Monday, 16 November 2026
Trending
Law & CourtsThe 48 Laws of Power

Play on People’s Need to Believe: Clean for Gene, the Pitchfork Brigade and the Limits of a New Hampshire Crusade

Tamworth Congregational Church. Photo: Carol M. Highsmith, Library of Congress.
Independent New Hampshire Journalism · Northfield, NH
The Power Playbook · Part Twenty-Seven of Forty-Eight
Play on People’s Need to Believe: Clean for Gene, the Pitchfork Brigade and the Limits of a New Hampshire Crusade

Robert Greene’s twenty-seventh law says people need something to believe in, and a leader who supplies it gains a devoted following. New Hampshire’s primary has hosted that kind of crusade from both parties. Belief carried each one through the state, and no further.

Listen to this article  ·  12 min
Narration read by a synthetic voice from the title, byline, summary and text of this article. Granite State Report.

In the winter of 1968, on a street in Concord, a college student shaved his chin in public. A slogan explained why: “Get Clean for Gene.” Time magazine reported the scene that March, along with another. A bearded canvasser, turned away at a door, borrowed a razor and shaved while he kept making the case for Sen. Eugene McCarthy. The volunteers slept on floors and lived on doughnuts, coffee and peanut butter, a former staffer later recalled to APM Reports.

Twenty-eight years later, on a Sunday in February 1996, more than a thousand people packed a Nashua rally for Patrick J. Buchanan and chanted “Go Pat Go,” The Harvard Crimson reported. Buchanan gave the campaign its image, in words NPR later replayed: “All the peasants are coming with pitchforks.”

Robert Greene’s twenty-seventh law says that people have a deep need to believe in something, and that a leader who gives them a cause, a ritual and an enemy can turn that need into a devoted following. New Hampshire’s primary is where that kind of following tends to form first, and the record holds one test from each party. McCarthy in 1968 and Buchanan in 1996 each built a movement whose members gave far more than a vote. Neither movement was a cult. Both used the tools Greene describes, and both show the law’s limit: belief can carry a candidate through New Hampshire, then it meets the rest of the country.

The stage

The New Hampshire primary lets almost anyone in. A candidate files a one-page declaration with the secretary of state in November and pays a fee. A candidate who cannot afford the fee can qualify by petition instead. There is no party screening and no polling threshold. That low door matters for this law. A movement does not need the blessing of a party to show up, and a cause can find its believers in small rooms, town by town, before anyone in Washington takes it seriously.

RSA 655:47 and 655:48, Presidential Primary Ballot. A candidate’s name is printed on the ballot “upon the filing of declarations of candidacy with the secretary of state,” filed between the first Monday and the third Friday in November unless the secretary sets another period. The fee under RSA 655:48 is $1,000. A candidate who proves indigence may instead file 10 primary petitions from each county, signed by registered voters of the party. Both sections trace to a 1979 act. Read RSA 655:47 → · Read RSA 655:48 →

Greene’s law describes how a following is built. Offer a cause larger than the leader. Give followers something to do and something to give up. Name an opponent. Let them feel they are part of history. The two campaigns below did each of those things in New Hampshire, a generation apart and from opposite ends of the political map.

The crusade of 1968

McCarthy, a Minnesota senator, challenged a sitting president of his own party over the Vietnam War, which he called an “immoral war.” His New Hampshire campaign began with $400 in the bank, APM Reports found. What it had instead was people. Hundreds of high school and college students came into the state to knock on doors. Their youth organizer, Sam Brown, was 24 and had left Harvard Divinity School to do the job, MPR News reported. Stars lent the cause their glow. Paul Newman campaigned in Nashua, and Tony Randall and Rod Serling recorded radio ads, according to APM Reports.

The campaign asked them to change how they looked. Volunteers with long hair or beards were urged to cut and shave so they would not put off New Hampshire’s generally conservative voters. Time reported the rules that came with the work. Boys slept in a gymnasium and girls in supporters’ homes, and the volunteers mostly stayed away from beer, in keeping with McCarthy’s austere image. The magazine headlined its report “Crusade of the Ballot Children.” One volunteer, Ann Hart, then 20, gave the movement’s creed in a sentence: “We wouldn’t do this cruddy work for anybody but Gene McCarthy.”

