Sunday, 15 November 2026
Trending
Civil LibertiesImmigrationPublic Records Requests

Fourteen Months to Answer a Five-Day Law

A historic brick courthouse displays New Hampshire police and immigration records services beside a courthouse security vehicle.
Independent New Hampshire Journalism · Northfield, NH
Public Records · Immigration Enforcement
Fourteen Months to Answer a Five-Day Law

The ACLU has taken the New Hampshire State Police to court over immigration records. The filing exposes a Right-to-Know Law that only works for people who can afford to sue.

Loading the Elevenlabs Text to Speech AudioNative Player...

Update, Sept. 22, 2026, 7:50 a.m. EDT: Relative dates were made specific, a reader poll was removed, and the RSA 91-A:4 citation now includes its 2026 amendment. No facts changed.

The New Hampshire State Police told the American Civil Liberties Union it would need until November 24, 2026 to answer a public records request the ACLU filed on September 12, 2025. Fourteen months of processing time, for a statute that gives agencies five business days to respond.

Disclosure: Granite State Report files public-records requests as a routine part of its reporting.

On August 25, the ACLU of New Hampshire took the State Police to Merrimack County Superior Court over that request and three others. The petition is worth reading for what it documents about how New Hampshire’s largest police force enforces federal immigration law. It is worth reading more closely for what it accidentally documents about RSA 91-A, which now functions roughly like this: an agency that would rather not produce a record can decline to produce it more or less indefinitely, and the only people who can do anything about that are the ones who can afford to hire lawyers.

The ACLU can. The Boston Globe can. A resident of Northfield with a question about her town’s police department cannot.

Four requests, one pattern

The petition, filed by ACLU-NH legal director Gilles Bissonnette and five other staff attorneys, covers four requests. The oldest, from September 2025, sought training materials given to troopers deputized under ICE’s 287(g) task force program. The other three, filed in March, April, and May 2026, sought records of specific stops and detentions, including two men the ACLU says were pulled over on Interstate 89 between exits 19 and 20 in May.

Track what happened to the training request. The State Police acknowledged it a week later and asked for 60 business days. In December it asked for another 30. In February it moved the date to May 1. In April it moved the date to June 30, citing an attorney’s month-long absence. On July 16 it wrote that “we will need until November 24, 2026” to finish evaluating the records.

Every one of those letters was lawful on its face. That is the problem.

What five business days buys you

RSA 91-A:4, IV(b) gives a public body three options when it cannot produce a record immediately. It can produce the record. It can deny the request in writing. Or it can provide a written statement of “the time reasonably necessary” to decide, plus the reason for the delay.

RSA 91-A:4, IV(b). Within 5 business days of a request, a public body or agency must either make the record available, deny the request, or provide a written statement of the time reasonably necessary to determine whether the request will be granted or denied, and the reason for the delay. Nothing in the paragraph limits how many times that statement can be reissued. Read RSA 91-A:4 →

Read that third option again. It is a promise to decide later. The statute attaches no cap to it, no outside limit, no penalty for missing the date the agency picked for itself. An agency that reissues the statement every few months has complied with the letter of the law every single time, and the requester has nothing to show for a year of correspondence.

The State Police did not invent this. It read the statute correctly.

Thirty-four minutes

There is one number in the ACLU petition that settles the question of whether these delays are about workload.

The Boston Globe asked the State Police for immigration enforcement records on November 10, 2025. The agency took four months to respond at all, then said in June it would need until October 8, 2026 to sort out what was exempt. The Globe sued on July 27. According to the ACLU’s filing, the State Police produced the records about 34 minutes later.

Records that had been under legal review for eight months turned out to be sitting in a file, producible, the same hour a filing fee cleared.

The ACLU petition adds a detail that makes this worse. Based on records the State Police later gave the Globe, the agency did not contact ICE about the November 2025 request until July 13, 2026. ICE signed off on releasing the records on July 16. The State Police sat on them for another eleven days, until the lawsuit landed.

Any agency can be slow. Slow is a budget problem, and New Hampshire agencies have real ones. What happened here is different in kind. The records existed, the legal review was finished, the federal partner had approved release, and the documents still did not move until someone paid a lawyer to make them move.

A federal veto that does not exist

Running underneath all of this is a jurisdictional claim that deserves more attention than it has gotten.

The State Police told the ACLU in August that 287(g) case records “would be considered joint records with DHS” and that it must confer with ICE before releasing anything. The ACLU says ICE has gone further with local departments. The petition attaches emails from June 2026 in which a federal official instructs a New Hampshire police department to route Right-to-Know requests through ICE and to make contact “prior to any release of info.”

