Monday, 16 November 2026
Trending
Law & CourtsThe 48 Laws of Power

Keep Your Hands Clean: A Phone-Jamming Scheme, a Fake Biden Call and Who Took the Fall in New Hampshire

The Merrimack River and a former mill in Manchester. Photo: Carol M. Highsmith, Library of Congress.
Independent New Hampshire Journalism · Northfield, NH
The Power Playbook · Part Twenty-Six of Forty-Eight
Keep Your Hands Clean: A Phone-Jamming Scheme, a Fake Biden Call and Who Took the Fall in New Hampshire

Robert Greene’s twenty-sixth law says to let others do the dirty work. New Hampshire’s record holds two phone schemes aimed at its voters, one run by Republican operatives and one by a Democratic consultant. Both times, the people closest to the phones answered first.

Listen to this article  ·  13 min
Narration read by a synthetic voice from the title, byline, summary and text of this article. Granite State Report.

At about 7:15 on the morning of Nov. 5, 2002, according to a police report, the phones at the Manchester Professional Fire Fighters Association started ringing and would not stop. The union was offering voters rides to the polls. Five Democratic Party lines were ringing too. Each time someone picked up, the caller hung up, and the next call came in. Nearly 1,000 calls hit those six lines that morning, a federal appeals court later found. By the court’s two accounts the lines stayed jammed for somewhere between 85 minutes and two hours.

Twenty-one years later, on Jan. 21, 2024, two days before the presidential primary, thousands of New Hampshire voters picked up a call from a voice that sounded like President Biden. It told them to “save your vote for the November election.”

Robert Greene’s twenty-sixth law says to keep your hands clean: hand the dirty work to someone else and keep a scapegoat ready to take the blame. New Hampshire’s record holds two tests of it, one run by Republican operatives and one by a Democratic consultant. In 2002 the law worked the way Greene promises for the most senior person charged. In 2024 it did not work for anyone for long. Both show where it breaks: the people who did the work were the ones who talked, and once they talked the clean hands were only as clean as the statute was narrow.

The chain of hands

The 2002 plan started with Charles McGee, the executive director of the New Hampshire Republican State Committee. McGee testified that he first thought about disrupting the Democrats’ turnout operation after Democrats protested outside his office that October. The vendors he called would not help. Three or four days before the election he went to James Tobin, the New England regional director of the Republican National Committee, who was in the state to coordinate visits by party figures.

Tobin did not run the operation. He made an introduction. He gave McGee the name of Allen Raymond, a longtime acquaintance whose business handled phone programs for campaigns, and he called Raymond to tell him to expect McGee. Raymond testified that Tobin described a phone project that would mean “jamming, essentially disrupting” the Democrats’ get-out-the-vote effort. After that, by the court’s account, Tobin dropped out of the conversation. McGee and Raymond worked out the details and the price by phone and email. McGee supplied six numbers: five Democratic Party lines and the firefighters’ union. Raymond hired the callers, and by the Monday before the election an Idaho firm was lined up to make them, the Associated Press reported.

As the polls opened, McGee’s boss, state party chairman John Dowd, ordered the plan stopped. Dowd later told the AP he had learned of it only the day before and blamed an aide for devising it. The calls went out anyway.

Every link in that chain served a purpose Greene would recognize. The state party’s executive director never touched a phone. The national party’s regional director only passed along a name. The vendor never dialed a number himself. The people placing the calls worked for a subcontractor in Idaho. On paper, almost no one had done anything.

Diagram titled The chain of hands, New Hampshire, Election Day 2002. Four links run from the idea to the phones: Charles McGee, New Hampshire Republican State Committee executive director, who had the idea and pleaded guilty, serving seven months; James Tobin, Republican National Committee regional director, who made the introduction and was convicted in 2005, then reversed on appeal in 2007 and acquitted in 2008, affirmed in 2009; Allen Raymond, phone vendor, who arranged the calls and pleaded guilty, serving three months after cooperating; and an Idaho telemarketing subcontractor that placed nearly 1,000 calls to six lines.
The chain of hands, 2002. The only person in the chain to be cleared was the most senior one charged.Chart: Granite State Report. Sources: United States v. Tobin, 480 F.3d 53 (1st Cir. 2007) and 552 F.3d 29 (1st Cir. 2009); Associated Press, April 11, 2006.