That is the structure Greene describes: a cause, a discipline, a sacrifice and an enemy. The leader stayed at a distance. McCarthy often seemed not to want the job very badly. In a television interview APM Reports preserved, he said he was probably the candidate “who least would like the presidency.” His followers wanted it for him. Before the vote they set their own bar. “Over 40%, we go on to Wisconsin,” one volunteer told Time. Belief had a number attached to it, and the number became the measure of a miracle.

President Lyndon B. Johnson did not file in New Hampshire. His name was not printed on the ballot and had to be written in, NPR’s Ron Elving recounted. Democratic regulars mounted what Encyclopaedia Britannica calls “a desperate write-in campaign.” On March 12, 1968, Johnson won about 49 percent to McCarthy’s 42, by the count APM Reports gives. Britannica puts Johnson at 48. Either way, a challenger who started with $400 and an army of shaved students had held a sitting president under 50 percent.

Bar chart titled A president held under 50 percent: the 1968 New Hampshire Democratic primary. Lyndon B. Johnson, write-in, about 49 percent; Eugene McCarthy about 42 percent. A note says Johnson's name was not on the printed ballot, and that within days Robert F. Kennedy entered the race and on March 31 Johnson announced he would not seek reelection.
A president held under 50 percent. The 1968 Democratic primary in New Hampshire, March 12. Johnson’s name had to be written in.Chart: Granite State Report. Sources: APM Reports, Campaign ’68; Encyclopaedia Britannica (Johnson at 48 percent); NPR, 2018.

“The young people have brought the country back into the system,” McCarthy said that night, NPR reported. The movement did not stop at the state line. Time reported that a cadre of about 300 New Hampshire veterans moved on to Wisconsin to organize up to 25,000 volunteers from four neighboring states. Robert F. Kennedy entered the race days after the primary. On March 31, Johnson announced he would not seek reelection.

The pitchfork brigade of 1996

Buchanan came at his party from the other side. He ran against free trade, the North American Free Trade Agreement and what he cast as a Republican establishment that had forgotten working people. At the Nashua rally he called for “fair trade, not free trade,” the Crimson reported, and blamed the trade deficit for unemployment in New Hampshire. A Manchester man in the crowd put the grievance in his own words: “Everything I buy is made in India or Mexico, and it all falls apart.”

The rally had the call and response of a revival. The crowd chanted his name. When Buchanan spoke about abortion, members of the audience answered “Amen,” the Crimson reported. His imagery was martial and rural. In a 2012 look back at the campaign, NPR aired another of his calls to supporters: “Mount up everybody and ride to the sound of the gun.” The enemy had a name too: the establishment, which he said was “coming for us.”

On Feb. 20, 1996, Buchanan won New Hampshire. Dartmouth College’s primary history gives the shares as 27.25 percent for Buchanan, 26.22 for Sen. Bob Dole and 22.59 for former Tennessee Gov. Lamar Alexander, an upset. The student newspaper The Dartmouth, with 98 percent of precincts counted, put the margin at 55,997 votes to 53,623. Sixty percent of voters told exit pollsters they had settled on a choice in the final week. About one in four named the economy and jobs as the issue that mattered most.

Bar chart titled The pitchfork win: the 1996 New Hampshire Republican primary. Pat Buchanan 27.25 percent; Bob Dole 26.22 percent; Lamar Alexander 22.59 percent; Steve Forbes 12.22 percent.
The pitchfork win. The 1996 Republican primary in New Hampshire, Feb. 20. About 2,400 votes separated first and second.Chart: Granite State Report. Sources: Dartmouth College, “1996: Presidential Primaries at Dartmouth College”; The Dartmouth, Feb. 21, 1996.

At his victory party in a Manchester banquet hall, Buchanan called the win “a victory for a brand new, bold conservatism,” the Crimson reported. “We have made history again tonight,” he said, according to The Dartmouth. He promised his followers a role, not just a policy: they would go to Washington as “the lobbyists for the people who don’t have lobbyists,” the Crimson reported.

