note above records where it differs from the articles.

New Hampshire By The Numbers

Made October 11, 2026 · AI hosts · 13:25

A tour of more than twenty GSR explainers: the Right-to-Know request builder, Election Day’s holiday status, the school tax cap court orders, the House’s size, pay and consent calendar, the state’s tax mix and amendment rule, and the 1788 ratification. The second half covers ice-out, moose, unions, rent, broadband, poverty, veterans’ care, school enrollment, radon, greenhouse cannabis, press law, wiretaps, the license plate case, small police departments and UFO footage.

Articles discussed in this episode

Listener’s note.

  • The hosts open with “Dexter Dow has been busy.” Two of the 24 articles carry his byline: the online testimony piece and “Win Through Actions, Not Argument.” The GSR Tools page is credited to Granite State Report, and the other 21 are bylined GSR Staff.
  • The hosts quote RSA 91-A:4 as saying “Every citizen may inspect all governmental records in a public body’s possession, custody, or control, and copy them, except as prohibited by statute or RSA 91-A:5.” That sentence is not in the statute or in any Granite State Report article. The GSR Tools post says only that the builder writes a request that cites RSA 91-A:4. The statute, RSA 91-A:4, I, reads: “Every citizen during the regular or business hours of all public bodies or agencies, and on the regular business premises of such public bodies or agencies, has the right to inspect all governmental records in the possession, custody, or control of such public bodies or agencies, including minutes of meetings of the public bodies, and to copy and make memoranda or abstracts of the records or minutes so inspected, except as otherwise prohibited by statute or RSA 91-A:5.”
  • The hosts say the GSR Tools post “flags that under paragraph IX, the fee waiver for public-interest disclosure expressly excludes media requestors.” The GSR Tools post says nothing about paragraph IX, fees or media requesters. Paragraph IX governs waivers of the per-communication charge in paragraph VIII; it does not change who may see records, and every person has the same right of access under RSA 91-A. Granite State Report’s reporting treats the media clause as unsettled: “Seven Laws Changed New Hampshire’s Right-to-Know Statute Since 2024” says the statute does not settle what the carve-out does.
  • The hosts say “Eight bills to give that holiday real meaning have died since 2014.” The article says “Between 2014 and 2025 at least eight bills proposed to close public offices on election days, add primaries to the list, or give workers time to vote. None became law.” The hosts drop “at least.”
  • The hosts say the 1788 ratification “cleared its own supermajority by exactly ten votes.” The article describes no supermajority. The convention voted 57 to 47, and “The convention’s journal records 57 yeas and 47 nays, a majority of 10.” The threshold the article names is Article VII’s nine states: the vote “met the threshold the Constitution set for itself.” A simple majority of the convention decided it.
  • The hosts say New Hampshire’s corporation net income share was “the highest share of any state for the tenth consecutive year.” The article says New Hampshire “has held the top spot on that measure in every one of the bureau’s annual counts from fiscal 2016 through fiscal 2025, the 10 years in this analysis.” The article did not look before fiscal 2016, so it does not say the run began there.
  • The hosts say of the remote-participation rule in RSA 91-A:2, IV that “The Legislature and every town are explicitly excluded from that requirement.” The article says paragraph IV “exempts the General Court, both chambers and every committee of either house.” Towns are not named in any exclusion. They fall under paragraph III, and the article says Granite State Report “found nothing in the section that requires a town, city or school board to let the public join remotely.”
  • The hosts say the bill that would have required committees to explain what they did with online testimony “died on a 123-207 vote.” The article says the House “laid it on the table by voice vote on March 5, 2026, refused to take it back up 123-207 a week later, and let it die when the session ended.” The 123-207 vote was on taking the bill off the table, not on the bill.
  • The hosts say “the state’s own announcements have used figures ranging from 3,000 to 4,000 depending on which release you read.” The article says the announcements said the population “is estimated to be about 3,000 animals” or that New Hampshire “has about 3,300 moose.” The 3,000 to 4,000 range comes from the department’s undated moose profile page: “about 3,000-4,000.”
  • The hosts say community care’s 38.2 percent share was “fourth-highest nationally, partly because the state has no full-service VA hospital.” The article ranks it fourth “Among the 50 states” (Guam was higher, at 58.1 percent) and says “The report itself does not explain any state’s share, and the overlap is Granite State Report’s observation, not a finding by the VA.” The hosts turn an observed overlap into a cause.
  • The hosts describe the Mortgage Specialists case as involving “a redacted loan chart.” The article says the website “linked to a document that purported to show the company’s 2007 loan figures” and quotes the court on the “Loan Chart.” It never says the chart was redacted.
  • The hosts say Wooley v. Maynard “has been cited in 1,262 opinions since.” The article says “As of October 5, 2026, CourtListener, a free case-law database, listed 1,262 opinions citing Wooley v. Maynard.” The count is one database’s, on one date.
  • The hosts refer to “New Hampshire’s 200 law enforcement agencies.” The article says “For 2024, 200 New Hampshire agencies answered with a number” and that the FBI’s explorer “listed 211 New Hampshire agencies.” 200 is the count of agencies with a 2024 figure, not the total.

Checked and holding: the GSR Tools post offers a free, in-browser Right-to-Know request builder that cites RSA 91-A:4 and needs no form; it computes the five-business-day deadline skipping weekends and RSA 288:1 holidays; the Oct. 5, 2026 correction made the builder apply RSA 288:2 to holidays falling on a Sunday; Election Day is on the RSA 288:1 list and has been a legal holiday since 1891; state offices stay open; the 1913 mill law makes requiring mill or factory work on a legal holiday a misdemeanor for a person and a felony for a company; the 2025 bill came out of committee 9-7 to pass and lost on the floor 166-205; the school tax cap question got past a superior court judge, one Supreme Court justice and four justices in 12 days; Judge St. Hilaire’s quotation on publications, radio addresses and public hearing commentary; RSA 32:5-i allows a hearing and requires none; neither Supreme Court order states reasons; more than 170,000 online sign-ins in 2025; Citizens Count’s about one-in-three match at 100 or more sign-ins; the Harvard authors’ quotation that no U.S. government has conferred decision-making power in an electronic venue; 400 seats, 1,377,529 residents, 3,444 per seat, the smallest ratio of any state chamber; $200 per two-year term in the constitution; four proposals from 2019 through 2026 to change size or pay died in the House; consent calendar placement takes a unanimous committee vote, ten members can remove a bill, and a removed bill goes to the end of the Regular Calendar; $3.37 billion in fiscal 2025 state tax collections, $1.11 billion or 32.9 percent on corporation net income, Alaska next at 21.7 percent; the individual income line fell by half the year the Interest and Dividends Tax repeal took effect; amendments need two-thirds of those voting on the question; nine won a majority and failed from 1986 through 2024; the 2024 retirement age amendment drew 65.6 percent and fell about 7,400 votes short; 57 to 47 in Concord on June 21, 1788, the ninth ratification under Article VII; the February convention adjourned rather than lose; a six-delegate switch would have reversed it; the USGS table covers 122 springs, 1887 through 2008, with two March ice-outs; at least four March ice-outs since 2010; earliest on record March 17, 2024; the moose herd peaked at 7,000 to 8,000 in the late 1990s and is about 3,000 now; 88 percent of radio-marked calf deaths tied to moderate or severe winter tick infestations; union membership 9.2 percent in 2024 and 8.9 percent in 2025, lowest in New England both years, with the bureau’s caution on 2025 state figures after the October shutdown gap; statewide median two-bedroom $1,833 in 2024, up 58 percent from 2015; Lebanon $2,923 and Coos $1,161; in every county the median two-bedroom exceeded what the county’s median renter income could afford at 30 percent; 13.4 percent of Coos households and 4.9 percent in Rockingham without an internet subscription; Coos poverty 13.8 percent, nearly double the state’s 7.3 percent, the lowest estimated state rate for 18 straight years; VA spending of $1.44 billion in fiscal 2025 with community care at 38.2 percent of medical spending; public school enrollment down 20.1 percent from 2000 to 2023, the largest drop of any state; more than a third of homes tested for radon at or above 4.0 pCi/L; SB 468 became law on the Aug. 19, 2026 veto override and lets alternative treatment centers ask to grow in greenhouses, under department rules with no deadline; Mortgage Specialists v. Implode-Explode (2010), its quotation on lawfully obtained information, and “no less a member of the press”; the Assange case turned on how he obtained the material; two state-court wiretaps in ten federal reports, both for 2019 and both drug cases, and 24 federal orders from the District of New Hampshire; George Maynard served 15 days in jail in 1975 rather than pay fines, and the Supreme Court ruled for him in 1977; more than two-thirds of reporting agencies had 10 or fewer full-time officers in 2024, median six, and since 2023 every agency must keep an internal affairs program and report certain cases to a state review committee; the Air Force’s 1965 Exeter file and the newsroom’s use of it as the standard for every clip; NHMA counsel’s “entirely the choice of the municipality”; state boards meeting remotely must let the public take part remotely under RSA 91-A:2, IV.

Read the transcript

Pip: Granite State Report covers the state where your license plate is legally required to tell you how to feel about death, and your government is legally required to ignore your opinion about it. Dexter Dow has been busy.

Mara: This episode covers the full range of what that means in practice: tools for filing records requests, the school tax cap's journey through three court orders, how New Hampshire's legislature is structured and funded, what the state's tax mix looks like, and how its constitution gets changed.

Pip: Plus moose, radon, rent, veterans, Assange, a 1975 Jehovah's Witness, and 170,000 sign-ins that nobody had to answer. Let's start with state finances and governance.

State Finances And Governance

Pip: New Hampshire's government produces a lot of paper, and the question this segment is about is who gets to read it, who gets to vote on it, and whether any of it actually changes anything.

Mara: Starting with the records side: the GSR Tools post lays out a free browser-based request builder for New Hampshire's Right-to-Know law. The statute it cites, RSA 91-A:4, says plainly: "Every citizen may inspect all governmental records in a public body's possession, custody, or control, and copy them, except as prohibited by statute or RSA 91-A:5."

Pip: So the right is universal, the form is nonexistent, and the tool fills the gap. Worth noting: the post flags that under paragraph IX, the fee waiver for public-interest disclosure expressly excludes media requestors. Reporters get no extra door.

Mara: The tool also computes the five-business-day response deadline, accounting for weekends and legal holidays under RSA 288:1, and a correction issued October 5th fixed the handling of holidays that fall on Sundays under RSA 288:2.

Pip: Which connects directly to the election-day post, since Election Day is on that same RSA 288:1 list. It has been a legal holiday since 1891, state offices stay open through it, and a 1913 mill law makes requiring factory work on any legal holiday a misdemeanor for a person and a felony for a company.

Mara: Eight bills to give that holiday real meaning have died since 2014. The most recent, in 2025, came out of committee with a 9-7 recommendation to pass and was defeated on the House floor 166-205.

Pip: The school tax cap story follows a similar pattern of law on paper, friction in practice. The question survived a superior court judge, a single Supreme Court justice, and four justices of the full court in twelve days.

Mara: The superior court's reasoning is the key detail. Judge St. Hilaire wrote that confusion in the ballot question "can be addressed via appropriate publications, radio addresses, and public hearing commentary." But the statute that put the question on the ballot, RSA 32:5-i, says only that nothing in the section shall prohibit a hearing. It does not require one.

Pip: So the judge pointed to a safeguard the law made optional, and neither Supreme Court order gave reasons at all.

Mara: The online testimony post adds the structural layer. In 2025, people signed in to House hearings more than 170,000 times, and Citizens Count found that when 100 or more people signed in, committees went the way of the online majority about a third of the time.

Pip: The research literature the post cites is unambiguous: Harvard scholars found that "no US government has conferred actual decision-making power to participants in an electronic venue." A click is not organizing.

Mara: The post on the House's size and pay puts numbers to the chamber doing all this. New Hampshire has 400 seats for 1,377,529 residents, 3,444 per seat, the smallest ratio of any state lower chamber. Members are paid $200 for a two-year term, written into the constitution. Four proposals to change either number, from 2019 through 2026, each died in the House.

Pip: The consent calendar post explains how hundreds of those bills move without debate. A unanimous committee vote puts a bill on the calendar; ten members can pull it off, but it goes to the back of the day.

Mara: On the tax side, the Census Bureau counted $3.37 billion in New Hampshire state tax collections for fiscal 2025. The largest single line was corporation net income taxes at $1.11 billion, 32.9 percent of the total, the highest share of any state for the tenth consecutive year. Alaska was next at 21.7 percent.

Pip: And the individual income line fell by half in fiscal 2025, the year the Interest and Dividends Tax repeal took effect.

Mara: The constitutional amendment post explains why changing any of this is hard. An amendment needs two-thirds of voters who answer the question. From 1986 through 2024, nine amendments won a majority and still failed. The 2024 judicial retirement age question got 65.6 percent, about 7,400 votes short of the threshold.

Pip: And New Hampshire's ratification of the federal Constitution in 1788 cleared its own supermajority by exactly ten votes, after the convention adjourned rather than lose its first attempt in February.

Mara: The 57-to-47 vote in Concord on June 21, 1788, was the ninth ratification, the number Article VII required. Six delegates switching would have reversed it.

Pip: The pattern holds across two centuries: the margins that matter in New Hampshire tend to be very small, and the rules around them very specific. That precision runs through the public services side of the ledger too.

Public Services And Living Costs

Pip: From constitutional thresholds to daily conditions: what does living in New Hampshire actually cost, and what's the state of the things people depend on?

Mara: Lake Winnipesaukee's ice-out record frames the environmental baseline. A USGS compilation covering 122 springs from 1887 through 2008 found only two March ice-out dates in that entire span. Since 2010, the lake has been declared open in March at least four times, with the earliest on record coming March 17, 2024.

Pip: The moose herd tells a parallel story of a number that keeps moving. The herd peaked at 7,000 to 8,000 in the late 1990s and stands at roughly 3,000 now, though the state's own announcements have used figures ranging from 3,000 to 4,000 depending on which release you read.

Mara: Researchers tracking radio-marked calves found that 88 percent of the deaths they examined were linked to moderate or severe winter tick infestations. The post on union membership adds a labor dimension: New Hampshire had the lowest union membership rate in New England in both 2024 and 2025, at 9.2 and 8.9 percent respectively, though the bureau flagged the 2025 state figures for caution due to missing October data from the federal shutdown.

Pip: On housing, the state's 2024 rent survey put the statewide median two-bedroom at $1,833, up 58 percent from 2015. Lebanon's median was $2,923; Coos County's was $1,161. In every county, the median two-bedroom cost more than a household at the county's median renter income could afford under the standard 30-percent threshold.

Mara: The broadband and poverty posts both show the same north-south divide. Census estimates put 13.4 percent of Coos County households without an internet subscription, against 4.9 percent in Rockingham. The poverty rate in Coos was 13.8 percent in 2024, nearly double the statewide 7.3 percent, which was itself the lowest estimated rate of any state for the eighteenth consecutive year.

Pip: The VA spending and school enrollment numbers round out the picture. The VA spent $1.44 billion in New Hampshire in fiscal 2025, with community care making up 38.2 percent of medical spending, fourth-highest nationally, partly because the state has no full-service VA hospital. And public school enrollment fell 20.1 percent from 2000 to 2023, the largest drop of any state.

Mara: The radon post and the medical cannabis law connect to how the state manages risk. More than a third of New Hampshire homes tested for radon came back at or above the federal action level of 4.0 picocuries per liter. And SB 468, overriding a veto on August 19, 2026, now lets alternative treatment centers ask to grow cannabis in greenhouses, pending rules the Health Department has no deadline to write.

Pip: Rights and the rules around them are where all of this lands next.

Rights, Courts, And Speech

Pip: New Hampshire has a long tradition of asking who exactly counts as the press, who can be forced to speak, and what happens when the government decides the answer is nobody you'd expect.

Mara: The Assange and Snowden analysis anchors this segment. The New Hampshire Supreme Court's 2010 ruling in Mortgage Specialists v. Implode-Explode Heavy Industries is the local touchstone. The court held that "the lawfulness of publishing information does not depend upon the nature of the information itself, but, rather, upon whether the information was obtained lawfully by the publisher."

Pip: That case involved a mortgage-industry website, a redacted loan chart, and a state banking confidentiality law. The court said a website is no less a member of the press. The federal Assange prosecution, by contrast, argued that how he obtained the material was the crime.

Mara: The wiretap post adds the surveillance layer. In the ten annual federal wiretap reports covering 2016 through 2025, New Hampshire superior court judges appear twice, both in 2019, both drug cases. Federal judges in the District of New Hampshire account for 24 orders over the same period.

Pip: The Wooley v. Maynard case is the compelled-speech anchor. George Maynard served 15 days in jail in 1975 rather than pay fines for covering "Live Free or Die" on his license plate. The Supreme Court ruled for him in 1977, and the case has been cited in 1,262 opinions since.

Mara: The police accountability post connects to who enforces the rules. More than two-thirds of New Hampshire's 200 law enforcement agencies reported 10 or fewer full-time officers in 2024. The median was six. Since 2023, state law has required every agency, regardless of size, to maintain a written internal affairs program and report certain complaints to a state review committee.

Pip: And the UFO footage post, which is exactly what it sounds like, makes the evidentiary standard explicit: the Air Force's 1965 Exeter case file shows what checking a claim actually requires. The newsroom applies the same method to every clip it receives. That standard of documentation connects back to where we started.

Online Testimony And Civic Participation

Pip: The online testimony post sits at the intersection of governance and civic institutions, so it's worth pulling out its specific claim about what the law requires.

Mara: The NHMA's legal counsel told local officials that continuing remote public access is "entirely the choice of the municipality." State boards meeting remotely must let the public participate remotely under RSA 91-A:2, IV. The Legislature and every town are explicitly excluded from that requirement.

Pip: So the state holds itself to a floor it doesn't extend to the places most people actually encounter government. The bill that would have required committees to explain what they did with online testimony died on a 123-207 vote. The tools exist; the obligation doesn't.

Pip: The thread across all of this is the gap between the rule on paper and the rule in practice. New Hampshire has a right-to-know law, a legal holiday on Election Day, a constitutional amendment process, and 170,000 sign-ins. The question each post asks is what any of it actually requires anyone to do.

Mara: Next episode will likely bring more of the same: the state's records, its numbers, and the distance between what the statute says and what happens when you try to use it.

Transcript as generated by the tool, unedited. The listener’s note above records where it differs from the articles.

New Hampshire Constitutional Battles

Made October 11, 2026 · AI hosts · 6:06

Two pieces in one episode: the 57-to-47 vote in Concord that made New Hampshire the ninth state to ratify the Constitution, and the two-thirds rule that has defeated nine state constitutional amendments that won a majority of voters since 1986.

Articles discussed in this episode

Listener’s note.

  • The hosts say “Dexter Dow has two pieces this week.” The ratification and amendment articles are bylined GSR Staff. The convention-question piece they mention is Dexter Dow’s.
  • The hosts say John Quincy Adams was “watching from Massachusetts.” The ratification article says “John Quincy Adams of Massachusetts, who watched the debates, wrote in his diary…” He was from Massachusetts and watched the debates; the article does not place him in Massachusetts while he watched. The quoted fragment itself is verbatim.
  • The hosts say the Exeter session “never even came to a vote,” then give its 56-to-51 adjournment vote. The article says the Federalists “concluded they did not have the votes and moved to adjourn instead,” and that motion was voted on. The first session never voted on ratification; it did vote.
  • The hosts say “The intervening months changed enough minds that the June vote held.” The article gives no reason for the shift. It reports that Pierse Long wrote the Federalists had counted on a majority of one at most and “to our surprise had a majority of Eleaven.”
  • The hosts say of the twelve recommended amendments, “And yet several were” adopted. The article is narrower: “Several of those ideas reached the Bill of Rights in different words.” The amendments themselves were not adopted as written.
  • The hosts read a quotation from the amendments article that is not verbatim: they splice the first two sentences together with a dash and drop the attribution. The article says “The yes side won, 452,307 votes to 237,221, according to the certified results Ballotpedia reports. That was 65.6 percent. The amendment failed, and the retirement age stayed at 70.”
  • The hosts say a new register of probate amendment “is on the” 2026 ballot as a flat fact. The article attributes it and dates it: “As published in October 2026, Ballotpedia lists a second amendment to eliminate the office, CACR 13 of 2026, on the Nov. 3, 2026 ballot.”

Checked and holding: the opening quotation, verbatim, on the 57-to-47 vote at 1 p.m. on Saturday, June 21, 1788, in Concord, ninth state; nine as the Article VII threshold; a 10-vote margin of 104 cast, and a six-delegate switch flips it (51 to 53); Federalist strength estimated at 30 to 48 of the 108 delegates in attendance, as the documentary history’s editors put it; the 56-to-51 adjournment vote and the return in June; the Adams fragment “was the offspring of the fears of the federal party” is verbatim; the twelve recommendations foreshadowed the First and Second Amendments among others; the Eleventh and Twelfth recommendations quoted verbatim; Tobias Lear wrote Washington the next day, June 22, and the paraphrase of his letter is fair; the companion piece on the decennial convention question (published Sept. 15, 2026) and its majority threshold; the 2024 question on raising judges’ retirement age from 70 to 75; 452,307 to 237,221, 65.6 percent, failed; a margin of about 215,000 (215,086); Part II, Article 100 and two-thirds of those voting on the question; 459,685 needed and about 7,400 short; House 321 to 27 and Senate 22 to 1; nine majority failures from 1986 through 2024 at 55.0 to 65.6 percent; six of twenty adopted; court-rules amendments failed in 2002, 2004 and 2012; the register of probate amendment failed at 62.9 percent in 2022; one no vote cancels two yes votes and a blank counts for neither; 1788 to 2024 is 236 years.

Read the transcript

Pip: Granite State Report is out here doing the kind of constitutional arithmetic most civics classes skip — the kind where the margin is ten votes and the stakes are a country.

Mara: Dexter Dow has two pieces this week, and together they trace how hard it is to change fundamental law in New Hampshire — whether you're ratifying a constitution in 1788 or amending one in 2024.

Pip: Turns out "supermajority required" is a sentence that has been quietly defeating popular ideas for a very long time.

Mara: Let's start with the ratification story — how New Hampshire became the ninth state, and how close it came to not being that at all.

New Hampshire's Ten-Vote Moment

Pip: The frame here is a single afternoon in Concord, June 21, 1788 — and what makes it remarkable is not just that New Hampshire ratified, but how narrowly, and how deliberately the Federalists maneuvered to get there.

Mara: The post sets the scene precisely: "At 1 p.m. on Saturday, June 21, 1788, in Concord, the New Hampshire Convention voted 57 to 47 to ratify the Constitution of the United States. New Hampshire was the ninth state to do it, and nine was the number the document named for itself."

Pip: Nine was the threshold, and New Hampshire was the ninth. The margin was ten votes out of 104 cast — shift six delegates and the count flips.

Mara: And that near-miss was not an accident of the moment. The first session, in Exeter that February, never even came to a vote. Federalist leaders concluded they were behind — estimates placed their strength at between 30 and 48 of the 108 delegates in attendance — and moved to adjourn instead. That motion carried 56 to 51.

Pip: So the strategy was: don't lose today, go home, work on it, come back in June.

Mara: John Quincy Adams, watching from Massachusetts, wrote in his diary that the adjournment "was the offspring of the fears of the federal party." The intervening months changed enough minds that the June vote held.

Pip: The post also covers what New Hampshire asked for in return — twelve recommended amendments whose echoes you can hear in the Bill of Rights, including an early version of what became the First and Second Amendments.

Mara: One of them reads: "Congress shall make no Laws touching Religion, or to infringe the rights of Conscience." Another: "Congress shall never disarm any Citizen unless such as are or have been in Actual Rebellion." Tobias Lear, writing to Washington the next day, was candid that the list was drawn up more to win over moderates than from any real expectation the amendments would be adopted.

Pip: And yet several were. The gap between political packaging and constitutional legacy is sometimes smaller than the framers admitted.

Mara: The post also connects to a companion piece on the other way New Hampshire changes its constitution — a decennial convention question that only needs a majority, which is a very different bar than what we're about to discuss.

When a Majority Isn't Enough

Pip: The second piece asks a pointed question: what does it mean when voters say yes and the answer is still no?

Mara: The 2024 ballot asked whether judges should serve until 75 instead of 70. The result: "The yes side won, 452,307 votes to 237,221 — that was 65.6 percent. The amendment failed, and the retirement age stayed at 70."

Pip: It won by more than 215,000 votes and lost. That is a sentence worth sitting with.

Mara: The reason is Part II, Article 100 of the New Hampshire Constitution, which requires two-thirds of voters who answer the question. Two-thirds of the total who weighed in was about 459,685 — the yes side fell roughly 7,400 votes short. The amendment had passed the House 321 to 27 and the Senate 22 to 1.

Pip: Near-unanimous in the legislature, majority in the electorate, still defeated. The bar is genuinely high.

Mara: And it's not a new pattern. From 1986 through 2024, nine proposed amendments won a majority of voters and failed anyway — yes shares ranging from 55 percent to that 65.6 percent in 2024. Only six of twenty cleared two-thirds.

Pip: Some ideas came back repeatedly and kept losing. Court-rules amendments failed in 2002, 2004, and 2012. The register of probate question failed in 2022 at 62.9 percent, and a new version is on the 2026 ballot.

Mara: The post also notes the arithmetic consequence for individual voters: one no vote cancels two yes votes, and a blank counts for neither side. That asymmetry is what turned a 215,000-vote margin into a defeat.

Pip: Constitutional change in New Hampshire is not designed to be easy. The 1788 story and this one are really the same story, told 236 years apart.

Mara: Next time, we'll see what else Granite State Report is tracking as we get closer to November.

Pip: Ten votes in 1788, seven thousand in 2024 — the distance between yes and ratified has always been its own kind of argument.

Mara: The record is on paper, and Granite State Report is reading it carefully. More to come.

Transcript as generated by the tool, unedited. The listener’s note above records where it differs from the articles.

New Hampshire’s Uneven Public Services

Made October 11, 2026 · AI hosts · 5:39

Three pieces in one episode: the fifth of its public school students New Hampshire lost from 2000 to 2023, what the state’s 2024 rent survey shows county by county and city by city, and the Census Bureau’s county estimates of poverty and household income.

Articles discussed in this episode

Listener’s note.

  • The hosts say Dexter Dow has been digging into the data. All three articles are bylined GSR Staff.
  • The hosts present the enrollment figures as a direct quote: “In fall 2000, New Hampshire’s public schools enrolled 208,461 students, according to the National Center for Education Statistics. In fall 2023 they enrolled 166,594.” The article reads “according to the National Center for Education Statistics, the U.S. Department of Education’s statistics office. In fall 2023 they enrolled 166,594.” The quote drops a clause with no ellipsis, so it is not verbatim. The numbers hold.
  • The hosts say kindergarten “was the smallest grade in the state.” The article says “kindergarten was New Hampshire’s smallest grade from kindergarten through grade 12, with 11,087 students.” The same table counts 4,399 prekindergarten students.
  • The hosts say fewer students enrolled means “fewer of those per-pupil amounts flowing to districts.” The article ties the formula to ADMR, not to the federal enrollment count, and says ADMR “is not the same number as the federal fall count, and the two need not move together.” Its conclusion is narrower: “fewer pupils in the ADMR means fewer of those amounts.”
  • The hosts say the projection of 156,600 by fall 2031 is “a further decline of about six percent from where it stands now.” The article measures from fall 2023, not from today: “That would be 9,994 fewer students than in fall 2023, a further decline of 6.0 percent.” It also says “A projection is a model’s estimate, not a count.”
  • The hosts say the post “puts it plainly” that “only registered nurses can afford more than the median gross rent of a 2-bedroom apartment.” Those are New Hampshire Housing’s words, which the article quotes as the report’s. The comparison covers selected occupations, one full-time earner at the median wage.
  • The hosts say Grafton’s 67 percent five-year increase “traces directly to the Lebanon and Plymouth areas pulling the county median up.” The article ties those areas to Grafton’s cost level, not to its increase: the report says Grafton’s high rental costs “are driven by the Lebanon/Enfield area and the Holderness/Plymouth areas.” The article also says the 67 percent rise was “about twice the rise in Rockingham, Strafford or Carroll,” not Rockingham alone.
  • The hosts say Coos “sits above the national rate of 12.1 percent.” The article does not make that comparison. Coos’s 13.8 percent estimate has a 90 percent interval of 11.3 to 16.3 percent, which takes in 12.1, and the article says “overlapping ranges leave the order open.”
  • In the poverty segment, the hosts say the bureau found statistically significant change in three counties: “Carroll and Sullivan went up. Strafford went down.” Listeners will hear that poverty rose in Carroll and Sullivan. The finding is about inflation-adjusted median household income: “Three New Hampshire counties are on the median income list. Carroll and Sullivan went up. Strafford went down.” On poverty the article says the opposite of a change: “On the list for the poverty rate at all ages, no New Hampshire county appears.”
  • The hosts say “Seventeen years, and the gap between the richest and poorest county is essentially where it started,” and the closing line about “a county-level income gap that hasn’t budged in nearly two decades.” The article says “The ratio between the two medians has moved up and down without a steady direction, from about 1.7 to about 2.2.” Its table puts the ratio at 1.84 in 2007 and 2.01 in 2024. A finding of no significant change in each county’s own median does not show that the gap between them held still.

Checked and holding: 208,461 students in fall 2000 and 166,594 in fall 2023, 41,867 fewer, 20.1 percent; no state lost a larger share from 2000 to 2023; Vermont next at 19.2 percent; national enrollment up 4.9 percent; kindergarten 11,087 in fall 2022, more than 2,000 below eighth grade; the formula is per pupil under RSA 198:40-a; projection of about 156,600 in fall 2031; a two-bedroom gap of more than $1,700 by place; statewide median two-bedroom $1,833, up 58 percent from $1,157 in 2015; Lebanon $2,923, highest of the nine cities; Coos $1,161, lowest county; Coos median renter income $31,704 and an affordable rent of about $793; 4 percent of surveyed Coos units and 1 percent in Sullivan affordable at median renter income; Grafton up 67 percent from 2019 to 2024, about twice Rockingham; lowest estimated state poverty rate in all 18 SAIPE years, 2007 through 2024; Rockingham $119,559 and 5.3 percent; Coos $59,499 and 13.8 percent, “about 1.9 times the state’s”; national poverty rate 12.1 percent; Rockingham and Coos not on the bureau’s significant-change list; thresholds do not vary by place, the same line in Portsmouth and Pittsburg; noncash benefits such as food assistance not counted.

Read the transcript

Pip: Granite State Report, where the numbers are always fine and everything is completely normal in New Hampshire.

Mara: Dexter Dow has been digging into the data behind three big questions the state is sitting with right now — how many students are in its public schools, what renters are actually paying, and how poverty and income break down county by county.

Pip: Three topics that turn out to be more connected than they look at first glance.

Mara: Let's start with the schools, and a decline that turns out to be the steepest of any state in the country.

New Hampshire's Vanishing Student Population

Pip: The question here is simple but the answer is striking — how much has New Hampshire's public school enrollment actually fallen, and how does that compare to everywhere else?

Mara: The post leads with the federal figures directly: "In fall 2000, New Hampshire's public schools enrolled 208,461 students, according to the National Center for Education Statistics. In fall 2023 they enrolled 166,594. That is 41,867 fewer students, a drop of 20.1 percent."

Pip: And that 20.1 percent is not just a big number in isolation — it is the largest share lost by any state over that period. Vermont came closest at 19.2 percent, while nationally enrollment actually rose 4.9 percent.

Mara: The grade-by-grade breakdown sharpens the picture. In fall 2022, kindergarten was the smallest grade in the state, with 11,087 students — more than 2,000 fewer than eighth grade that same year. The pipeline is narrowing at the front end.

Pip: And the funding formula is built per pupil under state statute, so fewer students enrolled means fewer of those per-pupil amounts flowing to districts.

Mara: The federal projection adds one more data point: enrollment is expected to reach roughly 156,600 by fall 2031, a further decline of about six percent from where it stands now.

Pip: Smaller schools, tighter budgets — and the rents those families are navigating don't make the picture any simpler.

What Renters Are Paying, Place by Place

Mara: The rent survey breaks down what the statewide median actually conceals — because where you live in New Hampshire moves your two-bedroom rent by more than seventeen hundred dollars.

Pip: The post on New Hampshire Housing's 2024 survey puts it plainly: "only registered nurses can afford more than the median gross rent of a 2-bedroom apartment."

