Sunday, 22 November 2026
Trending
ExplainersHistory

November 21 in New Hampshire History: The Court Rules the Legislature Is Not a Public Employer Under the Bargaining Law

Photograph by Carol M. Highsmith. Library of Congress (LOC 2017884903).
Independent New Hampshire Journalism · Northfield, NH
This Day in New Hampshire History · November 21
November 21 in New Hampshire History: The Court Rules the Legislature Is Not a Public Employer Under the Bargaining Law

A 1996 ruling kept House staff outside the state’s public-employee bargaining law, the same court ruled Franklin and other towns could not tax a phone company’s poles and equipment as real estate, and Josiah Bartlett was born in Amesbury.

Listen to this article · 8 min

Audio edition (8:00): a synthetic voice reads the article. The images, fact check and sources are on this page.

In 1993 an employee of the New Hampshire House asked the state labor board to declare that he and his full-time co-workers were public employees under the state’s collective bargaining law. The answer came from the state Supreme Court on November 21, 1996, and it turned on what the word “state” means in a 1975 law. The same day brought a second ruling on what towns may tax, and the calendar also marks the birth of a signer of the Declaration of Independence, the birth of a Know-Nothing governor and the death of a Portsmouth doctor who sat in the U.S. Senate.

The court that read “state” to mean the executive branch

Related coverage: GSR’s Live Free and Pay Nothing? examines how much of New Hampshire’s tax load falls on property, context for the 1996 telephone-pole entry below.

The petition came in October 1993 from Robert Cushing, a House employee. He wanted the Public Employee Labor Relations Board to rule that permanent House staff were covered by RSA chapter 273-A, the Public Employee Labor Relations Act. The United Auto Workers intervened. In May 1994 a board majority sided with him, calling the House a political subdivision of the state and clearing its staff to organize.

The House Legislative Facilities Subcommittee and the Speaker’s chief of staff, Lee Marden, sought rehearing, and the Senate entered the case. On rehearing the board dropped the political-subdivision finding but reached the same result by another route: as one of three equal branches of government, the board said, the Legislature was the state, and therefore an employer under the act.

The Supreme Court reversed in an opinion by Chief Justice Brock. Asked whether the General Court is a public employer under the act, the court answered, “We hold that it is not.” The act, it said, gives the governor control of bargaining with state employees and leaves lawmakers an advisory role plus the power to approve or reject cost items. The court declined to assume the Legislature meant to hand the governor the job of negotiating with its own staff, and it read “state” in the act as the executive branch alone.

The court also pointed to RSA chapter 17-E, passed the same year as the bargaining act, which created subcommittees that approve pay for House and Senate employees. It called the two chapters separate systems for legislative and executive workers. It was not persuaded by the union’s reliance on failed proposed amendments recorded in the 1995 Senate Journal, and it did not reach the separation-of-powers question. All justices concurred. The citation is Appeal of House Legislative Facilities Subcommittee, 141 N.H. 443 (1996).

Front of the granite New Hampshire State House with a gold dome, columned portico and a bronze statue on a pedestal in the plaza.
The New Hampshire State House, Concord. Home of the General Court, whose staff were the subject of the 1996 ruling. Photograph by Carol M. Highsmith. Credit: Library of Congress, Carol M. Highsmith Archive; no known restrictions on publication.

Josiah Bartlett is born in Amesbury

Josiah Bartlett was born in Amesbury, Massachusetts, on November 21, 1729, the date given by the National Archives, the National Governors Association and the National Constitution Center. The date falls before the British colonies changed calendars in 1752, and none of those sources says which calendar it follows.

Bartlett studied medicine as a teenager and set up practice in Kingston before he turned 21, according to the Constitution Center. He won a seat in the provincial assembly in 1765 and went to the Second Continental Congress in 1775. By the Constitution Center’s account, New Hampshire was called first on the independence vote and Bartlett answered with the first aye. Both the Center and the governors association list him as the second signer of the Declaration, after John Hancock.