That is a federal agency asserting a veto over New Hampshire public records. No such veto exists. RSA 91-A:5 lists the exemptions from disclosure, and none of them covers records a federal partner would prefer stayed quiet. The State Police’s own agreement with ICE says the arrangement does not limit compliance with state public records law as to records that are “solely state records and not ICE records.” New Hampshire courts have already held that a police department cannot contract its way out of RSA 91-A; the Supreme Court said as much in Stone v. City of Claremont in 2024, where a confidentiality agreement failed to shield disciplinary records.

A trooper’s incident report from a stop on I-89 is a New Hampshire record. It was written by a state employee, on state time, in a state cruiser, about a stop on a state highway. The federal government’s interest in that document does not convert it into a federal one.

The office that is supposed to handle this

New Hampshire built a cheaper alternative to litigation and then let it die.

The Legislature created the Office of the Right-to-Know Ombudsman in 2022 so residents could challenge a stonewall without hiring counsel. Thomas Kehr, appointed by Gov. Chris Sununu, resigned effective July 1, 2025, after lawmakers cut the position’s salary and operating budget from $105,000 to $30,000. Cases still pending when the cuts took effect were dismissed. As of July 2, 2026, according to reporting by the New Hampshire Bulletin, Gov. Kelly Ayotte had not nominated a replacement. The Concord Monitor reported in March that the governor’s office said no one had applied.

So the ombudsman’s docket is closed, and the only route left is the one the ACLU took on August 25, 2026: a petition in superior court under RSA 91-A:7, with a request for fees under RSA 91-A:8 where the agency knew or should have known it was breaking the law.

Consider what that means for enforcement. The people who can use New Hampshire’s Right-to-Know Law against a resistant agency are a civil liberties organization with six lawyers on the caption and a metropolitan daily newspaper. Both of them went to Merrimack County Superior Court in summer 2026, suing the same agency over the same subject. Everyone else gets the written statement of time reasonably necessary, and then another one.

What the records would show

The underlying subject matter is not procedural. The State Police signed its ICE agreement on April 10, 2025, and 58 troopers had been nominated for the program by that September, according to the Globe. Twenty-eight New Hampshire law enforcement agencies participated as of August 2026, a figure confirmed by the Keene Sentinel when Rindge became the latest to sign. New Hampshire is the only New England state where local police have taken on this authority under the task force model.

There is money attached. ICE has advertised a one-time payment of $100,000 for transportation and $7,500 per credentialed officer for equipment, plus quarterly stipends. The ACLU petition states that the Carroll Police Department deposited $122,515 from ICE in March and that Colebrook received $107,500 in connection with an arrest it made in late November 2025. The Valley News reported in July that Carroll has covered the salaries of all four of its full-time officers with federal money, following earlier reporting by WIRED.

Nobody outside the agency knows whether the State Police has taken any of it. That is one of the things the March 2026 request asked about, and the answer was still pending when the ACLU sued. The ACLU calls the agency a “black box” on the subject, and on the public record, that is fair.

The training question matters just as much. The ACLU says troopers get a self-paced online course they cannot print, cannot save, and cannot revisit after the window closes. The State Police told the ACLU in December that it had not distributed training materials outside the online portal. If that is right, then troopers exercising immigration arrest authority on New Hampshire highways are working from memory, and the department has no written standard describing when a trooper may ask about someone’s immigration status.

The fix is small and the Legislature knows it

None of this requires reopening the Right-to-Know Law. It requires closing one gap.

Amend RSA 91-A:4, IV(b)(3) to put an outside limit on the extension: a hard deadline the agency cannot renew past without going to court and justifying it to a judge. Make the second extension the one that requires a reason a court would accept. That single change would end the practice of answering a five-day law on a fourteen-month schedule, and it would cost the state nothing.

Then fill the ombudsman’s chair, and fund it at a number a competent attorney will accept. A $30,000 line item for the only non-judicial enforcement mechanism in the statute is not a budget decision. It is a decision about whether the law applies.

The State Police had not answered these allegations in court at publication, and it is entitled to. But the agency’s position so far, stated in its own emails, is that it needs until late November to finish reviewing training records it requested from ICE in the first place. Governor Ayotte encouraged departments to sign these agreements. Commissioner Robert Quinn welcomed the authority. Both of those were public statements, made willingly, about a program the public was told would make New Hampshire safer.

An agency that has time to enforce federal immigration law has time to tell the people paying for it how that enforcement works.