Mara: That median sits at $1,833 a month statewide, up 58 percent from $1,157 in 2015. Lebanon's median two-bedroom came in at $2,923 — the highest of the nine cities listed — while Coos County's was $1,161, the lowest county figure.

Pip: Coos being the cheapest county sounds like a relief until you check what people there actually earn.

Mara: Right. The survey found that in Coos, a household at the county's estimated median renter income of $31,704 could afford about $793 a month. Four percent of the units surveyed there were affordable at that income. In Sullivan County, it was one percent. The companion piece, "Why New Hampshire Rents Outpace Wages," covers the statewide version of that same gap.

Pip: And Grafton County's 67 percent five-year increase — roughly twice Rockingham's — traces directly to the Lebanon and Plymouth areas pulling the county median up.

Mara: That income gap in Coos connects directly to what the poverty data show across the north.

Poverty and the County Divide

Pip: New Hampshire holds the lowest estimated poverty rate of any state — and has for eighteen consecutive years of Census estimates. But that headline obscures a sharp internal divide.

Mara: The post on the Census Bureau's SAIPE figures frames it this way: Rockingham County had a median household income of $119,559 and a poverty rate of 5.3 percent. Coos County had a median of $59,499 and a poverty rate of 13.8 percent — "about 1.9 times the state's."

Pip: So the state wins the national comparison while one of its own counties sits above the national rate of 12.1 percent.

Mara: The bureau's own inflation-adjusted analysis found statistically significant change in only three of the state's ten counties since 2007. Carroll and Sullivan went up. Strafford went down. Rockingham and Coos — the top and bottom — showed no significant change either direction.

Pip: Seventeen years, and the gap between the richest and poorest county is essentially where it started.

Mara: The post is careful to note the limits: the poverty thresholds don't vary geographically, so the same line applies in Portsmouth and in Pittsburg, and noncash benefits like food assistance aren't counted as income.

Pip: Schools shrinking, rents climbing, and a county-level income gap that hasn't budged in nearly two decades — New Hampshire's headline numbers and its internal reality are doing very different things.

Mara: The data are all public, and Granite State Report is putting them in one place. More to come.

Transcript as generated by the tool, unedited. The listener’s note above records where it differs from the articles.

New Hampshire Politics And History

Made October 11, 2026 · AI hosts · 6:31

Three pieces in one episode: the internal affairs program state law requires of every New Hampshire police agency, though most reported 10 or fewer full-time officers; the two-thirds rule that defeated nine amendments with majority support; and the ten-vote ratification of 1788.

Articles discussed in this episode

Listener’s note.

  • The hosts say “Dexter Dow has three pieces out this week.” All three articles are bylined GSR Staff.
  • The hosts frame the police piece as asking “whether a uniform statewide law makes practical sense” and say the compliance burden “lands heaviest on the smallest places.” The article is a GSR Staff explainer that makes no such judgment. It says, in substance, that the size spread “matters” because the law applies to every agency with no size exception, and it lays out the duties without weighing them.
  • The hosts say the six agencies with no full-time officers are “departments staffed entirely by part-timers.” The article does not say that. It says “The FBI’s tables count full-time employees only, so a department staffed by part-time officers can appear in them with none.” That is a possibility, not a finding about Bridgewater, Danbury, Goshen, Groton, Madbury and Roxbury.
  • The closing line says the filing question is one “the public record can’t yet answer.” The article says only “The FBI figures also do not show whether a given agency has filed its internal affairs policies with the council.” It also says the chief “shall file copies of all written policies required by this section with the police standards and training council,” so the record exists somewhere; the article does not say it is unanswerable.
  • The hosts read a quotation from the amendments article that is not verbatim: they splice the first two sentences together with a dash and drop the attribution. The article says “The yes side won, 452,307 votes to 237,221, according to the certified results Ballotpedia reports. That was 65.6 percent. The amendment failed, and the retirement age stayed at 70.”
  • The hosts say a new register of probate amendment “is on the” 2026 ballot as a flat fact. The article attributes it and dates it: “As published in October 2026, Ballotpedia lists a second amendment to eliminate the office, CACR 13 of 2026, on the Nov. 3, 2026 ballot.”
  • The hosts say the returning-ideas pattern “runs through the whole dataset.” The article says “Some ideas returned to the ballot after failing, and some failed more than once,” and names three subjects: court rules, delegated rulemaking and the register of probate.
  • The hosts call the 57-to-47 vote the one “that put the Constitution into effect.” The article is careful on this point: Article VII made it binding only “between the States so ratifying,” and “Under Article VII the ninth ratification established the Constitution among the ratifying states that day, but the government it created did not meet until March 1789.” The article faults a Census Bureau page for a looser version of the same claim.
  • The hosts say John Quincy Adams was “watching from Massachusetts.” The ratification article says “John Quincy Adams of Massachusetts, who watched the debates, wrote in his diary…” He was from Massachusetts and watched the debates; the article does not place him in Massachusetts while he watched. The quoted fragment itself is verbatim.
  • The hosts say of the twelve recommended amendments, “Several were, eventually.” The article is narrower: “Several of those ideas reached the Bill of Rights in different words.”
  • The hosts say “The tight margin put New Hampshire fifth narrowest among the thirteen.” The article ranks by yes share: “New Hampshire’s yes share, 54.8 percent, was the fifth narrowest of the thirteen.” By raw vote margin the order differs: Rhode Island (2) and New York (3) were closer, and Virginia tied New Hampshire at 10.

Checked and holding: agencies range from hundreds of officers (State Police 313, Manchester 246) to none; “the median agency had six” is verbatim; HB 1682 was signed in 2022 (July 1) and took effect Jan. 1, 2023; every agency must adopt an internal affairs program, investigate misconduct complaints and report certain cases to the committee, with no exception for size; 138 of the 200 agencies with a 2024 figure reported 10 or fewer and six reported none; the three investigation routes; the committee may recommend a separate investigation when an agency lacks a valid program; the FBI figures do not show policy filings; the 2024 retirement-age question, 452,307 to 237,221, 65.6 percent, failed; a margin of about 215,000; two-thirds of those voting on the question; 459,685 needed and about 7,400 short; about 92 percent of House members voting (321 of 348) and 96 percent of senators voting (22 of 23); 20 amendments from 1986 through 2024, six adopted, nine majority failures at 55.0 to 65.6 percent; one no vote cancels two yes votes; the register of probate amendment drew 62.9 percent in 2022 and failed; 57 to 47 in Concord in 1788; the Article VII quotation is verbatim; the Exeter adjournment, 56 to 51; the article draws on the convention journal and period letters; the Adams fragment is verbatim; four months from Exeter to Concord and a margin of ten; the recommendations foreshadowed the First, Second, Third, Fifth, Seventh and Tenth Amendments, exactly the article’s list; Tobias Lear wrote Washington the next day, and the quoted words match the article except that it prints “&” where the hosts say “and”; fifth narrowest of the thirteen by yes share (54.8 percent; only Rhode Island, New York, Massachusetts and Virginia closer); Virginia, the tenth state, ratified 89 to 79, also by 10.

Read the transcript

Pip: Granite State Report covers New Hampshire — a state where the margin between history and a footnote has sometimes been exactly ten votes.

Mara: Dexter Dow has three pieces out this week, and together they span a lot of ground: how small police departments handle oversight requirements, how the state's constitutional amendment process works against majorities, and how New Hampshire became the ninth state to ratify the Constitution.

Pip: Let's start with the oversight question — because it turns out "every agency" means every agency, no matter the size.

Small Departments, Big Mandate

Mara: The question here is whether a uniform statewide law makes practical sense when the agencies it covers range from hundreds of officers down to, in several cases, zero.

Pip: The numbers set that up fast. The post draws on FBI staffing data and notes that "the median agency had six" full-time officers — and the law applies to all of them equally.

Mara: That's the core of it. House Bill 1682, signed in 2022 and effective January 1, 2023, requires every agency to adopt an internal affairs program, investigate misconduct complaints, and report certain cases to a state review committee — with no exception for size.

Pip: Six officers running a full internal affairs program is a staffing puzzle that would give any HR consultant a productive afternoon.

Mara: The post also notes that 138 of the 200 agencies with a 2024 figure reported ten or fewer full-time officers, and six reported none at all — departments staffed entirely by part-timers.

Pip: So the compliance burden lands heaviest on the smallest places. What does the law actually give agencies when they can't investigate themselves?

Mara: Three routes: investigate in-house, bring in an outside agency, or ask the council's own investigators to do it. The committee can also recommend a separate investigation if it decides an agency lacks a valid internal affairs program.

Pip: Which raises the question the post leaves open — whether the policies have actually been filed.

Mara: It does. The FBI figures don't show whether a given agency has submitted its written policies to the council. That's the next layer of the record. From there, the amendment question is really about a different kind of threshold problem.

Majorities That Lose

Pip: The constitutional amendment piece is about what happens when winning isn't enough — when a majority vote still falls short of the bar.

Mara: The post opens with the 2024 ballot question on raising the mandatory judicial retirement age. Here's the line that frames everything: "The yes side won, 452,307 votes to 237,221 — that was 65.6 percent. The amendment failed, and the retirement age stayed at 70."

Pip: Win by 215,000 votes, lose the amendment. That is a sentence worth sitting with.

Mara: The constitution requires two-thirds of voters who answer the question. The yes side needed roughly 459,685 and came up about 7,400 short. The amendment had cleared the legislature at around 92 percent in the House and 96 percent in the Senate.

Mara: The post tracks every proposed amendment from 1986 through 2024 — twenty total, six adopted. Nine drew a majority and failed anyway, at yes shares ranging from 55 percent up to that 65.6 percent.

Pip: The post also notes a practical asymmetry: under the two-thirds rule, one no vote cancels two yes votes.

Mara: And some questions came back. The register of probate abolition drew 62.9 percent in 2022, failed, and a new version is on the November 2026 ballot. That pattern of returning ideas runs through the whole dataset. The history segment shows New Hampshire has been navigating tight votes since well before any of this.

Ten Votes, Nine States

Pip: The ratification piece is the deepest cut — a 57-to-47 vote in Concord in 1788 that put the Constitution into effect, and how close it came to not happening at all.

Mara: Article VII of the Constitution set its own threshold: "The Ratification of the Conventions of nine States, shall be sufficient for the Establishment of this Constitution between the States so ratifying the Same." New Hampshire was nine.

Pip: And the convention almost didn't get there. When it first met in Exeter in February, the Federalists concluded they didn't have the votes and moved to adjourn instead of lose. That motion carried 56 to 51.

Mara: The post draws on the convention's own journal and letters from the period. John Quincy Adams, watching from Massachusetts, wrote that the adjournment motion "was the offspring of the fears of the federal party." Four months later in Concord, the roll was called and the margin was ten.

Mara: The post also covers what New Hampshire asked for in return — twelve recommended amendments, including early versions of what became the First, Second, Third, Fifth, Seventh, and Tenth Amendments.

Pip: Tobias Lear, writing to Washington the next day, suggested the amendment list was drawn up "more with a view of softening and conciliating the adoption" than from any real expectation the changes would be made.

Mara: Several were, eventually. The tight margin put New Hampshire fifth narrowest among the thirteen ratifying conventions — and Virginia, the tenth state, also ratified by exactly ten votes.

Pip: Ten votes in 1788, seven thousand in 2024 — New Hampshire keeps finding new ways to make the margin matter.

Mara: And the oversight piece adds a third kind of threshold: not a vote count, but a compliance question that the public record can't yet answer.

Pip: More to follow, presumably, once someone checks the filing dates.

Mara: That's usually how it goes.

Transcript as generated by the tool, unedited. The listener’s note above records where it differs from the articles.

Census Five-Year Estimates Put 38,414 New Hampshire Households Without an Internet Subscription. The State’s Federal Broadband Build Reaches 5,135 Locations.

Made October 11, 2026 · AI hosts · 4:15

One piece: the Census count of 38,414 New Hampshire households without an internet subscription, the state’s $196.5 million federal BEAD grant and the 5,135 locations its deployment awards cover, and why the two numbers measure different problems.

Articles discussed in this episode

Listener’s note.

  • The hosts say Dexter Dow has been doing the arithmetic. The article is bylined GSR Staff.
  • The hosts say SpaceX “got the most locations,” 1,105. That is wrong. The article’s awards table gives Consolidated Communications 2,573 locations. The article says SpaceX “was awarded 1,105 locations, more than one in five, for about 5 percent of the award money.” The least money and about $863 per location hold.
  • The hosts say that with 5,250 eligible locations against 38,414 unsubscribed households, “more than 33,000 remain outside the program’s reach.” The article frames it as a best case: “Even if every eligible location were a household with no subscription, more than 33,000 of the 38,414 would remain.” It also notes that “a location can be a business or another site as well as a home.”
  • The hosts say BEAD pays “only for building the wire.” The article says BEAD does not pay for subscriptions, but adds: “The allocation also covers planning and adoption programs, which the department’s page lists alongside infrastructure deployment.”
  • The hosts say the builds “are scheduled to wrap by February 2030.” The article calls that date an estimate: “The state’s project file sets Feb. 1, 2030, as the estimated end date for the builds.” The department’s page ties the service deadline to Governor and Council approval: four years after each subgrant is approved.

Checked and holding: 555,822 households in the 2020 to 2024 estimates; the quoted line on 38,414 with no subscription, 6.9 percent against 8.9 percent nationally; among the lowest shares in the country; Rockingham 4.9 percent and Coos 13.4 percent, with Coos more than double even at the edges of the margins; one Coos household in 10 with some satellite service against about one in 30 statewide; the survey cannot say why a household goes without; $196.5 million BEAD grant; the 2025 federal restructuring sent states back to pick builders; the quoted change from 9,527 to 5,250 eligible locations; 5,135 locations across Comcast, Consolidated Communications, New Hampshire Electric Cooperative and SpaceX; SpaceX 1,105 locations for the least money, about $863 each; 82 percent forested and satellite needs a clear view of the sky; $18.6 million in deployment awards, about 9.5 percent of the grant; the quoted doubt about funding for non-deployment activities; BEAD does not pay for subscriptions; the department’s page does not say whether the Governor and Council have acted.

Read the transcript

Pip: Granite State Report — where the broadband gap comes with footnotes, fact-checks, and a county-by-county breakdown. Dexter Dow has been doing the arithmetic so you don't have to.

Mara: Today we're looking at who in New Hampshire goes without home internet, what the federal government is paying to fix it, and why those two numbers don't actually measure the same thing.

Pip: Let's start with the gap itself — and what the Census data and the federal build do and don't tell us.

The Gap the Numbers Can't Quite Close

Mara: The core tension here is that New Hampshire has two different counts of an internet problem, and they're measuring different things entirely.

Pip: The Census figure is about households — real people, no subscription. The federal program is about locations — addresses where service is missing or too slow. Those are not the same population.

Mara: Right. On the household side, the American Community Survey puts New Hampshire at 555,822 households in its 2020 through 2024 estimates. The post quotes the key finding directly: "38,414 had no internet subscription of any kind: 6.9 percent, against 8.9 percent for the United States."

Pip: So New Hampshire is actually doing relatively well by national standards — one of the lowest unsubscribed rates in the country. The problem is that "relatively well" still means tens of thousands of households.

Mara: And the state is not uniform. Rockingham County sits at 4.9 percent without a subscription. Coos County is at 13.4 percent — and even at the edges of the margin of error, Coos is more than double Rockingham. Coos also leans heavily on satellite: one household in ten there reported some satellite service, compared to about one in thirty statewide.

Pip: The survey also can't tell you why a household goes without — whether nothing is offered, whether it costs too much, or whether no one wants it. That ambiguity is load-bearing.

Mara: On the federal side, New Hampshire has a $196.5 million BEAD grant. After a 2025 federal restructuring that sent states back to reselect builders, the eligible location list shrank — the Final Proposal notes that "the number of eligible locations changed from 9,527 to 5,250." The deployment awards cover 5,135 locations across four companies: Comcast, Consolidated Communications, New Hampshire Electric Cooperative, and SpaceX.

Pip: SpaceX got the most locations — 1,105 — for the least money, about 863 dollars each. The state's own plan explains why satellite ranks lower: New Hampshire is 82 percent forested, and satellite needs clear sky.

Mara: The deployment awards total $18.6 million, roughly 9.5 percent of the full grant. The post flags that the state's own planning documents "expressed doubt that there would be sufficient funding for non-deployment activities after deployment activities were funded."

Pip: So the construction money is a fraction of the total, and even that fraction doesn't close the gap. Set 5,250 eligible locations against 38,414 unsubscribed households and more than 33,000 remain outside the program's reach — and BEAD isn't paying for subscriptions anyway, only for building the wire.

Mara: The builds are scheduled to wrap by February 2030. Whether the Governor and Council have approved the subgrants, the post notes, the department's page does not say.

Pip: Two numbers, two tools — and a lot of distance still between them.

Mara: The infrastructure and the adoption problem are genuinely separate, and this piece is careful not to conflate them.

Pip: The wire gets built by 2030, maybe. The subscription question is still open. We'll be back with more from Granite State Report.

Transcript as generated by the tool, unedited. The listener’s note above records where it differs from the articles.

Granite State Report Takes UFO, Paranormal and Wildlife Footage. Here Is How Every Clip Gets Checked.

Made October 11, 2026 · AI hosts · 4:00

One piece: how Granite State Report checks reader footage of lights in the sky, the unexplained and New Hampshire wildlife, built on the Air Force’s 1965 Exeter case file and the Pentagon UAP office’s fiscal 2025 numbers.

Articles discussed in this episode

Listener’s note.

  • The hosts say Dexter Dow has written the manual. The article is bylined GSR Staff.
  • The hosts say AARO received 319 reports “in the most recent fiscal year.” The article gives the figures from AARO’s “annual report for fiscal year 2025,” covering June 2, 2024, through May 30, 2025.
  • The hosts say your phone embeds the date, time and GPS coordinates in the file, and that a screenshot loses that. The article is more careful: “Photos and video from phones can carry the date, the time and the location where they were taken” and “A copy may keep that data or may not. The original is the version that can be checked.”
  • The closing line says the Exeter officers’ account “survived sixty years because they wrote down the time, the place, and what they saw.” The article says it “outlived the night because they wrote down the time, the place, and what they saw, and because someone asked them the right question afterward.” The hosts drop the second reason, which is the article’s point about Quintanilla’s letter.

Checked and holding: Exeter officers’ sighting in September 1965; the Air Force split the case, putting earlier sightings down to aircraft from Big Blast and not the officers’ observation after 2 a.m.; the Blue Book record card’s conclusion reads UNIDENTIFIED; unidentified describes the evidence, not extraterrestrial origin; Maj. Quintanilla asked the officers whether they had seen any aircraft, and his letter’s quote (“would tend to eliminate this air operation as a plausible explanation for the objects observed”) is verbatim; the sky checks: ADS-B Exchange for aircraft, Heavens-Above for satellite passes, Stellarium for planets and stars, weather balloon launch times, and camera checks including lens flare, compression and edits; the Library of Congress Exif quote “date and time information, geographic data” is verbatim in the article and matches the Library’s Exif Family page; wildlife checks of time and place, biologists and reverse image search; Fish and Game’s statement that photo reports of mountain lions have been misidentified bobcats or house cats, or pictures taken from the internet; AARO received 319 reports and resolved 114, all to ordinary objects; 60 balloons, 44 satellites, 4 aircraft, 2 birds, 1 jet pack (the hosts skip the 2 drones and 1 rocket launch, which is an omission, not an error); 191 reports sent to an archive for lack of data; a clip without a time or place set aside for the same reason AARO set aside 191; the legal sidebar on wiretap law, drone authorization and criminal trespass.

Read the transcript

Pip: If you have ever watched something cross the New Hampshire sky and thought "that is definitely not a plane," Granite State Report would like you to send the original file — and Dexter Dow has written the manual for what happens next.

Mara: Right — today we are looking at how the newsroom vets footage of unexplained phenomena and wildlife, and what sixty years of UFO case history tells us about why the methodology matters.

Pip: Let's start with the verification process itself.

How Every Clip Gets Checked

Mara: The question this piece is really asking is: what does it take to call something genuinely unexplained, versus just unexplained so far? And the answer starts in 1965.

Pip: The Exeter case is the anchor here. The Air Force split the sighting — earlier reports attributed to military aircraft, but the officers' observation after 2 a.m. was different. The post quotes Project Blue Book's record card directly: the conclusion was "UNIDENTIFIED."

Mara: And that word is doing specific work. Unidentified doesn't mean extraterrestrial — it means the checking was done, and the checking ran out of answers. That's the standard the newsroom is adopting.

Pip: What's notable is how systematic the Air Force was even then. Maj. Quintanilla asked the officers one precise question: had they seen any aircraft that night? Because if they had, his letter reasoned, that "would tend to eliminate this air operation as a plausible explanation for the objects observed."

Mara: So the methodology is: name what you ruled out, then say what you couldn't. Granite State Report applies that same logic to submitted footage — aircraft tracks via ADS-B Exchange, satellite passes through Heavens-Above, planets and stars through Stellarium, weather balloon launch schedules, and then camera artifacts like lens flare, compression, and edits.

Pip: The original file requirement is where this gets quietly rigorous. Your phone embeds date, time, and GPS coordinates in the image data — what the Library of Congress describes as "date and time information, geographic data" in the Exif standard. A screenshot loses that. A screenshot is, essentially, a rumor.

Mara: Wildlife submissions go through parallel checks: time, place, confirmation with wildlife biologists, and a reverse image search. The post notes that every mountain lion photo Fish and Game has received turned out to be a misidentified bobcat, a house cat, or an image pulled from the internet.

Pip: The Pentagon's own numbers are instructive. AARO received 319 UAP reports in the most recent fiscal year, resolved 114, and every single resolved case was something ordinary — sixty balloons, forty-four satellites, a handful of aircraft, two birds, and, memorably, one jet pack.

Mara: The larger number is the 191 cases sent to an archive for lack of data. That's the point the post keeps returning to: a clip without a time or a place gets set aside for the same reason AARO set aside those 191.

Pip: So the bar for "unexplained" is actually high — which is what makes it meaningful when something clears it.

Mara: Exactly. And the legal sidebar on recording — wiretap law, drone authorization, criminal trespass — keeps the whole thing grounded in what you can actually do before you press record.

Pip: The standard holds whether the subject is lights in the sky or a bear acting strangely. The footage is the start of the question, not the answer.

Mara: The Exeter officers' account survived sixty years because they wrote down the time, the place, and what they saw.

Pip: Good notes outlast almost everything. More from Granite State Report next time.

Transcript as generated by the tool, unedited. The listener’s note above records where it differs from the articles.

New Hampshire Democracy And Records

Made October 5, 2026 · AI hosts · 7:41

Three subjects in one episode: what the WikiLeaks and Snowden disclosures exposed and what they changed, the index New Hampshire never built and the archive made to fill the gap, and two proposed constitutions offered for argument ahead of the 2032 convention question.

Generated by the WordPress.com podcast tool on October 5, 2026. On October 10 the script was revised and the episode re-recorded with synthetic voices. The player and the transcript carry the revised version.

Articles discussed in this episode

Listener’s note.

  • The hosts say the 2010 ruling meant New Hampshire “quietly settled the ‘is a website press’ question.” The article fences the ruling in: “The privilege it recognized is qualified. The dispute was commercial, with no national-security claim.” It adds that the ruling “binds New Hampshire courts, not federal courts or federal prosecutors.” Settled is stronger than the article goes.
  • The hosts say Snowden, as of the newsroom’s October 2026 reporting, “remained in Russia.” The article is more careful: “This newsroom found no report that he has left Russia, that the 2013 charges have been dropped, or that he has been pardoned.” Its fact-check row adds: “A search that finds nothing does not prove nothing exists.”
  • The WikiLeaks segment gives only the defenders’ record. The article says it “sets out the public record behind the case that defenders of WikiLeaks, Julian Assange and Edward Snowden make, and the record their critics cite against it,” and gives a full section to the critics: the unredacted cables, the Mueller report’s finding that the DNC emails were “stolen by the GRU,” and the House Intelligence Committee report.
  • The hosts say the ACLU of New Hampshire “waited fourteen months for State Police records.” Fourteen months is the State Police’s own projected timeline, not time already waited: “The New Hampshire State Police told the American Civil Liberties Union it would need until November 24, 2026 to answer a public records request the ACLU filed on September 12, 2025.” The ACLU sued on August 25, 2026, about eleven and a half months after filing.
  • The hosts say “seven amendments to the statute have passed since it was issued without a rewrite.” The index article says “Seven separate acts have amended RSA 91-A since that memorandum was issued, and the memorandum has not been rewritten.” Seven acts, not seven amendments, and as spoken the line attaches “without a rewrite” to the statute, when the unrewritten thing is the memorandum.
  • The hosts say “Four hundred dollars a day, no takers.” The figure is real: RSA 91-A:7-a pays “four hundred dollars for each day devoted to the work of the office” (index article and ombudsman article). “No takers” also has a source: the governor’s “staff told the Monitor in March that no one had applied” (ombudsman article). But the line turns the articles’ point upside down. Said alone, $400 a day sounds generous. The ombudsman article says “Reporting puts the appropriation behind those rates at $30,000, down from a full-time salaried office,” works out about 62 days a year at that rate, and the index article says the state “funded it like a stipend for a part-time position on a zoning board.”
  • The hosts say the Ledger column counts “a right-to-know office defunded and vacant.” Vacant holds. Defunded does not: “Then the Legislature cut the office’s pay and budget from $105,000 to $30,000.”
  • The hosts present the Ledger column as running “the numbers on what that frozen machinery produces,” tying it to the constitutional-amendment argument. The column places the causes in statute and in Concord, not in the constitution: “A flaw in the design cannot be voted out. A capture can.” It ends: “The minimum wage is set by the Legislature. The ombudsman’s budget was cut by the Legislature.” The “machinery has frozen” framing comes from the New Constitution essay, not the Ledger.
  • The hosts say RSA 106-F “carves out ‘accredited’ news organizations” and that this statute is “the reason” the records are free while the labor is paid. The exclusion covers people, not organizations: “persons engaged in reporting or providing information to an accredited news publication, media, or news outlet.” The index article stresses that the wording matters: “Whether it describes a sole proprietor who is the outlet is a question the text does not answer.” It also calls RSA 106-F “a second reason for that line,” not the only one.

Checked and holding: Mortgage Specialists v. Implode-Explode, 2010, Justice Conboy for a unanimous court, quotation verbatim; the ruling came one month after the April 5, 2010 Baghdad gun-camera video and three years before Snowden’s first disclosure; two federal appeals courts held the phone-records program unlawful and Congress ended it; an estimated 15,000 civilian deaths missing from Iraq Body Count’s tally; Assange’s 2024 guilty plea to one Espionage Act count; Snowden charged since 2013; the source-and-publisher closing line; RSA 91-A:4, VII quoted verbatim; the library-with-no-catalog image; the AG memorandum leaving out the part where requesters get the records; the $25 ombudsman route as the alternative to superior court; the seat vacant since July 1, 2025, when the first ombudsman’s term ended; every pending case dismissed; the seat still unfilled as of the July 2026 reporting; $400 a day is the statutory rate; 29 items across four series at publication, six of them RSA 91-A records; provenance stated for each item; the published exclusions list and the brochure line; RSA 106-F leaves accredited undefined and no state agency issues the credential; commissions limited to public-interest work, everything obtained published free to everyone, editorial control not transferred; New Hampshire adopted America’s first constitution; the convention question every ten years and on the 2032 ballot; Jefferson to Madison, 1789, mortality tables, “The earth belongs always to the living generation” verbatim; 935 national constitutions with an average lifespan of nineteen years; Madison’s 1790 reply won the argument; the federal constitution not amended in the living memory of most Americans now alive; Article 100’s fixed schedule against Article V’s lack of any clock; minimum wage at $7.25 since 2009; wealth concentration; both drafts labeled works of argument, not law; the New Hampshire draft keeps the 400-member House, the Right of Revolution word for word and the decennial question, and writes the education duty so a statute cannot recast it as a shared responsibility; the federal draft elects the president by national popular vote, lifts the 1929 House cap, and requires a convention every nineteen years with the existing constitution in force between drafts; delegates elected from House districts, about four hundred; ratification needs two-thirds of the voters; the byline split, with the press-freedom piece credited to the newsroom (GSR Staff) and the records and constitution pieces to Dexter Dow.

Read the transcript

Two synthetic voices read this episode. It summarizes Granite State Report articles; each claim was checked against those articles and their sources.

Pip: Granite State Report covers the state that wrote America's first constitution, still hasn't defined what "accredited" means for a news outlet, and asks its voters every ten years whether the rulebook needs updating. Welcome to the episode.

Mara: The newsroom has been doing the work here — press freedom and what Snowden and Assange changed, and, under Dexter Dow's byline, New Hampshire's public records gap, the archive built to fill it, and a pair of proposed constitutions aimed at the 2032 ballot and beyond. Let's start with the question of what leaks cost and what they bought.

What WikiLeaks and Snowden Changed — and What It Cost Them

Pip: The press-freedom argument around Assange and Snowden usually gets framed as a values debate, but this piece treats it as a factual record — what was revealed, what courts ruled, what Congress did, and what happened to the people who did the revealing.

Mara: The piece sets up the legal spine with a 2010 New Hampshire Supreme Court ruling: "The fact that Implode operates a website makes it no less a member of the press," Justice Conboy wrote for a unanimous court in Mortgage Specialists v. Implode-Explode Heavy Industries.

Pip: So New Hampshire quietly settled the "is a website press" question a month after WikiLeaks dropped the Baghdad gun-camera video — and three years before anyone had heard of Edward Snowden.

Mara: Two federal appeals courts later ruled the NSA phone-records program Snowden revealed unlawful, and Congress ended it. The Iraq war logs WikiLeaks published contained an estimated fifteen thousand civilian deaths missing from Iraq Body Count's tally. Assange pleaded guilty to one Espionage Act count in 2024; Snowden has faced charges since 2013 and, as of the newsroom's October 2026 reporting, remained in Russia.

Pip: The record sits where the piece leaves it — the information changed law and policy, and the public learned it because a source took the documents and a publisher printed them.

Mara: From there, the same questions about who counts as press and how documents are obtained run directly into how New Hampshire handles public records.

New Hampshire's Records Gap — and the Archive Built to Fill It

Pip: The premise here is structural: New Hampshire will hand you a document if you know to ask for it, but it will never tell you what it has.

Mara: The statute makes that explicit. RSA 91-A:4, VII states that nothing in the Right-to-Know Law requires a public body or agency "to compile, cross-reference, or assemble information into a form in which it is not already kept or reported by that body or agency."

Pip: Which means the public record is technically accessible the way a library with no catalog is technically a library — everything's there, findable only by people who already know what to ask for.

Mara: The piece walks through what that costs in practice. The ACLU of New Hampshire waited fourteen months for State Police records under a law written around five business days. The Attorney General's own Right-to-Know memorandum omits the part where requesters receive records, and seven amendments to the statute have passed since it was issued without a rewrite.

Mara: The enforcement mechanism has its own problem. The right-to-know ombudsman — the twenty-five-dollar alternative to Superior Court — went vacant on July 1, 2025, when the first ombudsman's term ended. Pending cases were dismissed, and as of the newsroom's July 2026 reporting, the seat remained unfilled.

Pip: Four hundred dollars a day, no takers. That's either a budgeting problem or a staffing philosophy.

Mara: The companion piece, the Granite State Record Room, is the direct response — a finding aid listing the documents the newsroom holds, with provenance stated plainly, free to access. At publication it described twenty-nine items across four series, six of them governmental records obtained under RSA 91-A. The exclusions list is published too: duplicates, working drafts, files without established provenance. An archive that only advertises its contents, the piece argues, is a brochure.

Pip: And the reason the records themselves are free while the labor of obtaining them can be commissioned sits in RSA 106-F — the private investigator statute, which carves out "accredited" news organizations but has never defined the word, and no state agency issues the credential.

Mara: That open question draws a precise line for the newsroom: public-interest assignments only, everything obtained published to everyone, editorial control stays put. The constitutional stakes behind that arrangement lead directly to the next question — whether the documents governing all of this need rewriting.

The 2032 Question — Two Constitutions Offered for Argument

Pip: New Hampshire has a standing appointment with its own founding document — every ten years, voters are asked whether to hold a convention. The next question lands on the 2032 ballot whether anyone prepares or not.

Mara: The main piece offers a number as its anchor: "The earth belongs always to the living generation," Jefferson wrote to Madison in 1789, working from mortality tables to argue no constitution should outlive the generation that consented to it. Scholars who later measured 935 constitutions found the average lifespan is nineteen years — Jefferson's exact figure.

