Independent New Hampshire Journalism · Northfield, NH
Robert Greene’s twenty-eighth law says to enter action with boldness, because hesitation infects everything after it. New Hampshire’s primary has rewarded that nerve in both parties. It has also shown that a bold move with nothing behind it goes nowhere.
In February 1975, a former Georgia governor most of the country had never heard of sat in a Concord living room and talked to 16 people. The house belonged to Thomas W. Gerber, editor of the Concord Monitor, the paper recounted half a century later. Back home, Atlanta’s largest newspaper had greeted his campaign with a mocking headline, “Jimmy Who?” A year later, Jimmy Carter won the New Hampshire primary.
Thirteen years after that, Vice President George H. W. Bush arrived in New Hampshire after finishing third in Iowa, a result he called “a humiliation,” Time reported. Days before the vote, he approved a television ad his own advisers had argued over for days. They called it “Senator Straddle.” It took every slot his campaign could buy on Manchester’s Channel 9, and Bush won by about nine points.
Robert Greene’s twenty-eighth law says to enter action with boldness: hesitation spreads to everything that follows, and a bold move covers mistakes that a timid one exposes. New Hampshire’s primary has tested that law from both parties. Carter in 1976 and Bush in 1988 each moved harder and earlier than the field expected, and each won the state on the way to the presidency. The record also shows the limit. Boldness paid when a campaign, a base and a plan stood behind it, and a bold move with nothing under it got almost nothing.
The stage
New Hampshire rewards candidates who show up in person and early. John H. Sununu, who was governor in 1988 and chaired Bush’s campaign in the state, described the method in a 2000 oral history for the University of Virginia’s Miller Center. He called it “see me, touch me, feel me”: breakfasts, town meetings, mall visits and trips to small towns in the snow. He also gave the interview a line about the state’s place in the calendar: “Iowa picks corn, New Hampshire picks Presidents.”
That kind of state has a low tolerance for a candidate who waits to see how things break. It also keeps a rule that matters for this law. A campaign that hits hard on television in New Hampshire today has to put its name on the hit.
Greene’s law, as summaries of the book put it, asks for decisive action and says that when you err, you correct it with even more boldness. In New Hampshire that advice runs into a small electorate that meets candidates face to face, decides late and expects to be asked. The two campaigns below show what boldness looks like under those conditions.
Jimmy Who, 1975 and 1976
Carter was not the first Democrat into the 1976 race. Morris Udall announced on Nov. 23, 1974. Carter followed on Dec. 12, according to Dartmouth College’s history of the primary. What set Carter apart was how soon and how often he came, and what he asked of himself while he did it.
His New Hampshire campaign ran from February 1975 to primary day, the Monitor found in its archives, and he came to Concord at least seven times. In May 1975 he opened a New England headquarters at 20 Pleasant St., with about 50 supporters on hand. The campaign had little money. Through the summer and fall of 1975 Carter slept in supporters’ homes instead of hotels. A Monitor columnist wrote that December that a few months earlier, Carter had been seen “by almost nobody as a serious contender.” He courted the state’s institutions as well. He told the state Senate that politicians “underestimate the people they are elected to represent.”
Bill Shaheen, who co-chaired Carter’s New Hampshire campaign, later described how the candidate worked: he “kind of just runs under the radar,” meeting people one at a time. The campaign then made its boldest move. In January 1976, weeks before the primary, almost a hundred Georgians chartered a plane and flew north to knock on doors in the dead of winter, according to the Jimmy Carter Presidential Library. They stayed a week.
Each canvasser carried a kit with literature, buttons, maps and a “door-to-door procedures sheet.” The instruction from the leaders was blunt: “You must be on the streets when the voters are home.” When nobody answered, they left handwritten notes praising Carter as Georgia’s governor and a future president. Their organizer, Dot Padgett of Douglasville, Ga., told Georgia Public Broadcasting the plan was simple: send “a plane full of Georgians to New Hampshire.” The volunteers came to be known as the Peanut Brigade. A voter who could not follow one volunteer’s Southern accent still took the brochure, Padgett recalled.
