Independent New Hampshire Journalism · Northfield, NHA New Hampshire court can jail a person, or put a curfew and a monitor on one, on the same level of proof it takes to make an arrest. The state does not count how often it happens.
The hearing that decides whether a person arrested in New Hampshire goes home can be held without a single witness. Under RSA 597:2, when the state asks a court to hold someone, the evidence at the first appearance comes in by offer of proof. That means a prosecutor tells the judge what the evidence would show. The statute presumes the alleged victim will not have to testify. A defendant who wants live testimony has to ask for a later hearing.
On that record a judge picks one of four outcomes the statute lists: release on a promise to appear, release with conditions, detention, or a temporary hold. Nobody has been found guilty of anything. The person standing there may have been in a cell for up to 36 hours already, not counting weekends and holidays.
My argument in this part is narrow. What a court orders at that first hearing restrains a person’s liberty as surely as a sentence does, it rests on the lowest standard of proof the law has, and New Hampshire keeps no public count of any of it.
Disclosure: The editor of Granite State Report has been named in New Hampshire police records and has requested those records under RSA 91-A. Those matters are not part of this series.
Related coverage: This is Part 4 of Punished First. Part 1, The Accusation Is the Sentence, makes the series argument. Part 2, The Report, covers the public arrest record. Part 3, The Booking, covers fingerprints and photographs. Earlier GSR pieces cover the people and the politics of bail: The Bail Commissioner’s Job and HB 592, Bail and Magistrates Overhaul. This piece is about what the hearing does to the accused, and does not repeat them.
The standard is probable cause
Probable cause is what an officer needs to make an arrest. It is now also what a New Hampshire judge needs to keep the arrested person locked up until trial.
It was not always that low. The 2023 version of the same section let a court order preventive detention only on clear and convincing evidence of danger. House Bill 592, signed on March 25, 2025, replaced that with probable cause. The statute’s source note lists it as Chapter 3 of the 2025 laws, effective Sept. 21, 2025. New Hampshire Public Radio reported that the bill also stretched the window for a first bail hearing from 24 hours to 36.
The section does more than lower the bar. It stacks presumptions on top of it. If there is probable cause that a person on release missed a court date, broke a bail condition, or committed a felony, a class A misdemeanor or an impaired-driving offense, the law presumes the person will not follow conditions and says the person shall be detained, unless the defendant rebuts the presumption. For 14 categories of charge, from homicide to any felony with force as an element, a bail commissioner may not hear the case at all, and the person waits in custody for a judge.
One protection survives. A court may not set a cash amount that jails someone only because the person cannot pay it. Even that has an exception, and the exception runs on probable cause too.
Release is a list of orders
Most people who go through this hearing walk out. They do not walk out free. Release comes on the condition that the person commit no crime, plus whatever further conditions the court adds, and the statute’s list ends with a catch-all: any other condition reasonably necessary to assure appearance and safety.
What that looks like on paper is a form with boxes. A 2019 Superior Court bail order described in a filing at the state Supreme Court shows the menu. The boxes checked in that case barred travel outside New Hampshire, barred possession of firearms and ammunition, barred excessive alcohol and any controlled drugs, and required a signed waiver of extradition. The judge wrote in two more: surrender the passport and do not drive. The form also carried a no-contact provision.
In domestic violence cases the statute names electronic monitoring and supervision as conditions a court may order. A separate paragraph lets a county bill a person who is not indigent for the cost of the monitor, with repayment allowed to run up to a year after the case closes. The section I read has no line that returns the money to a person who is later acquitted.

Break a condition and it is a new crime
The conditions have teeth of their own. Under RSA 597:7-a, a released person who knowingly breaks one can have release revoked, can be ordered detained, and can be prosecuted for contempt or charged with breach of bail, a class A misdemeanor. An officer who sees a breach can take the person into custody without a warrant.
Follow that through. A person is accused of one offense. A court, on probable cause, orders that person to be home by a set hour, or to stay out of a town, or to stay away from a drink. The person breaks the order. Now there is a second charge, and it stands even if the first one is dismissed. Missing curfew is legal for everyone in the state except the people a court has not yet found guilty of anything.
If the state moves to revoke release because of a new arrest, the judge has to order detention on probable cause that the person committed a crime while out, once the court also finds that no conditions will work or that the person will not follow them. For a felony, the law presumes no conditions will.