Pip: Madison won that argument in 1790, and we've been living inside his caution ever since — which is one way to describe a document not amended once in the living memory of most living Americans.

Mara: The companion piece, "New Hampshire Asks Every Ten Years Whether to Rewrite Its Constitution. The Country Never Has To," frames the asymmetry directly: Article 100 forces the question onto the ballot on a fixed schedule; Article V of the federal constitution has no equivalent clock. The third piece in this group, "Live Free or Die Is a Slogan. Here Is the Ledger," runs the numbers on what that frozen machinery produces — wealth concentration, a minimum wage unchanged since 2009, a right-to-know office defunded and vacant.

Mara: Both proposed constitutions are offered as works of argument, not law. The New Hampshire draft keeps the four-hundred-member House, the Right of Revolution word for word, and the decennial question — and makes the education funding duty enforceable in terms no statute can rename a shared responsibility. The federal draft elects the president by national popular vote, unfreezes the House from its 1929 cap, and builds in a mandatory convention every nineteen years while keeping the existing constitution in force between drafts.

Pip: The path for New Hampshire is almost embarrassingly concrete — the question is already on the 2032 ballot by constitutional command, and the delegates, if voters say yes, would be about four hundred ordinary residents elected from House districts.

Mara: The convention proposes. Only two-thirds of the voters dispose. The argument is that a process ending in a supermajority of the governed cannot run away from the governed — it can only force a public argument, which is precisely what the years before 2032 are for.

Pip: Three areas, one through-line: who counts as press, what records they can reach, and whether the rules governing all of it still fit the people living under them.

Mara: New Hampshire has a date on the calendar. The rest of the country doesn't.

Transcript of the revised script. The listener’s note above records where it differs from the articles.

Surveillance And Press Freedom

Made October 5, 2026 · AI hosts · 5:31

Three pieces in one episode: what WikiLeaks, Assange and Snowden exposed and what it cost them, with New Hampshire’s 2010 Implode ruling on who counts as press; the Verizon data demands that never reach a judge; and how the FBI, DEA and the Concord fusion center decide who gets watched.

Generated by the WordPress.com podcast tool on October 5, 2026. On October 10 the script was revised and the episode re-recorded with synthetic voices. The player and the transcript carry the revised version.

Articles discussed in this episode

Listener’s note.

  • The hosts say “The court also held that” the lawfulness of publishing depends on whether the publisher obtained the information lawfully. The quote is verbatim, but the article frames it as borrowed: “Citing the U.S. Supreme Court, the justices stated the rule this way.” The rule is the U.S. Supreme Court’s, quoted by the New Hampshire court.
  • The hosts say the central question in the Assange prosecution, how the material was obtained, “was already sitting in New Hampshire case law nine years before the Espionage Act charges landed.” The dates hold (ruling May 6, 2010; charges announced May 23, 2019), but the article is narrower. It says the court’s questions “run through both stories,” that the court “struck down an order against future publication and left open punishment after the fact,” and that “Those decisions concern orders to stop publication. The Assange case was a criminal prosecution after publication, and it turned on how he got the material.”
  • The hosts say that as of the October 2026 reporting, “Snowden remained in Russia under charges filed in 2013.” The article says “This newsroom found no report that he has left Russia, that the 2013 charges have been dropped, or that he has been pardoned,” and its fact check adds, “A search that finds nothing does not prove nothing exists.” The hosts turn a no-report finding into a flat fact.
  • The hosts say “a 2026 GAO report found” the 48 and 14 percent conversion rates. The article says the report was “obtained and published by Racket News rather than released by the GAO itself,” and its fact check marks the claim ATTRIBUTED. The hosts drop that qualifier.

Checked and holding: Justice Conboy wrote for a unanimous court in the 2010 Implode case; “The fact that Implode operates a website makes it no less a member of the press” is verbatim; the 2010 ruling came nine years before the May 2019 Espionage Act charges; two federal appeals courts ruled the phone-records program unlawful and Congress ended it; the 9th Circuit quote on Snowden’s disclosure prompting “significant public debate” is verbatim; Assange spent nearly seven years in the Ecuadorian Embassy (June 19, 2012 to April 11, 2019), then was sentenced to the 62 months already served in Britain; he pleaded guilty in Saipan on June 26, 2024; he told the Council of Europe in October 2024 “I pleaded guilty to journalism”; the Parliamentary Assembly voted the next day to recognize him as a political prisoner; the Snowden complaint was sworn in 2013; Brig. Gen. Robert Carr testified that his task force found no specific example of anyone killed in reprisal; the Saipan judge said there was no known physical injury, which the article says does not establish that nobody was endangered; the Implode ruling binds New Hampshire courts, not federal prosecutors; 291,486 Verizon demands in 2024, about 800 a day; the NSL quote “The FBI does not need to go to court to issue an NSL” and the internal certification of relevance to a terrorism or intelligence investigation; subpoenas and emergency requests totaled 218,822, or 75 percent, with NSLs outside that count; an FBI assessment requires “no particular factual predication”; 48 percent of sensitive assessments converted to investigations against 14 percent of ordinary ones, with news organizations in the sensitive category; the protection rests on the word “solely”; the New Hampshire Information and Analysis Center in Concord links to the FBI’s New Hampshire Joint Terrorism Task Force, the DEA’s El Paso Intelligence Center and Treasury’s financial-crimes network; about 81 percent of voters approved Article 2-b in 2018; it binds New Hampshire government and cannot switch off a FISA directive.

Read the transcript

Two synthetic voices read this episode. It summarizes Granite State Report articles; each claim was checked against those articles and their sources.

Pip: Granite State Report covers the kind of stories where the footnotes are the story — court orders, transparency reports, and the fine print nobody reads until it matters.

Mara: This episode draws on Granite State Report reporting, much of it Dexter Dow's, and it covers two territories that turn out to be the same territory: who counts as the press and what protections that status carries, and how much of your daily life the government can pull from a phone carrier before a judge ever sees the paperwork.

Pip: Let's start with the bigger picture — WikiLeaks, Snowden, and what the public record shows happened.

Whistleblowing, Press Freedom, and the Public Record

Mara: The question this piece sets out to answer is a specific one: what did the record change, and what did it cost the people who made it public? It lays out both sides — what defenders cite and what critics cite — without collapsing them.

Pip: The New Hampshire angle is the part that earns its place. A 2010 mortgage-industry website case produced a ruling that runs straight through the Assange and Snowden questions.

Mara: Justice Conboy wrote for a unanimous court: "The fact that Implode operates a website makes it no less a member of the press." The court also held that "the lawfulness of publishing information does not depend upon the nature of the information itself, but, rather, upon whether the information was obtained lawfully by the publisher."

Pip: So the central legal question in the Assange prosecution — not what was published, but how it was obtained — was already sitting in New Hampshire case law nine years before the Espionage Act charges landed.

Mara: And the Snowden disclosures produced concrete, documented results. Two federal appeals courts ruled the phone-records program unlawful. Congress ended it. The 9th Circuit put it plainly: "Snowden's disclosure of the metadata program prompted significant public debate over the appropriate scope of government surveillance."

Pip: The cost column is equally documented. Assange spent nearly seven years inside an embassy, then 62 months in British custody. He pleaded guilty in Saipan in June 2024, and that October he told the Council of Europe, "I pleaded guilty to journalism." The council's parliamentary assembly voted the next day to recognize him as a political prisoner.

Mara: As of the newsroom's October 2026 reporting, Snowden remained in Russia under charges filed in 2013. The piece is careful about what the record does and doesn't establish on harm — Brig. Gen. Robert Carr testified he found no specific example of anyone killed in reprisal, and the sentencing judge in Saipan said there was no known physical injury. The piece notes that doesn't prove nobody was endangered.

Pip: The Implode ruling binds New Hampshire courts, not federal prosecutors. That gap is where the whole debate lives.

Mara: And that's the connective tissue into what the surveillance infrastructure looks like day to day.

How Much of Your Data the Government Takes Without a Judge

Mara: The government sent Verizon 291,486 data demands in 2024 — roughly 800 a day. The piece walks through what each legal instrument is, what it reaches, and who has to sign off.

Pip: Verizon's own FAQ supplies the key line on National Security Letters: "The FBI does not need to go to court to issue an NSL." No judge — just an internal certification that the information is relevant to a terrorism or intelligence investigation.

Mara: In 2024, subpoenas and emergency requests alone — both requiring no judicial approval — accounted for 218,822 demands, 75 percent of everything the government sent. NSLs are not even in that count.

Pip: The piece on how the FBI, DEA, and New Hampshire decide who gets watched fills in the front end of that pipeline. An FBI assessment requires, in the agency's own language, "no particular factual predication" — no evidence, no allegation, only an authorized purpose.

Mara: And a 2026 GAO report found the FBI converted 48 percent of sensitive assessments — a category that includes news organizations — into investigations, against 14 percent of ordinary ones. The protection for journalists is the word "solely": no investigation may be opened solely on First Amendment activity. That word is doing a lot of work.

Pip: New Hampshire runs its own node in this system — the Information and Analysis Center in Concord, wired directly into the FBI's Joint Terrorism Task Force, the DEA's El Paso Intelligence Center, and Treasury's financial-crimes network.

Mara: New Hampshire voters did push back: in 2018, about 81 percent approved a constitutional right to privacy against governmental intrusion in personal information. It binds state and local actors. It cannot switch off a FISA directive.

Pip: The through-line across all of this is the same question the 2010 mortgage-site ruling asked: who counts as the press, and does that status protect you when it matters?

Mara: The record suggests the answer is: sometimes, partially, and only if someone is paying close attention to the fine print.

Transcript of the revised script. The listener’s note above records where it differs from the articles.

Hire, Run, Fire: The Judge, the Clerk and the Birthday

Made October 5, 2026 · Scripted from the articles · 19:21

Three entries from the Jobs in the Law series in one conversation: the circuit judges who carry nine of every ten cases, the appointed clerks who decide what a case is made of, and the two removal tools New Hampshire has never finished using, set beside the age-70 rule that has never failed. Hosts June and Theo are synthetic voices.

Articles discussed in this episode

How this episode was made. The script was written by Claude, an AI model made by Anthropic, from the three articles linked above, and every factual line in it traces to a sentence in one of them. Where the hosts talk about how an article is built, that is their reading of the article, not new reporting. The two voices are synthetic, generated with Kokoro, an open-weight text-to-speech model. None of the articles is legal advice, and neither is this episode.

Read the transcript

June: This is the GSR Podcast, from Granite State Report in Northfield, New Hampshire. I’m June.

Theo: And I’m Theo. Today, three entries from the Jobs in the Law series, and they work best in one sitting. What a judge does all day. Who runs the counter in front of the judge. And how you get a judge off the bench.

June: Hire, run, fire. The whole life cycle of the robe.

Theo: And the trick of the series is that it treats a judge like a job. Hours, caseload, pay, the boss, the exit interview. Once you see it as a job, the strange parts stand out.

June: Start with the first article. “Inside the Job: What a New Hampshire Judge Does All Day.” It’s a GSR Staff explainer, and it opens on a clock. By four in the afternoon, the Superior Court posts the next day’s docket. Somewhere a judge learns what tomorrow holds. A felony arraignment at nine. A suppression motion at ten thirty. A sentencing after lunch.

Theo: And the line right after is the thesis. The job looks almost nothing like the one on television. Most of it happens without a jury, much of it without an audience, and some of it on a video screen.

June: Then the map. One Supreme Court in Concord, a chief justice and four associates. A Superior Court with eleven locations, and it’s the only courtroom in the state where a jury ever sits. And a Circuit Court, created in 2011 by merging the old district, probate, and family courts. Ten circuits, thirty-four locations.

Theo: And no middle court. Appeals from both trial courts go straight to the Supreme Court. New Hampshire has no intermediate appellate court.

June: Now the number that reorganizes the whole picture. Roughly ninety percent of everything filed in the state lands in the Circuit Court. A 2022 study by the National Center for State Courts put the Circuit Court’s volume at an average of a hundred twenty-six thousand eight hundred eleven cases a year. The Superior Court, eleven thousand five hundred fifty-eight.

Theo: So when people picture a New Hampshire judge, they picture the Superior Court. A jury box, a felony trial. The article’s line is the corrective. A circuit judge is the judge most Granite Staters will ever stand in front of.

June: And what does that judge hear on a Tuesday? The article lists it. Misdemeanors, small claims, landlord-tenant cases, stalking petitions. In the Family Division, divorce, parenting plans, child support, protective orders. In Probate, wills, guardianships, name changes, adoptions, involuntary commitments.

Theo: Who’s carrying that? Per the branch’s 2025 outside assessment: forty-nine full-time circuit judges, four retired judges on senior active status, fifteen judicial referees, and three part-time or per-diem judges.

June: And that same 2022 study concluded the state needed eighteen more judges, seventeen of them in the Circuit Court, plus thirty-two more clerical staff, just to match the workload. When the consultants counted in spring 2025, the Circuit Court was carrying fifty-five vacant positions.

Theo: Then the Superior Court day. Arraignments, bail hearings, motion days, jury draws, trial weeks, sentencings. And the article slips in one detail that ties straight back to an earlier episode. Since September 2025, every card transaction on the courts’ filing systems carries a three percent processing fee.

June: Then the bail law. House Bill 592, signed March 25, 2025, effective September 21. For a list of serious charges, only a judge in the circuit or superior courts can now set bail, and the person waits in custody up to thirty-six hours for that arraignment. The law also ended the magistrate program.

Theo: And the article draws the consequence for the job. Weekend and holiday arraignment coverage is a judge’s problem again.

June: Then the Supreme Court, and the article calls its working day a reading day. Since January 2004, nearly every timely appeal from a final trial-court decision is accepted automatically. Most cases are decided on the briefs. No argument at all.

Theo: And when there is argument, there’s a detail I love. Full-court arguments get thirty minutes total, timed by lights at the podium. Amber is the four-minute warning. Red means sit down.

June: There’s also a three-justice panel the court calls 3JX, running since 2000. Five minutes per side, a unanimous result required, and an order that binds only that case.

Theo: Then the powers, and the article gets serious here. A judge decides who stays in jail before trial. Signs the protective order that bars a person from a home. The commitment order. The order terminating a parent’s rights. The decree dividing everything a family owns.

June: And the limits. Part 1, Article 35 of the state constitution promises judges “as impartial as the lot of humanity will admit.”

Theo: Which is the most New Hampshire sentence ever written. It doesn’t promise perfect judges. It promises as good as people get.

June: Then pay. One statute, RSA 491-A:1. The chief justice of the Supreme Court earns two hundred eight thousand one hundred fifty-seven dollars. Associate justices, the Superior Court chief, and the administrative judges earn two hundred one thousand eight hundred ninety-five. Every other full-time judge in the state earns one hundred eighty-nine thousand three hundred fifty.

Theo: No locality pay. No case bonus. No seniority ladder. A circuit judge and an associate superior judge make exactly the same money.

June: And then the hiring. No one elects a New Hampshire judge. The governor nominates, the five-member Executive Council confirms, after a public hearing the law requires on every nominee. Nothing in the constitution requires a law degree. In practice, every sitting judge is a lawyer.

Theo: And then tenure. Once confirmed, a judge holds office during good behavior, with exactly one expiration date. Part 2, Article 78. No person may hold the office of judge after age seventy. A line written in 1792.

June: Voters were asked in November 2024 to raise it to seventy-five. Four hundred fifty-two thousand thirty-one yes. Two hundred thirty-seven thousand one hundred five no. Sixty-five point five nine percent in favor.

Theo: And it failed. One point oh seven points short of two-thirds.

June: Hold that birthday. It comes back in the third article.

Theo: The first article ends by pointing at the next one. The people who make the courtroom run when the judge takes the bench, starting with the clerk.

June: And the clerk article is a different animal. It’s signed opinion by Dexter Dow, and its subtitle is the argument. “Real Power, No Ballot Line.”

Theo: It opens with what I think is the best sentence in the set. Judges decide cases. Clerks decide what a case is made of.

June: Because you never reach a judge without going through a clerk. The clerk takes the filing or rejects it. Sets the hearing date. Decides whether the paper you handed across the counter is now part of the record, and later certifies what that record says.

Theo: Then the constitution. Part II, Article 82. The judges of the courts, probate excepted, “shall appoint their respective clerks to hold their office during pleasure.”

June: During pleasure. No term. No confirmation hearing. No election. A judge hires the clerk, and a judge can let the clerk go.

Theo: Now the list of what a clerk can do without asking a judge, and this is where the article earns its headline. Superior Court Administrative Rule 1-6. A clerk schedules every hearing. Issues the notices to appear and the transport orders. And effectuates court orders, which the rule says includes commitment orders, arrest orders, and summonses for contempt.

June: A clerk selects counsel when the court has ordered counsel appointed, and appoints guardians ad litem in domestic and equity matters.

Theo: And then the part that surprised me. A clerk or deputy who’s a member of the bar can be appointed by a presiding justice as a master, to hear uncontested divorces, temporary orders, ex parte restraining orders in marital cases. The article’s line: that is not paperwork. That is adjudication by an appointed employee.

June: And the Judicial Branch says it in its own job postings. The work may include performing quasi-judicial functions as authorized by the court.

Theo: One more power, and it connects to the Cover Charge episode. Under RSA 499:18-b, when a person is represented by legal aid, a federally funded legal services project, or assigned counsel, filing costs shall be waived by the clerk without the necessity of a court order. No judge involved.

June: Then the money trail. RSA 499:18. The clerk sets aside six percent of each entry fee for an escrow account and thirty percent for the judicial branch information technology fund.

Theo: So nearly a third of what you pay to open a case funds court software.

June: Then the twist I’d want every records requester to hear. RSA 91-A, the Right-to-Know Law, does not reach the courts. It binds executive and legislative bodies. Not the judicial branch.

Theo: Court records are still presumptively public, but the right comes from the state constitution, as the courts read it. In Petition of Keene Sentinel in 1992, the Supreme Court said its records are public “absent some overriding consideration or special circumstance,” and put the burden on whoever wants a record sealed.

June: And the article’s sharpest analysis is right here. On paper, that constitutional standard is stronger than the statute. In practice, it’s weaker in the ways that matter to someone standing at a counter. No five-business-day clock. No written denial naming an exemption. No ombudsman, vacant or otherwise.

Theo: So the practical advice is blunt. If a clerk’s office refuses you a court record, don’t send an RSA 91-A request. The statute doesn’t apply, and the office is under no obligation to answer it. File a petition for access with the court that holds the record, and cite Keene Sentinel.

June: Then the comparison that gives the column its shape. There is exactly one courthouse office New Hampshire voters fill directly. The register of probate. And a 2011 restructuring stripped it down to almost nothing. The New Hampshire Bulletin’s description: the change took the position’s salary, office, duties, and telephone with it.

Theo: The telephone.

June: In 2022, the Legislature asked voters to abolish the office. It cleared the House two hundred ninety-four to forty-three. At the ballot box it drew sixty-two point nine percent. Short of two-thirds. So the office stayed, and so did the elections.

Theo: Same two-thirds wall that kept judges retiring at seventy.

June: And the article puts the two offices side by side. You elect the register of probate to do a job the Legislature already gave away. You have no say over the clerk who waives fees, issues arrest orders, certifies the record, and in some cases hears cases.

Theo: The column’s verdict: New Hampshire got that exactly backwards.

June: Then the budget. Roughly seventy-five percent of judicial branch spending is personnel. In April 2025, after the House passed a budget cutting the branch by close to eight percent, then-Chief Justice Gordon MacDonald imposed a hiring freeze and told the Concord Monitor fewer hands “is necessarily going to reduce our ability to get our decisions out.”

Theo: Two fixes to close it out. Decide whether the register of probate is a job or a title. And have the judiciary write itself a records-response rule with a deadline and a written-denial requirement. The last line: a constitutional presumption of openness is a fine thing to have. A clock is what makes it real.

June: Which hands us to the third article, which is about a very different clock.

Theo: “How to Remove a New Hampshire Judge, and Why It Almost Never Happens.” A staff explainer. And the subtitle is a punchline. The constitution gives elected officials two tools to force a judge off the bench. They have finished the job zero times since 1784. The mechanism that always works is a birthday.

June: Tool one. Impeachment. The House impeaches, the Senate sits as a court. The grounds, in the constitution’s words: “bribery, corruption, malpractice or maladministration, in office.”

Theo: And the track record. In two hundred forty-two years under this constitution, New Hampshire has impeached two judges. In 1790 the House impeached Supreme Court Judge Woodbury Langdon. He resigned before the Senate could try him.

June: The second one took two hundred ten more years. On July 12, 2000, the House voted two hundred fifty-three to ninety-five to impeach Chief Justice David Brock on four articles. The Senate tried him that fall, decided conviction would need two-thirds, and acquitted him on every article.

Theo: And the quote that came out of it, from Senator Burt Cohen. “Poor judgment is not enough.”

June: Two impeachments. Zero removals.

Theo: Tool two. The bill of address. Under Part II, Article 73, the governor and council can remove any commissioned officer for reasonable cause, on the address of both houses. The cause has to be stated fully, can’t be something impeachable, and the officer gets a hearing.

June: And the history here is the fun part. A New Hampshire Bar Association history describes nineteenth-century legislatures abusing it. Majorities would address the entire bench out of office, or abolish a court, create a successor, and stock it with their own people.

Theo: Which is why the modern story is the opposite. The address survives in the text, gets threatened in floor speeches, and has removed no judge in living memory.

June: And then tool three, which isn’t a tool at all. Article 78. Age seventy. No exceptions, and no finishing out the year.

Theo: And here the article lands a detail that ties the whole set together. The 2024 amendment to raise the age to seventy-five, the one that drew about sixty-five and a half percent and failed, had a prime sponsor. Windham Representative Bob Lynn. He was chief justice of the Supreme Court when the clock forced him out at seventy.

June: So the man who lost his seat to the birthday rule tried to change it, got nearly two-thirds of the state behind him, and lost by about a point.

Theo: Then the overseer. The Judicial Conduct Committee, run by the Supreme Court since 1977. Eleven members, and six of the seats belong to members of the public. So laypeople outnumber the judges on the panel that judges judges.

June: But its powers have a hard ceiling. It can dismiss, resolve informally, reprimand, or recommend formal discipline to the Supreme Court. It cannot remove anyone.

Theo: And the article tells you how to file, which most explainers skip. You need standing, meaning you were directly affected or present. The complaint has to be sworn under penalty of perjury. And a complaint that amounts to disagreeing with a ruling isn’t a misconduct complaint. The remedy for a wrong ruling is an appeal.

June: Then the live test. In October 2024, a Merrimack County grand jury indicted Supreme Court Justice Anna Barbara Hantz Marconi on two felonies and five misdemeanors. On October 7, 2025, she pleaded no contest to a single class B misdemeanor and was fined twelve hundred dollars. She admitted no guilt.

Theo: She stopped hearing cases on November 14, 2025. And on February 12, 2026, she turned seventy, and Article 78 did what no other mechanism had. It ended her tenure.

June: And notice what never happened. No impeachment moved. No bill of address advanced. The one process still standing was the Judicial Conduct Committee, and it outlasted her seat. In August 2026 it filed two formal misconduct charges, with a three-day public hearing set for December.

Theo: Against a retired justice. Because the committee keeps jurisdiction over conduct committed in office.

June: And then the chief justice himself. Gordon MacDonald, the same chief who froze hiring in the clerk article, resigned on September 15, 2026, after admitting three violations of the Code of Judicial Conduct.

Theo: Which means, by the time you finish all three articles, the chief justice named in the first article’s roster and quoted in the second is the subject of an update at the top of the third. The series caught the bench changing while it was writing about the bench.

June: The article’s closing summary is the one to remember. The removal power belongs to the elected branches, which have started the process twice in two hundred forty-two years and finished it never. Day-to-day discipline belongs to a committee whose strongest independent weapon is a reprimand. And the one check that has never once failed is the calendar.

Theo: And it leaves the judgment to you. Whether that protects judicial independence or shelters the bench from consequences is the argument the State House now faces.

June: So put the three side by side. A judge you never elect, paid by statute, who leaves at seventy no matter what. A clerk you never elect, who can be fired at a judge’s pleasure and never by you. And the one courthouse office you do elect, which no longer has a telephone.

Theo: Every one of those choices is written down. The articles’ move is to set them side by side and let you see the pattern. Voters stand outside almost the whole building.

June: And all three tell you exactly where the public doors are. The Council’s public hearing on every judicial nominee. The petition for access in a clerk’s office. The sworn complaint to the Judicial Conduct Committee. And the December hearing, which anyone can watch.

Theo: All three articles are linked on the podcast page, with the statutes and constitutional articles they rely on. None of them is legal advice, and neither is this episode.

June: This has been the GSR Podcast.

Transcript of the episode as produced.

Presumed to Know, Punished for Telling

Made October 5, 2026 · Scripted from the articles · 16:32

Two signed columns that make a trap when you read them together: the federal government has tried three times to count its own crimes and New Hampshire still says ignorance is no excuse, while the gun-counter form, the universal reporting statute and the clinic chart make telling the truth the costly choice. Hosts June and Theo are synthetic voices.

Articles discussed in this episode

How this episode was made. The script was written by Claude, an AI model made by Anthropic, from the two articles linked above, and every factual line in it traces to a sentence in one of them. Where the hosts talk about how an article is built, that is their reading of the article, not new reporting. The two voices are synthetic, generated with Kokoro, an open-weight text-to-speech model. Neither article is legal advice, and neither is this episode.

Read the transcript

June: This is the GSR Podcast, from Granite State Report in Northfield, New Hampshire. I’m June.

Theo: And I’m Theo. Two signed columns by Dexter Dow today, and they make a strange pair on purpose. The first says you’re presumed to know every law, and nobody can even count them. The second says when you do tell the truth, the law makes you pay for it.

June: “Nobody Can Count the Laws You’re Presumed to Know.” And “The Honesty Penalty: New Hampshire Still Punishes the People Who Tell the Truth.”

Theo: One is about what you’re supposed to know. The other is about what happens when you say what you know. Between them, there’s a trap.

June: The first column opens on a single week. On July 2, 2026, Governor Kelly Ayotte vetoed nine more bills, bringing her 2026 veto count at that point to twenty-four, double her 2025 total. One week, one branch, one small state.

Theo: Then it zooms out, and the claim is big. There are too many laws for anyone to count, let alone obey with full knowledge. And then the line that keeps it from being a slogan. It is arithmetic, and the arithmetic has been tried.

June: Try one. 1982. The U.S. Department of Justice set out to count how many federal crimes exist. The project ran two years. Staff turned pages by hand through a criminal code scattered across fifty titles and twenty-three thousand pages, according to the Law Library of Congress. The result was an estimate of roughly three thousand offenses.

Theo: An estimate. From the agency whose job is to prosecute them.

June: And the man who led it, Ronald Gainer, gave the quote the whole column hangs on. You will have died and resurrected three times before finishing the count.

Theo: Try two. 1998. The American Bar Association looked at it and declined to attempt a recount at all. Too massive. It settled for measuring growth, and found more than forty percent of federal criminal provisions enacted since the Civil War arrived after 1970.

June: Try three. 2008, a law professor’s update for the Heritage Foundation: at least four thousand four hundred fifty federal offenses. And then 2022, when Heritage researchers threw an algorithm at it. Their Count the Code study scanned about forty-eight thousand sections and estimated five thousand one hundred ninety-nine federal crimes as of 2019.

Theo: And even the algorithm called it an estimate.

June: The column’s summary of the sequence is the best paragraph in it. The most exhaustive effort ever mounted was abandoned as hopeless by the man who ran it. The lawyers’ own professional association refused to try. The best modern number required custom software and still carries an error bar. Congress writes the crimes. Nobody keeps the ledger.

Theo: And then it says statutes are the shallow end. The deeper water is regulation. The Federal Register ran two thousand six hundred twenty pages in its first year, 1936. In 2024 it hit one hundred six thousand one hundred nine, the highest ever recorded.

June: Now the clever move. The column doesn’t have to argue the federal government can’t count its own crimes. It lets the White House say it. Executive Order 14294, signed May 9, 2025, opens by saying the Code of Federal Regulations has over forty-eight thousand sections past a hundred seventy-five thousand pages, and no one, likely including the Department of Justice, knows how many criminal offenses hide inside it.

Theo: So the column’s star witness is the executive branch itself.

June: The order’s stated purpose is that no American should become a criminal for violating “a regulation they have no reason to know exists.” It gave every agency three hundred sixty-five days, a deadline that fell in May 2026, to post a complete list of every criminal regulatory offense it enforces.

Theo: And the column is careful here. Some agencies posted lists. Whether every agency met the deadline is its own story, and the column says plainly that Granite State Report has not audited the full set.

June: Then it notices the irony. That a list of crimes counts as a breakthrough in 2026 is the indictment.

Theo: Then the people the pile lands on. John Yates, a Florida fisherman. In 2007 a state officer flagged some of his red grouper as undersized. He was later charged under a federal records-destruction statute written after Enron’s shredders, carrying up to twenty years.

June: Because the tangible objects he was accused of destroying were fish. Thrown overboard.

Theo: The Supreme Court threw out the conviction in 2015. And Justice Neil Gorsuch and co-author Janie Nitze open their 2024 book, Over Ruled, with his story.

June: The column’s point there is about who’s making the complaint. A sitting justice of the Supreme Court believed the volume of American law had become a threat worth a book.

Theo: And it stacks the witnesses on purpose, across the spectrum. A Trump executive order. A Gorsuch book. Harvey Silverglate, a Boston criminal-defense lawyer, and his book Three Felonies a Day. Mike Chase’s How to Become a Federal Criminal, which documents the federal offense of making an unreasonable gesture to a horse in a national park.

June: And James Madison, in Federalist No. 62, warning it would mean little to elect lawmakers if the laws became “so voluminous that they cannot be read.”

Theo: The column says it out loud. This complaint does not belong to a party. That’s the craft. It picks witnesses nobody can wave off as the other side.

June: The editor also mentions his own book, Generational Malpractice, on the idea that every statute never repealed is an obligation handed to people who weren’t born when it passed.

Theo: Then New Hampshire. The largest state legislature in the country. Four hundred House members and twenty-four senators. The 2025 session saw seven hundred thirty-one House bills and two hundred ninety-six Senate bills introduced, by one session tally.

June: And in June 2026 the governor’s office announced fifty-four signings in a single release, including House Bill 1013. Its official title: “relative to games wherein the object is to capture a pig.”

Theo: New Hampshire now has a state law about pig scrambles.

June: And then below the statutes, the town ordinances. No New Hampshire statute makes female toplessness a crime. Laconia’s ordinance does. Three women were arrested at Weirs Beach in 2016, one of them mid-yoga. The state Supreme Court upheld the ordinance three to two in 2019.

Theo: The column’s line: conduct legal on one beach is a conviction on the next.

June: And then it delivers the punchline the whole column built. RSA 626:3. New Hampshire wrote the old maxim into its criminal code in 1971, effective 1973. Believing your conduct is legal doesn’t relieve you of liability, unless that belief rests on an official statement of the law, and you have to prove it.

Theo: So the state can’t hand you a list of its own crimes, and decided, in writing, that your ignorance of them is your problem.

June: The column is fair about why the rule made sense once. When criminal law tracked common conscience. Theft, assault, fraud. Things a person of ordinary judgment already knows are wrong.

Theo: And then it says what stopped making sense. A code that sprawls past what its own enforcers can catalog, and reaches pig scrambles.

June: The fixes cost nothing, the column says. Order every state agency and the Attorney General to publish one complete, annually updated list of every criminal offense in statute and rule. A default guilty-mind requirement for regulatory offenses. An enforcement note on every bill that creates a crime, the way fiscal notes flag cost. And any session that adds crimes names what it repealed.

Theo: And the closing line. Until a working person can find out in one place what the state forbids, “ignorance of the law is no excuse” is not a principle in New Hampshire. It is a bluff, and the state is holding handcuffs behind it.

June: Now flip it. Say you do know. Say you tell the truth. That’s the second column.

Theo: It opens with a date. August 22, 1979, when RSA 169-C:29 took effect and made every adult in New Hampshire a mandatory reporter of suspected child abuse or neglect. The physician, the teacher, the priest, and then the sweep-up clause. “Any other person having reason to suspect that a child has been abused or neglected.”

June: And the column carries its own disclosure up top. The editor has had personal contact with the reporting systems it describes, and says the piece is reported from statutes, court opinions, agency records, and published sources.