Who answered for it

The clean hands held for one man in the chain and no one else. McGee pleaded guilty to a federal telephone-harassment charge and served seven months. Raymond pleaded guilty to the same charge, testified for the government, and saw his sentence cut to three months. They were the government’s principal witnesses against Tobin. The owner of the subcontracting firm was under indictment in 2006, the AP reported.

A federal jury convicted Tobin on Dec. 15, 2005, of conspiracy and of aiding and abetting the making of repeated harassing calls, and acquitted him of conspiring to violate voters’ rights. He was sentenced to 10 months and fined $10,000. The Republican National Committee paid millions in legal bills for his defense, the AP reported, saying he was a longtime supporter who had told party officials he committed no crime.

Then the conviction came apart. In 2007 the U.S. Court of Appeals for the First Circuit threw it out because the jury instructions had stretched the harassment statute too far. Chief Judge Michael Boudin wrote that despite “the unattractive conduct,” the statute “is not a close fit for what Tobin did.” On remand the district judge entered an acquittal, ruling that the law required a purpose to cause emotional upset in the people answering the phones. In January 2009 the First Circuit agreed, after the government conceded that harassment was not Tobin’s purpose. The case was over.

The court made a point of saying what was missing. Some states, including Maine, make it a crime to tie up phone lines to disrupt someone’s activities. The federal statute used against Tobin was written decades earlier, aimed mainly at calls meant to frighten people, including the families of soldiers serving in Vietnam. The court suggested Congress write a law aimed squarely at deliberate interference.

The civil side ended quietly. The New Hampshire Democratic Party had sued the Republican State Committee. In December 2006, days before trial in Hillsborough County Superior Court, the two sides settled, JURIST reported. Democrats had sought $4 million for their turnout campaign; Republicans had argued damages should be limited to the $4,974 spent renting phones. The settlement amount was not disclosed. The Senate race on the ballot that day went to Republican John E. Sununu over Democrat Jeanne Shaheen, 51 percent to 46, the AP reported.

RSA 659:40, III, Voter Suppression. “No person shall engage in voter suppression by knowingly attempting to prevent or deter another person from voting or registering to vote based on fraudulent, deceptive, misleading, or spurious grounds or information.” Paragraph IV makes a violation, or a conspiracy to commit one, a class B felony. The section’s source note lists a 2008 amendment. RSA 666:7-a, enacted in 2003 according to its source note, makes it a misdemeanor to place a phone call while falsely representing oneself as a candidate. Read RSA 659:40 → · Read RSA 666:7-a →

The magician and the dial tone

The 2024 call was built with even more distance between the man who wanted it and the voters who heard it. Steve Kramer, a Democratic political consultant, wanted a recording that sounded like Biden. Paul Carpenter, a New Orleans street magician, made it with artificial intelligence. The Federal Communications Commission found that Kramer’s father paid the person who made the message $150 on Jan. 20, 2024. The next day a company called Voice Broadcasting initiated 9,581 calls at Kramer’s request, using the services of Life Corporation, which passed them to Lingo Telecom, the originating carrier.

The caller ID added one more layer. The calls were spoofed to show a number tied to the treasurer of a political committee backing a write-in campaign for Biden, the state attorney general said. In plain terms, anyone who checked the caller ID would have seen a number belonging to Biden’s own supporters.

Diagram titled The 2024 call chain. Steve Kramer, consultant, ordered the call; FCC fined him 6 million dollars and a Belknap County jury acquitted him of state charges. Paul Carpenter made the AI audio for 150 dollars. Voice Broadcasting initiated 9,581 calls on Jan. 21, 2024, using Life Corporation's services; the attorney general ordered Life Corporation to cease and desist. Lingo Telecom carried the calls and agreed to pay 1 million dollars. The caller ID was spoofed to a number tied to a Biden write-in committee's treasurer.
The 2024 call chain. Five layers between the man who wanted the call and the voters who heard it.Chart: Granite State Report. Sources: FCC Forfeiture Order FCC 24-104; N.H. Department of Justice releases of Feb. 6 and May 23, 2024; NHPR, June 13, 2025.

Investigators traced the calls to Life Corporation within about two weeks, the attorney general said. The man who ordered them stayed unnamed for about a month, until the chain’s human link broke. Carpenter went to NBC News, which reported his account in February 2024, with screenshots of texts and payments. He said he had believed Kramer was working for the Biden campaign. “I created the gun. I didn’t shoot it,” Carpenter said. Within days Kramer admitted he was behind the call and described it as a warning about artificial intelligence.

