Independent New Hampshire Journalism · Northfield, NHNew Hampshire already passed the law that says a dismissed case shall be erased. It never said who does the erasing. Five fixes for the Legislature, and one petition.
Seven parts of this series described what happens to a person in New Hampshire between an arrest and a verdict, and after a verdict that never comes. An officer’s account becomes a public record. A photo and ten fingerprints go into files. A judge sets conditions on probable cause. A docket goes up with a name on the caption. And when the case is dropped, most of that stays where it was.
I am not arguing that any of those steps is illegal. The U.S. Supreme Court has held that pretrial detention is regulation, not punishment, and that damage to a reputation alone is not a loss the Constitution protects. I am arguing that the state built every one of them to start by itself and built almost nothing to stop them when the charge fails.
The fix is not a new philosophy. It is five changes to statutes the Legislature has already written, and the first one is a single sentence it left unfinished in 2019.
Disclosure: The editor of Granite State Report has been named in New Hampshire police records and has requested those records under RSA 91-A. Those matters are not part of this series.
Related coverage: This is the last part of Punished First. Part 1, The Accusation Is the Sentence, makes the series argument. Part 2, The Report, covers the arrest record. Part 3, The Booking, covers fingerprints and photographs. Part 4, The Hearing, covers bail conditions. Part 5, The Court File, covers who can read the case. Part 6, The Eraser That Does Not Erase, covers annulment. Part 7, The Afterlife, covers background checks, employers and landlords. Each fix below rests on the reporting in the part named beside it.
One: finish the sentence
RSA 651:5, II-a says a person whose case ended without a conviction on or after Jan. 1, 2019, shall have the arrest record and court record annulled, 30 days after the case ends if nobody appeals. It names no clerk, no deadline for the court and no notice to the person. Part 6 found what filled that silence: a Judicial Branch petition form, a State Police page that says the process begins with a petition, and a 2026 law, Senate Bill 512, that waives the filing fee for “any petition to annul” under that paragraph starting Jan. 1, 2027.
So the state reads its own shall as may ask. The national scorekeepers have not caught up. The Collateral Consequences Resource Center’s 50-state chart lists New Hampshire among the states with automatic relief for non-conviction records. Its New Hampshire profile says the annulment happens on the filing of a petition. Both pages describe the same paragraph.
The repair is to say who acts. Pennsylvania did. Under its 2018 Clean Slate law, as that center describes it, the court administrator sends eligible cases to the State Police every month, the State Police check the list, and each county court issues its sealing orders from what comes back. A non-conviction is eligible at once, and the order is due within 30 days after the disposition and payment of any restitution. Nobody files anything.
New Hampshire’s paragraph already has the 30 days. It needs three more clauses: the clerk of the court that closed the case enters the annulment without a petition; the clerk sends notice to the State Police and to the person at the last known address; and the Judicial Branch publishes, every year, how many it entered. That last clause matters because of what the Branch told the Legislature’s budget office about SB 512. It said annulled case information is expunged from its system and “cannot be reliably tracked.” A count taken at the moment of entry does not need the erased file.
Two: count it
The state cannot say how many of its arrests end without a conviction. I located no published count. It cannot say how many people are held before trial or released on conditions; Part 4 found a state-funded bail study that ended in 2020 for lack of data. It cannot say how many annulments it has granted.
A system that jails, monitors and publishes on probable cause should be able to report how often probable cause turned out to be all there was. The Legislature should require the Judicial Branch to publish, yearly and by court, the number of criminal cases closed by conviction, dismissal, acquittal and non-prosecution, the number of people detained or released on conditions before trial, and the number of annulments entered. Part 4 asked readers to back that request. It stands.
Three: give the booking photo a rule
Part 3 found that an unproven arrest is confidential inside the State Police criminal records file, and that the booking photo taken the same day has no rule on release. A 2026 bill to write one, House Bill 1302, died after a 7 to 6 committee vote against it.
Vermont shows what an ending looks like. Its statute requires police, the state records center and jails to destroy an accused person’s fingerprints and photographs when no charge is filed, when the charge is dismissed, or when the person is acquitted. New Hampshire should adopt the same rule for non-conviction cases and should bar the release of a booking photo before conviction unless the person is a fugitive or police state a specific public safety reason in writing.