Theo: Then the second date. June 18, 2026. United States v. Hemani. The column reports all nine justices agreed the government couldn’t prosecute a Texas man as a felon for keeping a gun at home while using marijuana.

June: And his honesty was the whole case. Agents searching his family’s house for something else asked. He answered that he smoked about every other day. Six months later, the admission became the indictment.

Theo: The column is careful about how narrow the ruling is. The Court didn’t strike the 1968 drug-user gun ban. It held that prosecuting someone for marijuana use alone, with no claim of danger or misuse, can’t survive the Second Amendment. The text stays on the books.

June: Then the gun counter. ATF Form 4473, the form every buyer at a licensed dealer signs, still asks whether you unlawfully use marijuana, and still warns it’s unlawful federally regardless of your state’s law.

Theo: And here’s the trap, laid out in two sentences. Answer yes, and the dealer has to stop the sale. Answer no while using, and you’ve committed a federal felony.

June: The column’s phrasing: the possession offense is dead for the ordinary user. The paperwork survives, and its only guaranteed consequence lands on the person who tells the truth.

Theo: And the enforcement numbers make it sharper. A Washington Post review, cited by the U.S. Concealed Carry Association, found that of roughly a hundred twelve thousand federal purchase denials in 2017, twelve people were prosecuted.

June: The machine denies honest applicants at scale and pursues liars almost never.

Theo: And the New Hampshire stakes. Possession of up to three-quarters of an ounce has been a hundred-dollar civil violation here since 2017. Roughly fifteen thousand patients are in the state’s Therapeutic Cannabis Program.

June: Then back to the reporting statute. The trigger is low on purpose. The Attorney General’s model protocol says a reporter needs only “reason to believe that something could have happened.”

Theo: And every protection runs one direction. Good-faith reporters get civil and criminal immunity under RSA 169-C:31. Callers can stay anonymous. Privilege falls under 169-C:32.

June: The person reported on gets an assessment, a case file, and if the department finds abuse or neglect by a preponderance of the evidence, a founded finding with written notice and an appeal clock already running.

Theo: Now here’s the part I’d point to as the column’s best service. It stops to correct folk beliefs that its own readers might hold. A report is an accusation, and the system’s own rules say so. An anonymous call proves nothing. An assessment is not a verdict. No written finding in your mailbox means nothing has been determined about you.

June: And it kills the angriest myth outright. A child-protection report can’t strip your gun rights. The federal background check system denies buyers in a short list of categories. Felony conviction. Fugitive status. The drug-user provision. A mental-health adjudication or involuntary commitment. Certain protective orders. Domestic-violence misdemeanors.

Theo: And nowhere in that scheme is there a category for state child-protection reports, founded or unfounded. A voluntary therapy appointment isn’t a commitment. A substance-use screening isn’t one either.

June: That’s an outlet arguing the system punishes honesty, and in the same breath telling angry readers they’ve got one piece of it wrong. The column’s line: anger at the right target starts with pulling the actual record.

Theo: Then the clinic, which is where the two halves of the column meet. Federal drug-treatment confidentiality law exists, by the government’s own description, so a person who seeks help is “not made more vulnerable” than one who never walks in the door.

June: And then the doors in that wall. HIPAA lets providers disclose to child-protection authorities. The federal treatment-confidentiality rules have a child-abuse-reporting exception, and a court can open even confidential treatment communications where suspected abuse or neglect is in play.

Theo: And the column’s take on the clinicians is generous. They aren’t the villains. The statute gives them no discretion. The design is the defendant, and the design belongs to the legislature.

June: And then the sentence that names the trap. The safest legal strategy this state offers a struggling parent is silence. The statutes wrote that advice.

Theo: The column also follows the reports to where removed children went for three generations. The Youth Development Center in Manchester. The state’s own claims administration reported in May 2026: four hundred twenty-five abuse claims resolved for two hundred thirty-nine point three million dollars.

June: And the fixes are specific. ATF can finalize the form it already drafted. Congress can conform the gun ban to the ruling. Concord can pass the bills filed in 2026 to protect therapeutic-cannabis patients’ gun rights, and stop treating a hundred-dollar civil violation as a character verdict.

Theo: And the column’s closing: honesty is the input every one of these systems runs on, from the intake form to the federal form to the sworn petition. New Hampshire should stop billing for it.

June: So now put the two columns in the same room.

Theo: Column one. You’re presumed to know every law, and the state can’t count them. RSA 626:3 says your ignorance is your problem.

June: Column two. Say what you know, on a form or in a clinic, and the record you created is the one that gets used. Stay quiet, and nothing gets generated.

Theo: So the law expects you to know everything. And in the places these columns look, telling the truth about yourself is the expensive choice.

June: That’s our reading of the pair, not a line from either column. But each one gets there by the same method. Find the official document that makes the case for you. A Justice Department official who gave up counting. An executive order admitting nobody knows. A federal form that turns a yes into a denial and a no into a felony.

Theo: And each one marks its own limits. The first says it isn’t arguing for fewer protections against theft or violence. The second says it isn’t asking anyone to trust drugs or doubt child protection. Only to notice which behavior the statutes tax.

June: Both articles are linked on the podcast page, with the statutes, the orders, and the cases they rely on. Both are signed opinion. Neither is legal advice, and neither is this episode.

Theo: This has been the GSR Podcast.

Transcript of the episode as produced.

Both Are True: The Cop, the Hairdresser and the Holiday Nobody Gets Off

Made October 4, 2026 · Scripted from the articles · 16:50

Three Granite State Report articles built on side-by-side comparisons: a cosmetologist’s training hours against a police recruit’s, a federal SNAP fraud ceiling against federal manslaughter, and an Election Day holiday that a 1913 factory law still protects. The hosts look at how each article checks its own comparison and where each one says the comparison stops. Hosts June and Theo are synthetic voices.

Articles discussed in this episode

How this episode was made. The script was written by Claude, an AI model made by Anthropic, from the three articles linked above, and every factual line in it traces to a sentence in one of them. Where the hosts talk about how an article is built, that is their reading of the article, not new reporting. The two voices are synthetic, generated with Kokoro, an open-weight text-to-speech model. None of the articles is legal advice, and neither is this episode.

Read the transcript

June: This is the GSR Podcast, from Granite State Report in Northfield, New Hampshire. I’m June.

Theo: And I’m Theo. This episode is about a move Granite State Report keeps making, because it keeps working. Take two things the state already wrote down. Set them side by side. Let the reader feel the gap.

June: Three articles, three side-by-sides. A hairdresser and a police officer. Food stamp fraud and manslaughter. And a holiday nobody gets off.

Theo: Each headline sounds like something your uncle posted. That’s the hook. The craft is that every one of these articles checks its own comparison, and then tells you exactly where the comparison stops working.

June: Start with the hairdresser. The headline is “New Hampshire Licenses a Cosmetologist Slower Than It Certifies a Cop.” Dexter Dow wrote it as signed opinion.

Theo: It opens with a list. Everything New Hampshire requires before it hands someone a badge, a loaded sidearm, arrest powers, and the keys to a cruiser. A high school diploma or a GED. A clean record. A driver’s license. A background check, a fitness test, a psychological screen, and sixteen weeks at the academy in Concord. Certification has to land within six months of the date of hire.

June: And then one short sentence. That is the entire front door.

Theo: Now the other side of the ledger. To color your hair for money, the state requires fifteen hundred hours of schooling, or a three-thousand-hour apprenticeship spread over eighteen months. A barber needs eight hundred hours. A full-time police officer needs about seven hundred forty.

June: And a part-time certified officer, who carries the same gun and the same arrest powers, needs two hundred.

Theo: Two hundred. The national average for police basic training was eight hundred six hours in 2022, according to the federal Bureau of Justice Statistics. New Hampshire sits below it.

June: Here’s what makes the comparison land. It isn’t an outsider’s stunt. Every number on both sides comes out of New Hampshire’s own standards. The section heading says it: hours tell the truth. The state wrote both numbers. It just never set them on the same page.

Theo: Then the article does it again, with a car. Under RSA 263:14, New Hampshire licenses a driver at sixteen, and then for the next six months restricts how many young passengers that new driver can carry, because the state understands a fresh license is a risk.

June: Six months. The same span in which a police recruit goes from civilian to fully certified officer. The line in the article: the state trusts a new driver less than it trusts a new cop.

Theo: Then the article goes looking at what happens after the academy. Nationally, eighty-nine percent of academies required a separate field-training program in 2022, averaging five hundred three hours where academies ran it. New Hampshire’s rules set exact hours for the academy and none for field training. Each department runs its own. The article calls the first months alone in a cruiser the recruit’s most dangerous stretch, governed town by town, chief by chief.

June: And then the part I’d call the sharpest reporting in the piece. The hiring screen. Read the disqualifier list again, it says, and notice what it measures. No record. No drug history. No visible failure.

Theo: Which means the candidate who clears it cleanest is, by definition, the candidate who has lived the least.

June: And it proves the point with the state’s own paperwork. The Police Standards and Training Council’s minutes from October 28, 2025. The Nashua Police Department wanted to hire a man who was already working as a certified police officer in North Carolina.

Theo: The problem. As a high school sophomore, in 2010 or 2011, he sold a friend a bag of marijuana for twenty dollars. That tripped the drug-sale rule and forced a hearing before the state’s certification body.

June: A working cop. Twenty dollars. A teenager. A state hearing.

Theo: Meanwhile, the article says, the same rulebook waves through a twenty-one-year-old with an immaculate and empty record, who has never held a job under pressure, never sat with an addict, never been broke. The first profile needs a waiver. The second one gets a cruiser.

June: And notice what the article leaves out. It never names the Nashua candidate. The editor’s note says why. The point is the rule, not the man.

Theo: Then the evidence. A 2024 review in the journal Criminology and Public Policy reports that college-educated officers draw fewer citizen complaints and fewer misconduct cases, and that education is among the most consistent correlates of lower use of force. A 2019 study of Chicago complaint records found the risk of a use-of-force complaint drops steeply across an officer’s first decade on the job.

June: And the brain research. Impulse control and emotion regulation keep maturing into a person’s twenties. The article’s aside there is the best one-liner in the piece. Try renting a sedan at twenty-two without a surcharge. The rental counter already priced this in. The police rules treat it as a clean slate.

Theo: The fair-minded line comes right after. None of this says a twenty-one-year-old can’t become a fine officer. Plenty have. The point is structural.

June: And there’s a working model next door, in the state’s own building. A State Police trooper candidate must be twenty-one and bring sixty college credits or two years of qualifying experience. California raised its statewide hiring age to twenty-one in a 2021 law, Assembly Bill 89, for new hires starting in 2022.

Theo: So the first of the article’s five fixes is a twenty-one floor statewide. If twenty-one is the standard for a trooper on I-93, it’s the standard for an officer alone on a domestic call in Belmont at midnight.

June: And then the closing move, which I’d put up against anything on the site. Take the current screen to its logical end. If the ideal candidate never broke a rule, never touched a substance, never failed, and never suffered, then follow that logic all the way down and hire ten-year-olds.

Theo: No record is cleaner. No past is emptier.

June: That’s an argument that wins by agreeing with the other side all the way to the cliff. The Council held a public hearing on rewriting these rules on July 28, 2026. The article ends by telling readers that every rulemaking gives the public a say. Say it.

Theo: Second comparison. “SNAP Fraud Can Carry Twenty Years in Federal Prison. Manslaughter Caps at Fifteen. Both Are True.” This one is a GSR Staff explainer.

June: And this one starts life as a meme. The kind of thing that gets screenshotted with no source. The easy moves are to share it or to debunk it. This article audits it.

Theo: The federal SNAP fraud statute is 7 U.S.C. 2024. It covers anyone who knowingly uses, transfers, acquires, alters, or possesses benefits contrary to the law. And then the penalty is graded by one thing only. Dollars.

June: Five thousand dollars or more, up to twenty years and a two-hundred-fifty-thousand-dollar fine. A hundred dollars up to five thousand, up to five years. Under a hundred, a misdemeanor, up to a year.

Theo: And the article stops on one word. Knowingly. The government has to prove intent. A paperwork mistake is not a federal crime.

June: Now the other side. Federal manslaughter, 18 U.S.C. 1112. Voluntary manslaughter, a killing in a sudden quarrel or the heat of passion, caps at fifteen years. Involuntary, at eight.

Theo: So, in federal court, the meme holds. A big enough benefit fraud carries a higher ceiling than killing a person without malice.

June: And then comes the fine print, which is the whole point of the article. Federal manslaughter is a narrow statute. It reaches federal lands, military bases, ships at sea. Most homicides in this country are charged under state law.

Theo: And walk into a New Hampshire courtroom, and the comparison flips. RSA 630:2 punishes manslaughter with up to thirty years. That’s ten years above the worst federal SNAP count.

June: So anyone using the meme to describe New Hampshire law has it backwards. The headline says both are true, and the article shows you the one courtroom where each one is true.

Theo: Then it does the math nobody does. The fiscal 2026 maximum benefit for one person is two hundred ninety-eight dollars a month. The five-thousand-dollar line that unlocks the twenty-year maximum equals nearly seventeen months of a single adult’s maximum benefit.

June: And the hundred-dollar line between a misdemeanor and a felony? About ten days of one person’s maximum allotment. Those thresholds are fixed in the statute. They don’t adjust for inflation. Every annual cost-of-living increase quietly shrinks the time it takes to cross a felony line.

Theo: Then the reality check. Maximums are not sentences. On July 1, 2026, a federal judge in Trenton sentenced a sixty-seven-year-old New Jersey grocer, Victor Madera. According to federal prosecutors, his store ran more than two point two million dollars in benefits through inflated transactions. He pleaded guilty. His exposure ran to twenty years. His sentence was twenty-seven months, plus more than two point two million in restitution and forfeiture.

June: And most of the action in New Hampshire is administrative, run through the Department of Health and Human Services. First intentional violation, twelve months out of the program. Second, twenty-four. Third, permanent. Trafficking five hundred dollars or more, permanent on the first court finding.

Theo: The last idea in the article is the one that makes the meme make sense. The two bodies of law grade harm on different axes. Homicide by mental state: malice, provocation, recklessness. Fraud by dollars.

June: A single recipient would have to misuse every dollar of the maximum benefit for nearly seventeen straight months to reach the top tier. A store running a cash-for-benefits counter can cross the same line in a week. The comparison is real, the article says. The context is the part that never fits in a screenshot.

Theo: Third comparison. Election Day is a legal holiday in New Hampshire.

June: Hold on. It is?

Theo: Since 1891. A one-sentence act titled “An Act to Make Election Day a Legal Holiday,” approved March 19, 1891. It still sits in RSA 288:1, between Columbus Day and Veterans Day.

June: So everybody gets the day off.

Theo: The law doesn’t give anyone the day off. Not even the state’s own workers. The article checks all eleven legal holidays against two 2026 calendars, the executive branch’s and the courts’. The biennial election is the only one on neither. State offices stay open. The courts stay open.

June: So it’s a holiday in the law books and a Tuesday on the state’s own calendars.

Theo: Now the twist. In 1913 the Legislature passed a law that’s still on the books as RSA 275:28. No employee shall be required to work in any mill or factory on any legal holiday, except for work that’s both absolutely necessary and lawful on the Lord’s Day.

June: Any legal holiday.

Theo: Any. And the biennial election was already on the list when that law passed. The text wasn’t even original. Massachusetts approved an act with the same title, the same first section, and the same fine on March 17, 1911.

June: What was the fine?

Theo: In 1913, not more than five hundred dollars. Then New Hampshire’s criminal code went to work on it. One rule, RSA 625:9, makes a crime written outside the code a felony when a corporation commits it, if the maximum fine is more than two hundred dollars.

June: And five hundred is more than two hundred.

Theo: In 1973 the penalty was rewritten in one sentence. A misdemeanor for a natural person. A felony for any other person. A corporation is not a natural person.

June: So a company that requires factory work on a legal holiday commits a felony.

Theo: With a fine ceiling up to a hundred thousand dollars. Meanwhile Massachusetts, where the text came from, still treats it as a fine. Fifteen hundred dollars.

June: So the copy ended up meaner than the original.

Theo: Then the exception. Work that can lawfully be performed on the Lord’s Day. That used to have something to measure against, the Sunday business law, RSA chapter 332-D. The Legislature repealed that chapter in 2016. So the exception points at a law that isn’t there anymore.

June: Has anybody ever used this statute?

Theo: The article searched New Hampshire Supreme Court opinions and found no decision applying it, and it’s careful to say a search that finds nothing doesn’t prove nothing exists. The Department of Labor lists the section among the laws it administers and enforces. Its wage-and-hour questions page says nothing about holiday work in mills or factories.

June: My favorite detail is in the archives. The House Journal shows a fight. On May 15, 1913, a Mr. Clifford of Franklin offered an amendment to soften the bill. Six days later, one line: “Mr. Clifford withdrew his amendment.” The bill passed that day, May 21, 1913.

Theo: And the photo the article runs is workers waiting at the Amoskeag mill gate in Manchester at six in the morning on May 21, 1909. Four years to the day before the law was approved.

June: Lawmakers have tried to give the holiday some teeth. At least eight bills between 2014 and 2025, to close public offices, add the primaries, or give workers time to vote. None became law.

Theo: The first, in 2014, had a public hearing that opened at 2:13 in the afternoon and adjourned at 2:23. The committee voted eighteen to nothing to kill it. Its report gives the reason in one sentence: current law already fulfills this need.

June: It doesn’t name the law.

Theo: It doesn’t name the law.

June: And the article doesn’t tell anyone to walk off the line. It’s careful. It lists what a worker can use. At state elections, polls open no later than eleven in the morning and close no earlier than seven at night. If work keeps you away for all of polling hours, you can vote absentee, and caring for children or infirm adults counts as employment, paid or not. It calls all of that a reading of the text, not legal advice.

Theo: And it says plainly that the Department of Labor and the Department of Administrative Services were not asked to comment before publishing, and that any comment will be added with its date. You don’t see many articles tell you what they didn’t do.

June: The last line is the whole piece. The statute book says two things at once. The state’s calendar says it is a Tuesday.

Theo: So here’s what ties the three together. None of them needed a leak or a secret source. The cosmetology hours and the police hours. The fraud statute and the manslaughter statute. The holiday list and the factory law. Every one was already public. The reporting was reading the whole book and noticing which pages disagree.

June: And every one marks its own edges. The police piece says plenty of young officers turn out fine. The SNAP piece says the meme flips in a New Hampshire courtroom. The holiday piece says nobody knows whether anyone would enforce the law.

Theo: Which is why the comparisons hold up. They come with their own fine print.

June: All three articles are linked on the podcast page, with the statutes and sources they rely on. None of them is legal advice, and neither is this episode. This has been the GSR Podcast.

Transcript of the episode as produced.

Annulled, Not Erased: The Arrest File and the Mugshot

Made October 4, 2026 · Scripted from the articles · 17:56

Two signed columns that argue with the same statute from opposite ends of an arrest: what a $350 annulment does and does not remove, why the town keeps the arrest report permanently, and why the booking photo is the one record no court order can call back. Each column says where its author’s own interest cuts against his argument. Hosts June and Theo are synthetic voices.

Articles discussed in this episode

How this episode was made. The script was written by Claude, an AI model made by Anthropic, from the two articles linked above, and every factual line in it traces to a sentence in one of them. Where the hosts talk about how an article is built, that is their reading of the article, not new reporting. The two voices are synthetic, generated with Kokoro, an open-weight text-to-speech model. Neither article is legal advice, and neither is this episode.

Read the transcript

June: This is the GSR Podcast, from Granite State Report in Northfield, New Hampshire. I’m June.

Theo: And I’m Theo. This episode takes two articles that argue with the same state from opposite ends of an arrest. One is about how New Hampshire makes an arrest legally disappear. The other is about the one piece of that arrest that never disappears.

June: The booking photo.

Theo: The first article is “How to Annul a Criminal Record in New Hampshire, and Why the Police File Never Goes Away.” The second is “Mugshots Are Punishment Without a Verdict. Concord Buried the Fix Twice.” Both are signed opinion by Dexter Dow.

June: And both do something you don’t see often. Each one tells you where the author’s own interest cuts against his own argument. We’ll come back to that.

Theo: Start with the annulment piece. It doesn’t open with the forms. It opens with a sentence from the New Hampshire State Police’s own website. Quote: “New Hampshire CHRI has no expiration date and only is removed by way of a Petition to Annul granted by the court of jurisdiction, and all related fees are satisfied.”

June: CHRI is the criminal history file. And the article reads that sentence as the design document. Nothing ages out. Nothing gets purged at ten years, or twenty, or when you die. There’s one exit, it’s a court order, and the court order has a price.

Theo: Then it’s fair about what the order buys you, which is a lot. Under RSA 651:5, once a record is annulled, a job application, a license application, even a witness stand can only ask about a crime that has not been annulled. You answer no. You’re not lying, and nobody can make you explain.

June: The court file gets sealed. The State Police pull the entry out of the state repository and notify the federal system, which the agency says takes two to four weeks.

Theo: And then the provision almost nobody knows about. Since January 1, 2019, a case that ends in a dismissal, a nolle prosequi, or a not-guilty finding on every charge is annulled automatically, thirty days later. No petition. No fee.

June: The article’s line there is quietly brutal. If your case ended that way since 2019, it already happened, whether anyone told you or not.

Theo: Now the part the name hides. Annulment does not destroy anything. The article goes to a different statute, RSA 33-A:3-a, which tells towns and cities the minimum time to keep each kind of record.

June: And it reads like a grocery list. Fire incident reports, ten years. Police calls for service, five years. Motor vehicle violation paperwork, three years. The article notes it goes all the way down to airport fuel inspections at six months.

Theo: And then, for police arrest reports, the Legislature wrote one word. Permanently.

June: That’s the clever bit of structure. You don’t need a pundit to tell you the arrest report is special. The state gave a shelf life to nearly everything a town touches, and then made one exception.

Theo: When the annulment order reaches the arresting agency, its legal duty is to mark the file annulled. A label, not a shredder. And the statute keeps law enforcement’s right to hold arrest and conviction records outright and share them with other officers for investigations, or with the Police Standards and Training Council when it decides whether someone is fit to wear a badge.

June: There’s one more catch inside the promise. The statute says you’re treated as if you were never arrested. Then it says that if you’re convicted of something later, the judge can consider the annulled conviction at sentencing, and it still counts toward habitual offender status.

Theo: The article’s line: the record is gone for your landlord. It is not gone for the man in the robe.

June: Then the court case. In 2016, the New Hampshire Supreme Court decided Grafton County Attorney’s Office v. Canner. A man indicted on multiple felony counts, acquitted by a jury on all of them, then annulled by a judge in 2014. While that was pending, someone filed Right-to-Know requests for the trial records and the police investigative file.

Theo: And the court held those records are “not categorically exempt from public inspection.” The trial court put it more bluntly on the way up. The statute treats the person as if he was never arrested, not the record.

June: And the article is precise about the limit. The court didn’t declare annulled police files public. It sent the case back so the privacy and law enforcement exemptions could be applied document by document. What it removed was the automatic shield.

Theo: Here’s where the disclosure comes in. The author files public-records requests as a routine part of this outlet’s reporting. So he has a direct interest in that ruling, and he says so at the top. Then he says he thinks the ruling is right. Citizens need a way to audit how police and prosecutors used their power.

June: And then he turns around and looks from the other side of the counter. That man was acquitted by a jury, annulled by a judge, and his arrest file was still on the table.

Theo: It happens again two sections later. The end of RSA 651:5 has two paragraphs that settle what’s left. One shields a journalist from any civil or criminal penalty for publishing that someone had an annulled record. The other says no person or entity faces any penalty for refusing to remove or correct such a report.

June: It used to be a crime for a third party to disclose someone’s annulled record. That paragraph was repealed in 2012.

Theo: And the article says it out loud. That shield protects me. It’s why this outlet can report on an annulled case without a lawyer at my elbow. And it’s the flattest statement in New Hampshire law that annulment was never erasure.

June: So the newspaper archive stays up. The mugshot site stays up. The data broker who scraped the conviction keeps its copy and owes nothing.

Theo: Then the price. The circuit court lists a petition to annul at a hundred twenty-five dollars, charged per court location. Corrections charges a hundred to investigate you and report to the court. On a conviction, the State Police charge another hundred, per court. Then twenty-five for a fresh record check to confirm the work got done.

June: About three hundred fifty dollars for one conviction in one court.

Theo: There are fee waivers for people who are indigent, found not guilty, or whose case was dismissed. The article says use them. It also points out they’re three separate showings to three separate offices, each with its own form, by a person the state has already decided is too poor to pay.

June: And the article catches the state disagreeing with itself. The State Police annulment page lists a hundred-dollar court filing fee near the top, then says a few paragraphs down that the court will charge a hundred twenty-five.

Theo: The waiting periods run from the day you finish every term of the sentence, down to the last dollar of fines and restitution. One year for a violation. Up to ten for a class A felony. Some crimes can never be annulled. And one rule does more damage than all the rest.

June: Paragraph six. If you have more than one offense, every one has to clear its own waiting period before you can file for any of them. And if a single entry is barred, the whole file is barred.

Theo: The article’s example: one disqualifying conviction from 1997 locks everything you have done since.

June: Then a number. At the end of 2022, the federal Bureau of Justice Statistics counted five hundred ninety-five thousand six hundred individual subjects in New Hampshire’s criminal history file. The state’s population is about one point four million.

Theo: And the article stops you from misreading it. That’s not a count of living Granite Staters with records. It includes people arrested here who live elsewhere. And since the file never expires, it includes the dead. What it measures is how much this state has kept, and how little ever leaves.

June: One more irony. A separate statute lets you annul an arrest or conviction for three-quarters of an ounce of marijuana or less from before September 16, 2017. The Legislature made that conduct a civil violation that same year. The youth annulment statute waives its filing fee right on its face. The marijuana one says nothing about fees.

Theo: So you pay full freight to clear a charge the state stopped treating as a crime.

June: The article ends with four fixes. One payment and one waiver instead of three. The statute already compels annulment of many violations and class B misdemeanors unless a prosecutor objects, so drop the petition and let the computer do it. Waive the marijuana fee. And give people a written right to ask their police department whether an annulled file has been released since the order.

Theo: And it points out there’s no cheap place to fight about any of it. Thomas Kehr resigned as Right-to-Know ombudsman in July 2025, after lawmakers cut the job’s salary and budget from a hundred five thousand dollars to thirty thousand. As of July 2, 2026, the article reports, the governor had not nominated a replacement.

June: The closing line: what the state is not entitled to do is take three hundred fifty dollars across a counter and let the person walk out believing the file is gone.

Theo: Which hands us straight to the second article. Because the loudest piece of that file was never in the basement. It was on Facebook.

June: The mugshot piece opens with the scene. The camera comes out at the worst hour of a person’s life. Hair wrecked, eyes swollen, lit flat by fluorescent tubes, photographed by the government against a wall. No judge has heard a word. Nothing has been proven.

Theo: And the photo exists so officers can identify who’s in their custody. The article says it does a second job the law never assigned it. It convicts.

June: Then a sentence most outlets would never print. Publishing routine booking photos is abuse.

Theo: That’s a strong claim, so the article goes and gets witnesses who aren’t the author. In 2016, the full Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals reversed twenty years of its own precedent and held that people have a real privacy interest in their booking photos under the federal Freedom of Information Act. A disclosed booking photo, the court wrote, “casts a long, damaging shadow over the depicted individual.”

June: The U.S. Marshals Service now withholds federal mugshots as a rule. In June 2021 the Associated Press said it would stop running stories driven mainly by an embarrassing mugshot, because they have long lives on the internet and the wire rarely covers how a case ends. San Francisco police quit releasing most booking photos in 2020.

Theo: The article’s comparison is the line I’d remember. The federal government treats its own booking photos as private. Your local police department posts theirs between the road-closure notice and the K-9 fundraiser.

June: Then the industry built on top. Scraper sites that harvest booking records and republish them for search engines. And the business model blunt enough that legislatures gave it a name. Mugshot extortion. Charging the person in the photo to make it disappear.

Theo: By late 2017, the news service Stateline counted eighteen states with laws aimed at that model. The same reporting found them mostly failing. A University of California law professor who studied them, Eumi Lee, put it in three words. “They haven’t worked.” The sites move domains and reload the same photos.

June: So the article says takedown laws chase the water after the dam breaks. The dam is the government release itself, and only the government controls it.

Theo: And now the two articles click together. RSA 651:5, the annulment statute, says an annulled person “shall be treated in all respects” as if never arrested, convicted, or sentenced. And no New Hampshire statute governs when police may release a booking photo at all. Each department decides.

June: So the state hands the loudest arrest record there is to the open internet on day one. Then, years later, it tells the acquitted that a judge’s order has erased it.

Theo: The article’s phrase for that is a leak with paperwork.

June: Then the legislative history, which is where the article earns the word “twice” in its headline. In 2021, House Bill 125 would have kept post-arrest photos out of public release until conviction, with exceptions for fugitives, safety threats, and court orders. Two Democratic sponsors and a Republican.

Theo: The House Criminal Justice committee recommended it nineteen to two. The full House passed it on a voice vote. The Senate Judiciary Committee reported it ought to pass on May 25. Two days later it was sent back to committee. And in January 2022 it went to interim study.

June: The article’s description of interim study: where New Hampshire bills go to die politely.

Theo: And it names who showed up to kill it. At the Senate hearing, the New Hampshire Press Association, represented by Union Leader publisher Brendan McQuaid, opposed it as a threat to transparency. Manchester Police Chief Allen Aldenberg opposed it for the chiefs. The ACLU of New Hampshire supported it.

June: Two years later, the same idea came back from the other side of the aisle. Senate Bill 246 in 2023, sponsored entirely by Republicans. Same building. Same grave. Interim study on January 3, 2024. No floor vote on the merits.

Theo: And here’s the analysis I think makes the article. A Democrat-led bipartisan bill dies in the Senate. An all-Republican bill dies in the same Senate two years later. The article’s conclusion: when both parties file the same reform and committee process swallows it twice, the opposition is institutional, and party has nothing to do with it.

June: And it names the two constituencies. Police departments, which want the option. And, in the article’s words, my own industry, which wants the clicks.

Theo: That’s the second self-implication. A newspaper editor telling you the press is one of the reasons this bill keeps dying.

June: Other states moved. Utah made booking photos protected records in 2021, no release until conviction. Its sponsor, Representative Keven Stratton, said at the hearing, “we hang a virtual scarlet letter around the one that’s been accused.” California went further in 2023: booking photos police post on social media come down within fourteen days, retroactively, with narrow exceptions. Louisiana passed limits in 2022. New York’s 2019 budget pulled the State Police out of the routine mugshot business.

Theo: And the article points out what didn’t happen. Transparency didn’t collapse. Arrest logs stayed public. Names, charges, dates, arresting agencies stayed public. Courtrooms stayed open.

June: Then the hard part, and the article flags it as the hard part. The First Amendment. In Smith v. Daily Mail in 1979, the Supreme Court held the state can’t punish publishing lawfully obtained, truthful information on a matter of public significance without an interest of the highest order.

Theo: So a bill that gags the press loses in court. And the article says it should. The author says he wouldn’t sign one if it could pass.

June: So the fix goes upstream. The government took the photo. The government controls the tap. Stop routine pre-conviction release. Make agencies take posted photos down after acquittal, dismissal, non-prosecution, or annulment. And make charging a fee to remove a booking photo an unfair trade practice.

Theo: Every right the press holds today survives. What disappears, the article says, is the free feed.

June: And the article didn’t stop at arguing. Granite State Report drafted a model bill and published it with the piece, ready for any legislator to carry. Five provisions, including one that says in black letters that nothing in the act restricts anyone’s right to publish a lawfully obtained photograph.

Theo: The article’s reason for that clause: a bill that survives court is worth ten that feel good in a press release.

June: So put the two together. The annulment article shows a state that keeps everything and sells a label change. The mugshot article shows a state that releases the worst picture of you before anyone has proven anything. Same statute, two directions.

Theo: And both are written by someone who benefits from the opposite outcome, and says so. A records requester defending a ruling that hurts the people he’s writing for. A newspaper editor arguing his own industry should lose a free product.

June: That’s what keeps both arguments honest. You can see the author’s thumb, and he shows you where it’s resting.

Theo: Both articles are linked on the podcast page, with the statutes, cases, and the model bill. Neither one is legal advice, and neither is this episode.

June: This has been the GSR Podcast.

Transcript of the episode as produced.

