Sunday, 15 November 2026
Trending
CourtsOpinionSpecial Series

The Accusation Is the Sentence

A courthouse in Nashua. Photo: AlexiusHoratius via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0.
Independent New Hampshire Journalism · Northfield, NH
Punished First · Part 1 of 8
The Accusation Is the Sentence

In New Hampshire, the penalties start with the police report. The verdict only decides whether more get added.

Listen to this article · 10 min

On June 14, 1971, police in Louisville, Kentucky, arrested a newspaper photographer named Edward Charles Davis III for shoplifting. He pleaded not guilty. No court convicted him. In early December 1972, with the charge still sitting open, two Louisville-area police officials, one of them the city’s chief, sent about 800 local merchants a flyer captioned “ACTIVE SHOPLIFTERS.” It ran five pages of names and booking photos. Davis was on page 2.

The charge was dismissed on Dec. 11, 1972, days after the flyer went out. Davis sued. His argument was simple: the government had branded him a criminal without ever proving it and without giving him a hearing. On March 23, 1976, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled against him. Justice William Rehnquist wrote for the majority that reputation by itself, with no tangible loss such as a job attached, is neither liberty nor property under the Due Process Clause. Justice William Brennan dissented, joined by Justice Thurgood Marshall and in part by Justice Byron White.

That ruling is the reason for this series. Most people assume punishment comes after conviction. The record says otherwise. The accusation carries the penalties, and the verdict only decides whether more are added. This is Part 1 of eight on how that works in New Hampshire, stage by stage, and what the Legislature could do about it.

Disclosure: The editor of Granite State Report has been named in New Hampshire police records and has requested those records under RSA 91-A. Those matters are not part of this series.

Related coverage: GSR has reported on two pieces of this already. Mugshots Are Punishment Without a Verdict. Concord Buried the Fix Twice. covers booking photos and the bills meant to restrict them. How to Annul a Criminal Record in New Hampshire, and Why the Police File Never Goes Away walks through the annulment process. This series builds on both and does not repeat them.

What one researcher found in a lower court

The phrase most people use for this idea comes from a book. In 1979 the legal scholar Malcolm Feeley published The Process Is the Punishment, a study of how the Court of Common Pleas in New Haven, Connecticut, handled its criminal cases. The sentences that court handed out looked light. Feeley’s point was that the sentences were the wrong place to look.

According to the publisher, the Russell Sage Foundation, and a U.S. Justice Department abstract of the work, Feeley found that for people charged with misdemeanors and lesser felonies, the real costs landed before the case ever reached a judge: wages lost to missed work, bondsmen’s commissions, lawyers’ fees and time. Faced with those costs, defendants did the rational thing. They gave up the hearings and motions the system offered them and took the fastest way out. The publisher’s summary says prosecution and defense often agreed that the pretrial process was enough to “teach the defendant a lesson.”

Read that again as a description of a justice system. Both sides treated the run-up to trial as the penalty, applied to a person nobody had found guilty of anything.

Feeley studied one court in one decade, two states away. He did not study New Hampshire. The question this series asks is how much of his finding holds here, and the place to start is the statute book.

The New Hampshire version starts with a report

An arrest in this state produces a public document on day one. RSA 594:14-a says a record created by law enforcement to document the arrest of an adult is a governmental record under the Right-to-Know Law and is subject to disclosure under that chapter, with one exception the section ties to the State Police records statute. The section sets a floor for what the record has to say.

RSA 594:14-a, Arrest Records. An arrest record must contain, at a minimum: who was arrested; which officer or officers made the arrest, unless a supervisor has good cause to withhold that; a statement of why and how the arrest was made; the alleged crime; and whether there was a warrant. Read RSA 594:14-a →

Look at who speaks in that list. The officer does. The statute requires the government’s account of why and how. It does not require the accused person’s account, and nothing in the section makes disclosure wait for a judge, a plea or a verdict. One side’s version of events becomes the public version at the moment the other side has the least ability to answer it.

From there the stages stack up. There is a booking, with a photograph. There is a first court date, where conditions can be placed on a person’s freedom before any finding of guilt. There is a court file with the person’s name on the caption. Each stage leaves paper, and each piece of paper can be copied. Later parts of this series take those stages one at a time, with the statute for each opened and cited.

How many people does this touch? New Hampshire Employment Security, using FBI data, counted 47,840 arrests reported in the state in 2018 and 36,488 in 2022.

Bar chart of arrests reported in New Hampshire by year: 47,840 in 2018; 46,858 in 2019; 37,390 in 2020; 39,426 in 2021; 36,488 in 2022.
Arrests reported in New Hampshire, 2018 to 2022. Chart: Granite State Report. Source: N.H. Employment Security, Vital Signs 2024, from FBI data.

