Independent New Hampshire Journalism · Northfield, NHThe school tax cap question on every New Hampshire ballot for the Nov. 3, 2026, general election got past a superior court judge, a single Supreme Court justice and four justices of the Supreme Court in 12 days. Here is what each order decided, what none of them reached, and how the vote will be counted.
Correction, Oct. 15, 2026: This article said any 10 registered voters “from a town in the district” may ask for a recount. RSA 32:5-i, VII covers voters in any municipality the district serves, which includes cities. The sentence now says so. The article also quoted the text of the Supreme Court’s Sept. 28 order and named the justices who sat; the archived copy of that order could not be reopened for this review, so the passage now reports the ruling as InDepthNH.org and NHPR described it, and the fact-check table marks it ATTRIBUTED. The link to HB 1300’s final text now points to a copy that opens to the chaptered version. Two long news-outlet quotes were shortened. No other fact changed.
Update, Oct. 15, 2026: Bedford held a public hearing on the question on Oct. 13; nearly 50 residents attended, NHPR reported. NHPR also reported that whether ballots left blank on the question count toward the three-fifths total is unlikely to be settled until the attorney general’s office issues guidance.
Narrated with a synthetic voice. Download the MP3.
When Merrimack County Superior Court Judge Daniel I. St. Hilaire refused to block New Hampshire’s school tax cap question, he pointed to ways any confusion could be addressed. “As any lack of clarity in the Ballot Question can be addressed via appropriate publications, radio addresses, and public hearing commentary,” he wrote on Sept. 16, 2026, the court could not conclude that the two voters who sued faced “an immediate danger of irreparable harm” on that claim.
The statute that put the question on the ballot allows those hearings. It does not require one. On hearings, RSA 32:5-i says only that “Nothing in this section shall prohibit a municipality, school board, or school administrative unit board from holding a public hearing” on the question. The older law towns and school districts use to adopt a tax cap of their own, RSA 32:5-c, requires a hearing at least 15 days and no more than 30 days before the vote.
Granite State Report reported in July that the question’s description of the caps and the statute’s formula do not line up. Since then two voters sued, and three court orders let the question stand. This article reads those orders, and the statute they applied.

How the question got on every ballot
House Bill 1300 became Chapter 324 of the 2026 laws when Gov. Kelly Ayotte signed it on July 15, 2026. The House adopted the final version 183 to 170 on June 4, and the Senate adopted it 15 to 8 the same day. The new section, RSA 32:5-i, took effect Sept. 1, 2026.
It orders every town, and every ward in a city, to vote on the question at the November 2026 and November 2028 state general elections. The question appears “by operation of law and shall not require a warrant article, citizen petition, or separate local legislative approval.” As published in October 2026, the section expires Jan. 1, 2032, and any cap adopted under it ends that day.
One yes-or-no vote decides two caps. The first limits how much a school district’s property tax levy can grow: the prior year’s levy times one plus inflation plus “net new taxable property growth.” Bond costs for buying, building or making major structural renovations to real property, once the state certifies them, are left out of the calculation. Inflation is the 12-month change in the Consumer Price Index for All Urban Consumers, Northeast Region, using the figure published for March of the prior fiscal year. The second cap holds a school administrative unit’s central office spending to 6 percent of its member districts’ total appropriations, again leaving out bonded capital projects. The full ballot wording and how it compares with the formula are laid out in GSR’s July report.
The lawsuit
David Bates, a taxpayer in Warner who lives in the Kearsarge School District, and Kelly Wieser, an attorney and vice chair of the Campton School Board, filed suit in Merrimack County Superior Court on Aug. 31, 2026. They sued Secretary of State David M. Scanlan, the official who prepares the ballots, and asked the court to keep the question off the November ballot. Edward J. Sackman of the Hinckley Allen firm and Samira Omerovic represented them. Samuel R.V. Garland of the Attorney General’s Civil Law Bureau represented the secretary.
Their complaint attacked the wording on three grounds, all under Part I, Article 11 of the state constitution, which guarantees free elections and an equal right to vote. First, they said, the question is confusing. Second, it is misleading, because it “affirmatively assures voters that adopting the school funding caps will not impact classroom and other school-based services, even though both caps will inevitably affect both.” Third, it forces “a single vote—for or against the pair of school funding caps” though, they argued, the statute contemplates a separate choice on each.