The Supreme Court says none of this is punishment
Lawyers will object to the word I am using, and the law is on their side. In United States v. Salerno, decided May 26, 1987, the U.S. Supreme Court upheld pretrial detention under the federal Bail Reform Act by a vote of 6 to 3. Chief Justice William Rehnquist, who also wrote the opinion in the case that opened this series, held that such detention is regulation and not punishment, because Congress meant to protect the community and the restraint was not excessive for that purpose.
The same opinion contains a sentence defense lawyers have quoted ever since: in this country “liberty is the norm,” and detention before trial is the carefully limited exception. Justice Thurgood Marshall dissented, joined by Justice William Brennan. Justice John Paul Stevens dissented separately.
So the legal answer is settled. A curfew, a monitor, a travel ban and a jail cell are all regulatory when they come before the verdict. I am not arguing the Court got the doctrine wrong. I am arguing that the label does not change what it is like to live under the order. A person fired for missing work during a 36-hour hold was not regulated out of a job.
The other side, stated fairly
The people who wrote the 2025 law had reasons. Courts do release people who go on to hurt someone. A no-contact order is often the only thing standing between an alleged victim and the person she reported. Judges need authority to hold a dangerous defendant, and conditions are how a judge lets most people go home when the alternative is a cell. A system with no conditions would be a system with more detention.
I accept all of that. It is an argument for conditions that fit the risk and for a real hearing. It is no argument for flying blind.
What New Hampshire does not count
I looked for Judicial Branch data on bail and located none. The branch’s Data and Reports page lists annual case filings for the Circuit, Superior and Supreme courts and a link to national court statistics. I found nothing on it about bail, pretrial detention, conditions of release or failures to appear.
That gap is old. In 2019 the state hired the Pretrial Justice Institute, with $45,000 in federal grant money, to measure the effects of the 2018 bail law. The institute withdrew in March 2020 because the jails and courts could not supply the data, according to reporting by the Granite State News Collaborative published by New Hampshire Public Radio on April 6, 2022. A court spokesperson told the Collaborative the branch’s case-management system had limited data-gathering capabilities.
The 2025 law was passed and is now defended the same way. On April 7, 2026, the governor’s office marked the law’s first anniversary with a press release. It gave one number: pretrial detentions in Coös County up about 50 percent. The release named no baseline period, gave no statewide count and cited no court data.
So here is what I cannot tell you, because I have found no public record of it: how many people New Hampshire courts held before trial last year, how many were released under a curfew, a monitor or a travel ban, how many were charged with breach of bail, and how many of all those people were never convicted.
What the Legislature can do
- Order the count. Require the Judicial Branch to publish, by court and by year, detentions, conditions imposed, revocations, breach-of-bail charges and how each underlying case ended.
- Tie conditions to findings. Require a judge to write down which risk each condition answers. The statute already requires the order to list the conditions; it does not require a reason for each one.
- Refund the monitor. If a county bills a person for electronic monitoring and the case ends without a conviction, send the money back.
- End the orphan charge. Let a breach-of-bail charge fall when the case that produced the condition is dismissed or ends in acquittal, unless the breach was itself a crime.
Part 5 follows the paper: the court file with a person’s name on the caption, and who can read it.
— Dexter Dow, Granite State Report
Your Turn
Poll: What should a New Hampshire court need before it jails a person who has not been tried?
A) Probable cause, as now · B) Clear and convincing evidence · C) Proof at a hearing with live witnesses
Survey, six questions: 1) What town were you in? 2) Which court held the hearing, and in what year? 3) Were you held, released on conditions, or released on your own promise? 4) What conditions were set: curfew, no contact, travel limit, monitor, no alcohol, other? 5) Were you charged with breaking a condition? 6) How did the original case end: conviction, dismissal, not guilty, or never prosecuted?
Consent: GSR may contact me about my answers. Nothing I submit is published with my name without my written permission. Responses are kept for 24 months, then deleted or stripped of identifying details.
Petition: Count it. GSR asks the General Court to require the Judicial Branch to publish yearly numbers on pretrial detention, conditions of release, breach-of-bail charges and case outcomes. To add your name, email the address below with the subject line Count It, your name and your New Hampshire town.
Discuss: Is a curfew or a monitor before trial a punishment, whatever the courts call it? Should a breach-of-bail charge survive when the original case is dismissed?