Each of those arrests started a record. The number that matters most for this series is the one GSR could not find: how many ended without a conviction. I have located no published statewide count of arrests that ended in a dismissal, an acquittal or a decision not to prosecute. The state counts the people it arrests. I have found no public tally of how those cases came out.

The state can annul its own record. It cannot recall the copies.

The eraser, and what it leaves behind

New Hampshire does have a remedy, and it is better than most people think. Under RSA 651:5, II-a, for a case disposed of on or after Jan. 1, 2019, a person found not guilty on all charges, or whose case was dismissed or not prosecuted, shall have the arrest record and court record annulled. The statute says shall. Once a record is annulled, the law treats the person as if the arrest never happened, with narrow exceptions for later sentencing. In a job or license application, the only question the law allows is whether the person has a record “that has not been annulled by a court.”

Now read the rest of the same statute.

RSA 651:5, Annulment of Criminal Records. Paragraph X(e) has arresting and prosecuting agencies mark their files as annulled. Paragraph XI(b) preserves law enforcement’s right to keep arrest and conviction records and to share them with other officers for investigations and for defending civil suits. Paragraph XVII says no public or private person or entity faces a penalty for failing to remove or correct an earlier public report after a record is annulled. Read RSA 651:5 →

So the police file is marked and kept. In 2016 the New Hampshire Supreme Court went a step further in Grafton County Attorney’s Office v. Canner, holding that records of an annulled arrest and prosecution held by police and prosecutors are not categorically exempt from the Right-to-Know Law. And every copy that left the building before the annulment, whether a police department’s social media post, a news brief or a data broker’s listing, stays where it is. The statute imposes no duty on anyone to take it down.

There is also a gap between the word shall and the way the process is described. The State Police page on annulments says the process begins by filing a petition with the court. In 2026 the Legislature passed Senate Bill 512, which adds a sentence to paragraph II-a barring any filing fee for a petition brought under it, effective Jan. 1, 2027. A record that annulled itself would need no petition and no rule about petition fees. I have not established how often annulment happens without one. That is a records question, and a later part of this series is built around it.

The other side, stated fairly

Public arrest records exist for a good reason. A government that can arrest people without telling anyone is more dangerous than one that has to write the arrest down and hand the paper over. Open records are how reporters and families find out who is in custody, why, and on whose say-so. GSR files Right-to-Know requests as a matter of routine, and RSA 651:5, XVI protects a reporter who publishes a record without knowing it was annulled. This outlet benefits from the openness it is about to criticize.

So this series does not argue for secret arrests. It argues that the arrest record and the brand are two different things. The public needs to know that the state took a person into custody and what the officer claimed. The public does not need a booking photo on a department’s feed, a permanent search result, or a background-check hit for a charge a court threw out.

Guilty or not is the wrong question

The usual objection is that most people who get arrested did something. Maybe so. It does not matter to this argument, and that is the uncomfortable part. A penalty that falls the same way on the guilty and the innocent was never tied to guilt. It is tied to being accused.

The presumption of innocence is real, and it governs the trial. It does not govern the arrest log, the booking photo or the search result. The Supreme Court told Edward Davis as much in 1976: the Constitution, as the Court read it, did not require a hearing before the police put his face on a flyer. Brennan’s dissent lost. Half a century later the flyer is a web page, and it does not get thrown away.

None of this is beyond the Legislature’s reach. The General Court wrote RSA 594:14-a. It wrote RSA 651:5 and has amended it again and again, most recently in 2026. It can decide what an agency may publish before a conviction, who has to correct the record afterward, and whether shall be annulled means a clerk does it or a citizen has to ask. It can also order the count that does not appear to exist.

New Hampshire reported 36,488 arrests in 2022 and publishes no tally of how they ended. Start there.

— Dexter Dow, Granite State Report

Your Turn

Poll: Should an arrest record be public before a conviction?
A) Yes, always  ·  B) Yes, without the photo  ·  C) Only after charges are filed  ·  D) No

Survey, six questions: 1) What town were you in? 2) Which agency made the arrest? 3) What year? 4) How did the case end: conviction, dismissal, not guilty, or never prosecuted? 5) What followed: a job, housing, custody, a license, or nothing? 6) Was the record annulled, and did it surface afterward anyway?

Consent: GSR may contact me about my answers. Nothing I submit is published with my name without my written permission. Responses are kept for 24 months, then deleted or stripped of identifying details.