“I’m unsure what it would mean for my children,” Bates said when the suit was filed, according to InDepthNH.org. He said he was just as unsure what it would mean for hundreds of children in his district, and for taxpayers.
From the Final Vote to the Ballot
HB 1300 and the challenge to its ballot question, by date, with the record for each step
| Date (2026) | What happened | Record |
|---|---|---|
| June 4 | House adopts the final version, 183–170; Senate adopts it, 15–8 | HB 1300 docket |
| July 15 | Gov. Ayotte signs HB 1300, Chapter 324 | HB 1300 docket; chaptered law |
| Aug. 31 | Bates and Wieser sue the secretary of state in Merrimack County Superior Court, No. 217-2026-CV-00671 | Complaint, file stamp |
| Sept. 1 | RSA 32:5-i takes effect | Chapter 324, section 4 |
| Sept. 11 | Superior court hearing on the request for an injunction | Sept. 16 order |
| Sept. 16 | Judge St. Hilaire denies a preliminary injunction | Sept. 16 order |
| Sept. 17 | Justice Gould, sitting alone, denies an emergency restraining order, Supreme Court Case No. 2026-0612 | Sept. 17 order |
| Sept. 28 | The Supreme Court, four justices sitting, unanimously declines to take the case and gives no reason | InDepthNH.org and NHPR reports |
| Nov. 3 | State general election; the question is on the ballot in every town and city ward | RSA 32:5-i, I; complaint, ¶ 78 |
Granite State Report · Sources: HB 1300 docket and chaptered text, General Court; complaint and orders in Bates v. Scanlan, Merrimack County Superior Court; orders in Petition of David Bates & a., N.H. Supreme Court.
What the superior court decided
St. Hilaire ruled on one thing: the request for a preliminary injunction. His 12-page order is titled “Order on Motion for Preliminary Injunctive Relief,” and it ends by denying that request. To win an injunction, he wrote, a party must show it would likely succeed on the merits and that it faces immediate, irreparable harm with no adequate remedy at law. He found the voters had shown neither. The order is not a final ruling on whether the question is constitutional; a preliminary injunction, it notes, quoting an earlier New Hampshire Supreme Court decision, “preserves the status quo pending a final determination of the case on the merits.” He assumed, “without deciding,” that the voters had standing to sue, which the secretary had disputed.
On confusion, the judge applied a test the New Hampshire Supreme Court set out in Concrete, Inc. v. Rheaume Builders (1957) and repeated in Fischer v. Governor (2000): a ballot question “must give ‘the ordinary person a clear idea of what he [or she] is voting for or against.’” Under Concrete, clarity is judged in light of the surrounding circumstances, including voter guides, publications and radio addresses. The plaintiffs offered an expert report on the question’s language and structure by Deborah S. Bosley, and their own statements that the wording confused them. “Notably, however, none of this evidence takes into account the circumstances surrounding the presentation of the Ballot Question to the voters,” the judge wrote. Neither the expert nor the plaintiffs had considered statements at any public hearings that “might be held” under the statute. That analysis, he concluded, “cannot reasonably be performed on a prospective basis.”
On the claim that the question misleads, the plaintiffs filed affidavits from two people with school budgeting experience, Nathan Greenberg and Daniel Rossner, and a memorandum from Nate Byrne, the Northwood superintendent. The judge found that the plaintiffs’ offers of proof at the hearing described effects that “could” occur, not effects that inevitably would. He pointed to Greenberg’s own statement that the “availability of [school] funding sources other than property taxes is uncertain,” sources Greenberg put at about one third of a district’s revenue. “Given the speculative and uncertain nature of the evidence in the record,” St. Hilaire wrote, the plaintiffs had not shown they were likely to win on that point. In a footnote, he wrote that Byrne’s unsworn memorandum did not specify the staffing and program changes it predicted, and so the court could not conclude it lent meaningful support to the plaintiffs’ case.
On the single vote, the judge read the statute to call for one question, and he described how that one vote can still produce different results. Some school administrative units serve one district and some serve several. The district cap is counted among voters in each district; the central office cap is counted among all voters in the unit. A single question, he wrote, “could result in three possible outcomes: the adoption of neither cap, the adoption of only one cap, or the adoption of both caps.” And if lawmakers meant voters to decide each cap separately, “the Legislature can amend the statute prior to the 2028 general election.”