Kramer had a six-figure contract with the long-shot primary campaign of Rep. Dean Phillips, a Minnesota Democrat challenging Biden, NBC News reported. Kramer and the campaign both said the campaign did not know about the call or direct it. Phillips called such behavior “despicable” and said Kramer had been hired to help with ballot access.

The penalties followed the same pattern as 2002, in a different order. On May 23, 2024, Attorney General John Formella charged Kramer with 13 felony counts of voter suppression under RSA 659:40, III, and 13 misdemeanor counts under RSA 666:7-a, one of each for 13 voters in Rockingham, Belknap, Grafton and Merrimack counties. The FCC ordered him to pay $6 million under the Truth in Caller ID Act. Lingo Telecom agreed to pay $1 million. In June 2025 a Belknap County Superior Court jury in Laconia acquitted Kramer of every count that went to trial. Granite State Report examined what the AI companies’ own rules say about calls like this one in an earlier piece.

Nineteen seconds. Two phone schemes, who answered for them, and the GSR Power Index through twenty-six laws.Video: Granite State Report. No audio.

What the two cases share

Both operations were built the way Greene says to build them. The person with the motive stood several steps back from the act. Each step added a name, a company or a phone number that pointed somewhere else. In 2002 the intermediaries were a vendor and a subcontractor. In 2024 they were a magician, two calling companies, a carrier and a borrowed caller ID.

Both also failed at the same joint. Greene’s law quietly assumes that the cat’s-paw stays quiet. In New Hampshire it did not. McGee and Raymond became the government’s witnesses. Carpenter went to the press. Each intermediary who got caught became the evidence against the person above him.

And in both cases the criminal law struggled to reach the person who wanted the result. Tobin walked because the federal statute required a purpose the government conceded it could not prove. Kramer admitted what he did and still walked out of a state courtroom acquitted. The largest penalty in 2024 came from a federal regulator. The money in 2002 came through a civil settlement whose amount was never made public. Clean hands, in this record, depended as much on the fit of the statute as on the skill of the delegation.

A fair objection

The strongest case against this reading is that it treats legal outcomes as cover. Tobin was acquitted. An appeals court found that the conduct, however ugly, did not fit the crime charged, and the government agreed it could not prove harassment was his aim. Kramer was acquitted by a jury of New Hampshire residents. The Phillips campaign said it knew nothing, no one has shown otherwise, and it was never charged. Reading Greene into every acquittal risks smearing people the law cleared.

There is a second objection from the other side. Kramer did not keep his hands clean at all. He put his own name on the call once Carpenter talked, and he drew the largest announced penalty in either case. Dowd, the 2002 party chairman, said he tried to stop the plan. On that view the record shows less about clean hands than about people who got caught and people who were never asked to answer.

Both objections are fair. Neither changes the shape of the two chains. Each was designed so the person at the top could say someone else did it. In 2002 the people at the bottom paid first. In 2024 the chain broke from the bottom up, starting with the companies and the magician.

The verdict

Greene’s twenty-sixth law half-holds in New Hampshire. When it holds, it holds for the person at the top, protected by distance, by lawyers and by statutes that never quite fit. It fails for everyone in the middle, because the people who do the dirty work have the most reason to talk once investigators arrive. McGee and Raymond went to prison. Carpenter went to NBC.

The lesson for New Hampshire voters is practical. A trick that reaches you through a phone, a robocall or a spoofed number was built so you would blame the wrong person. The record says the chain usually breaks, but slowly, and the person who ordered the call is the last one the law reaches, if it reaches him at all.

The series keeps returning to the same stage. Part Twenty-Five showed candidates who named themselves before anyone else could. Part Twenty-Four showed an aide who fell when he became the story. Part Twenty-Six shows the opposite move: arranging things so someone else becomes the story.