Discuss: Where is the line between the public’s right to know about an arrest and a permanent brand on a person never convicted? If a charge is dismissed, who should have to correct the record: the court, the police, or the person?

You tell me: If an arrest that ended without a conviction still followed you, send the survey answers to granitestatereport@gmail.com

Fact check

#ClaimStatusSource
1Davis was arrested for shoplifting in Louisville on June 14, 1971, pleaded not guilty, and the charge stayed openVERIFIEDPaul v. Davis, 424 U.S. 693 (1976), opinion text, Cornell Legal Information Institute
2About 800 flyers captioned “ACTIVE SHOPLIFTERS,” five pages of names and booking photos, went to Louisville-area merchants in early December 1972; Davis was on page 2VERIFIEDPaul v. Davis, opinion text
3The charge was dismissed Dec. 11, 1972VERIFIEDPaul v. Davis, footnote 5
4Decided March 23, 1976; Rehnquist for the majority; Brennan dissenting, joined by Marshall and in part by White; reputation alone is neither liberty nor propertyVERIFIEDPaul v. Davis, opinion text
5Feeley’s 1979 study of the New Haven Court of Common Pleas found pretrial costs (lost wages, bondsmen’s commissions, lawyers’ fees, time) were the real penaltyATTRIBUTEDRussell Sage Foundation book page; U.S. Justice Department NCJRS abstract NCJ 186005. GSR relied on these summaries, not the book itself
6Prosecution and defense often agreed the pretrial process was enough to “teach the defendant a lesson”ATTRIBUTEDRussell Sage Foundation book page (publisher’s summary)
7Adult arrest records are governmental records under RSA 91-A, with a required minimum contentVERIFIEDRSA 594:14-a, gc.nh.gov
847,840 arrests reported in New Hampshire in 2018; 36,488 in 2022ATTRIBUTEDN.H. Employment Security, Vital Signs 2024, chapter 14, citing FBI data. Counts are arrests reported by participating agencies, not individual people
9No published statewide count of arrests ending without conviction was locatedATTRIBUTEDGSR search of State Police, Employment Security and Judicial Branch public pages. An absence of located evidence, not proof none exists
10Non-conviction cases disposed of on or after Jan. 1, 2019 shall be annulledVERIFIEDRSA 651:5, II-a, gc.nh.gov
11An annulled person is treated as never arrested, with sentencing exceptions; the permitted question is limited to records not annulledVERIFIEDRSA 651:5, X(a) and X(f)
12Agencies mark files as annulled; law enforcement may keep and share the records; no penalty for failing to remove an earlier public reportVERIFIEDRSA 651:5, X(e), XI(b), XVII
13Reporters face no penalty for publishing a record without knowledge of its annulmentVERIFIEDRSA 651:5, XVI
14Canner (2016): records of an annulled arrest and prosecution are not categorically exempt from the Right-to-Know LawATTRIBUTEDN.H. Supreme Court, No. 2016-065, confirmed by the opinion’s opening text and the N.H. Municipal Association case summary; the court’s site blocks automated reading
15The State Police describe annulment as beginning with a petition filed in courtATTRIBUTEDN.H. State Police, Criminal Record Annulments page
16SB 512 (2026), Chapter 105, bars a filing fee for a petition under RSA 651:5, II-a(a); approved May 28, 2026; effective Jan. 1, 2027VERIFIEDSB 512-FN final version, gc.nh.gov
Have a document, a tip, or a correction?
Reach the editor directly. Confidentiality respected where possible.
granitestatereport@gmail.com · 603-931-9264
Sources. Paul v. Davis, 424 U.S. 693 (1976). RSA 594:14-a. RSA 651:5. SB 512-FN (2026), Chapter 105. Grafton County Attorney’s Office v. Canner, N.H. Supreme Court No. 2016-065 (2016); N.H. Municipal Association summary. N.H. State Police, Criminal Record Annulments. N.H. Employment Security, Vital Signs 2024, chapter 14. Malcolm M. Feeley, The Process Is the Punishment (Russell Sage Foundation, 1979): publisher’s page; NCJRS abstract. Photo: a courthouse in Nashua, AlexiusHoratius via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0.

Editor’s note. Sources for this piece are the U.S. Supreme Court’s opinion in Paul v. Davis, the New Hampshire statutes and session law cited, the State Police and Employment Security pages cited, and published summaries of Feeley’s book; see the fact-check table. The Feeley findings are taken from the publisher and a Justice Department abstract, not from the book. No on-the-record interview was conducted for this part. Corrections: Granite State Report corrects verified errors promptly and appends a note identifying what changed and when.

Granite State Report · Northfield, New Hampshire · granitestatereport.com
Board