The judge also pointed to the override. A district that adopts a cap can exceed it by a three-fifths vote, the same fraction it takes to adopt one, unless a charter sets a different supermajority. He did not reach the parties’ arguments on the balance of the equities.
At the hearing, Garland told the judge, “There are some questions that the courts have recognized are political questions that need to be resolved in the political process,” NHPR reported.
What the Supreme Court decided
The voters then petitioned the New Hampshire Supreme Court. On Sept. 17, Justice Gould, acting alone under the court’s Rule 21(7), denied their emergency motion for a temporary restraining order in one sentence.
On Sept. 28 the court ruled on the petition itself and declined to take the case. The decision of the four justices was unanimous, InDepthNH.org reported, and the court did not give a reason, NHPR reported. Neither Supreme Court order addresses whether the question’s wording is lawful.
The hearing that may or may not happen
Two parts of the superior court’s reasoning look ahead to what voters will read and hear before they vote. The confusion claim, the judge wrote, could not be judged until those surrounding circumstances exist. And any lack of clarity could be addressed through publications, radio addresses and public hearing commentary. The judge also noted that RSA 32:5-i “clarifies that the statute does not ‘prohibit’” a hearing. The statute leaves that choice to municipalities, school boards and administrative unit boards.
The contrast with the law it sits beside is plain on the page.
Two Ways to Cap School Taxes in New Hampshire
The local-option tax cap and the new statewide school tax cap question, as published by the General Court in October 2026
| Rule | Local-option cap (RSA 32:5-b, adopted under RSA 32:5-c) | School tax cap question (RSA 32:5-i) |
|---|---|---|
| How it reaches voters | A warrant article placed by the governing body or by petition (32:5-c, II) | On the state general election ballot “by operation of law,” with no warrant article, petition or local approval (32:5-i, I–II) |
| Public hearing | Required, at least 15 and no more than 30 days before the vote, in each town of a multi-town district (32:5-c, III) | Allowed: “Nothing in this section shall prohibit” one (32:5-i, III) |
| When voters decide | At the annual meeting (32:5-c, I–II) | The November 2026 and November 2028 state general elections (32:5-i, I) |
| Votes needed | Three-fifths of those voting on the question; only yes and no votes count (32:5-c, I) | Three-fifths of “the voters voting in the municipalities and wards served by the school district” (32:5-i, VI) |
| How it ends | Voters may rescind it by a three-fifths vote (32:5-c, VI) | The section expires Jan. 1, 2032, and caps adopted under it lose legal effect (32:5-i, XVII) |
Granite State Report · Sources: RSA 32:5-b, 32:5-c and 32:5-i, Revised Statutes Annotated, as published by the General Court.
How the Nov. 3 vote will be counted
- District cap. It binds a school district if three-fifths of the voters voting in all the towns and wards the district serves approve. The count is district-wide, not town by town. That paragraph does not say whether ballots left blank on the question count toward the total; the override paragraph says only yes and no votes count. GSR’s July report laid out why that matters.
- Central office cap. It binds a school administrative unit if three-fifths of the voters voting in all the towns and wards the unit serves approve.
- Reporting. Each town or ward moderator reports the result to the secretary of the school administrative unit board, who certifies it to the Department of Revenue Administration.
- Recount. Any 10 registered voters from any town or city the district serves may apply in writing to the school district clerk within 7 days of the election, with a $10 fee. A recount on the central office cap goes to the unit’s secretary under the same terms.
- When a cap starts. A cap approved in November 2026 applies beginning with the fiscal year 2028 budget.
- Enforcement. The Department of Revenue Administration may not approve a tax rate above a certified limit unless the budget is within the cap or a valid override vote was taken, and any taxpayer in a member district has standing to enforce the section in superior court.
- Existing caps. A stricter limit already in law, a city charter or a local ordinance stays in force, and every applicable limit must be met. The plaintiffs’ complaint lists Dover, Franklin, Laconia, Manchester, Rochester and Somersworth as cities with tax caps in their charters.
What both sides say
Ayotte, signing the bill, said in a statement reported by NHPR: “This bill gives voters a say about their local property taxes and ensures Granite Staters’ voices are heard.” After the superior court ruling, Rep. Ross Berry, R-Weare, chair of the House Election Law Committee, called it “a win for every New Hampshire taxpayer” and said, “This question is simple, should voters decide when to rein in out-of-control property taxes?” InDepthNH.org reported.