Four: make the log tell the ending
I do not want arrest records closed. A state where police can take someone into custody without the public knowing is worse than anything this series described, and RSA 594:14-a, the law that makes adult arrest records public, is one this outlet uses. Part 2 said so.
The problem with the arrest log is that it is a story with no last page. Nothing in the statute requires an update when the charge is dropped. The fix is small: an agency that posts arrest logs online must print on each one that an arrest is not a conviction, and must take a name down from its own website when the case is annulled. That reaches only the government’s own pages. It is still more than the law asks now.
Five: take the dead charge out of the hiring file and the rental file
Part 7 found that the federal guidance on arrests that never became convictions was withdrawn or rescinded in 2025 and 2026, that New Hampshire repealed its only law on the criminal-record question in hiring, and that the state’s anti-discrimination law does not name an arrest record in the paragraphs that govern a hiring or rental decision.
The Legislature should add one protected basis to RSA 354-A:7 and to RSA 354-A:10, I through VI: an arrest or charge that did not result in a conviction. It should keep the existing exemption for inquiries that state or federal law requires, so that a school or a police department can still run the checks it must. And it should raise the salary line in the state’s own background check statute, RSA 359-B:5, which stops applying at a salary of $20,000.

The other side, stated fairly
There are honest objections. Employers who hire for work with children or money want to know about an arrest even when it was dropped, and a dismissal is not a finding of innocence. Victims sometimes see a case collapse for reasons that have nothing to do with what happened. Reporters, including this one, rely on open police and court records to check what the government does with its power to arrest.
None of the five closes a record while a case is open. None hides a conviction. The first restates what the Legislature already ordered in 2019. The fifth keeps every check a statute requires. And the evidence from states that automated this is that it works better than asking people to petition. A study led by Colleen Chien of the University of California, Berkeley, summarized by the Clean Slate Initiative, which paid for it, found that about 98 percent of non-conviction records that should have been sealed did not show up on commercial background checks. The same summary says fewer than 1 in 10 eligible people get a record sealed where they have to file for it.
That study carries a warning too. In Pennsylvania and Nebraska, up to a third of records that looked eligible had not been sealed yet. Its lead author’s conclusion, as the summary quotes it: “passing the law is just the first step.” New Hampshire is seven years into proving that.
What I have not done is put a price on any of this. The only number I have is from the SB 512 fiscal note: the courts collected $221,425 in annulment filing fees in 2024 and expected to lose between $10,000 and $100,000 a year by waiving the fee for non-conviction petitions. What it would cost clerks to enter annulments without a petition, the Branch has not said and I have not asked.
The petition
Five fixes, one ask. The rest can wait for a session. This one is a paragraph the Legislature already voted for.
Finish the Sentence. We, residents of New Hampshire, ask the General Court to amend RSA 651:5, II-a so that it does what it says. When a criminal case ends in an acquittal, a dismissal or a decision not to prosecute, the clerk of the court shall enter the annulment on the 30-day schedule the paragraph already sets, with no petition and no fee; shall notify the State Police and the person; and the Judicial Branch shall publish each year the number of annulments entered under the paragraph.
To sign, email granitestatereport@gmail.com with the subject line Finish the Sentence, your name and your New Hampshire town.
A person the state could not convict should not have to hire the state to say so. The Legislature wrote that in 2019. It should finish the sentence.
— Dexter Dow, Granite State Report
Your Turn
Poll: Which of the five fixes should the Legislature take up first?
A) Annul without a petition · B) Count the outcomes · C) A booking photo rule · D) Hiring and housing protection
Petition: Finish the Sentence. Email the address below with that subject line, your name and your New Hampshire town.
Survey, five questions: 1) What town do you live in? 2) Have you, or has someone in your household, had a New Hampshire criminal case end without a conviction? 3) In what year? 4) Was the record annulled, and did it take a petition? 5) Would you speak with your state representative or senator about this if GSR sent you the bill number when one is filed?
Consent: GSR may contact me about my answers. Nothing I submit is published with my name without my written permission. Responses and petition names are kept for 24 months, then deleted or stripped of identifying details.
Discuss: Should a dismissed case be erased without the person asking? Which of the five fixes would you drop, and why?
