Independent New Hampshire Journalism · Northfield, NHThe national Democrats have slotted New Hampshire third for 2028. State law says first. On Dec. 2, a Democratic Legislature picks the one official who decides which wins.
The Democratic National Committee has a date for New Hampshire’s 2028 presidential primary: Tuesday, Feb. 8, two weeks and three days after South Carolina and one week after Nevada. New Hampshire’s secretary of state has a different plan. In a New Hampshire Bulletin report published this morning, David Scanlan said the state law that requires New Hampshire to go first still governs, and that he intends to wait out the other states and then set the date. “New Hampshire is a very nimble state,” he said.
The catch is that Scanlan may not be the one who sets it. The secretary of state is not elected by voters. The Legislature chooses the office every two years, and on Dec. 2 a newly elected General Court with Democrats in firm control of both chambers will decide whether to keep Scanlan, a Republican, or replace him with one of at least three Democrats who want the job.
That vote is twelve days away, and it is the biggest decision about the 2028 primary left on New Hampshire’s calendar this year. Granite State Report takes no side on which candidate should win it. GSR does take a side on how it should be decided: in the open, with every candidate on the record about the one power that matters most, the power to pick the date.
Related coverage: GSR’s Nov. 16 piece on Webster, Pierce and Eisenhower covers the 1952 primary that made New Hampshire’s contest a national event, the tradition both sides of this fight say they want to protect.
The calendar and the law
The full DNC approved its 2028 early-state lineup by voice vote on Aug. 15. South Carolina votes first on Jan. 22, 2028, followed by Nevada on Feb. 1, New Hampshire on Feb. 8, New Mexico on Feb. 15, Michigan on Feb. 22 and Virginia on Feb. 29. The Washington Examiner reported that the party also stiffened its penalties for states that jump the order, including the loss of all of a state’s delegates and a $270,000 fine.
The case for that calendar is not hard to state, and New Hampshire readers should hear it straight. Its backers want the first votes cast in states with large Black, Latino and union electorates. Former DNC chair Howard Dean put it bluntly to the Associated Press: “These states look more like the country,” he said of the new early states, adding that Iowa and New Hampshire do not.
New Hampshire’s answer is written into statute, and it does not care what either national party wants.
Run the DNC’s dates through that statute and the math is short. If South Carolina holds its Democratic primary on Saturday, Jan. 22, 2028, the seven-day rule points New Hampshire to Jan. 15 or earlier. New Hampshire votes on Tuesdays, and the last Tuesday that clears the bar is Jan. 11. That is GSR’s arithmetic, not anyone’s announcement. The real date depends on what every other state does between now and then, which is exactly why Scanlan says he wants to wait.
One official, one trigger
New Hampshire did not end up first by accident of tradition alone. For 45 years the job belonged to Bill Gardner, a Democrat who retired in January 2022. Scanlan, his longtime deputy, took over and faced the hardest test the law has had. In November 2023 he set the 2024 primary for Jan. 23, ahead of South Carolina, with leaders of both state parties standing beside him. The DNC refused to recognize the contest. President Joe Biden stayed off the ballot and still won the Democratic primary on write-ins.
That record is the core of Scanlan’s pitch now. At a Legislative Office Building press conference on Nov. 17, he told reporters he has support from both parties and believes “I have a shot at this,” according to the Boston Globe. He called the Democrats’ alternative untested and argued that choosing a secretary of state on party lines would set a precedent the state would regret.
Gov. Kelly Ayotte, a Republican, has backed him on the same grounds. She told reporters it would be “the wrong thing to do to politicize the Secretary of State’s Office.” State Republican chair Scott Maltzie told WMUR that replacing Scanlan would make protecting the primary harder.
The Dec. 2 vote
The state constitution settles who decides. Part Second, Article 67 says the secretary and treasurer are “chosen by joint ballot of the senators and representatives assembled in one room.” That room will hold 424 lawmakers on Dec. 2, and Democrats will hold close to 300 of the 400 House seats and 15 of the 24 Senate seats, according to the Bulletin. If the majority votes as a bloc, the job is theirs to fill.