Megan Tuttle, president of NEA-New Hampshire, said in July that voters can already cap local school budgets and taxes and have repeatedly chosen not to, “because they understand the real costs schools face,” NHPR reported. She named utilities, health care premiums and student support services. House Minority Leader Alexis Simpson, D-Exeter, faulted the ruling for letting a question she considers deliberately misleading reach voters, according to InDepthNH.org.
The judge drew no conclusion about whether a cap is good policy, and neither does this article. The three orders keep the question on the November 2026 ballot. Whether voters hear it explained in a public hearing before they mark it is left to local boards. For the property tax bill the caps would act on, see GSR’s guide to the four lines on a New Hampshire tax bill.
— Granite State Report
Your Turn
Tell us: has your school board or school administrative unit scheduled a public hearing on the tax cap question, or decided not to hold one? Send the notice, the date or the minutes to granitestatereport@gmail.com. No person or agency named in this article was asked to comment for it. Any of them may write to the same address; a response will be added here with its date.
Fact check
| # | Claim | Status | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | House Bill 1300 became Chapter 324 when Gov. Ayotte signed it July 15, 2026; the House adopted the final version 183–170 and the Senate 15–8 on June 4, 2026; RSA 32:5-i took effect Sept. 1, 2026. | VERIFIED | HB 1300 docket and roll calls, and chaptered final version, sections 324:1 and 324:4, General Court, read Oct. 5, 2026. |
| 2 | RSA 32:5-i requires a vote in every town and city ward at the November 2026 and November 2028 state general elections, by operation of law and without a warrant article, petition or local approval; the section expires Jan. 1, 2032. | VERIFIED | RSA 32:5-i, I and XVII; Chapter 324:3. |
| 3 | The levy formula, the inflation measure (12-month change, Consumer Price Index for All Urban Consumers, Northeast Region, March of the prior fiscal year), the exclusion of certified bond costs for acquisition, construction or major structural renovation of real property, and the 6 percent central office cap. | VERIFIED | RSA 32:5-i, VIII, IX and XVI. |
| 4 | RSA 32:5-i, III says nothing in the section prohibits a hearing and requires none; RSA 32:5-c, III requires a hearing 15 to 30 days before a local tax cap vote, in each town of a multi-town district. | VERIFIED | RSA 32:5-i, III; RSA 32:5-c, III. |
| 5 | The local-option cap is placed by warrant article or petition, decided at the annual meeting by three-fifths of yes and no votes, and may be rescinded by three-fifths. | VERIFIED | RSA 32:5-c, I, II and VI. |
| 6 | Bates lives in Warner, in the Kearsarge School District; Wieser is an attorney and vice chair of the Campton School Board; they sued Secretary of State David M. Scanlan on Aug. 31, 2026, in Merrimack County Superior Court, No. 217-2026-CV-00671, represented by Edward J. Sackman of Hinckley Allen and Samira Omerovic; and Samuel R.V. Garland of the Attorney General’s Civil Law Bureau represented the secretary. | VERIFIED | Complaint, caption, file stamp, ¶¶ 4–6, signature block and certificate of service; NHPR, Sept. 17, 2026 (Garland argued for the state at the hearing); Supreme Court orders of Sept. 17 and 28, distribution lists. |
| 7 | The complaint’s three grounds under Part I, Article 11, and the quoted language. | VERIFIED | Complaint, ¶ 2 and introduction. |
| 8 | Bates’s quoted and paraphrased statement. | ATTRIBUTED | InDepthNH.org, Garry Rayno, Sept. 16, 2026. |
| 9 | The superior court held a hearing Sept. 11, 2026; the Sept. 16 order is titled “Order on Motion for Preliminary Injunctive Relief,” runs 12 pages, denies that request, quotes the “status quo pending a final determination” standard, assumes standing “without deciding,” and declines to address the balance of the equities. | VERIFIED | Superior court order, Sept. 16, 2026, at 1, 3 and 12. |