The night before the vote, a fire at an energy substation knocked out power across central New Hampshire, and Carter’s press secretary, Brad Woodward, worked alone in the dark Pleasant Street office, the Monitor recounted. On Feb. 24, 1976, Carter won with 28.4 percent. Udall had 22.7, Birch Bayh 15.2, Fred Harris 10.8 and Sargent Shriver 8.2, Dartmouth’s history records. Carter narrowly lost Concord to Udall and still carried the state easily, the Monitor reported. On election night he looked back to the start: “I remember when we couldn’t find a microphone.”

Carter became the Democratic nominee and defeated President Gerald R. Ford that November, Encyclopaedia Britannica records. The man who started in a living room with 16 people ended in the White House.
Senator Straddle, 1988
Bush came to New Hampshire in 1988 in trouble. Sen. Bob Dole of Kansas had won Iowa. The Rev. Pat Robertson finished second. Bush, who had won Iowa eight years earlier, came in third, Time reported, and Dole also picked up the endorsement of Alexander Haig. Haig had shared the Republican debate stage at Dartmouth with both men in January.
Sununu’s answer was more contact. By his account, the campaign held a New Year’s Eve hot chocolate event in Concord, packed breakfasts at Wendy’s and McDonald’s, and put Bush in a 12-wheeler truck. It sent him north into the snow for a rally in Wolfeboro. Sununu credits the north country with the margin.
The decisive move came on television. Roger Ailes, Bush’s media adviser, brought in an ad that showed a stern-faced Dole switching positions, above all on taxes, Time reported in its 1988 account of the campaign. Campaign manager Lee Atwater wanted it on the air. Nicholas Brady and Robert Mosbacher objected, citing President Reagan’s informal rule against attacking fellow Republicans, and Bush at first sided with them. Atwater told Bush the race was tied and that only the ad would put him ahead. Barbara Bush backed the ad. Sununu told Bush that New Hampshire voters could handle it.
Bush said yes late on a Friday, Sununu recalled, after the stations had closed their books for the weekend. Sununu called David Zamatch, general manager of Channel 9 in Manchester, and asked him to reopen them. Within hours, Time reported, the campaign had bought every available 30-second spot through primary day.
Dole’s campaign moved the other way. At a strategy session the Wednesday before the vote, Time reported, it decided not to run negative ads. When it tried to answer over the weekend, it could not produce a new ad in time. When it tried to run an older one, the slots were already gone.
On Feb. 16, 1988, Bush won with 38 percent, 54,915 votes. Dole had 29 percent, 41,746 votes. Jack Kemp had 13 percent, Pete du Pont 10 and Robertson 10, by The Associated Press count with 99 percent of precincts in. Dole’s reaction that night was blunt: “Stop lying about my record,” UPI reported. Bush told supporters that reports of his political death had been greatly exaggerated.

Bush took the Republican nomination, Dartmouth’s history notes, and defeated Michael Dukakis that November, according to Britannica. Dukakis had won New Hampshire’s Democratic primary the same night with 37 percent.
The bold move that went nowhere
The same 1988 ballot holds the case against reading too much into boldness. Gary Hart had dropped out of the Democratic race. He came back into it in December 1987, Dartmouth’s history records, weeks before the voting began. It was as bold an entry as any in the field. In New Hampshire he drew 4 percent, 4,549 votes, behind six other candidates, by the AP count.
Hart’s return had nerve and nothing under it. Carter’s early start had a year of living rooms and a planeload of volunteers. Bush’s ad had a governor who could reopen a station’s books on a Friday night and a ground campaign that had already spent weeks in diners and truck cabs. Boldness magnified what each campaign already had. For Hart, there was little to magnify.
A fair objection
The first objection is that neither winner was bold in the way Greene’s law imagines. Bush resisted the Straddle ad. His advisers split, his wife weighed in, and he said yes only when told the race was tied. Atwater later played down the genius of it: “It wasn’t because we were geniuses or anything,” he told Time. That is fair. But Greene’s law is about the moment of action, not the debate before it. Once Bush decided, his campaign bought every slot it could. Once Dole decided, his campaign held back.
The second objection is that Carter won with 28.4 percent. The four candidates behind him combined for 56.9 percent. A split field helped him as much as his early start did. That is also fair, and it is the reason this piece does not credit boldness alone. Carter’s boldness put him in front of a field that had not yet settled on anyone, and in New Hampshire that was enough.