Three Democrats are in the race. Carleigh Beriont is a Hampton Select Board member who lost this year’s 1st Congressional District primary. James Butler worked as a policy adviser to former Gov. Maggie Hassan and now works for Eversource. State Rep. Patrick Long of Manchester has served as a ballot clerk and poll watcher. The Bulletin reported that former Senate President Donna Soucy, who addressed the DNC’s August meeting as a New Hampshire Democratic committeewoman, has been mentioned as a possible candidate.
The challengers have made their own case, and it deserves a fair hearing. Butler’s letter to lawmakers lists expanding voting rights, modernizing the office and upholding the first-in-the-nation primary, and tells them “We have the chance to make meaningful change,” according to the Boston Globe. Beriont, who also serves on Hampton’s election commission, has put youth voter registration and support for local election officials alongside the primary. Long argues that lawmakers in both parties want a secretary devoted to the work. The office does more than set one date every four years: it runs elections, registers businesses, regulates securities and keeps the state archives. Republicans controlled the Legislature from 2021 until this month’s election, and a new majority choosing its own officer is how the constitution is built to work.
Scanlan’s side answers that the job is technical, that he has spent more than two decades in the office, and that the primary is the one place where the state cannot afford a learning curve. Both arguments are serious. Neither one settles the question lawmakers face on the date.
WMUR reported that every Democratic candidate says they will follow state law and fight for New Hampshire’s place at the front. State Democratic chair Ray Buckley is running candidate forums he says will let them “share their perspectives on protecting New Hampshire’s unique role.”
Here is the problem. The Globe reported those forums are closed to the public and open to incoming Democratic lawmakers. The office that runs every election in the state, and that holds the one decision national parties fight over, is being auditioned behind a party door.
What lawmakers should ask on the record
Every candidate says the right thing about the statute. That is the floor, not the test. RSA 653:9 does not enforce itself; it works only if the person holding the office is willing to set a date that a national party has told them not to set, and to do it on a timeline other states control. Scanlan has done that once, against a Democratic president. None of his challengers has had to.
So before the joint session, every candidate, the incumbent included, should answer these questions in public, in writing, where voters can read the answers:
- If the DNC holds to Feb. 8 and South Carolina holds to Jan. 22, will you set New Hampshire’s primary at least seven days before Jan. 22, as RSA 653:9 requires?
- Will you make that decision without consulting either national party about the date, and will you disclose any contact you have with them about it?
- If your own party’s national committee threatens New Hampshire’s delegates, does that change your answer?
None of those questions favors a party. A Republican secretary could face the same pressure from the Republican National Committee in some future cycle. They are questions about whether the officeholder treats the statute as an order or as a talking point.
GSR will publish any answers candidates send, unedited. GSR is also preparing a Right-to-Know request to the Secretary of State’s office for its correspondence with both national parties about the 2028 calendar, so readers can see what has already been said in private.
Why it matters past 2028
The fight over the first primary usually gets framed as tradition against fairness. Both have real weight, and neither is GSR’s call to make for a national party. What New Hampshire controls is narrower and more important: whether its own law means anything. The Legislature wrote that law, and on Dec. 2 the Legislature picks the person who has to carry it out under fire.
On Sunday, the 63rd anniversary of John F. Kennedy’s assassination, GSR publishes a look at the 1960 campaign that started on the plaza outside Nashua City Hall. Kennedy ran nearly unopposed here and worked the state anyway, and the record he set in March carried him to the nomination. That is the primary both parties say they are defending. The lawmakers who walk into that one room on Dec. 2 should make every candidate say, out loud, what they would do to keep it.
— Dexter Dow, Granite State Report
Your Turn
Poll: How should the Legislature choose the next secretary of state?