Justice Has a Cover Charge

Made October 4, 2026 · Scripted from the articles · 14:55

Two signed columns on what justice costs in New Hampshire: the eighty-dollar exhibit set, the fee waiver that stops at the cash register, and the transcript deposit an appeal dies without; then the innocence law that took a veto override, set beside a seven-count indictment that closed with a $1,200 fine. Hosts June and Theo are synthetic voices.

Articles discussed in this episode

How this episode was made. The script was written by Claude, an AI model made by Anthropic, from the two articles linked above, and every factual line in it traces to a sentence in one of them. Where the hosts talk about how an article is built, that is their reading of the article, not new reporting. The two voices are synthetic, generated with Kokoro, an open-weight text-to-speech model. Neither article is legal advice, and neither is this episode.

Read the transcript

June: This is the GSR Podcast, from Granite State Report in Northfield, New Hampshire. I’m June.

Theo: And I’m Theo. This episode pairs two signed columns by Dexter Dow about what justice costs in New Hampshire. One is about the price of being poor in a courtroom. The other is about what happens to a criminal charge when the defendant is powerful.

June: “The Price of Proof: New Hampshire Courts Bill the Poor for Justice.” And “Two Tiers of Justice: Who New Hampshire Convicts, and Who Pays a Fine.”

Theo: Different subjects. Same engine. Watch for how many times money turns into time, and time turns into an outcome.

June: The first column opens on the most boring document imaginable. The Judicial Branch’s page on preparing for court. It tells you you’re responsible for giving the other side copies of all your documents ahead of time, to bring extra copies, and that if you show up without enough, the judge may have to delay the proceedings.

Theo: And the column says, sensible advice. Now read it again with four dollars in your checking account.

June: Then it does the math. At the clerk’s counter, the court copies documents at fifty cents a page. The public kiosk prints at a quarter. Say your evidence runs forty pages. Bank statements, photos, a police report, the texts that prove your side. One set for the judge, one for the other party, one for the witness stand, one for you.

Theo: A hundred sixty pages. At the courthouse rate, handing the court the truth costs eighty dollars.

June: That phrase is the column in miniature. Handing the court the truth costs eighty dollars.

Theo: The column also tells you who’s writing. It discloses that the editor is a self-represented litigant in New Hampshire courts and writes from direct experience with these costs. So you know where the receipts come from.

June: Then the law. RSA 499:18-b. Any person, by reason of poverty, can ask to be relieved of fees payable to a court, a clerk of court, or a sheriff. The application is free. And the court “may, in its discretion,” grant it.

Theo: The column stops on the verb. May. Nobody is entitled to it.

June: And then on the boundary. The waiver covers fees payable to a court, a clerk, or a sheriff. The door charge. It doesn’t buy paper, or toner, or the internet connection you need for mandatory e-filing, or gas to the courthouse, or the shift you lose to a Tuesday hearing.

Theo: The line: the waiver stops at the courthouse cash register. Everything past the register is on you.

June: Then a detail that reads like satire and isn’t. As of September 3, 2025, every electronic court transaction paid with a credit or debit card through File and Serve or TurboCourt carries a three percent processing surcharge. The card terminals at the clerk’s window add the same. And small claims cases have to be filed electronically unless the court grants an exemption.

Theo: So the person with the least money, in the forum built for ordinary people, pays a technology tax to reach the docket at all.

June: The fee schedule keeps going. Ten dollars for a certificate. Twenty-five dollars for the audio recording of your own hearing. The case file is a public record you can inspect for free. Owning any of it costs money.

Theo: Then the appeal. The New Hampshire Supreme Court’s own FAQ explains that without a transcript, the court will generally assume the evidence supported the trial court’s result and only review errors of law. Transcripts come from a private contractor, eScribers, with a deposit due up front. And the order form says if you don’t pay the deposit by the deadline, your appeal can be dismissed.

June: The column’s line there is the one I’d put on a T-shirt. In this state, the second look at a verdict is sold, and the return policy is dismissal.

Theo: Then the scale of it. Nearly eighty-five percent of circuit court cases involve at least one unrepresented party, according to reporting in the New Hampshire Bar Association’s Bar News, citing the Judicial Branch’s Access to Justice Commission. One in five Granite Staters is poor enough to qualify for free legal aid.

June: And the aid doesn’t stretch. 603 Legal Aid’s deputy director told Bar News the organization turned away six hundred eighty-four cases in 2023 for lack of resources.

Theo: And then federal court, which sounds like the escape hatch. The federal in forma pauperis statute lets a poor litigant sue without prepaying fees. In 1996, Congress struck the words “and costs” from that waiver. And a federal regulation says in civil cases there’s no provision for paying witnesses called by the indigent.

June: So you can subpoena the witness who saw what happened to you. If you can pay the witness fee yourself.

Theo: Then the column turns to the other table. When your opponent is a town, an insurer, a landlord with a property manager, or a state agency, its copies come out of a supply closet. Its lawyer is a line item someone else pays. A continuance costs it a calendar entry. The same continuance costs you a lost shift, a ride you had to beg, and childcare you can’t cover twice.

June: And the argument the whole piece builds to: money buys time as surely as it buys lawyers, and time wins cases, because the side that can wait can outlast the side that can’t.

Theo: Now the clever part. The fixes. The first one doesn’t need a new law. The copy, certification, and audio charges are on the court’s own schedule. In the statute’s words, they’re fees payable to a court or clerk. Which means the waiver statute the state already has already reaches them.

June: So a standing order saying a granted fee waiver covers a party’s reasonable copy and audio costs would end the eighty-dollar exhibit problem tomorrow.

Theo: That’s the move I’d point a journalism student at. Don’t ask the Legislature for something new. Read the law the state already passed, and show it already says yes.

June: The other fixes: an indigent transcript fund for civil appeals, fund the legal aid organizations until the six hundred eighty-four turned away becomes zero, and publish the numbers. How many fee waivers get filed, granted, denied, by court. The column’s line: if the system believes its waiver works, the data should be easy to share.

Theo: And the ending. The words carved over the U.S. Supreme Court read Equal Justice Under Law. New Hampshire’s version, the column says, is posted at the clerk’s window in smaller print. Fifty cents a page.

June: Now the second column, and it’s built on a side-by-side. Two events in the same twelve months.

Theo: Event one. On August 19, 2026, the New Hampshire House voted three hundred fourteen to seven to override its own governor and give convicted prisoners a way to put new evidence of innocence in front of a judge. The Senate followed, eighteen to six. Governor Kelly Ayotte, a former prosecutor and former attorney general, had vetoed the bill in July.

June: Until then, state law gave a convicted person three years to ask for a new trial. Then the door shut. If someone else confessed in year four, the door stayed shut. DNA was the only exception. New Hampshire was one of three states running a hard clock like that, alongside Arkansas and Idaho.

Theo: The new law, House Bill 1422, takes effect January 1, 2027. It lifts the three-year deadline when the person was convicted of a felony or class A misdemeanor, is still serving or bearing the consequences of the sentence, and specifically alleges both new evidence and innocence. A judge screens every petition before any hearing.

June: Then the column takes on the state’s best argument. The National Registry of Exonerations counts three thousand eight hundred forty-seven exonerations nationwide since 1989. New Hampshire has three. And Thomas Velardi, a director at the Attorney General’s Office, told senators in April that wrongful conviction is “not a problem that exists in New Hampshire.”

Theo: And the column offers a second reading of the number three. If the state built a system where proving innocence after three years was close to impossible, almost nobody would prove it.

June: That’s the whole trick of the piece, in one paragraph. Same number, two readings, and the column lets you decide which one the system was built to produce.

Theo: It adds one fact that leans hard. Cynthia Mousseau of the New England Innocence Project is the only full-time innocence attorney working in the state. She represents roughly twenty people who say they were convicted of things they didn’t do, and keeps a waiting list she can’t reach.

June: And the floor speech that carried the override came from Representative Robert Lynn of Windham, who retired as chief justice of the New Hampshire Supreme Court. He had opposed earlier versions. This time, per the Union Leader, he told the House, “We aren’t in the business here of letting innocent people stay in jail.”

Theo: Now event two. In October 2024 a Merrimack County grand jury indicted Associate Justice Anna Barbara Hantz Marconi of the New Hampshire Supreme Court on two class B felonies and five class A misdemeanors. Prosecutors alleged she arranged a private meeting with then-Governor Chris Sununu and pressed him about the criminal investigation into her husband.

June: On October 7, 2025, the case ended in under fifteen minutes. She pleaded no contest to one class B misdemeanor. The fine was twelve hundred dollars, plus two hundred eighty-eight in court fees. No jail.

Theo: And the column is careful to give her side. Her attorney said she still disagrees with how the attorney general described her conduct, and that she pleaded to avoid the spectacle of a high-profile trial. And a no-contest plea is not an admission of guilt.

June: The detail the column says is worth sitting with is inside the deal. Prosecutors agreed to classify her conduct as not a “serious crime” under the attorney discipline rules. She was back hearing oral arguments the following week. On November 14, 2025, she told colleagues she would no longer hear cases, and she retired at the mandatory age of seventy on February 12, 2026.

Theo: Her husband’s case closed the same way. Two felonies and four misdemeanors became a guilty plea to a single misdemeanor, thirty days fully suspended, a two-thousand-dollar fine. He resigned.

June: And then the line I think carries the whole column. Nobody here was above the law. That is the point. The law reached them, tapped them on the shoulder, took a few thousand dollars, and let them go home.

Theo: Which is a much harder argument to wave away than “the powerful escaped.” It concedes the system worked as written. Then it asks what the system does to everyone else.

June: Which is where the bail law comes in. In March 2025, Governor Ayotte signed House Bill 592, which took apart most of the state’s 2018 bail reform. It dropped the standard for holding someone before trial from clear and convincing evidence of dangerousness to probable cause. According to a review by the ACLU of New Hampshire, only Virginia holds people on a standard that low.

Theo: And the column’s best evidence comes from the state itself. On the law’s first anniversary, Attorney General John Formella reported the Coös County jail population up fifty percent in a year, and Merrimack County up thirty. Then, in an interview with the New Hampshire Bulletin, he explained what detention does for his side. It gives prosecutors more bargaining room on a plea, and moves cases faster, because, quote, “they don’t have any incentive to put a trial off.”

June: The column’s reading: the state’s chief law enforcement officer described pretrial detention as a tool for getting pleas. And he was making the case for it.

Theo: Now set it against the justice’s file. Seven counts became one because she had lawyers, liberty, time, and a trial the state didn’t want to hold. A man sitting in the Coös County jail because a judge found probable cause has none of those.

June: And the public defenders who’d stand next to him are stretched. The Sixth Amendment Center, hired by the state’s own Judicial Council, found roughly three-quarters of them over the seventy-case cap in their contract by mid-2021, with Dover attorneys reporting around a hundred fifty cases apiece.

Theo: The last turn in the column is the most revealing. Senator Bill Gannon of Sandown had co-sponsored earlier versions of the innocence bill. He flipped to sustain the veto after the Attorney General’s Office assured him prosecutors would reverse their own wrongful convictions if they found them.

June: The column’s response is one sentence. Trust the office that won the conviction to undo it.

Theo: And the Bulletin asked the office whether prosecutors might have some incentive not to announce they’d put an innocent person in prison. The office did not answer.

June: The column also tells you where its author stands. It discloses that Granite State Report files public-records requests as a routine part of its reporting, including with institutions discussed in the piece, and asks readers to weigh the column knowing that.

Theo: Its fixes are three, and none needs a new agency. Publish how often felony charges against public officials resolve down to misdemeanors, compared with everyone else. Move deadly force reviews out of the Attorney General’s Office to an independent reviewer with subpoena power. And fund indigent defense to the caseload cap the state already agreed to.

June: So put the two columns together. The first one shows the price list at the bottom. Fifty cents a page, three percent on the card, a transcript deposit or your appeal dies.

Theo: The second one shows what the price list looks like at the top. Seven counts, fifteen minutes, twelve hundred dollars. And the bail law that makes the wait itself the pressure.

June: Both columns end up where the first one put it in four words. Same rules, different wallets. And the wallet decides how long you can afford to wait.

Theo: Both articles are linked on the podcast page, with the statutes, the court pages, and the reporting they rely on. Both are opinion, signed by the editor. Neither is legal advice, and neither is this episode.

June: This has been the GSR Podcast.

Transcript of the episode as produced.

Who Decides Before the Judge: Bail Commissioners and Prosecutors

Made October 4, 2026 · Scripted from the articles · 10:33

Two entries from the Jobs in the Law series in one conversation: the part-time bail commissioner who fixes bail “in the same manner as the court might do,” the magistrate office New Hampshire built and abolished in nine months, and the three tiers of prosecutors, only one of which answers to voters. Hosts June and Theo are synthetic voices.

Articles discussed in this episode

How this episode was made. The script was written by Claude, an AI model made by Anthropic, from the two articles linked above, and every factual line in it traces to a sentence in one of them. The two voices are synthetic, generated with Kokoro, an open-weight text-to-speech model. Neither article is legal advice, and neither is this episode.

Read the transcript

June: This is the GSR Podcast, from Granite State Report in Northfield, New Hampshire. Today, two entries from the Jobs in the Law series: the bail commissioner who decides whether you go home, and the prosecutor who decides what you are charged with.

Theo: Start after midnight. The first article says most Granite Staters who ever touch the criminal courts touch them first in a police station, across a table from a bail commissioner. That person is not a judge. The law does not require them to be a lawyer.

June: The credential is a justice of the peace commission. It comes from the governor with the consent of the Executive Council and runs five years. The Secretary of State’s office requires a candidate to have been a registered New Hampshire voter for at least three years. It does not require a law degree or a day of courtroom experience.

Theo: Plenty of commissioners are lawyers, and some are clerks of court or police officers. The statute asks for none of it. The superior court appoints them under RSA 597:15, the circuit court under 597:15-a, and both bar anyone whose service would present a conflict of interest or an appearance of bias.

June: Training under RSA 597:18-a is at least 16 hours on appointment, then 8 hours a year. It pays a fifty-dollar stipend per eight-hour block.

Theo: Then RSA 597:18 opens the door all the way. Before arraignment, a commissioner may fix the amount of bail “in the same manner as the court might do,” except in murder cases. That language dates to 1895.

June: The power now stops at a list. Under RSA 597:2, a person charged with a qualifying offense may not be brought before a commissioner at all. That person is held for arraignment before a judge within 36 hours, not counting weekends and holidays.

Theo: The list began at twelve named crimes, including homicide, first and second degree assault, felony domestic violence, kidnapping, felony stalking, trafficking in persons and robbery, along with the sexual assault and child exploitation offenses. Since January 11, 2026, it has fourteen entries.

June: The two additions are categories. Any felony that has the use, attempted use or threatened use of physical force against a person as an element. And any felony at all where the person has twice before been convicted of something on the list.

Theo: That came through HB 57, and the article caught something odd. The bill reached the governor’s desk carrying a printed analysis that describes a different proposal entirely, about releasing state prisoners into community college programs. The Senate replaced the contents and left the summary behind. Governor Kelly Ayotte signed it on July 15, 2025.

June: A commissioner’s call is reviewable fast. Under RSA 597:6-e, the defendant or the state can get a hearing before a justice within 48 hours of a commissioner-ordered release.

Theo: Then the part of the story that reads like a stress test. In 2024, HB 318 created full-time magistrates, lawyers available on weekends and holidays, so that anyone arrested on a serious charge saw a judicial officer within 24 hours. The act directed the Judicial Branch to fund fifteen.

June: Three were appointed, sworn in on December 2, 2024, to five-year terms beginning January 1, 2025. Eighty-three days later, the Legislature voted to erase the office. Governor Ayotte signed HB 592 on March 25, 2025, and the magistrate chapter was repealed effective September 21, 2025.

Theo: The Judicial Branch had asked lawmakers to let the three finish their terms. Its fiscal note said, quote, “A judge’s salary and benefits are twice those of a magistrate.” Three magistrates were costing roughly four hundred eighty thousand dollars a year, all in.

June: By late August 2025, two of the three were already gone. One departure followed months of public pressure over an April 2025 release decision in a case that ended in a killing in Berlin that July. A Judicial Branch review concluded there had been enough evidence to hold the man in preventive detention. He died in that incident and was never tried.

Theo: The article’s point is about design. The state decided the trained lawyers it hired had made a bad call, and its answer was to route the same calls back to judges and part-time justices of the peace.

June: Then the money. The bail commissioner fee is sixty dollars under RSA 597:20. Since January 2025, the court has to pay the commissioner within 90 days of a reimbursement request.

Theo: And then the state bills the person who was arrested. Under RSA 597:2-b, a defendant found not indigent is ordered to reimburse the court, on a schedule that may run a year past the closing of the case. A person found indigent owes nothing.

June: The article calls that an improvement in dignity, and in whether commissioners get paid. It also means New Hampshire runs a collection program against people not convicted of anything, and the size of that program is nowhere in public view.

Theo: That is the gap. The public record does not show how many bail commissioners hold current appointments, how many calls they take in a year, what has been paid out under the 90-day rule, or how much has been collected.

June: Meanwhile, on June 29, 2026, the governor announced that bail orders now feed in real time into the State Police database an officer queries on a traffic stop. The state paid five hundred thousand dollars for that system. In the article’s words, a part-time officer’s 3 a.m. decision is pushed to every cruiser in the state within minutes, and the state still cannot tell a resident how many such officers there are.

Theo: Now the prosecutor. The second article opens with the state supreme court in State v. Smith, from 2020: prosecutors “possess the sole authority to decide whether and whom to charge.” No judge signs off first. No jury reviews it.

June: New Hampshire splits that power three ways. Under RSA 7:6, the attorney general prosecutes crimes punishable by death or life imprisonment, which in practice means homicide, and has general supervision of criminal cases in the superior and supreme courts.

Theo: RSA 7:11 adds that any officer enforcing criminal law is subject to the attorney general’s control whenever the attorney general chooses to exercise it. And the attorney general is appointed, nominated by the governor and confirmed by the Executive Council for a four-year term. John Formella was confirmed to a second term in September 2025.

June: Tier two is the ten county attorneys. RSA 7:33 requires each one to be a member of the New Hampshire bar, elected every two years, with Rockingham and Coos moved to four-year terms. These are the workhorse offices.

Theo: And here is the structural oddity. RSA 7:34 places every elected county attorney under the direction of the appointed attorney general. Under RSA 7:33-f, a county attorney cannot even hire an assistant without approval from both the county commissioners and the attorney general.

June: Tier three is the circuit court, where most people meet the system. Rule 42 of the state’s criminal procedure rules lets certified police officers who are not lawyers prosecute misdemeanors and violations. The Judicial Branch’s guide tells defendants the prosecutor may be an attorney or an officer, and only rules out the officer who made the arrest.

Theo: A class A misdemeanor carries up to a year in jail. The article notes that the person across the courtroom from a defendant who cannot afford counsel is often employed by the same department that made the arrest.

June: The heaviest duty after the charge is disclosure. Under Brady v. Maryland and New Hampshire’s 1995 decision in State v. Laurie, a prosecutor must hand over evidence favorable to the accused, including material that damages the credibility of a police witness.

Theo: Then the gap in the statute. RSA 7:6-d bars the attorney general and every Department of Justice lawyer from private practice. County attorneys get no uniform rule. Eight counties have their own sections, and in Belknap the bar covers only private criminal practice.

June: That leaves Hillsborough and Merrimack with no statutory limit on their county attorney’s private practice. The article says plainly that this accuses no one holding those offices. The defect is in the statute, and fixing it would take a single sentence.

Theo: Both articles end with asks. For bail commissioners: publish the roster, and publish the money. Fees paid out, amounts ordered repaid, and amounts collected.

June: For prosecutors, three questions for any county attorney candidate. What is your diversion policy? When an officer on the Exculpatory Evidence Schedule is a witness, what does your office disclose, and when? And how many open cases does each of your attorneys carry?

Theo: Both articles land in the same place. The first decisions in a criminal case get made before any judge reads the file, by people most voters never think about. Knowing who they are and what the law lets them do is where the questions start.

June: Both articles are linked on the podcast page, with the statutes and cases they rely on. Neither one is legal advice. This has been the GSR Podcast.

Transcript of the episode as produced.

Your Medical File and the Police

Made October 4, 2026 · Scripted from the articles · 10:41

Two Granite State Report explainers in one conversation: the five narrow doors New Hampshire law opens between your doctor and the police, the six federal law enforcement permissions in 45 CFR 164.512(f) and the one that needs a judge, and why the same prescription sits under two different standards. Hosts June and Theo are synthetic voices.

Articles discussed in this episode

How this episode was made. The script was written by Claude, an AI model made by Anthropic, from the two articles linked above, and every factual line in it traces to a sentence in one of them. The two voices are synthetic, generated with Kokoro, an open-weight text-to-speech model. Neither article is legal advice, and neither is this episode.

Read the transcript

June: This is the GSR Podcast, from Granite State Report in Northfield, New Hampshire. Today, two articles about the line between your medical file and the police: when your doctor can call them, and when they can come get your records.

Theo: Start with the belief most people carry. They picture HIPAA as a wall that stops an officer at the front desk. The first article says that belief is wrong. The federal privacy rule is a permission structure. It tells your hospital, your pharmacy and your insurer when they are allowed to hand your information to the government.

June: And the default, on paper, is silence. New Hampshire’s RSA 329:26 puts what you tell your doctor “on the same basis as those provided by law between attorney and client.” That is the strongest confidentiality comparison state law knows how to make.

Theo: With an escape hatch. The privilege holds except as otherwise provided by law. In a 2004 fight over grand jury subpoenas for hospital records, the state supreme court called it “not fixed and unbending.”

June: So the second article lays out five narrow doors from the exam room to the police. Door one is the wellness-check call. Under 45 CFR 164.512(j), a provider may disclose what is necessary to prevent or lessen a serious and imminent threat, to someone positioned to intervene. Police qualify. So do family members.

Theo: Two limits. It covers necessary information. For a welfare check, that means your name, your address and the reason for concern, and nothing like your chart. And under federal law it is a permission, never a duty. HIPAA does not require your doctor to call anyone.

June: The Office for Civil Rights has said so in writing, including a message to the nation’s providers after the Newtown shooting saying HIPAA was no barrier to that call. Its guidance also says regulators will not second-guess a clinician’s good-faith judgment about the threat.

Theo: Door two is where New Hampshire turns may into must. RSA 329:31 puts a duty to warn on every licensed physician when a patient communicates “a serious threat of physical violence against a clearly identified or reasonably identifiable victim.”

June: Or, in a clause most states never wrote, a serious threat of substantial damage to real property. Threaten a person or a building in the exam room, specifically, and confidentiality stops being the doctor’s choice.

Theo: The doctor can discharge that duty three ways: warn the intended victim, notify the police department closest to the patient’s or the victim’s residence, or obtain civil commitment. Disclosures made to discharge the duty carry statutory immunity.

June: And the trigger is narrow. Vague worry is not a trigger. A hard week is not a trigger. The statute demands a communicated, serious threat aimed at an identifiable target.

Theo: Door three runs the other way: police coming to ask. This is where the first article spends most of its time. Paragraph (f) of the federal rule holds six numbered law enforcement permissions. Only one of them has a judge in it.

June: Walk through them. Records another law requires, like a wound-reporting statute. A court order, a court-ordered warrant, or a subpoena from a judicial officer. That is the judge. A grand jury subpoena, drafted and served by prosecutors without advance judicial review. And an administrative subpoena.

Theo: The administrative subpoena is the one most people have never heard of. It is a document the investigating agency writes for itself. No judge reviews it. The rule attaches three conditions: relevant and material to a legitimate inquiry, specific and limited in scope, and de-identified data would not do. Every one of those judgments is made by the agency that wants the file.

June: Then there is the identifier list. To help locate a suspect, fugitive, material witness or missing person, a provider may give an officer your name and address, date and place of birth, Social Security number, blood type, type of injury, dates and times of treatment, and distinguishing physical features down to scars and tattoos. No paperwork required.

Theo: The regulation does draw a line there. DNA and its analysis, dental records, and the typing of body fluids or tissue stay out of that handover.

June: The first article found a strange asymmetry. Under paragraph (e), a lawyer who serves a subpoena on your doctor without a court order needs written assurance that you were notified and your window to object has closed, or a qualified protective order.

Theo: The agency’s self-issued administrative subpoena carries none of that. No notice. No protective order. No chance to object, because you will not know it happened. The opposing party in your custody fight faces a higher procedural bar than a police agency investigating you.

June: Door four: the reports the law forces. RSA 631:6 makes it a misdemeanor for anyone who knowingly treats a gunshot wound, or any injury believed caused by a criminal act, to fail to notify law enforcement immediately with all the information they have about the injury.

Theo: One exception. An adult victim of sexual assault, or of abuse as the domestic violence chapter defines it, can object and stop the report. Unless the injury is a gunshot wound or other serious bodily injury. Then the report goes in over the objection.

June: Child abuse reporting under RSA 169-C:29 runs through physicians, nurses, teachers and clergy, and ends at “any other person having reason to suspect” abuse or neglect. And RSA 161-F:46 requires an immediate report of suspected abuse, neglect, self-neglect or exploitation of a vulnerable adult.

Theo: Door five is the commitment certificate under RSA 135-C. An approved physician, physician assistant or advanced practice registered nurse can sign an involuntary emergency admission certificate, and RSA 135-C:29 puts a police officer into the chain for transport.

June: The chapter also lets a completed certificate be rescinded before police take custody, when a mobile crisis team or a community provider accepts the person’s care. The article calls that the legislature’s attempt to keep handcuffs out of health care where a clinical handoff will do.

Theo: Now the pharmacy. In December 2023, Senator Ron Wyden and Representatives Pramila Jayapal and Sara Jacobs reported that all eight pharmacy chains they examined said they would turn over prescription records on what their letter called a “mere subpoena” rather than a warrant.

June: Compare the state’s own drug database. New Hampshire’s prescription drug monitoring program, run by the Department of Health and Human Services under RSA 126-A, requires a court order based on probable cause for law enforcement, and no police agency may query it directly.

Theo: Same prescription, two standards. The article’s line is that the protection follows the filing cabinet, not the patient.

June: Two vaults hold better. Federal substance use disorder records under 42 CFR Part 2 cannot be used against a patient in a criminal case without written consent or a court order meeting specific requirements. And when a provider learns of a violent-crime admission in counseling or therapy, the federal threat-disclosure permission does not apply. The couch stays sealed.

Theo: The Constitution draws one hard line. In Ferguson v. City of Charleston in 2001, the Supreme Court held that a state hospital’s diagnostic test to get evidence of a patient’s crime for police “is an unreasonable search if the patient has not consented.” That turned on it being a state hospital. A private hospital is not a government actor.

June: And what happens at your door is a separate question. In Caniglia v. Strom in 2021, a unanimous Supreme Court held there is no freestanding community-caretaking exception that lets police search a home or seize property during a welfare check. A lawful disclosure by your doctor does not launder an unlawful entry by the police.

Theo: New Hampshire has its own counterweight. In 2018 voters added Part I, Article 2-b to the state constitution, a right to live free from governmental intrusion in private or personal information. In State v. Zarella in 2025, the state supreme court used it to raise the bar for a defendant seeking counseling and medical records held by private providers.

June: And its own hole. The New Hampshire Data Privacy Act, RSA 507-H, treats a health condition or diagnosis as sensitive data. But RSA 507-H:3 excludes government bodies and HIPAA covered entities. In the first article’s words, it reaches neither the hospital nor the police department.

Theo: So, what to do. Ask your provider, in writing, for its policy on law enforcement requests, and specifically on administrative subpoenas. Ask for an accounting of disclosures under 45 CFR 164.528: what went out, to whom, when, and under which provision.

June: If the answer does not hold up, the federal Office for Civil Rights takes HIPAA complaints, and the New Hampshire Board of Medicine takes conduct complaints against physicians.

Theo: Both articles land in the same spot. The doors between your medical file and the police are narrow, most are marked may, and a patient who knows which door a disclosure went through is the one positioned to ask whether it was opened lawfully.

June: Both articles are linked on the podcast page, with the statutes and cases they rely on. Neither one is legal advice. This has been the GSR Podcast.

Transcript of the episode as produced.

Your Rights at Town Hall: Recording and Records Policies

Made October 4, 2026 · Scripted from the articles · 10:35

Two Granite State Report explainers in one conversation: when New Hampshire’s wiretapping law lets you press record, why it never reaches an open public meeting, and why a town’s own Right-to-Know policy cannot narrow RSA 91-A. Hosts June and Theo are synthetic voices.

Articles discussed in this episode

How this episode was made. The script was written by Claude, an AI model made by Anthropic, from the two articles linked above, and every factual line in it traces to a sentence in one of them. The two voices are synthetic, generated with ElevenLabs. Neither article is legal advice, and neither is this episode.

Read the transcript

June: This is the GSR Podcast, from Granite State Report in Northfield, New Hampshire. Today, two articles about what you are allowed to do at town hall: when you can press record, and what a town’s own records policy can and cannot demand of you.

Theo: Start with the recorder. New Hampshire’s wiretapping law is RSA 570-A. It took effect on August 31, 1969, when tapping a call meant alligator clips on a phone line. It still governs a state where every pocket holds a recorder.

June: And it is strict. Record a conversation you are part of without the other side’s permission, and that is a misdemeanor. Record a conversation you are not part of, without everyone’s consent, and it is a class B felony, with up to seven years of prison exposure.

Theo: The article points out that a class B felony is the same grade the criminal code gives second-degree assault. For recording a conversation you are not part of.

June: And the word intercept covers recording with any device. The voice memo app on your phone counts. So does the audio track under a video.

Theo: So where is the line? It runs through the definition of oral communication. The law protects speech by a person who has a reasonable expectation that it is not being intercepted. A quiet conversation in your kitchen is inside the statute. A speech to a crowded room is not.

June: Which brings us to the place officials get wrong most often: the public meeting. The Right-to-Know Law, RSA 91-A:2, paragraph two, says any person shall be permitted to use recording devices at open meetings. No consent, no announcement, no permission slip.

Theo: The article has a case where that went sideways. In February 2017, the chairman of the Gilford Budget Committee stopped a public meeting to warn a Laconia Daily Sun reporter that taping it without each speaker’s consent was a felony, the paper reported. He had reached for the wrong statute. The meeting was open, and no consent was needed from anyone.

June: The second setting is police at work in public. In March 2010, Carla Gericke tried to film a late-night traffic stop in Weare. She was arrested and charged with several crimes, including under the wiretapping statute. She was never brought to trial, and she sued.

Theo: In May 2014, the First Circuit, whose rulings bind New Hampshire, held that on her version of the facts she was exercising a clearly established First Amendment right to film officers doing their jobs in public, and it affirmed the denial of qualified immunity. Weare settled weeks later for fifty-seven thousand five hundred dollars, the Associated Press reported.

June: The article is careful about the limit. That protection is constitutional, not statutory, and it covers open recording of officials on the job. It is not a license to secretly tape anyone, anywhere.

Theo: Then there is the other half of the chapter, the government’s side. After the consent rule come thirteen lettered exceptions, most of them written for the state.

June: The biggest one: an officer investigating the offenses the chapter lists can record with only one participant’s consent, if the attorney general’s office finds reasonable suspicion that the recording will produce evidence of a crime. The approval can be verbal, with a memo within seventy-two hours. In drug cases, that power can be delegated to county attorneys.

Theo: The rest of the list reads like every microphone the state has added since 1969. Cruiser cameras. Recorders wired to Tasers. Body cameras. School bus audio. 911 lines. The list has been amended so many times that two of its subparagraphs, c and g, are word for word identical.

June: A full wiretap needs a judge. Only the attorney general’s office, or a county attorney with its written approval, can ask a superior court for one, and only for a listed set of crimes. Orders run ten days at most, and the recordings are sealed for ten years.

Theo: And if someone breaks the rule, the person who was recorded can sue. Damages start at a hundred dollars a day or a thousand dollars, whichever is higher, plus punitive damages and attorney’s fees.

June: In 2024, in State versus Clark, the New Hampshire Supreme Court narrowed the chapter’s exclusion rule. Evidence is thrown out under it only for felony-grade violations. And under the 1999 Fischer case, which still sets the standard, a good-faith belief that the recording was legal defeats the felony.

Theo: The article ends that section with rules to live by. Ask before you record a call. Mind the state line. Treat doorbell cameras that pick up audio as unsettled ground. Record any public meeting you want. And record police in public openly, at a reasonable distance.

June: One more piece of history. New Hampshire is one of roughly a dozen states that still require every party’s consent. In 2026, a bill to allow secret one-party recording, House Bill 1508, drew a fifteen to one committee vote against it, and the full House killed it by voice vote on February 5.