GSR Power Index
Law 26 — Keep Your Hands Clean
An editorial rating, not a measurement. Axis three asks whether handing off the work kept the most senior person clean.
Frequency in NH 5/10
Two documented phone schemes a generation apart. Both were traced, which suggests the trick is more tempting than common.
Cost of breaking it 7/10
McGee and Raymond served prison time. Kramer drew a $6 million FCC penalty. Delegation did not protect the middle of the chain.
Did clean hands hold? 5/10
For Tobin, after years of trial and appeals. Not for Kramer, who admitted the call once his magician talked.
Does it predict outcomes? 6/10
Partly. The most senior person tends to slip the criminal law, but the chain usually breaks.
Composite: 5.8 / 10 — the cat’s-paw talks. Lower half of the series. The law protects the top of a chain only while the bottom stays quiet, and in New Hampshire it did not stay quiet.
Running index — 26 of 48 scored
Law 1: Never Outshine the Master 6.8/10
Law 2: Never Trust a Friend 6.3/10
Law 3: Conceal Your Intentions 5.3/10
Law 4: Always Say Less Than Necessary 6.9/10
Law 5: So Much Depends on Reputation 6.8/10
Law 6: Court Attention at All Cost 6.5/10
Law 7: Get Others to Do the Work 6.0/10
Law 8: Make Other People Come to You 6.3/10
Law 9: Win Through Actions, Not Argument 6.7/10
Law 10: Avoid the Unhappy and Unlucky 5.5/10
Law 11: Learn to Keep People Dependent on You 7.8/10
Law 12: Use Selective Honesty and Generosity to Disarm Your Victim 6.5/10
Law 13: Appeal to Self-Interest, Never to Mercy or Gratitude 7.0/10
Law 14: Pose as a Friend, Work as a Spy 6.5/10
Law 15: Crush Your Enemy Totally 6.5/10
Law 16: Use Absence to Increase Respect and Honor 5.3/10
Law 17: Keep Others in Suspended Terror 3.8/10
Law 18: Do Not Build Fortresses to Protect Yourself 7.3/10
Law 19: Know Who You’re Dealing With 6.8/10
Law 20: Do Not Commit to Anyone 7.0/10
Law 21: Play a Sucker to Catch a Sucker 6.0/10
Law 22: Use the Surrender Tactic 5.5/10
Law 23: Concentrate Your Forces 6.5/10
Law 24: Play the Perfect Courtier 7.0/10
Law 25: Re-Create Yourself 7.0/10
Law 26: Keep Your Hands Clean 5.8/10
Twenty-six laws in. Law 26 scores 5.8, above only Laws 3, 10, 16, 17 and 22.

Next: Law 27, on playing to people’s need to believe, tested against the New Hampshire record.