The governors association lists him on the state Supreme Court from 1782 to 1790 and as chief justice in 1789; the Constitution Center dates the chief-justice appointment to 1788. He led the state as its chief executive from 1790 to 1794. While he held the office, according to the governors association, constitutional amendments in 1792 renamed it from president to governor, and he served as the New Hampshire Medical Society’s first president. He died on May 19, 1795.

Ralph Metcalf, a Know-Nothing governor, is born in Charlestown

Ralph Metcalf was born in Charlestown on November 21, 1798, according to the National Governors Association. He graduated from Dartmouth in 1823 and practiced law. Starting in 1831 he served five years as New Hampshire’s secretary of state. Later he worked as a clerk under Treasury Secretary Woodbury from 1838 to 1840, kept Sullivan County’s probate records as register from 1845 to 1851, and chaired the 1850 committee assembling a compilation of state law.

Metcalf won the governorship in 1855 as the Know-Nothing nominee and was reelected in 1856, holding office from June 7, 1855, to June 4, 1857. During his tenure, the governors association says, stronger immigration laws were lobbied for and a liquor prohibition bill was approved. He died on August 26, 1858.

Clement Storer, Portsmouth doctor and senator, dies

Clement Storer died in Portsmouth on November 21, 1830, according to the U.S. House’s biographical record. Born in Kennebunk, Maine, in 1760, he trained in medicine in Portsmouth and in Europe and practiced in Portsmouth. He rose through the militia ranks to major general.

Storer served one term in the U.S. House beginning in 1807. He sat in the New Hampshire House from 1810 to 1812 and was its speaker for one year. After Jeremiah Mason resigned from the U.S. Senate, Storer was elected to finish the term and sat from June 27, 1817, until March 3, 1819. From 1818 to 1824 he was high sheriff of Rockingham County.

The same day, towns lose a fight to tax telephone poles

The court issued a second opinion that day on local taxation. New England Telephone had sought abatement from Franklin and 15 other municipalities of taxes they assessed on its poles, wires, underground conduits and central office switching equipment as real estate. Two other telephone companies brought a similar case against Hopkinton. The superior court ruled the equipment was personal property that the towns had no authority to tax.

In an opinion by Justice Horton, the Supreme Court affirmed. It found the equipment could be removed and moved elsewhere without impairing the use of the land or buildings, so it was not a fixture. It noted the pole-licensing statute allows removal on ten days’ notice. It distinguished earlier cases that let towns tax ski lifts, and it held that pole licenses on public ways are not easements. The court said it was not deciding whether the companies’ easements on private land could be taxed. The citation is New England Telephone & Telegraph Co. v. City of Franklin, 141 N.H. 449 (1996).

For GSR’s look at how much of the state’s tax load falls on property, see Live Free and Pay Nothing?

Your Turn

Tell us. Did you work for the House, the Senate or a town assessing office in the 1990s, or do you have family papers tied to Kingston, Charlestown or Portsmouth? Write to granitestatereport@gmail.com or call (603) 931-9264. We read everything and will ask before quoting anyone.