Theo: So the rule stands. All parties, or no recording. Except in the two places the article says accountability needs it most: the open meeting, and the public officer at work in public view.

June: Which sets up the second article. Once you are in that meeting, or at the clerk’s counter asking for records, the town may hand you its own Right-to-Know policy. The piece is called A Town Policy Is Not a Law.

Theo: It starts with where a town’s power comes from. A New Hampshire town is not a small sovereign. It holds the powers the legislature handed it. The main list is RSA 31:39, and it is specific. Cemeteries and parks. Horses going at large. Mufflers on gasoline-powered boats. Roller skating rinks. The retail display of throwing stars and nunchaku.

June: Public records access is not on the list. The legislature kept that for itself, in RSA 91-A.

Theo: The article gives the counterargument its due. Towns can make bylaws for their own prudential affairs, which covers internal office procedure: who opens the mail, who logs the request. But that is a housekeeping power. It lets a town decide how to meet an obligation, not how much of it to meet.

June: Then the preemption rule. The New Hampshire Supreme Court restated it in 2019, in State versus Lilley. A local rule loses when it conflicts with state law. And, citing Forster versus Town of Henniker, it also loses when it frustrates the purpose of the statute, even without a direct conflict.

Theo: And RSA 91-A states its purpose in its opening lines: the greatest possible public access. A local policy does not have to defy that to lose. It only has to get in its way.

June: Here is the detail the article says almost nobody cites. The legislature did tell public bodies to write one records policy. One. It sits in RSA 91-A:4, paragraph eight, on the charge for large email requests. No charge for the first two hundred fifty communications, no more than a dollar each after that, and a written policy with a waiver for indigent and public-interest requesters.

Theo: So the legislature knew how to tell a town to write a records policy. It did it once, for fees on high-volume electronic requests.

June: The article’s sidebar sorts the rest. A town can name who receives requests, adopt that fee policy, state its actual cost of a photocopy, offer a form as a convenience, and suggest narrowing a request, as a suggestion.

Theo: It cannot require a particular form or a stated reason as a condition of access. It cannot stretch the five-business-day deadline, or deny a request without naming the specific exemption and explaining it. It cannot charge anything for inspection, or create an exemption the statute does not have. And it cannot condition access on press credentials. There is no media tier for access under state law.

June: So why do these policies survive? Enforcement. The right-to-know ombudsman’s seat has been empty since July 1, 2025, after the office’s funding was cut, and as of September 2026 no replacement had been nominated. What is left is superior court, which costs a filing fee and months. For a single record, almost nobody goes.

Theo: The article’s advice to a requester is one question, in writing: under what statutory authority was this provision adopted, and how does it square with RSA 91-A:4? A town that cannot name the authority has told you what the provision is worth.

June: And for a select board: put the policy next to the statute and read them line against line. Keep the internal routing and the fee policy. Strike everything the statute does not impose.

Theo: Both articles land in the same place. The law gives you more room at town hall than the person behind the counter sometimes says. Record the meeting. Ask for the record. And when someone cites a rule, ask where it came from.

June: Both articles are linked on the podcast page, with the statutes and cases they rely on. Neither one is legal advice. This has been the GSR Podcast.

Transcript of the episode as produced.

Power Tactics and Political Maneuvering

Made October 3, 2026 · AI hosts · 7:49

The first eight installments of the Power Playbook, which tests Robert Greene’s 48 Laws of Power against New Hampshire government: unsigned bill drafting, in-person hearings in Concord, the 2026 Senate primary, the Executive Council, nonpublic sessions, stock refusal phrases, the Laurie List and primary-season attention.

Generated by the WordPress.com podcast tool on October 3, 2026. On October 10 the script was revised and the episode re-recorded with synthetic voices. The player and the transcript carry the revised version.

Articles discussed in this episode

Listener’s note.

  • The hosts say hearings moved to 1 Granite Place for the 2026 session. The article says every House hearing moved there; Senate hearings were held in State House rooms.
  • The hosts say McCain held 114 town halls. The article says he held “more than 114 town hall meetings in the state” in 2000.
  • The hosts say the Laurie List was made public by statute in 2021. The article says RSA 105:13-d was enacted in 2021 through House Bill 471, the first public version appeared at the end of 2021, and on March 29, 2022, 174 names were made public while 91 more entries stayed redacted.
  • The hosts say two of the three conversation-ending phrases lost their legal footing. The article says “pending litigation” was never an exemption; only “personnel matter” had footing to lose, when the New Hampshire Supreme Court replaced the old rule with a balancing test on May 29, 2020.

Checked and holding: 424 legislators at $100 a year with no personal staff; the drafting office and “None of their names appear on the bills”; Law 7’s 10 for frequency and 6.0 composite; weekday, daytime, in person, Concord, and no video testimony; 74 bills that died unvoted in March 2026; the Sununu endorsement and the Brown pass-over; the $105,000-to-$30,000 ombudsman budget cut and the July 2025 resignation; the two May 29, 2020 opinions; the six-newsroom lawsuit over the Laurie List; the 2008 Obama polling miss; and Sununu’s roughly 69-to-27 primary win.

Read the transcript

Two synthetic voices read this episode. It summarizes Granite State Report articles; each claim was checked against those articles and their sources.

Pip: Granite State Report is running Robert Greene's 48 Laws of Power against the actual machinery of New Hampshire government, one law at a time, and the machinery keeps winning.

Mara: Dexter Dow is behind the whole series — eight laws scored through the Law 8 installment, covering legislative bill-writing, public hearings, gubernatorial alliances, closed-door secrecy, the phrases agencies use to end conversations, police credibility registries, and primary-season attention games.

Pip: A power manual meets the Granite State. Let's start with who writes the bills around here.

Who Writes the Bill? The Seventh Law in Concord

Mara: The question this installment puts on the table is whether Robert Greene's seventh law — get others to do the work and take the credit — describes a strategy anyone in New Hampshire is running, or whether it has become something else entirely.

Pip: The piece sets up the architecture first. The post describes 424 legislators paid a hundred dollars a year, no personal staff, and over a thousand bills to process each session. The office that turns those requests into legal language has about two dozen people, roughly seven of them drafters, and they worked through every holiday from Thanksgiving to Christmas.

Mara: And the post names the upshot plainly: "None of their names appear on the bills."

Pip: So the seventh law isn't a strategy here. It's the plumbing.

Mara: That's the central finding. When every player runs the same play, the play stops being an advantage and becomes the floor. The post scores Law 7 a perfect ten on frequency and still lands it at a composite 6.0, because a law everyone obeys confers no edge on anyone.

Pip: The bill origin question is where it gets sharper. A bill idea can come from a legislator, a private citizen, an interest group, or a state agency — the only requirement is that a member agrees to sponsor it. One advocacy group tells its supporters the absence of research staff "provides an opportunity for individuals and groups to influence policy."

Mara: The post is careful to say that's not a scandal. Both that quote and a taxpayer group's how-to guide for getting a bill filed are published openly. The problem the post identifies is narrower: sponsorship is documented and origin is not, so the public record captures who took the credit and omits who did the work of deciding what the law should say.

Pip: Which is Greene's seventh law rendered as a filing system. The post also makes a case for why the design is defensible — a neighbor with 3,300 constituents rather than a gatekeeping staff means a retiree who noticed a problem at her town hall walks through the same door as a trade association.

Mara: The post's honest concession is that the door is used far more efficiently by people who do this professionally, and the record doesn't distinguish between the two. That connects directly to the follow-up piece on Law 8, which asks what happens once the bill gets its hearing.

Pip: New Hampshire promises every bill a public hearing. What it doesn't promise is that anyone outside Concord can get there.

Mara: The Law 8 piece makes that case in four words: weekday, daytime, in person, Concord. Testimony is not accepted by video. The room is whichever building the Legislature chooses — and for the entire 2026 session that wasn't even the building most people would look for, because the Legislative Office Building was closed and hearings moved to 1 Granite Place.

Pip: The New Hampshire Bulletin called the every-hearing, every-vote rule "a cherished State House maxim." In March 2026 it stopped being true for 74 bills that ran out of calendar and died unvoted.

Mara: The post's conclusion on Law 8 is that the ground does the work. The people who reliably show up are the ones paid to — lobbyists, agency liaisons, trade association staff. The most open rule in American legislatures is also one of its most effective filters, not by design but by venue.

Pip: And that connects back to Law 7. The bill's origin goes unrecorded, and its hearing is attended by people whose organizations may have supplied it. A resident trying to trace both is often looking at the same names twice.

Mara: The earlier installments in the series build the same pattern from different angles. The Law 1 piece tests whether the servant who shines too brightly gets punished — running three New Hampshire cases, including the 2026 Republican Senate primary where John E. Sununu called Trump a loser in print and received the endorsement anyway, while the loyalist Scott Brown was passed over.

Pip: The master doesn't want flattery. The master wants to win.

Mara: Law 2 lands on the Executive Council, where Governor Ayotte's four Republican allies blocked her contracts over printed paperwork, and the Senate, where her party holds a veto-proof majority, overrode her transportation veto 24 to 0. The post's correction to Greene is that a friend in New Hampshire politics is a temporary alignment of two election calendars, not a character type you can screen for.

Pip: Laws 3 and 4 are the Right-to-Know installments. The nonpublic session piece shows that the rules for closing a door are detailed and specific — but the ombudsman who was supposed to enforce them resigned in July 2025 after the Legislature cut the position's budget from $105,000 to $30,000, and as of September 2026 the seat was still empty.

Mara: The Law 4 piece goes after the three sentences that end conversations in New Hampshire government. "No comment." "That's a personnel matter." "It's pending litigation." The post documents that two of those three lost their legal footing years ago — the personnel exemption was replaced by a balancing test in two Supreme Court opinions issued on the same day in May 2020 — and almost nobody outside a courtroom was told.

Pip: The Law 5 piece is the Laurie List — the statewide registry of officers with credibility problems that was kept secret for decades, fought through the courts by six newsrooms, and finally made public by statute in 2021. The post's line on it: reputation in New Hampshire is whatever the file says once the file gets out.

Mara: And Law 6 is the primary piece, published six days before the September 8 vote. It uses McCain's 114 town halls and the 2008 Obama polling miss to argue that New Hampshire doesn't reward attention — it audits it. Sununu won the nomination roughly 69 to 27 percent.

Pip: The series keeps finding the same variable. Where a citizen has a working enforcement mechanism, the score goes up. Where the mechanism was defunded or never existed, it doesn't.

Mara: That thread runs from the empty ombudsman's office straight through to the hearing room in Concord that a working adult from Colebrook can't reach without taking a day off and driving two hours each way.

Pip: Forty laws remained after Law 8, and the state keeps supplying the test cases.

Mara: The Law 8 piece names Law 9 as next — winning through action rather than argument, against a chamber that decides most of its bills on a consent calendar.

Pip: The through-line across all eight laws is the same question: who has a tool they can use?

Mara: Greene writes manuals for individuals. New Hampshire keeps demonstrating that the contest is between procedures and the willingness to fund them.

Pip: Forty laws remained after Law 8. The state's not running out of material.

Mara: Neither is the series.

Transcript of the revised script. The listener’s note above records where it differs from the articles.

GSR Tools

Made October 3, 2026 · AI hosts · 3:03

A short tour of GSR Tools, four free browser-based utilities for New Hampshire’s Right-to-Know law: the 91-A Request Builder, Redact, the Granite State Record Room and the Noncompliance List, with how the response deadline is counted and why there is no press tier for access.

Articles discussed in this episode

Listener’s note.

  • The hosts say RSA 91-A:4, paragraph IX, “the fee waiver provision,” “expressly excludes media requestors.” The article says “the public-interest fee waiver there expressly excludes media requestors,” and that paragraph IX waives only the paragraph VIII per-communication charge: “This is a fee provision. It has nothing to do with your right of access.” The statute’s indigence waiver is separate.
  • The hosts quote “Anyone who tells you a reporter gets a faster or wider door is wrong” as a point about press treatment. The article sets it under “There is no press tier” and first says RSA 91-A:4, I gives every citizen the same right of access.

Checked and holding: the opening quotation about filing a request; the four tools; a free email subscription opens the builder, Redact and the Record Room catalog while the Noncompliance List is open to everyone; the undefined business day and the RSA 288:1 holiday list without Juneteenth; and nothing typed into the tools is sent to the newsroom.

Read the transcript

Pip: Granite State Report is out of Northfield, New Hampshire — one reporter, no paywall, and now apparently a toolbox.

Mara: Dexter Dow has been building out what the site calls GSR Tools — browser-based utilities for anyone who wants to use New Hampshire's Right-to-Know law without hiring a lawyer. That's the territory today.

Pip: Let's start with what's actually in the toolbox and why it exists.

The Right-to-Know Toolbox

Mara: The core question here is access — not just the legal right to government records, but whether an ordinary person can actually exercise it without getting lost in procedure.

Pip: The post puts it plainly. The framing is: "Filing a records request in New Hampshire takes no lawyer and no form. It does take a letter that cites the right paragraphs, a deadline counted correctly, and sometimes a clean way to black out a page before it goes anywhere."

Mara: So the tools exist to close that gap between the right existing on paper and someone actually being able to use it. There are four of them: the 91-A Request Builder, a redaction tool called Redact, the Granite State Record Room, and the Noncompliance List.

Pip: The Noncompliance List is the one that doesn't require a subscription — it's open to everyone, which is a meaningful distinction.

Mara: Right. The subscription is free, and it unlocks the builder and the other tools, but the Noncompliance List — the standing record of which public bodies meet their RSA 91-A duties and which don't — sits outside that gate entirely.

Pip: The Redact tool is worth naming specifically: it doesn't just cover text, it destroys it at the pixel level, so there's no layer underneath to recover.

Mara: On the Request Builder, the post makes a point that cuts against a common assumption. RSA 91-A:4, paragraph IX — the fee waiver provision — "expressly excludes media requestors." The post is direct: "Anyone who tells you a reporter gets a faster or wider door is wrong."

Pip: A newsroom building a tool that tells you the press gets no special treatment is either admirably honest or quietly enjoying the irony. Possibly both.

Mara: The post also flags a genuine statutory ambiguity: the chapter never defines "business day" for the records deadline. The tool takes the conservative reading — skipping weekends and every holiday listed in RSA 288:1 — and notes that Juneteenth is not on that list.

Mara: And nothing typed into the tools is sent to the site. The fields run entirely in the browser.

Pip: One reporter, Northfield, no paywall — and now a deadline calculator that reads the statute more carefully than some agencies probably do.

Pip: The right to inspect government records means something different when the tool to actually do it is sitting in your browser.

Mara: More from Granite State Report next time.

Transcript as generated by the tool, unedited. The listener’s note above records where it differs from the articles.

Open Records and Public Access

Made October 2, 2026 · AI hosts · 5:41

The newsroom’s free Right-to-Know tools, Redact and the 91-A Request Builder; a column arguing that New Hampshire’s public meetings are open but mostly empty; the statute that excuses agencies from building an index; and the Record Room catalog built in response.

Articles discussed in this episode

Listener’s note.

  • The hosts say most redaction fails before anyone tests it. The Redact page says “Most redaction fails the first time somebody tests it.”
  • The hosts say the Request Builder takes the conservative reading of a business day. The article says the tool states its own assumption on the page, skipping weekends and RSA 288:1 holidays; it does not call that reading conservative. RSA 91-A:2, II defines business day for meeting minutes only.

Checked and holding: the Redact quotation about black rectangles; pages burned to pixels with text and metadata gone; nothing uploaded; both tools free behind a free email subscription; “A right nobody exercises is indistinguishable, from the inside of a public body, from a right that does not exist”; the Hopkinton moderator’s ten percent; the Eagle Times suspension on June 30, 2025; RSA 91-A:4, VII; and “What the subscription opens is the list, which is the part this newsroom made.”

Read the transcript

Pip: Granite State Report covers New Hampshire open-government law the way a very patient person explains something that should not need explaining — which is to say, repeatedly, with citations.

Mara: Dexter Dow has been doing exactly that, with posts covering the tools residents can use to file records requests and redact documents, the legal architecture that makes access possible but findability nearly impossible, and the archive this newsroom built to fill that gap.

Pip: Let's start with the tools themselves.

Right-to-Know Tools: What They Do and Why They Exist

Mara: The Redact tool and the GSR Tools hub both address a practical gap in how New Hampshire's Right-to-Know Law gets used in practice — not the right to ask, but the mechanics of doing it safely and correctly.

Pip: On redaction specifically, the post makes a point worth sitting with: most redaction fails before anyone even tests it, because drawing a black box in a PDF editor leaves the text intact underneath.

Mara: The post is direct about how that happens: "Drawing a black rectangle in a PDF editor puts a shape on top of the words. The words are still in the file, and anyone can select them, copy them, and read what you meant to hide. Government agencies have published records this way. So have law firms, and so have newspapers."

Pip: So the failure mode is not hypothetical — it is documented, and it crosses every kind of institution that handles sensitive documents.

Mara: The tool addresses it by converting pages to pixels first, then burning the redaction into the image layer. The original text does not survive. Neither does the document's metadata. The post is explicit that the unsearchable result is not a side effect — it is the design.

Pip: And nothing leaves the user's machine. The file opens in the browser, the redaction runs locally, and the finished PDF saves to the downloads folder.

Mara: The GSR Tools hub collects this alongside the 91-A Request Builder, which writes a properly cited records request and computes the five-business-day response deadline, skipping weekends and the legal holidays listed in RSA 288:1. Both tools run in the browser and cost nothing beyond a free email subscription.

Pip: The deadline math alone is doing real work — the statute says "five business days" and never defines what a business day is for records requests, so the tool takes the conservative reading.

Mara: Both tools are free, and the post is clear they always will be. That framing connects directly to the broader argument about who the law actually serves.

Pip: Which is the question the column takes head-on.

Open Government Access: The Right Exists. The Room Is Empty.

Mara: The column argues that New Hampshire's open-government law is genuinely strong — and that strength is almost beside the point, because the rooms where decisions get made are mostly empty.

Pip: The hook is a Matrix reference, which earns its keep: the woman in the red dress is a distraction, and the column's argument is that distraction is cheaper and more reliable than secrecy.

Mara: The column puts it plainly: "A right nobody exercises is indistinguishable, from the inside of a public body, from a right that does not exist."

Pip: That is the sentence the rest of the piece earns.

Mara: The column cites a Hopkinton town moderator's estimate that the business session — where the budget actually gets amended — draws about ten percent of registered voters. And it notes that when the Eagle Times suspended operations in June 2025, nothing about Claremont city government changed. The meetings still happened. The agendas still posted. The only thing gone was the person sitting in the back of the room.

Pip: The companion piece on New Hampshire's record index picks up the structural side of this — the state's Right-to-Know Law hands over documents one at a time but has never required any agency to say what it holds.

Mara: RSA 91-A:4, VII is the sentence that locks that in: agencies are never required to compile, cross-reference, or assemble information into a form they don't already keep. The documents are nearly free. Everything around them is expensive.

Pip: So the archive is the answer to a statutory gap, not a bonus feature.

Public Records Indexing: The List the State Won't Keep

Mara: The Granite State Record Room is this newsroom's direct response to that gap — a catalog of every document GSR holds, with provenance, format, size, and rights status stated plainly for each entry.

Pip: The conditions of access say it cleanly: "What the subscription opens is the list, which is the part this newsroom made."

Mara: Government records in the archive carry no copyright, and the page says so explicitly — because a reader who doesn't know that will ask permission they don't need. The catalog also lists what was held out and why, from superseded duplicates to an untitled file with no established provenance. An archive that only advertises its contents is a brochure.

Pip: The exclusions are what let you trust the rest.

Mara: The through-line across all of this is that the legal architecture is already there — the access, the enforcement path, the tools. What's missing is the assembly.

Pip: Someone has to keep the list. Might as well be the person who read the statute carefully enough to know no one else is required to.

Transcript as generated by the tool, unedited. The listener’s note above records where it differs from the articles.

Faith, Mind, and Power

Made October 2, 2026 · AI hosts · 10:14

Essays on Christianity’s origins and New Hampshire’s 1784 religious clause, two Matrix film analyses, three schizophrenia pieces including the editor’s family essay, a column on the cost of prosecuting a Concord drug case, Pew data on belief, AI forecasts, and the rest of John Stark’s toast.

Generated by the WordPress.com podcast tool on October 2, 2026. On October 10 the script was revised and the episode re-recorded with synthetic voices. The player and the transcript carry the revised version.

Articles discussed in this episode

Listener’s note.

  • The hosts say the state’s whole public record on the editor’s fiancée’s death is a four-paragraph press release. The article says the State Police release has four paragraphs plus an update.
  • The hosts say 48 percent unaffiliated is the highest share in the country. The article says New Hampshire is effectively tied with Vermont, at 46, and that the margins of error overlap.

Checked and holding: Constantine in 312, 313 and 325 and his deathbed baptism; Theodosius in 380; the 1968 amendment; CACR 28, the 14-to-1 committee vote and the House voice vote; the 1807 Slave Bible; $7.25 since 2009; Kapur’s aberrant salience and the 2011 study; Jung’s “one falling and the other diving”; the eight-month investigation, the 200 yards and the housing-cost quotation; Pew’s 48 percent; and the 2047 forecast.

Read the transcript

Two synthetic voices read this episode. It summarizes Granite State Report articles; each claim was checked against those articles and their sources.

Pip: Granite State Report covers New Hampshire politics, policy, and accountability journalism — and then, apparently, also the entire history of Western civilization.

Mara: Dexter Dow has been doing exactly that. This episode moves through Christianity's origins and its gap from practice, the messiah story as it runs through film, what schizophrenia does to the brain, and the collision of drug policy, AI timelines, and belief itself. Let's start with how a carpenter from Nazareth ended up on the Roman Empire's payroll.

Rome's Hire, New Hampshire's Retainer

Pip: The core claim here is almost too blunt to be interesting until you sit with it: the government that executed Jesus eventually made his religion its law, and New Hampshire ran a version of that arrangement for nearly two centuries.

Mara: The post opens with what it calls reading the résumé cold: "Hometown: Nazareth, a village so obscure that one of his own future disciples asks whether anything good can come out of it. Trade: construction. Net worth: nothing on record. Publications: none. He never wrote a word we have. Employment: roughly three years of itinerant preaching, unpaid, no fixed address. Exit: arrested and executed by the Roman state, using a method it reserved for slaves and rebels."

Pip: And the next line on that résumé is King of Kings, Lord of Lords, co-owner of the universe. The gap between those two entries is the whole story.

Mara: The post traces how it happened. Constantine won a battle in 312, credited his god, made Christianity legal in 313, convened Nicaea in 325, and by 380 Theodosius had made the Nicene version the empire's official religion. The post notes Constantine wasn't baptized until his deathbed — by a bishop from the faction that lost at Nicaea.

Pip: He could not even die on-message.

Mara: New Hampshire's version ran from 1784 to 1968. The original constitution grounded morality on evangelical principles, let towns tax residents for Protestant teachers of religion, and required the state's president and its senators to be Protestant. The sectarian language stayed in Article 6 until voters amended it in 1968. Then in 2026, four House Republicans filed CACR 28 to restore the 1784 text word for word — evangelical principles, Protestant teachers, protections specifically for Christians.

Pip: The New Hampshire Council of Churches, representing roughly 300 congregations, filed testimony against it, citing Jesus's own teaching about rendering to Caesar.

Mara: The committee voted 14 to 1 against. The full House killed it by voice vote. The series also includes What Made Jesus Angry, which catalogs what the Gospels say enraged him — money squeezed from the poor, staged piety, rules weaponized against mercy — and holds that record against 2026 housing costs and immigration enforcement. The companion piece What We Did Anyway extends that argument, tracing how the 1807 Slave Bible cut the Book of Exodus entirely while keeping "servants, be obedient," and connecting that method to H.R. 1's Medicaid cuts. Forgive Us Our Debts closes the series by reading the Lord's Prayer as a conditional sentence: God forgives us exactly as we forgive others, then watches New Hampshire hold its minimum wage at $7.25 since 2009 and fund its schools last in the nation.

Pip: The Dead Sea Scrolls piece and the Paul essay fill in the origin story from the other direction — the scrolls showing the theological vocabulary was already circulating a century before the Gospels, Paul showing how a man who never met Jesus became the religion's principal architect. That gets us to a film that noticed the same pattern.

The Messiah Story Never Stops Running

Pip: The Matrix analysis makes a claim that sounds like film-nerd trivia but lands somewhere more serious: the savior who dies and returns keeps getting retold not because cultures copy each other but because the fear underneath it is identical.

Mara: The post on the original Matrix traces the architecture deliberately. A customer greets Thomas Anderson at his door as "my own personal Jesus Christ." The ship is the Nebuchadnezzar, named for the Babylonian king of Daniel. The hull plate reads Mark III, No. 11 — which viewers read as a nod to the Gospel verse where unclean spirits fall down and name the Son of God. Neo is betrayed, killed, and revived by a kiss.

Pip: The Wachowskis did not bury their sources. They shelved them in the shot.

Mara: The post argues the more important claim is the second one: Neo is not an invention, he is a retelling. Joseph Campbell named the pattern in 1949 — the hero who leaves an ordinary life, descends, dies, and returns with the power to free everyone — and found it across cultures. The Matrix Resurrections piece picks up where that leaves off, noting that the fourth film puts its messiah on a therapist's couch, prescribed blue pills for memories the Analyst has reframed as psychosis. Mark 3:21 records Jesus's own family going out to restrain him because, in the King James rendering, "they said, He is beside himself." The machines' best weapon in 2021 is a diagnosis.

Pip: Which connects directly to what the brain does when it starts manufacturing messiahs of its own.

When the Brain Manufactures Meaning

Pip: The schizophrenia explainer makes a point that the film analysis sets up perfectly: the brain does not produce random delusions. It produces culturally furnished answers to overwhelming internal experiences.

Mara: The post grounds this in Shitij Kapur's 2003 concept of aberrant salience — dopamine misfiring so that neutral events get stamped as deeply significant. The delusion is not the origin of the experience; it is the explanation the mind builds to contain it. A 2011 Columbia review found that delusional content tracks the dominant religious framework around the patient, and a century of records at one American psychiatric hospital shows delusions about syphilis in the early 1900s, Germans during World War II, and spies and Communists during the Cold War. A 2025 UCLA study found more than half of patients with delusions wove in the internet or new technology.

Pip: The KGB became the algorithm.

Mara: Falling and Diving extends this into genetics, tracing sixty years of family studies that find the inheritance behind schizophrenia does something different in unaffected relatives — Carl Jung's observation about James Joyce and his daughter Lucia: the same river, "one falling and the other diving." The personal essay Schizophrenia Runs in My Family connects it directly: the editor describes building Granite State Report's verification discipline as a defense against his own pattern-recognition engine, citing beads-task research reporting that the same jump-to-conclusions bias turns up in first-degree relatives of people with psychosis.

Pip: The question of who gets to name what is real — the institution or the person holding the document — runs from the psychiatric ward straight into drug policy and the state's ledger.

The Ledger the State Keeps

Pip: The drug policy piece is the sharpest thing in this batch, and the most uncomfortable, because it is written by someone with standing to make the argument.

Mara: The post covers the 2026 case against Matthew Snyder, charged, not convicted, after an eight-month multi-agency investigation into drug sales from a tent on state-owned rail land roughly 200 yards from a methadone clinic. The post calculates a 20-year sentence at roughly $65,000 per year — about $1.3 million — and notes: "The state of New Hampshire could have housed Matthew Snyder in permanent supportive housing for sixty-five years at $20,000 a year, with a case worker and a substance abuse counselor, with money left for his dental work."

Pip: The author's fiancée died of a fentanyl overdose in 2021. The state's entire public record on her death is a four-paragraph press release. No task force, no manhunt, no press conference.

Mara: Nobody Chooses to Believe in God runs a parallel argument about a different kind of institutional claim — that belief and unbelief are choices people make. Pew's data puts 48 percent of New Hampshire adults as religiously unaffiliated, the highest share in the country, but the post argues the number hides what happened: almost nobody decided. Belief erodes when experience stops confirming it, and the erosion takes years. The AI timeline piece closes the loop on who holds the wheel when the stakes are generational — lab executives promising AGI within a decade, a researcher survey putting 50-50 odds on machines outperforming humans at every task by 2047, and a forecast that moved 13 years closer in a single year.

Pip: The office-holders answering those timelines will be retired, or gone, before the coin flip lands.

Mara: Death Is Not the Worst of Evils pulls the thread personal again — the editor on the full line of John Stark's toast behind New Hampshire's motto, the clause that didn't make it onto the license plate: death is not the worst of evils. He reads it as permission to stop waiting for rescue that the record suggests has always arrived through human hands or not at all.

Pip: The thread that runs through all of this is the same one: who gets to define what is real, and who is accountable when the definition is wrong.

Mara: Whether it's a constitutional clause, a diagnosis, a dopamine misfire, or a budget line — that is the thread worth pulling.

Transcript of the revised script. The listener’s note above records where it differs from the articles.

Records Access, the Press Exemption and the Courts

Made October 2, 2026 · AI hosts · 13:18

Granite State Report’s Right-to-Know reporting in one pass: a federal FOIA workshop closed to requesters, a Department of Safety denial, an outdated Attorney General manual, the newsroom’s records tools, seven changes to RSA 91-A, the undefined press exemption, Chief Justice MacDonald’s resignation and the 2032 convention question.

Articles discussed in this episode

Listener’s note.

  • The hosts say two justices have called the Insular Cases a rotten foundation and five have not. The article, corrected October 2, 2026, says the two justices who wrote that the Insular Cases were wrong are Neil Gorsuch, concurring in United States v. Vaello Madero (2022), and Sonia Sotomayor, dissenting in the same case; no other justice joined either opinion, and the record does not sort the other seven into a camp.
  • The hosts credit the February 6, 1899 date and the Downes v. Bidwell quotation to the constitutional renewal piece. Both come from “When Did America Become an Empire?”
  • The hosts describe a piece on how the statute bars agencies from building an index. RSA 91-A:4, VII does not bar an index; it never requires an agency to compile one.
  • The hosts call the Department of Safety’s reply a blank response. The article says the Department answered on day five, denied items one through five under RSA 159-D:2, and gave item six a December 16, 2026 completion estimate.
  • The hosts say the companion post lists three open questions about the press exclusion. They come from “A Sole Proprietor Faces a Misdemeanor,” which lists four; the fourth asks whether the Department of Safety, a court or the advisory board has ever construed paragraph VIII.
  • The hosts say a statutory cap cut David Meehan’s $38 million verdict to $475,000. The article, updated October 4, 2026, says that ruling is under review: the New Hampshire Supreme Court heard arguments on the cap in November 2025, and a ruling was pending as of September 16, 2026.
  • The hosts close by promising an episode about what the newsroom does on December 16. No such episode has been made; the articles record only the December 16 estimate.
  • The hosts say a federal appeals court “just” ruled. The Seventh Circuit decided the case on August 25, 2026.

Checked and holding: August 11, 2026 and the “two-hour seminar” quotation; June 15, 2017; 1,707,197 requests, up 13.7 percent, about $661 million; RSA 91-A:4, IV(e)’s “may suggest”; the $105,000-to-$30,000 cut and the July 2025 resignation; the Department’s workload quotation and 139 days; page 69; IV(f) and the zero-character test; the RSA 106-F:4, VIII quotation; $49,856.83 and the Judicial Conduct Committee quotation; and the SNAP notice’s seven departures.

Read the transcript

Pip: Granite State Report out of Northfield, New Hampshire — a one-reporter newsroom that spent the past few weeks reading every statute, manual, and resignation letter it could find, and then built tools so you could too.

Mara: Dexter Dow is behind all of it. This episode covers the mechanics of public-records access at the federal and state level, the tools the newsroom built to help people use those rights, a legal question about who counts as press in New Hampshire, and the courts, constitutions, and civic power structures underneath all of it.

Pip: Let's start with the records beat itself — a federal training session, a blank response from the Department of Safety, and a right-to-know manual that has not caught up to the law it explains.

The Federal Workshop and the State of New Hampshire's Records Access

Pip: The core question here is who gets to shape the rules around public-records requests — and whether the public is even in the room when those rules get made.

Mara: The anchor is a Justice Department training session held August 11, 2026, on how agencies should negotiate with requesters. The post puts it plainly: "So the federal government convened a two-hour seminar on how to negotiate with the public, and the public could not get in the room."

Pip: And it is not just a closed door — there are legal consequences to being on the outside of it. Under FOIA, if you refuse to narrow your request, that refusal can be used against you in court. Agencies get trained on the negotiation; requesters get the outcome.