| 10 | The Concrete and Fischer standard, the Bosley report, and the quoted passages on confusion, including “might be held” and “prospective basis.” | VERIFIED | Same order, at 4–6. |
| 11 | The Greenberg and Rossner affidavits, the Byrne memorandum and the court’s footnote 1 finding on it, counsel’s “could” offers of proof, the quoted Greenberg passages, and “speculative and uncertain.” | VERIFIED | Same order, at 6–7 and n. 1. |
| 12 | The single-question reading, the three-outcomes passage, the amend-before-2028 passage, and the matching three-fifths override threshold. | VERIFIED | Same order, at 8–12. |
| 13 | The lede quotation on publications, radio addresses and hearing commentary, and the “clarifies” passage on RSA 32:5-i, III. | VERIFIED | Same order, at 10. |
| 14 | Garland’s quoted statement at the hearing. | ATTRIBUTED | NHPR, Annmarie Timmins, Sept. 17, 2026. |
| 15 | On Sept. 17, 2026, a single justice (Gould, J.) denied the emergency motion for a temporary restraining order under Rule 21(7), Case No. 2026-0612. | VERIFIED | N.H. Supreme Court order, Sept. 17, 2026. |
| 16 | On Sept. 28, 2026, the four justices unanimously declined to take the case and gave no reason; neither Supreme Court order addresses the wording. | ATTRIBUTED | InDepthNH.org, Garry Rayno, Sept. 29, 2026 (unanimous, four justices); NHPR, Annmarie Timmins, Sept. 28, 2026 (no reason given); Sept. 17 order. The archived copy of the Sept. 28 order could not be reopened for the Oct. 15, 2026, review. |
| 17 | District-wide and unit-wide three-fifths counts; reporting to the unit board secretary and certification to the Department of Revenue Administration; the 10-voter, 7-day, $10 recount; the fiscal 2028 start; rate approval and taxpayer standing; stricter existing limits stay in force. | VERIFIED | RSA 32:5-i, VI, VII, X, XI, XII, XIII and XIV. |
| 18 | The complaint lists Dover, Franklin, Laconia, Manchester, Rochester and Somersworth as cities with charter tax caps. | VERIFIED | Complaint, ¶ 76 (the plaintiffs’ statement). |
| 19 | The 2026 state general election falls on Nov. 3, 2026. | VERIFIED | Complaint, ¶ 78; 2 U.S.C. § 7 (the Tuesday after the first Monday in November of even-numbered years). |
| 20 | Ayotte’s quoted statement on signing. | ATTRIBUTED | NHPR, Annmarie Timmins, July 15, 2026. |
| 21 | Berry’s quoted statements after the ruling, and his title. | ATTRIBUTED | InDepthNH.org, Sept. 16, 2026. |
| 22 | Tuttle’s quoted and paraphrased statement. | ATTRIBUTED | NHPR, July 15, 2026. |
| 23 | Simpson said the court allowed a deliberately misleading question to go before voters (paraphrase). | ATTRIBUTED | InDepthNH.org, Sept. 16, 2026. |
| 24 | The State House photograph, by Farragutful, taken April 24, 2022, is licensed CC BY-SA 4.0. | VERIFIED | Wikimedia Commons file page for “New Hampshire State House 01.jpg,” read Oct. 5, 2026. |
| 25 | Bedford held a public hearing Oct. 13, 2026, attended by nearly 50 residents; how blank ballots count is unlikely to be settled before attorney general guidance. | ATTRIBUTED | NHPR, Annmarie Timmins, Oct. 14, 2026. |
Hearing notices, school board minutes, court filings and the dates on them are what build the record. Confidentiality respected where possible. granitestatereport@gmail.com · (603) 931-9264.
Editor’s note. The account of the lawsuit is drawn from the complaint filed Aug. 31, 2026, in Merrimack County Superior Court, the superior court’s order of Sept. 16, 2026, and the New Hampshire Supreme Court’s orders of Sept. 17 and Sept. 28, 2026. The legislative history is drawn from the General Court’s docket for HB 1300, and statutes are quoted from the Revised Statutes Annotated as published by the General Court. Statements by officials, the plaintiffs and others are attributed to NHPR and InDepthNH.org as noted. Granite State Report is a newsroom, not a law firm, and nothing here is legal advice.
Corrections: Granite State Report corrects verified errors promptly and appends a dated note identifying what changed and when. The corrections policy and the corrections register are public, and correction notes are never removed.