You tell me: If you lived under bail conditions in a case that ended without a conviction, send the survey answers to granitestatereport@gmail.com
Fact check
| # | Claim | Status | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Evidence for preventive detention at the initial appearance comes by offer of proof; a later hearing with live testimony is on the defendant’s request; a rebuttable presumption that the alleged victim will not be required to testify | VERIFIED | RSA 597:2, VI, gc.nh.gov |
| 2 | Four outcomes at initial appearance: personal recognizance or unsecured bond, release with conditions, detention, temporary detention | VERIFIED | RSA 597:2, I |
| 3 | A person may be held up to 36 hours after arrest, excluding weekends and holidays; detention on probable cause that release will not assure appearance or will endanger the person or others | VERIFIED | RSA 597:2, III(a) |
| 4 | The 2023 text allowed preventive detention only on clear and convincing evidence | VERIFIED | RSA 597:2 (2023 edition), Justia |
| 5 | HB 592 signed March 25, 2025; 2025 Chapter 3, effective Sept. 21, 2025; hearing window went from 24 to 36 hours | ATTRIBUTED | RSA 597:2 source note for the chapter and date; New Hampshire Public Radio, March 25, 2025, for the signing date and the 24-hour figure |
| 6 | Rebuttable presumption and mandatory detention on probable cause of a failure to appear, a bail violation, or a felony, class A misdemeanor or impaired-driving offense while on release | VERIFIED | RSA 597:2, III(b) |
| 7 | Fourteen categories of qualifying offense may not go before a bail commissioner; the person is held for arraignment | VERIFIED | RSA 597:2, III(c) |
| 8 | No financial condition that detains a person solely for inability to pay, with an exception on probable cause after a hearing | VERIFIED | RSA 597:2, IV |
| 9 | Release is conditioned on committing no crime plus further conditions, including any other condition reasonably necessary | VERIFIED | RSA 597:2, III(a) and VII(a) |
| 10 | A 2019 Superior Court bail order checked boxes on travel, firearms, alcohol and drugs, and extradition, with a passport and driving condition written in; the form includes a no-contact provision | ATTRIBUTED | Defendant’s Memorandum on Bail, State v. Zhukovskyy, N.H. Supreme Court No. 2021-0168, filed May 24, 2021. One order in one case, as described by defense counsel |
| 11 | Electronic monitoring and supervision named as conditions in domestic violence cases; a county may order a non-indigent person to repay monitoring costs, up to one year after the case closes | VERIFIED | RSA 597:2, IX and XV |
| 12 | RSA 597:2, XV has no refund provision on acquittal | ATTRIBUTED | GSR reading of the paragraph. An absence in the text, not a ruling |
| 13 | A knowing breach of a release condition can bring revocation, detention, contempt or a class A misdemeanor charge of breach of bail; an officer who witnesses a breach may detain | VERIFIED | RSA 597:7-a, I and II |
| 14 | On a revocation motion the court must order detention on probable cause of a new crime plus a finding that no conditions will work or will be followed; a felony raises a presumption | VERIFIED | RSA 597:7-a, III |
| 15 | United States v. Salerno, May 26, 1987, 6 to 3, Rehnquist for the Court; pretrial detention under the Bail Reform Act is regulatory; Marshall dissenting with Brennan, Stevens dissenting separately | VERIFIED | United States v. Salerno, 481 U.S. 739 (1987), Cornell Legal Information Institute |
| 16 | The Judicial Branch Data and Reports page lists annual filings and national court data and nothing on bail | ATTRIBUTED | N.H. Judicial Branch, Data and Reports page, courts.nh.gov. An absence of located data, not proof none exists |
| 17 | A 2019 state-funded bail study ($45,000) ended in March 2020 for lack of data; a court spokesperson cited limited data-gathering capabilities | ATTRIBUTED | Paul Cuno-Booth, Granite State News Collaborative, published by New Hampshire Public Radio, April 6, 2022 |
| 18 | The governor’s April 7, 2026 release cited a roughly 50 percent rise in Coös County pretrial detentions, with no baseline, statewide count or court data | VERIFIED | Office of the Governor, press release, April 7, 2026 |
Reach the editor directly. Confidentiality respected where possible.
granitestatereport@gmail.com · 603-931-9264
Editor’s note. Sources for this piece are the New Hampshire bail statutes, the U.S. Supreme Court’s opinion in Salerno, a defense filing at the New Hampshire Supreme Court, the Judicial Branch’s data page, the governor’s press release, and reporting by the Granite State News Collaborative and New Hampshire Public Radio; see the fact-check table. The bail-order form is described from one 2019 order. Statements that no data or no provision was found are the author’s reading of the pages and texts cited. No on-the-record interview was conducted for this part. Corrections: Granite State Report corrects verified errors promptly and appends a note identifying what changed and when.