Fact check

#ClaimStatusSource
1Appeal of House Legislative Facilities Subcommittee, 141 N.H. 443, decided Nov. 21, 1996; Brock, C.J.; reversed; all concurredVERIFIEDCourtListener opinion record and text (date filed 1996-11-21)
2Oct. 1993 petition by House employee Robert Cushing under RSA 273-A:1, IX; UAW intervened; May 1994 PELRB majority found House a political subdivision and staff could organizeVERIFIEDOpinion text
3Rehearing sought by the subcommittee and Lee Marden; Senate intervened; PELRB revoked subdivision finding and ruled the Legislature is the state itself and a public employerVERIFIEDOpinion text
4Holding: General Court not a public employer; “state” means executive branch; governor controls bargaining; legislative role advisory plus cost-item approval; RSA 17-E separate scheme; UAW argument from failed proposed amendments (N.H.S. Jour. 844 (1995)) rejected; separation of powers not reachedVERIFIEDOpinion text
5Public Employee Labor Relations Act enacted 1975; RSA 17-E enacted the same yearVERIFIEDOpinion text (Laws 1975, 490:1; “Enacted the same year as the Act”)
6Josiah Bartlett born Amesbury, Mass., Nov. 21, 1729; physician; died May 19, 1795VERIFIEDNational Archives signers fact sheet; NGA; National Constitution Center
7Calendar: the 1729 date predates the 1752 change and the sources do not state which calendarATTRIBUTEDAbsence of a calendar statement in NARA, NGA and NCC pages opened
8Bartlett studied medicine as a teen, practiced in Kingston before 21; assembly 1765; Continental Congress 1775; first aye on independence roll call; second signerATTRIBUTEDNational Constitution Center biography (first-aye account is the Center’s); NGA for second signer
9Bartlett on state Supreme Court 1782–1790, chief justice 1789 (NCC says 1788); chief executive 1790–1794; 1792 amendments changed title from president to governor; first president of N.H. Medical SocietyVERIFIEDNational Governors Association; National Constitution Center for the 1788 date
10Ralph Metcalf born Charlestown Nov. 21, 1798; Dartmouth 1823; secretary of state from 1831 for five years; Woodbury clerk 1838–1840; register of probate 1845–1851; 1850 laws committee; Know-Nothing governor elected 1855, reelected 1856; term June 7, 1855–June 4, 1857; died Aug. 26, 1858VERIFIEDNational Governors Association, Gov. Ralph Metcalf
11During Metcalf’s tenure, stronger immigration laws were lobbied for and a liquor prohibition bill was approvedATTRIBUTEDNGA summary; not checked against session laws
12Clement Storer born Kennebunk 1760; physician in Portsmouth; major general of militia; U.S. House 1807–1809; N.H. House 1810–1812, speaker one year; U.S. Senate June 27, 1817–March 3, 1819 (Mason vacancy); high sheriff 1818–1824; died Portsmouth Nov. 21, 1830VERIFIEDU.S. House History, Art & Archives, STORER, Clement (Biographical Directory text)
13New England Tel. & Tel. Co. v. City of Franklin, 141 N.H. 449, decided Nov. 21, 1996; Horton, J.; affirmed; all concurred; Franklin and 15 other municipalities; Hopkinton case by MCT and CVT; equipment not fixtures; ten days’ notice; ski-lift cases distinguished; licenses not easements; private easements left openVERIFIEDCourtListener opinion record and text (date filed 1996-11-21)
14Images: LOC 2017884898 and 2017884903, Carol M. Highsmith, rights “No known restrictions on publication”VERIFIEDLibrary of Congress item records (JSON API, loc.gov/item/<id>/?fo=json); item pages block automated browsers
Have a document, a tip, or a correction?
Write to the editor. Confidentiality is respected where possible.
granitestatereport@gmail.com
Sources.

Primary and official: Appeal of House Legislative Facilities Subcommittee, 141 N.H. 443, 685 A.2d 910 (1996), and New England Telephone & Telegraph Co. v. City of Franklin, 141 N.H. 449, 685 A.2d 913 (1996), opinion texts via CourtListener (courtlistener.com). National Archives, Signers of the Declaration of Independence fact sheet. National Governors Association, Gov. Josiah Bartlett and Gov. Ralph Metcalf. U.S. House of Representatives, History, Art & Archives, STORER, Clement. Library of Congress, Carol M. Highsmith Archive, item 2017884898 and item 2017884903 (featured image).

Secondary: National Constitution Center, Josiah Bartlett.

Related GSR coverage: Live Free and Pay Nothing?.

Editor’s note. This edition draws on two New Hampshire Supreme Court opinions issued November 21, 1996, the National Archives, the National Governors Association, the U.S. House Office of the Historian and Clerk’s Biographical Directory record, the National Constitution Center, and the Library of Congress.

Corrections: Granite State Report corrects verified errors promptly and appends a dated note identifying what changed and when. The corrections policy and the corrections register are public, and correction notes are never removed.

Granite State Report · Northfield, New Hampshire · granitestatereport.com
Board