A) Keep the experienced incumbent · B) The majority should pick its own candidate · C) Whoever answers the date question in public
You tell me: Is your state representative or senator voting Dec. 2? Ask them where they stand and send me the answer. granitestatereport@gmail.com
Fact check
| # | Claim | Status | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | DNC approved its 2028 early calendar by voice vote on Aug. 15, 2026: S.C. Jan. 22, Nev. Feb. 1, N.H. Feb. 8, N.M. Feb. 15, Mich. Feb. 22, Va. Feb. 29. | ATTRIBUTED | Washington Examiner, Aug. 15, 2026; South Carolina Daily Gazette/States Newsroom, Aug. 17, 2026; New Hampshire Bulletin, Nov. 20, 2026 |
| 2 | Stiffer DNC penalties: loss of all delegates and a $270,000 fine. | ATTRIBUTED | Washington Examiner, Aug. 15, 2026 |
| 3 | Howard Dean quote on the new early states. | ATTRIBUTED | Associated Press, via NBC New York |
| 4 | Scanlan plans to disregard the DNC order and go first; “very nimble state” quote. | ATTRIBUTED | William Skipworth, New Hampshire Bulletin, Nov. 20, 2026 |
| 5 | RSA 653:9 text and the secretary of state’s sole authority over the date. | VERIFIED | RSA 653:9, General Court website |
| 6 | Jan. 22, 2028 is a Saturday; seven days earlier is Jan. 15; last Tuesday on or before is Jan. 11. | VERIFIED | GSR calendar computation. This is GSR’s reading of the statute, not an announced date. |
| 7 | Gardner served 45 years, retired January 2022; Scanlan was his deputy. | ATTRIBUTED | Boston Globe, Nov. 18, 2026; WMUR, Nov. 19, 2026 |
| 8 | Scanlan set the Jan. 23, 2024 primary in November 2023 with both state party leaders present; DNC did not recognize it; Biden won as a write-in. | ATTRIBUTED | New Hampshire Bulletin, Nov. 16, 2023 and Nov. 20, 2026; Portsmouth Herald via Yahoo News |
| 9 | Scanlan’s Nov. 17 press conference; “I have a shot at this”; calls alternative untested; warns against party-line pick. | ATTRIBUTED | Boston Globe, Nov. 18, 2026 |
| 10 | Ayotte backs Scanlan; quote on politicizing the office. | ATTRIBUTED | New Hampshire Bulletin, Nov. 10, 2026 |
| 11 | Maltzie and Buckley statements; all Democratic candidates say they will follow state law. | ATTRIBUTED | WMUR, Nov. 19, 2026 |
| 12 | Constitution, Part Second, Art. 67: joint ballot of senators and representatives in one room. | VERIFIED | NH.gov, State Constitution text |
| 13 | 424 lawmakers; Democrats hold close to 300 of 400 House seats and 15 of 24 Senate seats; vote set for Dec. 2. | ATTRIBUTED | New Hampshire Bulletin, Nov. 10, 2026; Boston Globe, Nov. 18, 2026 |
| 14 | Candidates’ backgrounds (Beriont, Butler, Long); Soucy mentioned as possible candidate. | ATTRIBUTED | New Hampshire Bulletin, Nov. 10, 2026 |
| 15 | Soucy spoke at the DNC’s August meeting. | ATTRIBUTED | South Carolina Daily Gazette/States Newsroom, Aug. 17, 2026 |
| 16 | Candidate forums closed to the public, open to incoming Democratic lawmakers. | ATTRIBUTED | Boston Globe, Nov. 18, 2026 |
| 17 | Butler, Beriont and Long priorities; Butler quote; office duties; GOP control 2021-2026; Scanlan two decades as deputy. | ATTRIBUTED | Boston Globe, Nov. 11, 2026 |
| 18 | Dec. 2 is 12 days after Nov. 20; S.C. to N.H. on the DNC plan is 17 days. | VERIFIED | GSR calendar computation |
Send answers, documents or corrections to the editor. Candidate answers will be published unedited.
granitestatereport@gmail.com · 603-931-9264
Editor’s note. Every factual claim above was checked against the sources in the fact-check table. Most rows are ATTRIBUTED because they rest on other outlets’ reporting of statements and votes GSR did not witness. GSR has not interviewed Scanlan or the challengers for this piece; their positions come from those published reports, and each will get the same offer to answer the questions above in full. This piece criticizes the closed candidate forums described by the Boston Globe; GSR did not reach the New Hampshire Democratic Party for comment before same-day publication and will add any response it sends. The chart is a GSR original. The narration is a synthetic voice reading this text. Corrections: Granite State Report corrects verified errors promptly and appends a note identifying what changed and when.