The loyalty ran deep and far. An 85-year-old supporter from Andover, Mass., told the Crimson, “Pat is honest and very loyal.” The Christian Science Monitor found a South Carolina clothing manufacturer who planned to volunteer for Buchanan in two Southern states. Buchanan called his platform a “conservatism of the heart.”

Then the rest of the party answered. The establishment coalesced around Dole, Dartmouth’s history records. Buchanan beat Dole again in Missouri on March 9, which the same history lists as Dole’s last loss. Dole took the nomination. Looking back, Buchanan described the reaction in Washington: senators, he said, had only one objective, “to stop Pat Buchanan.”

Nineteen seconds. Two crusades, one from each party, and the GSR Power Index through twenty-seven laws.Video: Granite State Report. No audio.

What the two crusades share

Set side by side, the two campaigns run on the same parts. Each offered a cause bigger than the candidate: ending a war, saving the jobs and sovereignty of working people. Each gave its followers rituals. In 1968 they were a haircut, a gymnasium floor and a dry campaign. In 1996 they were the chant and the shouted “Amen.” Each asked for sacrifice, in floors slept on, classes skipped and days spent on doorsteps. Each named an opponent, the war-making administration or the establishment. And each leader told his followers what their work meant. The young people, McCarthy said, had brought the country back into the system. Buchanan told his that they had made history.

Both also found the same wall. Belief travels well in New Hampshire because the state is small enough for volunteers to reach every door and voters decide late. It travels less well across a continent of primaries and caucuses, where organizations and money count for more than devotion. McCarthy did not win the nomination. Neither did Buchanan. What each did was change the race. Nineteen days after McCarthy’s showing, a sitting president announced he would not seek another term. Buchanan’s win pushed his party’s establishment to close ranks behind Dole.

A fair objection

The strongest objection is that the word “cult” insults the people who did this work. The students of 1968 opposed a war in which young Americans were being drafted and killed. Many of the voters of 1996 believed trade deals had cost them work. They believed because they had reasons, and a law that treats followers as marks misses why they followed. That objection is right, and this piece does not call either movement a cult.

A second objection runs the other way: neither campaign won its party’s nomination, so the law did not work. That is also fair, as far as it goes. But Greene’s law promises a following, not a victory. Both men got the following. Neither got the prize, and the gap between those two outcomes is the most useful thing the New Hampshire record teaches about this law.

The verdict

Greene’s twenty-seventh law holds in New Hampshire, and the primary is built for it. The low filing barrier, the small towns and the late-deciding voters reward a candidate whose followers believe enough to give up their weekends and their beards. McCarthy and Buchanan both proved it. Both also proved the limit. A cause that fills a Nashua hall can still lose a national nomination, because devotion is not the same as a majority.

The lesson for New Hampshire voters cuts both ways. The state’s primary works partly because people care enough to show up for a cause. The same machinery can reward a crowd’s fervor over a candidate’s record. Voters who join a crusade can still ask the plain question every volunteer should ask: what exactly does this candidate promise to do?

The series has moved from the scene to the following. Part Twenty-Six showed operations built so the person at the top could stay clean. Part Twenty-Five showed candidates who renamed themselves on a single night. Part Twenty-Seven shows what happens when a candidate gives other people something to believe in, and how far that belief can carry him.