— Dexter Dow, Granite State Report

Your Turn

You tell me: Have you filed a Right-to-Know request in New Hampshire and gotten a written statement of time instead of records? Send me the correspondence. granitestatereport@gmail.com

Fact check

#ClaimStatusSource
1ACLU-NH filed a RSA 91-A petition against the NH Division of State Police on August 25, 2026, in Merrimack County Superior Court (No. 217-2026-CV-006502).VERIFIEDPetition filed 8/25/2026; ACLU-NH case page.
2RSA 91-A:4, IV(b) gives an agency 5 business days to produce, deny, or provide a written statement of time reasonably necessary, and sets no limit on reissuing that statement.VERIFIEDRSA 91-A:4, NH General Court (as amended through 2026, 206:5).
3The State Police extended its response to the September 12, 2025 training request five times, most recently to November 24, 2026.VERIFIEDPetition ¶¶ 35–39, quoting the agency’s own dated emails.
4The State Police produced records to the Boston Globe roughly 34 minutes after the Globe filed suit on July 27, 2026.ATTRIBUTEDPetition ¶ 12 and Exhibit 8, citing Globe v. NH State Police, No. 217-2026-cv-00576. GSR has not independently reviewed the Globe docket.
5The State Police did not contact ICE about the Globe’s November 2025 request until July 13, 2026; ICE approved release July 16, 2026.ATTRIBUTEDPetition ¶ 12, based on records the State Police produced to the Globe on July 30, 2026.
6An ICE official instructed a NH police department in June 2026 to consult ICE prior to any release of information in response to 91-A requests.ATTRIBUTEDPetition ¶ 13 n.11 and Exhibit 17 (Weare materials). Allegation in a court filing; ICE has not responded on the record.
7The State Police / ICE agreement states it does not limit compliance with state public records law as to records that are solely state records.VERIFIEDMOA section XIII, quoted in Petition ¶ 18 (Exhibit 5, Apr. 25, 2025 MOA).
8The Right-to-Know Ombudsman position has been vacant since July 1, 2025; Kehr resigned after the budget was cut from $105,000 to $30,000; no replacement nominated as of July 2026.VERIFIEDNH Bulletin, July 2, 2026; NHPR, July 6, 2026; Concord Monitor, March 20, 2026 (no applicants; pending cases dismissed).
928 New Hampshire law enforcement agencies participate in the 287(g) program.VERIFIEDPetition ¶ 15; independently confirmed by the Keene Sentinel’s August 2026 report on Rindge PD, citing ICE’s participating-agency list.
10The State Police signed its 287(g) MOA on April 10, 2025; ICE signed April 25, 2025; 58 troopers were nominated as of September 2025.VERIFIEDPetition ¶¶ 16–17 and Exhibit 5 (MOA); trooper figure per Boston Globe, Sept. 12, 2025, cited at Petition ¶ 15 n.14.
11Carroll PD deposited $122,515 from ICE in March 2026; Colebrook PD received $107,500 tied to a late-November 2025 arrest.ATTRIBUTEDPetition ¶ 19 (Carroll figure citing WIRED, Mar. 24, 2026; Colebrook per Exhibit 15). Valley News, July 21, 2026, separately reported Carroll’s officer salaries are federally funded.
12ICE advertises a $100,000 one-time transportation payment and $7,500 per credentialed officer for equipment, plus quarterly stipends.ATTRIBUTEDPetition ¶¶ 11–12 and Exhibit 10, quoting an ICE stipend fact sheet. Figures are ICE’s own published terms.
13New Hampshire Supreme Court held in Stone v. City of Claremont (2024) that a confidentiality agreement did not block disclosure of police disciplinary records.VERIFIEDStone v. City of Claremont, 176 N.H. 477 (2024), cited at Petition ¶ 41; holding described consistently in ACLU-NH’s public case summaries.
14State Police told the ACLU in December 2025 it had not disseminated training materials outside the online portal.VERIFIEDPetition ¶ 36, quoting the agency’s December 17, 2025 email.
Have a document, a tip, or a correction?
Reach the editor directly — confidentiality respected where possible.
granitestatereport@gmail.com · (603) 931-9264
Sources. Primary: American Civil Liberties Union of New Hampshire v. New Hampshire Department of Safety, Division of State Police, No. 217-2026-CV-006502 (Merrimack Cty. Super. Ct., filed Aug. 25, 2026); RSA 91-A:4, New Hampshire General Court; ACLU-NH case index. Secondary: New Hampshire Bulletin, “New Hampshire’s right-to-know ombudsman position has been vacant for a year,” July 2, 2026; Concord Monitor, March 20, 2026; Keene Sentinel, August 2026 (Rindge PD 287(g) agreement); Valley News, July 21, 2026 (Carroll PD federal funding); Boston Globe, Sept. 12, 2025 (trooper nominations).

Editor’s note. Every factual claim above was checked against a primary source or an identified publication before release; see the fact-check table. Allegations drawn from the ACLU’s petition are marked ATTRIBUTED and are the petitioner’s contentions, not findings of a court. The New Hampshire Department of Safety and the Division of State Police have not filed a response in this case and have not answered these allegations publicly. Corrections: Granite State Report corrects verified errors promptly and appends a dated note identifying what changed and when. The corrections policy and the corrections register are public, and correction notes are never removed.

Granite State Report · Northfield, New Hampshire · granitestatereport.com
Board