Mara: The post traces the workshop series back to 2014, when it ran both directions — agency staff and requester-community representatives on the same panel. The last time a requester sat on one of those panels was June 15, 2017. Every session since has been agency staff only.

Pip: Nine years is a long time to take your own advice off the wall.

Mara: The published takeaways from that 2017 session, still posted on the Office of Information Policy's website, include a bullet telling agencies to "Seek input from requester community" and to reach out to civil society organizations periodically. The office wrote it down and then stopped doing it.

Mara: The volume numbers are real: in fiscal 2025 the executive branch received 1,707,197 FOIA requests, up 13.7 percent in a single year, at a cost of roughly $661 million. The operational pressure is genuine.

Pip: But volume is an argument for public negotiation standards, not against them. When the commodity being rationed is access to the government's own records, the rationing rules belong in daylight.

Mara: New Hampshire's own narrowing provision is notably different — RSA 91-A:4, IV(e) says an agency "may suggest" a narrower scope, with no clause converting your refusal into a factor against you. No fee that reattaches because you let three emails sit.

Mara: But the state's failure is elsewhere. The right-to-know ombudsman's seat has been empty since Thomas Kehr resigned in July 2025, after lawmakers cut the office's budget from $105,000 to $30,000. The Secretary of State's website carries a standing notice that the office can take no action on any filing.

Pip: So New Hampshire drafted better law than Congress on narrowing, and then defunded the only referee.

Mara: The Department of Safety response to a six-item records request shows what that looks like in practice. Five items were resolved in one sentence — one RSA 159-D:2 citation, no per-item explanation — and the sixth was given a completion estimate of December 16, 2026, citing, in the Department's own words, "the workloads of the personnel participating in the processing of your request."

Pip: One hundred thirty-nine days. The statute's decision yardstick is five.

Mara: RSA 91-A:4, IV(c) requires the specific exemption and a brief explanation of how it applies to the record withheld. A chapter-and-section citation stretched across five distinct requests satisfies half of one requirement.

Mara: The Attorney General's own right-to-know manual compounds this. Read line by line against the statute, it drops the third option from the five-day rule entirely. Page 69 tells officials they must either deny the request in writing or notify the requestor when records will be available. Production inside five days is simply gone from the sentence.

Pip: The manual also misses seven statutory amendments since March 2024 — the entire fee architecture, the county public comment requirement, the ombudsman's restructuring. A trade association published a four-page advisory with a model fee policy a month before the fee law took effect. The Attorney General has had two and a half years.

Mara: The Granite State Record Room and the GSR Tools hub address the gap from the other direction — a catalog of every document the newsroom holds, a request builder that cites the right paragraphs and computes the five-day deadline, and a piece on how New Hampshire's statute bars agencies from building the kind of index that would make records findable in the first place.

Pip: RSA 91-A:4, VII says no agency has to compile, cross-reference, or assemble information into a form it doesn't already keep. A library with no catalog is technically open to everyone.

Mara: Which is why the newsroom published its own index — and why the Record Room lists what it left out, with the reason for each exclusion. An archive that only advertises its contents, as the post puts it, is a brochure.

Pip: The tools and the ombudsman vacancy connect to the same question: what is access worth if enforcement costs a lawsuit?

Redaction, Law Changes, and a Constitutional Question About AI Images

Pip: The right-to-know statute has moved seven times since the Attorney General's manual was published, and one of those changes created a legal shield for redaction software — without asking whether the software works.

Mara: RSA 91-A:4, IV(f), added in 2024, says a public body is not liable for accidentally releasing exempt information if it acted in good faith to redact, and that using automated redaction software with spot checks qualifies as good faith. The shield runs to the public body. The consequence of a redaction that didn't hold runs to whoever was named in the document.

Pip: So the newsroom built a tool that actually destroys the text — converts every page to pixels, burns the black in as part of the image, and produces a file with zero extractable characters. Then it published three tests so you can verify any redacted document, not just one made there.

Mara: The companion post on the seven statutory changes since 2024 — with a word-for-word redline — shows where the manual now diverges from the law it explains, including the fee structure, the county public comment requirement, and the domain-name answer option added August 31, 2026.

Pip: Meanwhile, a separate post raises a harder constitutional question: New Hampshire passed an AI child-abuse-image law in 2024 with no recorded no vote, and a federal appeals court just refused to enforce the narrower federal version of the same idea. The state's own purpose clause still cites Ferber — a case about real children — for a provision that needs no real child at all.

Who Counts as Press in New Hampshire

Pip: New Hampshire's private investigator law carries a carve-out for journalists — but it turns on a credential nobody in the state issues.

Mara: RSA 106-F:4, VIII exempts "persons engaged in reporting or providing information to an accredited news publication, media, or news outlet." The chapter never defines accredited. No New Hampshire agency issues the credential. The post on the penalty structure puts the stakes plainly: a sole proprietor faces a misdemeanor under RSA 106-F:14, and an incorporated newsroom faces a felony — on identical facts.

Pip: Incorporation is the responsible choice everywhere else. Here it reads as an aggravating factor.

Mara: The companion post traces the word to a 2010 amendment that added the press carve-out, notes that the same chapter uses "accredited" correctly once — for colleges, where a real accrediting body exists — and identifies three open questions the text doesn't resolve: whether "accredited" modifies all three nouns, whether the preposition "to" requires a publisher above you, and whether the public-interest phrase in the definition keeps publishers out of the chapter before the exclusions even matter.

Pip: Until someone answers, this falls hardest on the newsrooms that took the responsible step — and the sentence written to protect the press asks for a credential that does not exist.

Courts, Constitutions, and Civic Power

Pip: The final territory is the constitutional layer underneath all of it — a chief justice's resignation, the civil-criminal divide, and the question of whether New Hampshire's founding documents still hold what they promise.

Mara: Chief Justice Gordon MacDonald's resignation letter runs five sentences. The record behind it runs past 700 pages. He admitted three violations of the Code of Judicial Conduct tied to a $49,856.83 payout for a longtime aide — and the Judicial Conduct Committee was candid about the cost of settling: "In resolving this case by Stipulation and Agreement, the public is deprived of the full scope of transparency that would accompany an adversarial hearing."

Pip: An agreed record is not a proven one, and the questions a public hearing would have pressed — starting with how three other justices came to put their names on a statement the committee found inaccurate — will not be tested in one.

Mara: The post on civil versus criminal cases in New Hampshire uses the same set of facts to explain why two courtrooms can reach different results: different burdens of proof, different parties, different remedies. A civil jury set David Meehan's damages at $38 million; a statutory cap cut it to $475,000; and a criminal mistrial left the former staffer he accused still presumed innocent. Two courtrooms, two sets of rules, almost nothing crosses between them.

Mara: The constitutional renewal piece traces a legal date — February 6, 1899, the Senate vote to keep the Philippines — as the moment the United States stopped promising the people it governed that they would become its equals. Justice White's phrase from Downes v. Bidwell still governs: "foreign to the United States in a domestic sense." Two justices have now called that foundation rotten. Five have not.

Pip: New Hampshire's own constitution has a scheduled appointment with that question — the 2032 ballot asks whether to hold a convention, and the Power Playbook entries on legislative hearings and bill drafting show what happens to public participation when the ground is set by the institution: weekday, daytime, in person, Concord, and the people reliably in the room are the ones paid to be there.

Mara: The SNAP work notice piece brings it back to the individual level — a nine-page letter that misstates the federal rules it was written to explain, sets no deadlines for the requirements it applies, and leaves a person unable to tell whether the three-month time limit applies to them at all.

Pip: Seven departures from the federal regulation, most of them dropping a protection. The fixes, as the post notes, are not hard.

Pip: A redaction tool, a request builder, a record room, a graded manual, a resigned chief justice, and a 127-year-old constitutional question — it is a lot of ground for one newsroom to cover.

Mara: The thread running through all of it is enforcement: who holds the referee's chair, and what happens when it's empty.

Pip: Next episode, we find out what Granite State Report does when December 16 arrives on the calendar.

Transcript as generated by the tool, unedited. The listener’s note above records where it differs from the articles.

New Hampshire Open Government Battles

Made October 2, 2026 · AI hosts · 14:07

A long pass through the records beat and beyond: a federal FOIA workshop closed to requesters, the vacant ombudsman seat, a graded Attorney General manual, redaction and request tools, the Record Room, the undefined press exemption, and the 2032 constitutional convention question.

Generated by the WordPress.com podcast tool on October 2, 2026. On October 10 the script was revised and the episode re-recorded with synthetic voices. The player and the transcript carry the revised version.

Articles discussed in this episode

Listener’s note.

  • The hosts say three unanswered emails from an agency can restore fee charges after it misses its deadline. The article says that applies only “If the agency declared unusual circumstances and more than 5,000 pages are needed.”
  • The hosts say the New Hampshire Supreme Court rejected a law in 2008. In State v. Zidel the court threw out nine felony convictions and held private possession protected; it did not strike the statute.
  • The hosts say a statutory cap cut David Meehan’s $38 million verdict to $475,000. The article, updated October 4, 2026, says that ruling is under review: the New Hampshire Supreme Court heard arguments on the cap in November 2025, and a ruling was pending as of September 16, 2026.

Checked and holding: the July 15 notice and the “exceptional circumstances” quotation; June 2017; the ombudsman vacancy and budget cut; five items denied under one citation and 139 days; the manual’s grades and its C composite; IV(f); the RSA 91-A:4, VII quotation and 29 items at publication; the “some concerns” quotation; the RSA 106-F:14 wording; the Judicial Conduct Committee quotation; seventeen conventions and 2032; 57 to 27; Jefferson’s nineteen years; and the SNAP notice findings.

Read the transcript

Two synthetic voices read this episode. It summarizes Granite State Report articles; each claim was checked against those articles and their sources.

Pip: Granite State Report covers New Hampshire, which means covering a state that wrote the right of revolution into its constitution, holds a public hearing on every single bill, and, as of July 2026, had not found anyone to fill its transparency enforcement office. Normal Tuesday.

Mara: Dexter Dow has been doing the work behind all of it. This episode covers the federal and state right-to-know machinery and the tools built to use it, how New Hampshire archives and accesses its public records, what the private investigator law means for press freedom, and the bigger constitutional questions about who power serves.

Pip: Let's start with the FOIA training session that forgot to invite the public.

The Workshop That Trained Only One Side

Pip: The Justice Department held a two-hour session on how to negotiate with records requesters and did not let any requester in the room. That is the whole situation, and it gets worse from there.

Mara: The post sets up the stakes precisely. The July 15 announcement said registration was for federal employees and the event was described as open to agency FOIA professionals. That is the line. And the consequences of that arrangement are written into the statute itself.

Pip: Right, because FOIA negotiation is not a courtesy. Refusing to narrow a request can be used against you in court.

Mara: Exactly. A requester's refusal to reasonably modify the request or agree to an alternative schedule "shall be considered as a factor in determining whether exceptional circumstances exist" — and exceptional circumstances is the finding that lets a judge give the agency more time. Three unanswered emails from the agency can also restore fee charges after it has already missed its own deadline.

Pip: So the agency teaches its side the playbook, the requester never sees it, and then the requester's choices get evaluated against rules they were not trained on. That is a structural advantage baked into the statute.

Mara: And the workshop history makes it worse. The last panel to include a requester-community representative was June 2017. Every session since has been agency staff only, covering backlogs, appeals, technology. The 2017 session's own published takeaways tell agencies to seek input from the requester community. OIP wrote that advice down and then stopped following it.

Pip: An agency teaching only its own side how to negotiate is not running a training program. It is running a playbook.

Mara: The New Hampshire side of this piece is its own story. RSA 91-A's narrowing provision is more balanced than the federal version — no penalty attaches if a requester declines a narrowing suggestion. But as of the newsroom's summer 2026 reporting, the state's enforcement office had been vacant since Thomas Kehr resigned in July 2025 after lawmakers cut the budget from $105,000 to $30,000, and the Secretary of State's website said no action could be taken on any filing until a new ombudsman exists.

Mara: The piece on the Department of Safety's response to a firearms-records request shows what that vacancy means in practice — five items denied in a single sentence under one statute citation, the sixth item given a 139-day completion estimate citing personnel workload, and no referee available to contest either.

Pip: December 16 will have to explain itself. Meanwhile the Attorney General's Right-to-Know manual, which every police department and select board in the state uses, leaves out the part where the agency hands over the records — the five-day rule, in the manual's operative instruction, collapses to two options, both of them letters.

Mara: That piece grades the manual across five dimensions. Command of doctrine earns an A-minus. Fidelity to statutory text gets a D-plus. Currency — reflecting seven amendments since March 2024 — fails outright. The composite is a C, and the piece notes the fix requires no litigation, no lobbying, no wait for a court: open the statute, open the manual, fix the sentences that no longer match.

Pip: The redaction piece rounds out this territory with two free browser tools — one that destroys text layers rather than covering them, one that builds a properly cited request letter. The law says automated redaction software used with spot checks qualifies as good faith, but it never asks whether the software works.

Mara: The GSR Tools hub collects both, along with the Noncompliance List. The redaction piece reports a test of the tool on the fifteen-page text of RSA 91-A itself: 3,342 extractable characters on page one of the original, zero in the output across all fifteen pages. The three tests any reader can run on any redacted document are straightforward — drag across a blacked-out area, select all and paste into a text editor, search for a word you redacted.

Pip: A redaction you have not tested is a guess you are making with somebody else's information.

Mara: The piece is direct about the tradeoff: the output is not searchable, because the text layer is gone. That is the price of the words being gone rather than covered.

Pip: From the tools that help you get records to the question of whether New Hampshire even keeps track of what it holds.

No Index Required

Pip: New Hampshire law requires agencies to hand over records one at a time, but it never requires any agency to tell you what it holds. RSA 91-A:4, VII says a public body is never required "to compile, cross-reference, or assemble information into a form in which it is not already kept or reported by that body or agency." That is the sentence that guarantees the gap.

Mara: The response to that gap is the Granite State Record Room — twenty-nine items described at publication, six of them governmental records obtained under RSA 91-A, each with accession number, source, date, format, and a plain statement of rights. Government records carry no copyright, and the page says so. The archive also lists what was held out and why, because an archive that only advertises its contents is a brochure.

Pip: The piece on the AI child-abuse-image law sits in this territory too, and it is a different kind of gap — the legislature passed a 2024 law that reaches further than the one New Hampshire's own Supreme Court rejected in 2008, and in August 2026 a federal appeals court refused to enforce the narrower federal version.

Mara: The Seventh Circuit held in August 2026 that the federal possession ban on obscene AI images of non-existent children cannot be enforced against home possession. The court wrote that it had "some concerns about the lines these cases draw" and no authority to redraw them. New Hampshire's statute drops the obscenity element entirely, which puts it on the wrong side of a line the Supreme Court drew in 2002 and the state's own high court applied in 2008.

Pip: The column on civic attention argues the access is already there — every meeting posted, every record requestable, every room open — and what is missing is the person sitting in the back row noticing. The Eagle Times suspended operations in June 2025, and Claremont's city council kept meeting without a newspaper watching.

Mara: The Record Room and the Seven Laws redline, which tracks every statutory change since the 2024 memorandum word for word, are the structural answer to that problem — somebody has to keep the list, and until the legislature changes paragraph VII, it falls to whoever will do it for free.

Pip: From the records beat to the question of who counts as press in the first place.

One Word Nobody Defined

Pip: New Hampshire's private investigator law exempts people reporting for an "accredited" news outlet from a licensing scheme backed by criminal penalties. The state has never defined accredited, and no agency issues the credential. That one word decides who counts as press, and it points at nothing.

Mara: The penalty structure makes it worse. RSA 106-F:14 makes a violation "a misdemeanor for a natural person and a felony for any other person." A sole proprietor is a natural person. An LLC, a corporation, a nonprofit — each is some other person. Same reporting, same records, same story, different class of crime. The piece is careful to note that the threshold question — whether publishing for a public interest keeps a newsroom out of the chapter entirely — has never been tested in court.

Pip: The chapter knows what accreditation means when a real accreditor exists. It uses the word properly one section over, for colleges and universities, where the New England Commission of Higher Education publishes a member list you can check in a minute. For news outlets it points at nothing, in the same chapter.

Mara: The Chief Justice MacDonald resignation piece lands in this segment too — it documents a case where the Right-to-Know Law does not reach at all, because RSA 91-A does not apply to the judicial branch. Public access to court records rests on the state constitution and the courts' own procedures. The Judicial Conduct Committee's own summary report acknowledged the cost of settling: "In resolving this case by Stipulation and Agreement, the public is deprived of the full scope of transparency that would accompany an adversarial hearing."

Pip: Three violations admitted, three others charged but not resolved, and a record of more than 700 pages that most people will not read. The explainer on civil versus criminal cases in New Hampshire provides the framework for understanding why — two different machines, different burdens, different remedies, and the Right-to-Know Law runs almost entirely on the civil track.

Mara: That piece uses the YDC litigation to show the asymmetry concretely: a civil jury set David Meehan's damages at $38 million, the statutory cap cut it to $475,000, and no jury has returned a verdict on the criminal charges arising from the same allegations. Hiding a record is a lawsuit. Shredding one is a misdemeanor.

Pip: From who counts as press to who counts as a citizen, and what the document governing all of it promises.

The Constitution and the Living Generation

Pip: New Hampshire has held seventeen constitutional conventions, more than any other state, because it wrote a recurring referendum on whether to reconsider into the document itself. The next question appears on the 2032 ballot whether anyone prepares or not.

Mara: The special report offers two complete draft constitutions — one for New Hampshire, one for the country — as works of public argument. A separate piece on empire traces the legal date when the United States became an empire in the strict sense: February 6, 1899, when the Senate voted 57 to 27 to keep the Philippines under Article IX of the Treaty of Paris, which left the political status of the ceded population to Congress with no promise and no clock. Justice White's phrase from Downes v. Bidwell still governs: "Foreign to the United States in a domestic sense."

Mara: The companion piece on New Hampshire's decennial question frames the Jefferson-Madison argument directly. Jefferson calculated a generation at nineteen years and argued no constitution should outlive it. "The earth belongs always to the living generation." Madison answered that expiry would strip government of stability. The draft resolves it by keeping the existing charter in force until the people revise or reaffirm it — the scheduled question without the scheduled cliff.

Pip: The Power Playbook entries on legislative hearings and bill drafting show the machinery up close. Every bill gets a public hearing, but the room is in Concord on a weekday during working hours with in-person testimony only — the most open rule in American legislatures is also one of its most effective filters, selecting for whoever is paid to be there.

Mara: The bill-drafting piece adds that the Office of Legislative Services writes nearly every bill on behalf of sponsors who may not have drafted a word, and no rule requires the public record to identify who supplied the idea. The Live Free or Die ledger pulls the threads together with two dozen numbers — incarceration rates, debt loads, housing costs, union membership, the ombudsman vacancy — measured against Part First, Article 10's declaration that government exists for the common benefit and not the private interest of any class of men.

Pip: The Rome piece and the SNAP work-notice piece sit in this segment too — one tracing how an empire that executed a carpenter made his creed the law, and one documenting a nine-page state letter that misstates the federal rules it was written to explain, in ways that mostly drop protections for the reader.

Mara: The SNAP piece is built from the author's own notice, which left the time-limit list blank, stated the work exemption two contradictory ways, and omitted penalty procedures, commuting standards, and good-cause protections that federal regulations require. The fixes the piece lists are not complicated.

Pip: The through-line across all of this is the same sentence: the rules exist, the access exists, and the gap is between the text and whoever is positioned to use it.

Mara: New Hampshire put that gap on a ten-year clock. The 2032 ballot question will ask whether to open the document. The reporting before then is the argument.

Transcript of the revised script. The listener’s note above records where it differs from the articles.

New Hampshire Open Records and Power

Made October 1, 2026 · AI hosts · 12:05

Granite State Report’s Right-to-Know reporting in one pass: a federal records workshop closed to requesters, an out-of-date Attorney General manual, a stalled Department of Safety request, and the empty ombudsman seat. Then the press carve-out in the private investigator law, Chief Justice MacDonald’s resignation, how legislative hearings filter who testifies, and a set of history and civic-ledger pieces.

Articles discussed in this episode

Listener’s note.

  • The hosts say three unanswered emails from an agency can restore federal search fees after a missed deadline. The article says that applies only when the agency has declared unusual circumstances and more than 5,000 pages are needed.
  • The hosts say the New Hampshire Supreme Court struck a law in 2008. In State v. Zidel the court reversed nine possession convictions. The statute stayed on the books, and the Legislature amended it that year.
  • The hosts say the 91-A Request Builder is open to anyone and only the redaction tool needs a subscription. Both tools now sit in the GSR Tools hub, which a free email subscription opens. Both are free.
  • The hosts say an incorporated newsroom faces a felony where a sole proprietor faces a misdemeanor. The article says that holds only if RSA 106-F reaches journalism at all, which no court has decided, and the felony class applies to the entity, not the person running it.
  • The hosts quote Article IX of the Treaty of Paris as “to be determined by Congress.” The treaty reads “shall be determined by the Congress.”
  • The hosts say the SNAP notice drops the “or” in the work exemption. The notice keeps the “or,” then adds a line requiring earnings of at least $217.50 a week, which as written cancels the hours test.
  • The hosts say three documents give three answers on where to send a hearing request. The article says two letters give different addresses for a hearing request. Its three-documents finding is about where to get legal help.

Checked and holding: the July 15 workshop notice and its registration terms, the last requester panel on June 15, 2017, the manual’s seventeen drifts and page 69, the ombudsman budget cut from $105,000 to $30,000 and Thomas Kehr’s July 2025 resignation, the one-sentence denial and 139-day estimate to December 16, the RSA 91-A:4, VII and RSA 106-F quotations, the Judicial Conduct Committee quote, the seven acts since March 2024, 3.6 million people in the territories, Pierce and the 1856 Guano Islands Act, the minimum wage unchanged since 2009, and Article 10’s “absurd, slavish, and destructive.”

Read the transcript

Pip: Granite State Report covers New Hampshire government the way an auditor covers a crime scene — methodically, with receipts. Dexter Dow has been busy.

Mara: This episode covers four territories: the tools and legal gaps shaping public-records requests at both the state and federal level, the state of New Hampshire’s archives and access infrastructure, questions about press freedom and government power, and a wide look at constitutional history and civic life.

Pip: In other words: your rights, on paper, versus your rights in practice.

Mara: Let’s start with the records-access machinery itself — the workshops, the software, and the manual that governs how agencies respond.

The Workshop Nobody Invited the Public To

Pip: The Justice Department ran a two-hour seminar in August on how to negotiate with records requesters, and the people those negotiations happen to were not allowed in the room.

Mara: The post lays out exactly what that means legally. The July 15 notice limited registration to federal employees and described the event as "open to agency FOIA professionals."

Pip: So the federal government convened a training on how to talk down your records request, trained only the side doing the talking, and called it a best practices workshop.

Mara: And the stakes are real. Under the Freedom of Information Act, a requester who refuses to narrow a request can have that refusal used against them in court — it becomes a factor in whether a judge gives the agency more time. Meanwhile, three unanswered emails from the agency count as good-faith outreach, which can restore the agency’s right to charge search fees even after it missed its own deadline.

Pip: Negotiation under FOIA carries a price tag: it can restore the agency’s power to bill you after it has already missed its own deadline.

Mara: The post also traces the history. The last time a requester sat on one of these panels was June 15, 2017. The published takeaways from that session still tell agencies to "Seek input from requester community." OIP wrote the advice, posted it, and then stopped following it.

Pip: A second post on the Attorney General’s Right-to-Know manual finds seventeen places where the official guidance drifts from the statute — and nearly every drift runs toward the government. The most striking: the manual’s page 69 instruction tells officials the five-day deadline is satisfied by a letter, dropping the option of simply producing the records.

Mara: New Hampshire’s own narrowing provision is actually drafted more favorably for requesters. RSA 91-A:4, IV(e) says an agency "may suggest" a narrower scope — no penalty for refusing, no fees that reattach. But the state’s enforcement mechanism has collapsed. The right-to-know ombudsman’s chair has been empty since Thomas Kehr resigned in July 2025 after lawmakers cut the office’s budget from $105,000 to $30,000.

Pip: A third post documents what that vacancy looks like in practice. The Department of Safety answered a six-item records request by citing a single exemption across five items with no per-item explanation, and estimating 139 days to produce the sixth — because of "the workloads of the personnel participating in the processing."

Mara: The statute requires the agency to name the specific exemption and briefly explain how it applies to each withheld record. One citation stretched across five requests doesn’t satisfy that.

Pip: December 16 will have to explain itself, the same way the blanket exemption will.

Mara: Two additional posts address the tools side. The redaction post explains that drawing a black rectangle over text in a PDF leaves the words selectable and recoverable — and that New Hampshire law counts automated redaction software used with spot checks as good faith, without asking whether the software actually destroys the underlying text. Granite State Report built and published a browser-based tool that converts pages to pixels and burns the redaction in, so the text layer is gone rather than covered.

Pip: The test is three steps: drag across a blacked-out area and see if text highlights, select all and paste into a plain text editor, then search for a word you redacted. A file that passes gives you nothing on all three.

Mara: The GSR Tools hub collects that redaction tool alongside a request builder that generates a letter citing the correct statutory paragraphs and computing the five-business-day response deadline — with a plain disclosure that the statute never actually defines "business day" for records requests.

Pip: The tools are free. The request builder is open to anyone. The redaction tool requires a free email subscription, because, as the post puts it, a newsroom run by one person in Northfield has no other way to know anybody is out there.

Mara: That enforcement vacuum — no ombudsman, no cheap alternative to superior court — runs through all of these posts. The AI-generated CSAM law piece connects here too, showing a different kind of gap: a 2024 statute that reaches further than the one the New Hampshire Supreme Court struck in 2008, passed without a recorded no vote, and now sitting on the wrong side of a line a federal appeals court just reinforced.

Pip: Which brings us to the question of what the public actually has access to — and who’s keeping the index.

The Index Nobody Is Required to Build

Mara: RSA 91-A:4, VII states that nothing in the Right-to-Know Law requires a public body or agency "to compile, cross-reference, or assemble information into a form in which it is not already kept or reported by that body or agency."

Pip: You can get any document you know to ask for. You cannot ask what documents exist.

Mara: The post on New Hampshire’s records index frames the consequence plainly: the public record is public the way a library with no catalog is a library. Everything is technically available. Nothing is findable. The people who can work that system are the ones who already know what to ask for.

Pip: A companion column makes the civic version of this argument, noting that a right nobody exercises is indistinguishable, from the inside of a public body, from a right that does not exist.

Mara: In response, Granite State Report published its own archive — the Granite State Record Room — cataloging every document the newsroom holds, with accession numbers, provenance, rights status, and a table of what was excluded and why.

Pip: An archive that only advertises its contents is a brochure. The exclusions are what let a reader judge the rest.

Mara: The seven-laws redline and its companion article document every change to RSA 91-A since the Attorney General’s March 2024 memorandum — seven acts in all, covering per-communication charges, county meeting comment rights, minutes requirements, ombudsman restructuring, lottery-winner anonymity, a word swap in the certification exemption, and the new domain-name response option. The memorandum reflects none of them.

Pip: From the records beat to the courtroom — because the same accountability gaps show up there too.

Press, Penalties, and the Undefined Word

Mara: New Hampshire’s private investigator statute, RSA 106-F, exempts "persons engaged in reporting or providing information to an accredited news publication, media, or news outlet." The chapter never defines "accredited," and no body in the state issues the credential.

Pip: A licensing office should not be the arbiter of who is a journalist. On paper, in New Hampshire, it is.

Mara: A follow-up post refines the penalty analysis. RSA 106-F:14 makes a violation "a misdemeanor for a natural person and a felony for any other person." A sole proprietorship is a natural person. An LLC or nonprofit is not. Same reporting, same records, same story — and the incorporated newsroom faces a higher class of crime than the unincorporated one.

Pip: The responsible step of forming an entity to separate your business from yourself turns out to be an aggravating factor under this statute.

Mara: The Chief Justice MacDonald resignation post covers a different accountability gap. The Judicial Conduct Committee settled rather than hold a public hearing, and said plainly: "In resolving this case by Stipulation and Agreement, the public is deprived of the full scope of transparency that would accompany an adversarial hearing."

Pip: Also worth noting: the Right-to-Know Law doesn’t reach the courts at all. Public access to court records rests on the state constitution and the courts’ own procedures.

Mara: The Power Playbook entries — on courting attention in New Hampshire politics and on how bills get drafted — round out this segment. The hearing-guarantee post documents that every bill gets a public hearing, but testimony is in person only, in Concord, on a weekday, during working hours. The population that reliably meets all four conditions is the population paid to.

Pip: The most open door in American legislatures, and a filter. The rule is generous. The ground it sets decides who walks through.

Mara: Which connects directly to the constitutional territory ahead.

The Documents That Govern and the Questions They Leave Open

Mara: The empire post anchors this segment with a legal date: February 6, 1899, when the Senate ratified the Treaty of Paris and kept the Philippines. Article IX of that treaty left the political status of the ceded populations "to be determined by Congress" — no promise, no clock.

Pip: "Foreign to the United States in a domestic sense." Justice White wrote that in 1901, and it is still the law for about 3.6 million people who elect no senator and whose House delegates cannot vote on the floor.

Mara: New Hampshire appears twice in that history: Franklin Pierce signed the Guano Islands Act in 1856, the first law allowing the country to hold land it never intended to make a state, and Portsmouth hosted the 1905 treaty ending the Russo-Japanese War.

Pip: The constitutional renewal post proposes two complete replacement documents — one for New Hampshire, one for the country — and traces the lawful path to each. The New Hampshire road runs through a question already printed on the 2032 ballot.

Mara: The SNAP notice post is a close read of a nine-page letter from the Bureau of Family Assistance that misstates several of the federal rules it was written to explain — dropping the "or" in the working exemption, omitting penalty procedures, and leaving the time-limit applicability list blank while a same-day decision notice warns in capitals that the reader must prove compliance.

Pip: Three documents, three different answers on where to send a hearing request.

Mara: The Rome post and the Live Free or Die ledger close the segment. The ledger runs two dozen numbers — incarceration rates, debt loads, housing costs, the minimum wage unchanged since 2009 — against New Hampshire’s own constitutional language, which calls nonresistance to arbitrary power "absurd, slavish, and destructive."

Pip: The through-line across all of this is the same: rights that exist on paper, enforcement mechanisms that have been hollowed out, and the question of who keeps the list when no one is required to.

Mara: New Hampshire puts that question on the ballot in 2032. The next episode will look at what else is on the ledger.

Transcript as generated by the tool, unedited. The listener’s note above records where it differs from the articles.

Constitutional Change and American Power

Made October 1, 2026 · AI hosts · 7:52

Dexter Dow’s two proposed constitutions, one for New Hampshire and one for the United States, and the legal path each would take. Then the question of when the country began holding people it never promised to make citizens, from a guano law signed by a New Hampshire president to the 1899 Senate vote on the Philippines.

Generated by the WordPress.com podcast tool on October 1, 2026. On October 10 the script was revised and the episode re-recorded with synthetic voices. The player and the transcript carry the revised version.

Articles discussed in this episode

Listener’s note.

  • The hosts say Justice White called “the territories” foreign to the United States in a domestic sense. In Downes v. Bidwell, White said it of Puerto Rico.
  • The hosts credit the 202-year wait for the Twenty-seventh Amendment to “New Hampshire Asks Every Ten Years.” That piece says “more than two centuries.” The 202-year figure is in “A New Constitution for New Hampshire.”
  • The hosts say every acquisition “before 1898” came with a promise. The article dates the break to the Senate vote of February 6, 1899.
  • The episode closes by saying the empire “arrived in the fine print of a guano law.” The article calls the 1856 Guano Islands Act a loophole and names the February 6, 1899 Senate vote as the date.

Checked and holding: Jefferson’s nineteen-year generation and the 935-constitution study, the 237-year age of the U.S. Constitution, New Hampshire’s seventeen conventions and the Part Second, Article 100 path to 2032, the features of both drafts, the Guano Islands Act and its Section 4, the 57-to-27 Senate vote, the war casualty figures, independence on July 4, 1946, the Downes v. Bidwell quotation, and Portsmouth in 1905.

Read the transcript

Two synthetic voices read this episode. It summarizes Granite State Report articles; each claim was checked against those articles and their sources.

Pip: Welcome to Granite State Report, where the founding documents are not just history — they are apparently a to-do list. Dexter Dow has been busy.

