Independent New Hampshire Journalism · Northfield, NHA reader asked whether vacation homes and short-term rentals pushed families out. Census data for every town shows the student decline hit nearly everywhere, with one narrower exception.
A reader from New York’s Adirondacks wrote to Granite State Report after reading our piece on falling school enrollment. In his part of New York, he wrote, restaurants and churches have closed and locals have been pushed out as buyers from downstate turned houses into second homes and short-term rentals. He suspected New Hampshire’s student losses came from the same thing, and he suggested we check.
We checked. GSR pulled U.S. Census Bureau survey data for every town, city and unincorporated place in New Hampshire and compared two five-year windows, 2006 to 2010 and 2019 to 2023. The question was simple: did towns full of second homes, or towns that added the most of them, lose more of their public-school students?
The answer is mostly no. Students fell nearly everywhere, and most of the loss came from towns with almost no second homes. One narrower pattern does show up. Towns where second homes grew fastest lost more students than the rest, but the town-by-town data is too noisy to call that a cause.
Related coverage: this piece follows New Hampshire’s Public Schools Lost a Fifth of Their Students From 2000 to 2023. No State Lost a Larger Share. That piece used federal school enrollment counts. This one uses Census survey estimates of public-school students by where they live, over a shorter span, so the two percentages are not directly comparable.
The decline is statewide
In the 2006–2010 survey window, about 200,300 New Hampshire residents were enrolled in public school from kindergarten through 12th grade. In the 2019–2023 window, about 168,500 were. That is a drop of 15.9 percent. The number of children under 18 fell 13.2 percent over the same span.
The drop reached almost every corner of the state. Of the 233 places with public-school students in the earlier window, 174 had fewer in the later one. Manchester fell 13.4 percent, Nashua 19.7 percent, Concord 12.9 percent and Derry 19.8 percent. None of those cities has many second homes.
Sorting towns by second homes
The Census counts a home as seasonal when it sits vacant because its owner uses it for vacations, recreation or occasional stays. In the earlier window, about 10.1 percent of New Hampshire’s homes were seasonal. In the later one, about 10.2 percent were. Across the whole state, in these survey windows, the share barely moved.
GSR sorted every town into four groups by how many of its homes were seasonal at the start, then added up the students in each group.
| Seasonal share of homes, 2006–10 | Towns | Public K–12 students, 2006–10 | 2019–23 | Change |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Under 5% | 93 | 147,617 | 124,772 | −15.5% |
| 5% to 15% | 45 | 22,085 | 18,464 | −16.4% |
| 15% to 30% | 39 | 15,614 | 13,031 | −16.5% |
| 30% or more | 62 | 14,967 | 12,268 | −18.0% |
Source: U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 5-year estimates, tables B14002, B25004 and B25024, computed by GSR. Students are counted where they live. Group totals carry margins of error of roughly 800 to 2,900 students.
The towns most dominated by second homes did lose a larger share of their students, but only by about 2.5 percentage points more than towns with almost none. The bigger fact sits in the first row. Towns where fewer than one home in 20 is seasonal lost about 22,800 students. That is about 72 percent of the statewide drop.

Where the reader has a point
A town’s share of second homes is one measure. Growth is another. Among the 183 towns with at least 1,000 people, GSR split them into thirds by how many seasonal homes they added for every 100 homes they had at the start.
The third that added the most, about six seasonal homes per 100, lost 21.3 percent of their resident public-school students. The other two thirds each lost 14.6 percent. The fast-growth towns also grew more slowly overall, adding 2.9 percent to their population while the others added 5.8 to 7.8 percent.
That gap is the strongest evidence in the data for the reader’s idea, and it comes with three warnings.
First, those towns were already older. Residents 65 and over made up 16.0 percent of their population at the start and 23.7 percent at the end, more than in the other groups. An older town has fewer families to begin with. Second, the gap between the groups is about as large as the survey’s margin of error for those totals. Third, at the level of single towns the link nearly disappears. A statistical test that weighted each town by its number of students could not tell the effect of added second homes apart from zero.
Single towns show why. Bartlett and Alton, where nearly half of homes or more are seasonal, lost about 55 and 37 percent of their resident students. Moultonborough and Gilford, also heavy second-home towns, lost almost none. The survey’s margins for towns that size run to hundreds of students, so no single town settles the question.
What else the record shows
A 2023 study by New Hampshire Housing, the state’s housing finance authority, found that short-term rentals cut the state’s vacancy rate by 14 percent from 2014 to 2023. In Lincoln, more than 40 percent of housing units were listed as short-term rentals.