You tell me: If you are a legislator, a clerk or a prosecutor and think one of these is wrong or unworkable, write to granitestatereport@gmail.com
Fact check
| # | Claim | Status | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | The U.S. Supreme Court held that reputational harm alone is not a deprivation of liberty or property (1976) and that pretrial detention is regulatory, not punishment (1987) | VERIFIED | Paul v. Davis; United States v. Salerno (see Parts 1 and 4) |
| 2 | RSA 651:5, II-a: shall have the arrest record and court record annulled, 30 days after the finding absent an appeal; names no actor, court deadline or notice | VERIFIED | RSA 651:5, II-a, gc.nh.gov. The absences are GSR’s reading of the text (see Part 6) |
| 3 | The Judicial Branch lists a petition form for non-conviction annulments; the State Police say the process begins with a petition; SB 512 (2026), Chapter 105, bars a filing fee for “any petition to annul” under II-a(a), effective Jan. 1, 2027 | VERIFIED | N.H. Judicial Branch annulment forms page; N.H. State Police annulments page; SB 512-FN final version (see Part 6) |
| 4 | The 50-state chart lists New Hampshire among states with automatic relief for non-conviction records; the New Hampshire profile describes annulment on the filing of a petition | ATTRIBUTED | Collateral Consequences Resource Center, 50-State Comparison and New Hampshire profile (updated April 13, 2026) |
| 5 | Pennsylvania: non-convictions immediately eligible; order within 30 days of disposition; court administrator transmits monthly to State Police, which validate; county courts issue monthly orders; in effect June 28, 2019 | ATTRIBUTED | Collateral Consequences Resource Center, Pennsylvania profile (updated June 27, 2026), describing 18 Pa.C.S. § 9122.2. GSR has not read the statute. The profile notes the 30 days also runs from payment of any restitution |
| 6 | The Judicial Branch said annulled case information is expunged from its case management system and “cannot be reliably tracked”; $221,425 in annulment fees in 2024; estimated loss of $10,000 to $100,000 a year | VERIFIED | SB 512-FN fiscal note (see Part 6) |
| 7 | No published statewide count of arrests ending without conviction, or of annulments, was located | ATTRIBUTED | GSR search for Parts 1 and 6. An absence of located evidence, not proof none exists |
| 8 | A state-funded bail study ended in March 2020 for lack of data | ATTRIBUTED | See Part 4 |
| 9 | Non-conviction information is confidential in the State Police file; no statute governs booking photo release; HB 1302 (2026) received a 7 to 6 Inexpedient to Legislate committee report and did not become law | VERIFIED | RSA 106-B:14 and the State Police repository rules; HB 1302 docket (see Part 3). The no-statute finding is an absence of located evidence |
| 10 | Vermont requires destruction of fingerprints and photographs when no charge is filed, on dismissal, or on acquittal | VERIFIED | 20 V.S.A. § 2061 (see Part 3) |
| 11 | RSA 594:14-a makes adult arrest records governmental records; nothing in it requires an update with the outcome | VERIFIED | RSA 594:14-a, gc.nh.gov (see Part 2). The absence is GSR’s reading |
| 12 | Federal guidance withdrawn or rescinded in 2025 and 2026; RSA 275-H repealed July 1, 2025; RSA 354-A:7 and 354-A:10, I through VI do not name arrest records; RSA 359-B:5 exempts jobs at a $20,000 salary | VERIFIED | See Part 7 and its fact-check table |
| 13 | About 98 percent of non-conviction records that should have been sealed did not appear on commercial background checks; in Pennsylvania and Nebraska up to a third of apparently eligible records were not yet sealed; fewer than 1 in 10 eligible people seal records by petition; the quoted conclusion | ATTRIBUTED | Clean Slate Initiative, Oct. 9, 2025, summarizing a North Carolina Law Review study led by Colleen Chien that the Initiative funded. GSR has not read the study |
| 14 | “Seven years into proving that” | VERIFIED | GSR arithmetic: 2026 minus 2019 |
Reach the editor directly. Confidentiality respected where possible.
granitestatereport@gmail.com · 603-931-9264
Editor’s note. This is opinion. Sources are the statutes and records cited in Parts 1 through 7, the Collateral Consequences Resource Center’s state profiles and 50-state comparison, and the Clean Slate Initiative’s summary of a study it funded; see the fact-check table. The proposals are the author’s. None has been costed, and no legislator has been asked to sponsor one. No on-the-record interview was conducted for this part. Corrections: Granite State Report corrects verified errors promptly and appends a note identifying what changed and when.