Mara: He has. This episode covers constitutional reform at both the state and federal level, and a sharp historical question about exactly when the United States became something other than a republic of equal states.

Pip: Let's start with the constitutions — both of them.

New Hampshire Constitutional Reform, and a Draft for the Nation

Mara: The central tension here is one Jefferson named in 1789: constitutions are written for one generation but end up binding the next. The question is whether the machinery for changing them still works — and whether New Hampshire's scheduled mechanism offers a model the country has never tried.

Pip: The piece opens with a number that does a lot of work. Jefferson ran the mortality tables and landed on nineteen years as the natural span of a political generation. Then, two centuries later, three scholars measured 935 actual constitutions and got the same figure. As the piece puts it: "Jefferson did not offer an opinion. He performed a calculation, and the data of two hundred years returned his exact number."

Mara: And the U.S. Constitution had run for 237 years as of the piece's September 2026 publication — the oldest written national constitution still operating anywhere. New Hampshire's is five years older than that. The piece is not a complaint about age; it is a delivery: two complete proposed constitutions, one for the state and one for the country, with the legal pathway for each spelled out.

Pip: The New Hampshire road is almost embarrassingly concrete, which is a phrase the piece uses and earns.

Mara: Right. Part Second, Article 100 puts the convention question on the 2032 ballot whether anyone lifts a finger. A simple majority calls the convention, delegates are elected from the same House districts — about four hundred people — and nothing they produce becomes law without two-thirds of voters approving it. The convention proposes; only the people dispose.

Pip: New Hampshire has held seventeen of these conventions, more than any other state. The national average is five.

Mara: The companion piece, "New Hampshire Asks Every Ten Years Whether to Rewrite Its Constitution. The Country Never Has To," makes the contrast explicit. The federal Article V has cleared its bar twenty-seven times in 237 years, and the most recent amendment waited 202 years between proposal and ratification. There is no scheduled moment that forces the country to ask whether the rules still fit.

Pip: The state draft keeps what works — the 400-member House, the Executive Council, the Right of Revolution preserved word for word — and fixes what the last forty years have broken. Education funding gets an enforceable article that cannot be renamed a shared responsibility by statute.

Mara: The federal draft elects the president by national popular vote with ranked choice, unfreezes the House from its 1929 cap, ends the filibuster's standing supermajority, and puts eighteen-year staggered terms on Supreme Court justices. And at its center is the answer to Madison: a mandatory national convention every nineteen years, while the existing constitution stays in force until the people revise or reaffirm it.

Pip: So the republic never goes dark between drafts. Jefferson gets his clock; Madison keeps his guardrails.

Mara: The piece addresses the runaway-convention fear directly — the answer is arithmetic. In New Hampshire, a convention's proposals are waste paper without two-thirds of voters. Federally, thirteen states can kill anything. A process ending in a supermajority of the governed cannot run away from the governed.

Pip: From the founding machinery of New Hampshire to the question of what the founders' republic became — that is where we go next.

When the Republic Became an Empire

Mara: The piece on America's imperial origins asks a precise legal question: when did the United States stop being a republic that promised eventual equal membership to everyone it governed? The answer turns on a single treaty article.

Pip: Every acquisition before 1898 came with a promise. Louisiana, 1803: inhabitants incorporated, citizenship promised. The Northwest Ordinance: statehood once a territory held 60,000 free inhabitants. Then came the Treaty of Paris, 1898, and the language changed. Article IX says the political status of the people ceded to the United States "shall be determined by the Congress." No promise. No clock.

Mara: That is the break. The piece traces it back one step further, to a New Hampshire president. Franklin Pierce signed the Guano Islands Act on August 18, 1856 — a short law allowing Americans to claim islands for their bird droppings, with the land described as "appertaining to" the United States. Not annexed. Not on the road to statehood. And Section 4 said nothing obliged the country to keep the island once the guano was gone. First time Congress wrote a way to own land with no intention of making it part of the country.

Pip: Pierce's signature on a bill about bird droppings turns out to be the first draft of the machinery 1899 would run at scale. History has a sense of humor, but it is a very dry one.

Mara: The Senate ratified the Treaty of Paris on February 6, 1899, fifty-seven to twenty-seven, one vote past the two-thirds line — knowing that American and Filipino forces had already begun shooting two days earlier. The war that followed killed more than 4,200 Americans, more than 20,000 Filipino fighters, and as many as 200,000 Filipino civilians. The Philippines received independence on July 4, 1946, and the proclamation counted the forty-eight years of American control out loud.

Mara: Two years after the Senate vote, the Supreme Court put a legal name to what had happened. Justice Edward Douglass White's concurrence in Downes v. Bidwell supplied the phrase that has outlived everyone who wrote it: the territories were "foreign to the United States in a domestic sense." That doctrine turned 125 years old in May 2026 and is still the law.

Pip: About 3.6 million people live under it, by the 2020 Census count — in Puerto Rico, Guam, the Virgin Islands, American Samoa, and the Northern Mariana Islands. No Senate votes. House delegates who can speak but not vote on the floor. Two justices have written that the Insular Cases were wrong; Justice Gorsuch said they rest on a rotten foundation. Congress has not answered at all.

Mara: The piece also notes New Hampshire's second chapter in this story: Portsmouth, 1905, where Theodore Roosevelt brokered the peace between Russia and Japan, and New Hampshire hosted the moment the United States stopped asking whether it was an empire and started refereeing the others. Six years separated the Senate vote from the Navy Yard.

Pip: Two constitutions drafted for argument, and an empire that arrived in the fine print of a guano law. Quite a run for the Granite State.

Mara: The thread connecting them is the same question: who decides the rules, and for how long can the dead govern the living? New Hampshire has a date on the calendar. The country does not — yet.

Transcript of the revised script. The listener’s note above records where it differs from the articles.

New Hampshire Law and Civic Power

Made October 1, 2026 · AI hosts · 11:53

Redaction and the RSA 91-A good-faith shield, the undefined “accredited” press exclusion in New Hampshire’s private investigator law, why liable is not guilty, and a SNAP work notice that misstates federal rules. Then constitutional renewal and the 2032 convention question, the 1899 vote that made America an empire, and how Rome put a carpenter’s creed into law.

Articles discussed in this episode

Listener’s note.

  • The hosts say every piece in the episode is by Dexter Dow. “Liable Is Not Guilty” carries the byline GSR Staff.
  • The hosts say RSA 91-A:4, IV(f) shields a public body if it used redaction software with spot checks. The shield covers a body that acted in good faith and not wantonly or recklessly. Software with spot checks is one named route to good faith.
  • The hosts say an incorporated newsroom faces a felony where a sole proprietor faces a misdemeanor. The article frames that as a consequence only if RSA 106-F reaches journalism at all, which nobody has tested.
  • The hosts list three open questions in the press exclusion. The article lists four. The one left out comes first: whether “for a private rather than a public interest” keeps publishers out of the chapter entirely. The article’s last question asks whether the Department of Safety, any court, or the advisory board “has ever construed paragraph VIII,” not whether the department has “read” it.
  • The hosts say New Hampshire “sent out” a nine-page SNAP notice whose errors run “almost always” against the reader. The article examines one notice, addressed to the editor, who discloses that he receives SNAP, and says most departures work against the reader.
  • The hosts say two justices have said the Insular Cases’ foundation is rotten. “Rotten foundation” is Justice Gorsuch’s phrase alone, from a 2022 concurrence.
  • The hosts say the draft constitutions “address exactly this kind of structural freeze” right after discussing the territories. The constitution article does not discuss the territories or the Insular Cases.
  • The hosts describe “three centuries of persecution” before Constantine. The article says persecution ran over the next 250 years.
  • The hosts say New Hampshire kept Protestant requirements in its constitution until 1968. The Protestant test for state senators ended in 1877. What lasted until 1968 was the sectarian language in Article 6.
  • The hosts say the Council of Churches spoke “on exactly this dynamic,” meaning Constantine. Its testimony opposed CACR 28 and cited the teaching about Caesar. It did not address Nicaea.
  • The pieces discussed ran September 15 to 19, 2026. “This week” refers to that run.
  • The hosts say two justices have called the Insular Cases a rotten foundation and five have not. The article, corrected October 2, 2026, says the two justices who wrote that the Insular Cases were wrong are Neil Gorsuch, concurring in United States v. Vaello Madero (2022), and Sonia Sotomayor, dissenting in the same case; no other justice joined either opinion, and the record does not sort the other seven into a camp.
  • The hosts say a statutory cap cut David Meehan’s $38 million verdict to $475,000. The article, updated October 4, 2026, says that ruling is under review: the New Hampshire Supreme Court heard arguments on the cap in November 2025, and a ruling was pending as of September 16, 2026.

Checked and holding: the quoted lines from the redaction, SNAP, Jefferson, Council of Churches and civil-criminal pieces; the $38 million Meehan verdict and the criminal mistrial; the RSA 106-F:14 penalty wording; Part Second, Article 100 and the 2032 vote; the 435-seat House, 27 amendments and the two-thirds ratification rule; February 6, 1899, the 1901 doctrine and 3.6 million residents; Nicaea in 325; the 14-to-1 committee vote and the March 5, 2026 voice vote; and Pew’s 48 percent and 50th-of-51 ranking.

Read the transcript

Pip: Granite State Report, out of Northfield, New Hampshire — a one-person operation that this week managed to cover redaction software, private investigator law, SNAP benefits, constitutional theory, American empire, and the Roman Empire, which is either impressive range or a sign that Dexter Dow does not sleep.

Mara: All of it from Dexter Dow, yes. Today we’re looking at press freedom and liability, a government benefits notice that misstates the rules it was written to explain, constitutional change at the state and national level, and a long view of how empires — ancient and modern — handle the people they acquire. Let’s start with the legal exposure facing New Hampshire newsrooms.

Press Freedom And Liability

Pip: This segment is about the legal ground underneath New Hampshire journalism — specifically, what the law says about redaction, what it says about who counts as press, and what happens when you get either question wrong.

Mara: The redaction piece opens with a plain demonstration of the problem. Draw a black rectangle over a name in a PDF, and the name is still in the file. As the piece puts it: "Select the area, copy it, paste it into any text editor, and the name you thought you hid comes back whole."

Pip: So the black box is decoration. The name is still there, waiting for anyone with a text editor and thirty seconds.

Mara: Right, and the law does not close that gap. Under RSA 91-A:4, IV(f), a public body is shielded from civil damages if it used automated redaction software alongside spot checks — the statute asks whether the body used software and looked at some output, not whether the redaction actually held. The piece names who absorbs the risk: a resident who filed a complaint, a witness, a person who called for help.

Pip: The shield runs to the body. The consequence runs to whoever was named in the document.

Mara: The piece is careful to say IV(f) is not indefensible — a body facing ruinous liability for one miss in thousands of pages will stop releasing anything, and a records law that produces nothing is worse than one that occasionally produces too much. But it calls the assumption behind the provision one nobody is checking, and says the checking is cheap. The newsroom built two free browser-based tools: a redaction tool that destroys the text layer entirely, and a request builder that cites the relevant statutes and computes the five-business-day deadline.

Pip: On the deadline math — the statute says five business days and never defines business day for records requests, so the tool states its own assumption on the page rather than hiding it.

Mara: That gap connects directly to the second piece, on RSA 106-F, New Hampshire’s private investigator law. A sole proprietor newsroom and an incorporated one doing identical reporting face different exposure under that chapter: the statute makes a violation a misdemeanor for a natural person and a felony for any other person. The press exclusion in RSA 106-F:4, VIII was supposed to resolve this, but it asks for a credential — accreditation — that no body in New Hampshire issues.

Pip: So the carve-out meant to protect the press depends on a word nobody has defined and a status nobody grants.

Mara: And three questions in the text remain unresolved: whether "accredited" modifies only "news publication" or carries across to the whole list, whether the preposition "to" requires a publisher above you, and whether the Department of Safety has ever read paragraph VIII at all. The piece notes that the one-person operation is a category the chapter explicitly knows — it prices a one-licensee agency separately — but is also the one the press exclusion does not squarely address.

Mara: The third piece in this segment pulls back to the courtroom level. "Liable Is Not Guilty" uses the David Meehan case — a civil jury awarded him $38 million over alleged abuse at the Youth Development Center, a cap cut it to $475,000, and a criminal trial over the same allegations ended in a mistrial — to explain that civil and criminal cases are two different machines running on different standards and producing different outcomes.

Pip: A $38 million verdict and a mistrial are not a contradiction. They are the same facts processed by two different systems, and the piece is a useful map of which system does what.

Mara: It covers burden of proof, who pays for a lawyer, statutes of limitations, and the one place the Right-to-Know Law goes criminal: knowingly destroying a requested record is a misdemeanor, but withholding one is a civil petition. Hiding a record is a lawsuit. Shredding one is a crime.

Pip: Which brings us somewhere adjacent — what those records are supposed to say, and what happens when the government gets even that wrong.

Public Benefits And Administrative Errors

Pip: New Hampshire sent out a nine-page SNAP work notice in September, and the piece examining it found that the letter misstates the federal rules it was written to explain — almost always in the direction that drops a protection for the reader.

Mara: The most striking structural problem is on page one. The notice lists who is subject to the time-limit rules that can end benefits after three months, and then, as the piece puts it, prints nothing. The decision notice sent the same day tells the reader in capitals: "YOU MUST SHOW US YOU ARE MEETING THESE ABAWD WORK REQUIREMENTS." The two letters together leave a person unable to tell whether the time limit applies to them.

Pip: A blank list and an unconditional warning in the same envelope. That is a well-designed system for producing confusion.

Mara: The substantive errors run further. The federal work exemption turns on the word "or" — a person working thirty hours a week or earning the equivalent is exempt. The notice copies that sentence, then adds a parenthetical making earnings a requirement for everyone, canceling the hours test in the same sentence. The penalty section omits the required sequence: the state must first determine good cause, then send a notice of adverse action, and the penalty begins only after that period. The notice says none of this. The piece also flags that the form directing readers to legal help is dated 2019, calls the program "Food Stamps" — a name retired in 2008 — and sends readers to a telephone directory.

Pip: From there, the question of what the rules actually say — and who gets to write them — scales up considerably.

Constitutional Change And Civic Order

Pip: This segment asks the largest question of the week: if a constitution is broken, or simply old, what is the lawful way to replace it — and does New Hampshire have something the country doesn’t?

Mara: The anchor piece opens with a calculation Thomas Jefferson made in 1789. Writing to Madison from Paris, he worked out from mortality tables that a generation turns over about every nineteen years and argued that no constitution should outlive the generation that consented to it. The piece quotes him directly: "The earth belongs always to the living generation."

Pip: Madison talked him down, and we have been living inside Madison’s caution ever since — which is either wise stability or the dead governing the living, depending on your mood.

Mara: The piece offers two complete draft constitutions, one for New Hampshire and one for the country, as works of public argument. The New Hampshire path is concrete: Part Second, Article 100 places a convention question on every ballot at least once a decade, and the next one is already scheduled for 2032. A majority calls the convention, four hundred delegates are elected from the same districts as the House, and nothing the convention produces takes effect without two-thirds of voters approving it.

Pip: The companion piece, focused on the decennial question itself, makes the procedural point plainly: New Hampshire never drifts far from asking whether its own design still works, because the asking is built into the calendar.

Mara: That piece also notes what the federal constitution lacks — no scheduled moment that forces the country to consider the question, a House frozen at 435 seats since 1929, and an amendment process that has cleared its bar twenty-seven times in two hundred thirty-seven years, with the most recent waiting two centuries between proposal and ratification. The historical piece on American empire fits here too: it traces the legal date the country stopped promising statehood to the people it acquired — February 6, 1899, when the Senate ratified the Treaty of Paris and left the political status of the Philippines to Congress with no clock and no promise.

Pip: A government that holds people it has not promised to make its equals — that is the definition the piece offers, and it is a legal one, not a mood.

Mara: About 3.6 million people still live under the doctrine the Supreme Court wrote in 1901, in the unincorporated territories, with no Senate seat and no presidential vote. Two justices have now said the foundation is rotten. Five have not. The constitutional drafts in the anchor piece address exactly this kind of structural freeze — and the Rome piece, just next door, is a long view of what happens when an empire decides to absorb the thing it once tried to destroy.

Empire Faith And Historical Power

Pip: The résumé is hard to explain. Executed by the state. No publications. Net worth: nothing on record. Current title: King of Kings.

Mara: The piece traces how that arc happened — Rome’s execution, Rome’s three centuries of persecution, and then Constantine’s reversal. He convened the bishops at Nicaea in 325, put the imperial post at their disposal, and watched them vote on the nature of God. The piece quotes the New Hampshire Council of Churches, which filed testimony against a 2026 attempt to restore the state’s 1784 Protestant language, on exactly this dynamic: the churches argued the carpenter himself drew the boundary between state and God, and drew it "not to weaken faith, but to protect it from being coopted by political power."

Pip: The churches told the legislature that the retainer was never his idea, and the committee voted fourteen to one against bringing it back.

Mara: New Hampshire kept Protestant requirements in its constitution from 1784 until 1968, when voters amended Article 6 to remove the sectarian language. CACR 28 would have restored the 1784 text word for word — evangelical principles, public Protestant teachers, protections limited to Christians. It died by voice vote on March 5, 2026, in a state where Pew’s most recent survey puts 48 percent of adults claiming no religion and places New Hampshire fiftieth out of fifty-one on its religiousness scale.

Pip: The thread across all of it is the same: rules written for one world, running in another, and the question of who pays when they don’t fit.

Mara: New Hampshire has a mechanism for asking that question on a schedule. The next episode will show whether the answers are keeping up.

Transcript as generated by the tool, unedited. The listener’s note above records where it differs from the articles.

RSA 91-A Redline: Every Change Since the Attorney General’s March 2024 Memorandum

Made October 1, 2026 · AI hosts · 4:09

A walk through the seven acts that have changed New Hampshire’s Right-to-Know Law since the Attorney General’s March 2024 memorandum, from the 2024 fee law to the 2026 website-answer rule, plus the memo’s own settlement-agreement error and the residency bill that stalled.

Articles discussed in this episode

Listener’s note.

  • The hosts credit Dexter Dow with the redline. The page carries the Granite State Report name, compiled September 16, 2026.
  • “A dollar per email, with the first 250 free” is shorthand. Under RSA 91-A:4, VIII the charge applies only to requests running past 250 electronic communications, and $1.00 per communication is a ceiling, not a set price.

Every act, effective date, and statutory detail in the episode was checked against the redline: HB 1002 (Aug. 13, 2024), HB 1125 and its three-minute county comment rule, HB 265, HB 2 and the ombudsman sunset repeal, HB 485 and its three lottery conditions, SB 575, HB 164 (Aug. 31, 2026), the memorandum’s settlement-agreement error, and SB 626 laid on the table.

Read the transcript

Pip: New Hampshire's right-to-know law is one of those statutes where the official guidance and the actual statute quietly drift apart, and nobody sends you a memo about the memo being wrong.

Mara: That's exactly what Dexter Dow has mapped out for Granite State Report — a redline of RSA 91-A showing every change to the state's Right-to-Know law since the Attorney General's March 2024 memorandum. Let's start with what that document actually tracks.

RSA 91-A Redlined: What Changed Since the 2024 Memo

Pip: The Attorney General's 2024 memorandum is the standard reference most people use to understand New Hampshire's Right-to-Know law. The question this redline answers is: how far has the statute moved since that document was published?

Mara: The post lays out its method plainly. The baseline is the Attorney General's memorandum released March 14, 2024, and the current text is RSA 91-A as published by the New Hampshire General Court. The post states: "Each block below reproduces the enrolled text of the act. Underlined text was added. Crossed-out text was removed."

Pip: So this isn't analysis — it's the raw legislative record, formatted so you can see exactly what each act did to the statute. Seven acts in roughly two years is a meaningful pace of change for a foundational transparency law.

Mara: The first and largest change came from HB 1002, effective August 13, 2024, which rewrote the fee structure for records requests. It added paragraphs VIII and IX — a per-electronic-communication charge framework, a 30-day aggregation rule for multiple requests, and a fee-waiver process for indigent requesters and those seeking records in the public interest.

Pip: A dollar per email, with the first 250 free — that's the kind of provision that sounds reasonable until someone files a request that touches a busy inbox.

Mara: HB 1125 added RSA 91-A:2-c, requiring county commissioner and delegation meetings to allow public comment from county residents, with at least three minutes guaranteed per speaker. HB 265, effective August 2025, updated the minutes requirement — meetings must now record start and end times and the name of the person who produced the minutes.

Pip: The budget bill, HB 2, handled the ombudsman's survival — it repealed the 2022 sunset provisions that would have ended the office on July 1, 2025, and moved the office administratively to the Office of State and Public Sector Labor Relations.

Mara: HB 485 created RSA 91-A:5-b, allowing lottery winners to remain anonymous if they meet specific conditions — domestic violence victim status, an active restraining order, or a successful superior court petition. SB 575 updated the certification-records exemption from "teacher" to "educator." And HB 164, effective August 31, 2026, lets a public body answer a records request by providing a website domain name if the record has been uploaded to a publicly accessible state-designated site.

Pip: The post also flags where the memorandum itself contains an independent error — it cites the wrong subsection for settlement agreements and inverts the legal conclusion, separate from anything the legislature did.

Mara: Right. And the post notes that SB 626, which would have restricted right-to-know requests to New Hampshire residents, was laid on the table in the Senate and went no further — so that's one change that didn't happen.

Pip: Seven acts, one frozen memo, and a gap that keeps widening — that's the record New Hampshire's transparency advocates are now working from.

Mara: The underlying tension here is straightforward: official guidance ages, statutes don't wait, and the distance between the two is where confusion lives.

Pip: Next time, we'll see what else Granite State Report is watching — because in New Hampshire, the ledger is rarely closed.

Transcript as generated by the tool, unedited. The listener’s note above records where it differs from the articles.

New Hampshire Records and Benefits

Made September 17, 2026 · AI hosts · 6:00

Three pieces in one episode: how RSA 91-A has moved since 2024, the index New Hampshire never built and the Record Room built to replace it, and the SNAP work notice that turns an “or” into a requirement.

Generated by the WordPress.com podcast tool on September 17, 2026. On October 10 the script was revised and the episode re-recorded with synthetic voices. The player and the transcript carry the revised version.

Articles discussed in this episode

Read the transcript

Two synthetic voices read this episode. It summarizes Granite State Report articles; each claim was checked against those articles and their sources.

Pip: Granite State Report covers New Hampshire, where the right to know what your government is doing is technically guaranteed, and technically is doing a lot of work in that sentence.

Mara: Dexter Dow has been tracking that gap closely. We're looking at how New Hampshire's public-records law has shifted since 2024, what tools exist to work with it, and where a state SNAP notice goes wrong in ways that cost real people real protections.

Pip: Let's start with the statute itself — seven acts, and a guide that predates all of them.

Right-to-Know Law: Seven Acts, One Outdated Guide

Mara: The question here is straightforward: what has changed in RSA 91-A since the Attorney General's 2024 memorandum, and does anyone working from that guide know?

Pip: The piece on every word that moved puts it plainly: "Anyone working from the 2024 memorandum, or from memory, is reading a law that has moved."

Mara: And it has moved significantly. The fee rule most requesters will feel came from HB 1002 in 2024 — up to a dollar per electronic communication beyond the first 250. The ombudsman office that handles fee disputes lost its only occupant in July 2025 and, as of the newsroom's September 2026 reporting, had not been filled. The companion redline piece, RSA 91-A Redline, reproduces every enacted word across all seven acts so readers can see exactly what changed.

Pip: So the quick lane for fee fights runs through an empty office. The longer route is superior court, which costs the money and time the ombudsman was created to save.

Mara: That's the practical upshot. Meanwhile HB 265 added start times, end times, and the producer's name to meeting minutes. HB 485 lets lottery winners stay anonymous in specific circumstances. The 2026 acts are narrower — one swapped "teacher" for "educator," the other lets agencies answer with a website address if the record is already posted on a state-designated site.

Pip: Which brings us to the archive built to hold what the law doesn't require anyone to organize.

Public Records: The Index Nobody Had to Build

Mara: The core tension here is a single sentence in RSA 91-A:4, paragraph VII — the law hands over documents one at a time but never requires an agency to say what it holds.

Pip: The piece on the index frames it this way: "Each document goes out to the person who asked, and then stops existing anywhere a second person can find it."

Mara: So the upshot is a public record system that is technically open and practically opaque — findable only to people who already know what to ask for. The Granite State Record Room, published the same day, is the direct response to that gap.

Pip: At publication, twenty-nine items, four series, and a table of what got left out — which is the part that makes it an archive rather than a brochure.

Mara: Right. Series one holds records obtained under RSA 91-A, along with the requests that produced them. Series two keeps the statute and the Attorney General's guidance, because, as the page notes, authoritative copies move and old versions stop resolving. Series three holds drafting files, including a proposed state constitution drafted for the 2032 convention question. Series four holds cited research, with copyright ownership plainly marked.

Pip: The index piece also explains why the records are free but the work isn't — and that explanation turns on RSA 106-F, the private investigator statute, which contains the word "accredited" and then declines to define it.

Mara: That's the legal constraint the index piece works through carefully. The exclusion in RSA 106-F:4 covers persons reporting to an accredited news outlet, but no state agency issues that credential, and the text doesn't resolve whether a sole proprietor who is the outlet qualifies. So commissioned work is structured as public-interest labor — the request, the clock, the challenge — with everything obtained published to everyone on the same terms.

Pip: A catalog of what the government won't catalog, free to anyone who signs up with an email address. Now to a letter the government did produce, and got wrong.

SNAP Notice: When the Letter Misstates the Rule

Mara: The piece on New Hampshire's SNAP work notice identifies a specific problem: a nine-page letter that federal regulations dictate must explain the rules accurately, but doesn't.

Pip: The clearest example is the employment exemption. Federal rules say a person working 30 hours a week or earning the equivalent is exempt. The notice copies that "or," then adds: "for this exemption you must be earning at least $217.50 weekly" — turning an alternative into a requirement.

Mara: That parenthetical appears in the general rules, the time-limit section, and the state form. The department's own Food Stamp Manual keeps the "or." The notice also leaves the time-limit list blank with no explanation, while a same-day decision notice tells the reader in capital letters to prove compliance or lose benefits. The DHHS records request, the questions put to the department, and its reply are all posted in the Granite State Record Room.

Pip: A letter explaining conditions for buying groceries should at least get the conditions right.

Mara: That's the closing line of the piece, almost verbatim.

Pip: An outdated guide, a missing index, and a benefits letter that misstates the rule it was written to explain — the common thread is information that exists but doesn't reach the people who need it.

Mara: That's the territory Granite State Report keeps returning to. More to come.

Transcript of the revised script.

Want the articles themselves?

The Audio Articles page holds Granite State Report articles read aloud in full, newest first, many of them in Dexter Dow’s own voice. Each one links back to the article it was read from.

Heard something wrong? If an episode gets a fact wrong that the listener’s note missed, say so and the note is corrected under the corrections policy. granitestatereport@gmail.com · (603) 931-9264
The podcast is free, like every article on this site. The support page is how the reporting behind it gets paid for.
Version log. The GSR Podcast v1.0, October 1, 2026: page created with the ten newest article narrations. v2.0, October 1, 2026: the narrations moved to the Audio Articles page; this page now carries only the AI conversation episodes made with the WordPress.com podcast tool, two episodes, each checked against its source articles, with a listener’s note, links to every article discussed, and the transcript. v3.0, October 1, 2026: three episodes added, newest first: “New Hampshire Open Records and Power,” “Constitutional Change and American Power,” and “New Hampshire Law and Civic Power,” each checked against its source articles with a listener’s note, article links, and the unedited transcript. v4.0, October 4, 2026: seven episodes added, newest first: “Your Rights at Town Hall: Recording and Records Policies,” the first episode scripted from the articles rather than generated by the WordPress.com tool, and six WordPress.com episodes, “Power Tactics and Political Maneuvering,” “GSR Tools,” “Open Records and Public Access,” “Faith, Mind, and Power,” “Records Access, the Press Exemption and the Courts” and “New Hampshire Open Government Battles,” each checked against its source articles with a listener’s note, article links and the transcript. The listener’s notes for “Constitutional Change and American Power” and “New Hampshire Law and Civic Power” gained entries for the October 2 correction to the Empire article, and the latter for the October 4 update on the Meehan damages cap. The page now carries one block per episode. v4.1, October 4, 2026: two episodes added, newest first, both scripted from the articles: “Who Decides Before the Judge: Bail Commissioners and Prosecutors,” from the Jobs in the Law entries on the bail commissioner and the prosecutor, and “Your Medical File and the Police,” from the two health privacy explainers on police access to medical records and on when a doctor can call the police. Each has article links, a note on how it was made, and the transcript. Their voices were generated with Kokoro, an open-weight text-to-speech model. v4.1.1, October 4, 2026: the audio file for “Who Decides Before the Judge” was replaced after a check of the recording against the script found one line, on bail commissioner training, with two garbled words (the “a” in RSA 597:18-a and “eight-hour”). That line was re-recorded and the episode re-cut; the script, transcript and running time are unchanged. v4.2, October 4, 2026: three episodes added, newest first, all scripted from the articles: “Both Are True: The Cop, the Hairdresser and the Holiday Nobody Gets Off,” from the articles on police certification hours, on the SNAP fraud and manslaughter ceilings, and on the Election Day holiday and the 1913 mill law; “Annulled, Not Erased: The Arrest File and the Mugshot,” from the columns on annulment and on booking photos; and “Justice Has a Cover Charge,” from the columns on court costs for poor litigants and on two tiers of justice. These run longer than earlier episodes and spend more time on how each article is built; each says so in its note on how it was made. Each has article links and the transcript. Their voices were generated with Kokoro. v4.3, October 5, 2026: two episodes added, newest first, both scripted from the articles in the longer format: “Hire, Run, Fire: The Judge, the Clerk and the Birthday,” from the three Jobs in the Law entries on what a judge does all day, on the clerk of court, and on removing a judge; and “Presumed to Know, Punished for Telling,” from the columns on the uncountable criminal code and on the honesty penalty. Each has article links, a note on how it was made, and the transcript. Their voices were generated with Kokoro. Two superseded audio files from v4.2, never linked on this page, were removed from the media library. v4.3.1, October 5, 2026: the version line under the page title now reads 4.3; it had read 4.0 since October 4. No episode changed. v4.4, October 11, 2026: eight WordPress.com episodes added, newest first: “New Hampshire By The Numbers,” “New Hampshire Constitutional Battles,” “New Hampshire’s Uneven Public Services,” “New Hampshire Politics And History,” the broadband episode and the footage-checking episode, each titled for its article, and two episodes the tool made on October 5 whose scripts were revised and re-recorded on October 10, “New Hampshire Democracy And Records” and “Surveillance And Press Freedom.” Each is checked against its source articles, with a listener’s note, links to every article discussed and the transcript; the two revised episodes also carry a note on how they were made. v4.4.1, October 11, 2026: the article “Why New Hampshire Rents Outpace Wages” is linked again under “New Hampshire’s Uneven Public Services.” It had been left off in v4.4 because the article misstated a figure from New Hampshire Housing’s rent survey report; the article now carries a correction. The version line under the page title reads 4.4.1. No other episode changed. v4.4.2, October 13, 2026: under each episode, the list of articles discussed and the listener’s note now open and close like the transcript, so the page is shorter to scroll. Nothing in them changed. The note on how an episode was made, on the eight episodes scripted from the articles, now opens and closes the same way. Within the hour the script behind it was rewritten, because WordPress altered two of its characters on the way to the page and the lists and notes had kept showing open. The version line under the page title reads 4.4.2. v4.5, November 10, 2026: two episodes the WordPress.com tool made on October 11 added at the top, newest first: the state tax collections episode, titled for its article, and “New Hampshire Policy And Change.” Each is checked against its source articles, with a listener’s note, links to every article discussed and the transcript. The version line under the page title reads 4.5. No other episode changed. v4.6, November 11, 2026: five episodes the WordPress.com tool made on November 10 and 11 added at the top, newest first: “AI, Minds, And Public Records,” “Ghosts, UFOs, And Newsmaking,” “Ghosts And UFOs In New Hampshire,” “November 10 In History” and “Wealth, Work, And Morality.” Each is checked against its source articles, with a listener’s note, links to every article discussed and the transcript. The two ghost-and-UFO episodes draw on the same six articles; both are kept because the tool wrote two different scripts from them. The episodes’ source posts stay unpublished drafts; the page plays the audio files directly. The version line under the page title reads 4.6. No other episode changed. This page is never edited without a log entry.