The pandemic briefly pushed the other way. In 2020, school officials in Conway and Waterville Valley reported new students from families that had moved into their second homes full time. Officials in Laconia, Moultonborough and Alton reported no such surge.
What Montana did
The reader pointed to Montana, which changed how it taxes second homes. Under laws signed in 2025, Montana now taxes primary residences and long-term rentals at lower tiered rates. Starting in 2026, second homes and short-term rentals pay a flat 1.90 percent rate. New Hampshire has no such split. The 2026 tax year is the first under Montana’s new rates, and whether they change who lives in its resort towns will take years to show.
The bottom line
New Hampshire’s schools are losing students for reasons that reach every town, including fewer births and an older population. Second homes do not explain the statewide drop. The towns where second homes grew fastest did lose more students, and that pattern is worth watching as the state argues over housing. It is not proof.
The reader asked a good question, and the data answered part of it. If your town’s school has lost families to rising prices, second homes or short-term rentals, GSR wants to hear the specifics.
— Granite State Report
Your Turn
Poll: What do you think is the biggest reason New Hampshire schools have fewer students?
A) Fewer births · B) Housing costs pushing families out · C) Second homes and short-term rentals · D) Families choosing private school or homeschool
Short survey: (1) What town do you live in? (2) Has your town’s school lost students or merged classes in the last ten years? (3) Do you know of homes in your neighborhood that became second homes or short-term rentals? About how many? (4) Have you or someone you know left town because of housing costs? (5) May GSR contact you to follow up, and may we use your name? Send answers to granitestatereport@gmail.com. GSR keeps survey answers only for its reporting, does not sell them, and deletes contact details on request.
Talk about it: Should New Hampshire tax second homes at a different rate than primary homes, as Montana now does? And: what has changed in your town’s school over the last decade?
Fact check
| # | Claim | Status | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Resident public K–12 students: about 200,283 (2006–10) and 168,535 (2019–23), down 15.9%; children under 18 down 13.2%; 174 of 233 places with students in 2006–10 had fewer in 2019–23. | VERIFIED | Census ACS 5-year, B14002 and B01001, 2010 and 2023 releases; computed in code by GSR |
| 2 | Statewide seasonal share of homes about 10.1% (2006–10) and 10.2% (2019–23). | VERIFIED | Census ACS 5-year, B25004 and B25024; computed by GSR |
| 3 | Group table: four seasonal-share groups lost 15.5%, 16.4%, 16.5% and 18.0%; under-5% towns account for about 72% of the drop. | VERIFIED | Census ACS 5-year; computed by GSR |
| 4 | Among 183 towns of 1,000+, the third adding the most seasonal homes lost 21.3% vs. 14.6%; population grew 2.9% vs. 5.8–7.8%; 65+ share 16.0% to 23.7%; town-level weighted regression coefficient not distinguishable from zero (95% bootstrap interval −1.4 to +0.4). | VERIFIED | Census ACS 5-year; computed by GSR |
| 5 | Town figures for Manchester, Nashua, Concord, Derry, Bartlett, Alton, Moultonborough and Gilford. | VERIFIED | Census ACS 5-year; margins of error reported in GSR’s data file |
| 6 | Short-term rentals cut the state’s vacancy rate 14% from 2014 to 2023; more than 40% of Lincoln’s units are short-term rentals. | ATTRIBUTED | NHPR, Oct. 6, 2023, on New Hampshire Housing’s report |
| 7 | In 2020, Conway and Waterville Valley saw new students from second-home families; Laconia, Moultonborough and Alton did not report a surge. | ATTRIBUTED | NH Business Review, 2020; Concord Monitor, Nov. 6, 2020 |
| 8 | Montana taxes primary residences and long-term rentals at lower tiered rates; second homes and short-term rentals pay a flat 1.90% from 2026; laws signed in 2025. | VERIFIED | Montana Department of Revenue; Montana Free Press Capitol Tracker, HB 231 |
| 9 | The reader’s account of closures and displacement in the Adirondacks. | ATTRIBUTED | Reader email to GSR, Nov. 17, 2026 |
Reach the editor directly, with confidentiality respected where possible.
granitestatereport@gmail.com · (603) 931-9264
Editor’s note. GSR computed every figure from Census data in code. Students are counted by where they live, not by the district they attend, so tuition arrangements, cooperative districts and shifts to private school or homeschooling are not captured. Survey estimates for small towns carry wide margins of error; group totals reduce but do not remove that noise. Correlation is not cause. The reader who raised the question is not named here. Corrections: Granite State Report corrects verified errors promptly and appends a note identifying what changed and when.