GSR Power Index
Law 27 — Play on People’s Need to Believe to Create a Cultlike Following
An editorial rating, not a measurement. Axis three asks whether the following paid off for the leader.
Frequency in NH 7/10
The primary breeds crusades: a low filing bar, small towns and late deciders. Two clear cases, one from each party.
Cost of breaking it 5/10
A candidate without true believers can still win New Hampshire. Dole lost the state by about 2,400 votes and still took the nomination.
Did belief pay? 6/10
McCarthy held a president under 50 percent; Buchanan won the state. Neither won his party’s nomination.
Does it predict outcomes? 4/10
Weakly. Devotion wins rooms and sometimes the state. It rarely wins the nomination.
Composite: 5.5 / 10 — belief wins the state, not the nomination. Lower half of the series. New Hampshire rewards a following more than most places do, but a following is not a majority.
Running index — 27 of 48 scored
Law 1: Never Outshine the Master 6.8/10
Law 2: Never Trust a Friend 6.3/10
Law 3: Conceal Your Intentions 5.3/10
Law 4: Always Say Less Than Necessary 6.9/10
Law 5: So Much Depends on Reputation 6.8/10
Law 6: Court Attention at All Cost 6.5/10
Law 7: Get Others to Do the Work 6.0/10
Law 8: Make Other People Come to You 6.3/10
Law 9: Win Through Actions, Not Argument 6.7/10
Law 10: Avoid the Unhappy and Unlucky 5.5/10
Law 11: Learn to Keep People Dependent on You 7.8/10
Law 12: Use Selective Honesty and Generosity to Disarm Your Victim 6.5/10
Law 13: Appeal to Self-Interest, Never to Mercy or Gratitude 7.0/10
Law 14: Pose as a Friend, Work as a Spy 6.5/10
Law 15: Crush Your Enemy Totally 6.5/10
Law 16: Use Absence to Increase Respect and Honor 5.3/10
Law 17: Keep Others in Suspended Terror 3.8/10
Law 18: Do Not Build Fortresses to Protect Yourself 7.3/10
Law 19: Know Who You’re Dealing With 6.8/10
Law 20: Do Not Commit to Anyone 7.0/10
Law 21: Play a Sucker to Catch a Sucker 6.0/10
Law 22: Use the Surrender Tactic 5.5/10
Law 23: Concentrate Your Forces 6.5/10
Law 24: Play the Perfect Courtier 7.0/10
Law 25: Re-Create Yourself 7.0/10
Law 26: Keep Your Hands Clean 5.8/10
Law 27: Play on People’s Need to Believe to Create a Cultlike Following 5.5/10
Twenty-seven laws in. Law 27 scores 5.5, level with Laws 10 and 22.

Next: Law 28, on entering action with boldness, tested against the New Hampshire record.

Fact check

#ClaimStatusSource
1A youth shaved his chin on a Concord street under “Get Clean for Gene”; a bearded canvasser borrowed a razor at a door; boys slept in a gymnasium and girls in supporters’ homes; volunteers mostly avoided beer; about 300 New Hampshire veterans went to Wisconsin to organize up to 25,000 volunteers; Ann Hart quote; “Over 40%, we go on to Wisconsin”; headline “Crusade of the Ballot Children”ATTRIBUTEDTime, March 22, 1968
2Campaign began with $400; hundreds of student volunteers; haircut and shaving request to avoid alienating conservative voters; “immoral war”; Paul Newman in Nashua, Tony Randall and Rod Serling radio ads; volunteers slept on floors and ate doughnuts, coffee and peanut butter (Ann Hart’s recollection); “least would like the presidency” interview; March 12 result about 49 to 42 percent; Kennedy entered three days later; Johnson’s March 31 announcementATTRIBUTEDAPM Reports, Campaign ’68, “Eugene McCarthy,” parts 1 and 2
3Johnson’s name was not printed on the ballot and had to be written in; McCarthy’s “brought the country back into the system” remark; hundreds of young volunteersATTRIBUTEDRon Elving, NPR, March 11, 2018 (as published by GBH)
4Regulars “mounted a desperate write-in campaign”; Johnson 48 percent, McCarthy 42ATTRIBUTEDEncyclopaedia Britannica, “United States presidential election of 1968”
5Sunday rally in Nashua of more than a thousand; “Go Pat Go”; “Amen” during his abortion remarks; “fair trade, not free trade”; trade deficit and New Hampshire jobs; Charlie O’Brian quote; Isabel Balfrey, 85, of Andover, Mass., quoteATTRIBUTEDKathryn M. Meneely, The Harvard Crimson, Feb. 20, 1996
6“All the peasants are coming with pitchforks”; “Mount up everybody and ride to the sound of the gun”; “the establishment is coming for us”; senators’ objective “to stop Pat Buchanan”ATTRIBUTEDNPR, All Things Considered transcript, 2012 (archival audio and interview)
7Feb. 20, 1996 shares: Buchanan 27.25, Dole 26.22, Alexander 22.59, Forbes 12.22; described as an upset; establishment coalesced around Dole; Buchanan beat Dole in Missouri on March 9ATTRIBUTEDDartmouth College, “1996: Presidential Primaries at Dartmouth College”; Encyclopaedia Britannica, “United States presidential election of 1996” (Dole captured the nomination)
855,997 to 53,623 with 98 percent counted; 60 percent decided in the final week; about one in four named the economy and jobs; “We have made history again tonight”ATTRIBUTEDThe Dartmouth, Feb. 21, 1996
9Victory party at a Manchester banquet hall; “a victory for a brand new, bold conservatism”; “the lobbyists for the people who don’t have lobbyists”ATTRIBUTEDDavid L. Greene, The Harvard Crimson, Feb. 21, 1996
10Sam Brown, 24, left Harvard Divinity School to be McCarthy’s youth organizerATTRIBUTEDTim Pugmire, MPR News, Nov. 20, 2006
11A South Carolina clothing manufacturer planned to volunteer for Buchanan in two states; “conservatism of the heart”ATTRIBUTEDThe Christian Science Monitor, “GOP at a Pitchfork in Road,” February 1996
12RSA 655:47 text, filing window and finality of the secretary’s decision; RSA 655:48 $1,000 fee and indigence petitions (10 per county); both trace to 1979VERIFIEDgc.nh.gov, RSA 655:47 and RSA 655:48
13Featured photograph: the steeple of the Tamworth Congregational Church, Carol M. Highsmith, LC-DIG-highsm-48306, no known restrictionsVERIFIEDLibrary of Congress catalog record 2017884936
14Robert Greene’s Law 27 is “Play on People’s Need to Believe to Create a Cultlike Following,” from The 48 Laws of Power, Viking, 1998VERIFIEDPublished table of contents; Shortform summary
15GSR Power Index scores for Laws 1 through 27EDITORIALGranite State Report’s own rating, not a measurement. Method stated in the chart