Fact check

#ClaimStatusSource
1Tobin, RNC New England regional director, introduced McGee to Raymond and called Raymond; McGee’s idea followed an October 2002 Democratic protest; vendors were unhelpful; McGee and Raymond set the details; six numbers, five Democratic and one firefighters union offering rides; Dowd ordered it called off as polls opened; about 85 minutes of continuous ringing; McGee served seven months; Raymond’s sentence reduced to three months; Tobin convicted Dec. 15, 2005 on conspiracy and aiding and abetting, acquitted on 18 U.S.C. 241; 10 months and $10,000 fine; conviction reversed; “not a close fit” language; Maine statute citedVERIFIEDUnited States v. Tobin, 480 F.3d 53 (1st Cir. 2007)
2Nearly 1,000 calls to five Democratic numbers and the firefighters union, lines jammed for two hours (the 2007 opinion says about 85 minutes); district court acquittal on remand; government conceded harassment was not Tobin’s subjective purpose; acquittal affirmed; court suggested Congress address deliberate interferenceVERIFIEDUnited States v. Tobin, 552 F.3d 29 (1st Cir. 2009); United States v. Tobin, 545 F. Supp. 2d 189 (D.N.H. 2008)
3Idaho firm hired by Nov. 4, 2002; Dowd learned of the plan that day, tried to stop it and blamed an aide; firefighters reported calls from about 7:15 a.m. for about two hours; RNC paid millions for Tobin’s defense and called him a longtime supporter; subcontractor owner under indictment; Sununu defeated Shaheen 51 to 46ATTRIBUTEDAssociated Press, “Records: Tobin called White House,” April 11, 2006, via the Sun Journal
4Civil suit by the N.H. Democratic Party against the Republican State Committee settled before trial in Hillsborough County Superior Court; Democrats sought $4 million; Republicans argued for $4,974; amount not disclosedATTRIBUTEDJURIST, December 2006
5RSA 659:40, III text and class B felony penalty; source note 1979, 2008. RSA 666:7-a text; source note 2003, 2004, 2009VERIFIEDgc.nh.gov, RSA 659:40 and RSA 666:7-a
6Calls on Jan. 21, 2024; “save your vote for the November election”; caller ID spoofed to a former state party chair’s number; Life Corporation identified as source and ordered to cease and desist; Lingo Telecom the originating providerVERIFIEDN.H. Department of Justice release, Feb. 6, 2024
7Charges of May 23, 2024: 13 felony counts under RSA 659:40, III and 13 misdemeanor counts under RSA 666:7-a, by county; spoofed number tied to the treasurer of a Biden write-in committeeVERIFIEDN.H. Department of Justice release, May 23, 2024
8$6 million forfeiture; Kramer’s father paid $150 for the message on Jan. 20, 2024; Voice Broadcasting initiated 9,581 calls on Jan. 21 using Life Corporation, which passed them to Lingo Telecom; Truth in Caller ID ActVERIFIEDFCC Forfeiture Order FCC 24-104, adopted Sept. 26, 2024
9Carpenter made the audio; six-figure Phillips contract; Kramer and the campaign denied the campaign knew; Kramer said he did it to prompt AI rulesATTRIBUTEDNBC News, 2024
10“I created the gun. I didn’t shoot it.”; Carpenter believed Kramer worked for the Biden campaign; Kramer’s admission statement of Feb. 26, 2024; campaign hired Kramer for ballot accessATTRIBUTEDSpectrum News, Feb. 26, 2024, quoting the AP
11Phillips called the behavior “despicable” and described Kramer as hired for ballot access; Carpenter’s account first reported by AP and NBCATTRIBUTEDJURIST, February 2024
12Belknap County Superior Court jury in Laconia acquitted Kramer on all counts tried, 11 of each charge; FCC fine; Lingo $1 million; Formella statementATTRIBUTEDNew Hampshire Public Radio, June 13, 2025
13Featured photograph: the Merrimack River and a former textile mill in Manchester, Carol M. Highsmith, LC-DIG-highsm-47338, cropped below the rooftop signs; no known restrictionsVERIFIEDLibrary of Congress catalog record 2017883969
14Robert Greene’s Law 26 is “Keep Your Hands Clean,” from The 48 Laws of Power, Viking, 1998VERIFIEDPublished table of contents; Shortform summary
15GSR Power Index scores for Laws 1 through 26EDITORIALGranite State Report’s own rating, not a measurement. Method stated in the chart

Your voice

Poll. When a political dirty trick is traced, who should answer for it?
The person who ordered it · Everyone in the chain · The campaign or party it helped · Not sure

Survey: calls you got. Five questions: your town; whether you ever got a political call you believe was fake or misleading; about when; what it said; and whether you reported it. Granite State Report asks before using your name or story.

Discuss. Should the person who orders a dirty trick face the same penalty as the people who carry it out? And should New Hampshire make it a crime on its own to jam a campaign’s or a union’s phone lines on Election Day?

Verified New Hampshire residents vote and answer at granitestatereport.com. Or write to granitestatereport@gmail.com with your town in the subject line.

Did you work a phone bank in 2002, or get the Biden call in 2024?
Granite State Report wants to hear from people on any side who saw these operations up close. granitestatereport@gmail.com, 603-931-9264. Confidentiality on request.
Sources. United States v. Tobin, 480 F.3d 53 (1st Cir. 2007); United States v. Tobin, 552 F.3d 29 (1st Cir. 2009); United States v. Tobin, 545 F. Supp. 2d 189 (D.N.H. 2008); RSA 659:40 and RSA 666:7-a (gc.nh.gov); N.H. Department of Justice releases, Feb. 6 and May 23, 2024; FCC Forfeiture Order FCC 24-104; Associated Press, April 11, 2006; JURIST, 2006 and 2024; NBC News, 2024; Spectrum News, Feb. 26, 2024; New Hampshire Public Radio, June 13, 2025; Library of Congress, Carol M. Highsmith Archive; Robert Greene with Joost Elffers, The 48 Laws of Power, Viking, 1998. Related GSR coverage: Every AI Company Bans the Biden Robocall. Read the Fine Print Anyway. The Power Playbook, Part Twenty-Five and Part Twenty-Four.

Editor’s note: Commentary and analysis, not legal advice. The First Circuit opinions, the FCC order, the attorney general’s releases and both statutes were read directly. Accounts of the people involved come from court records and attributed reporting. James Tobin and Steve Kramer were acquitted of the criminal charges described here, and no charge was brought against the Phillips campaign. The GSR Power Index is editorial, not data.

NH Wire
Board