Your voice

Poll. Have you ever volunteered for a New Hampshire primary campaign?
Yes, more than once · Yes, once · No, but I’ve thought about it · No

Survey: the campaign you believed in. Five questions: your town; which campaign you worked for or followed; about what year; what drew you in; and whether you would do it again. Granite State Report asks before using your name or story.

Discuss. When a campaign asks volunteers to change how they look or give up their weekends, is that commitment or control? And does New Hampshire’s primary reward a candidate’s following more than a candidate’s plan?

Verified New Hampshire residents vote and answer at granitestatereport.com. Or write to granitestatereport@gmail.com with your town in the subject line.

Did you get clean for Gene in 1968, or ride with the pitchfork brigade in 1996?
Granite State Report wants to hear from volunteers and voters on any side of any New Hampshire primary crusade. granitestatereport@gmail.com, 603-931-9264. Confidentiality on request.
Sources. Time, “Crusade of the Ballot Children,” March 22, 1968; MPR News, Nov. 20, 2006; APM Reports, Campaign ’68, “Eugene McCarthy”; Ron Elving, NPR, March 11, 2018; Encyclopaedia Britannica, “United States presidential election of 1968” and “of 1996”; The Harvard Crimson, Feb. 20 and Feb. 21, 1996; NPR, All Things Considered, 2012; Dartmouth College, “1996: Presidential Primaries at Dartmouth College”; The Dartmouth, Feb. 21, 1996; The Christian Science Monitor, February 1996; RSA 655:47 and RSA 655:48 (gc.nh.gov); Library of Congress, Carol M. Highsmith Archive; Robert Greene with Joost Elffers, The 48 Laws of Power, Viking, 1998. Related GSR coverage: The Power Playbook, Part Twenty-Six and Part Twenty-Five.

Editor’s note: Commentary and analysis, not legal advice. Both statutes were read directly. Accounts of both campaigns come from contemporary and later reporting and are attributed. The 1968 vote shares differ slightly by source and both figures are given. The Secretary of State’s results database could not be read for this piece. The GSR Power Index is editorial, not data.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

NH Wire
Board