The third objection belongs to Dole. Choosing not to go negative is not timidity. Attack ads carry costs, and a campaign can lose a state and keep its dignity. The record does not say Dole was wrong to hold back. It says what holding back cost him in a race that turned in its last four days.
The verdict
Greene’s twenty-eighth law holds in New Hampshire with a condition attached. The state rewards the candidate who moves first and moves hard, in person and on the air, and it punishes the one who waits to see how a weekend breaks. Carter and Bush both proved it, and both went on to the White House. Hart proved the condition. Boldness without a base drew 4 percent.
New Hampshire’s own law adds one more rule. Any campaign bold enough to run an attack ad here today must sign it, out loud and on screen. The state lets candidates be bold. It requires them to own it.
The series has moved from the following to the first move. Part Twenty-Seven showed crusades that belief carried through the state and no further. Part Twenty-Six showed operations built so the person at the top could stay clean. Part Twenty-Eight shows what happens when a candidate stops waiting, and what has to be in place for that to work.
Next: Law 29, on planning all the way to the end, tested against the New Hampshire record.
Fact check
| # | Claim | Status | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Carter’s first New Hampshire visit, February 1975, at the home of Monitor editor Thomas W. Gerber, 16 people; at least seven Concord visits; New England headquarters at 20 Pleasant St. in May 1975 with about 50 supporters; stayed in supporters’ homes in summer and fall 1975; December columnist’s “by almost nobody as a serious contender”; Carter’s remark to the state Senate; eve-of-primary substation fire and outage, with press secretary Brad Woodward alone at the office; Bill Shaheen co-chair quote; narrowly lost Concord to Udall; “I remember when we couldn’t find a microphone” | ATTRIBUTED | Jeremy Margolis, Concord Monitor, Jan. 6, 2025 |
| 2 | Atlanta’s largest newspaper ran the headline “Jimmy Who?”; Carter announced in late 1974 as a little-known governor | ATTRIBUTED | WABE (Atlanta), “Jimmy Carter: White House rise depended on twists before ’76” |
| 3 | Udall announced Nov. 23, Carter Dec. 12; Feb. 24, 1976 results: Carter 28.4, Udall 22.7, Bayh 15.2, Harris 10.8, Shriver 8.2 | ATTRIBUTED | Dartmouth College, “1976 Presidential Primaries at Dartmouth College” |
| 4 | In January 1976 almost a hundred Georgians chartered a plane to New Hampshire, canvassed door to door for a week, carried kits with a “door-to-door procedures sheet” and left handwritten notes praising Carter as governor; “You must be on the streets when the voters are home” | ATTRIBUTED | Jimmy Carter Presidential Library and Museum, “Jimmy Carter, the Peanut Brigade, and the ’76 Democratic Primaries” (Google Arts & Culture) |
| 5 | Dot Padgett of Douglasville organized the trip; “a plane full of Georgians”; the accent anecdote | ATTRIBUTED | Orlando Montoya, Georgia Public Broadcasting, April 9, 2024 |
| 6 | Carter was the 1976 Democratic nominee and defeated Ford; Bush defeated Dukakis in 1988 | ATTRIBUTED | Encyclopaedia Britannica, “United States presidential election of 1976” and “of 1988” |
| 7 | Iowa 1988: Dole first, Robertson second, Bush third after winning Iowa in 1980; “a humiliation”; Haig endorsed Dole; Ailes’s ad showed a stern-faced Dole switching positions, especially on taxes; Atwater for it; Brady and Mosbacher against, citing Reagan’s informal rule; Bush first sided with them; Atwater’s tied-race argument; Barbara Bush backed it; Sununu said voters could handle it; every available 30-second spot bought through primary day; Dole’s Wednesday decision against negative ads; no new ad in time and older ad’s slots sold; Atwater’s “geniuses” quote | ATTRIBUTED | Richard Stengel, “Nine Key Moments,” Time, Nov. 21, 1988 |
| 8 | “See me, touch me, feel me”; “Iowa picks corn, New Hampshire picks Presidents”; New Year’s Eve hot chocolate in Concord, Wendy’s and McDonald’s breakfasts, a 12-wheeler, Wolfeboro rally, north country margin; decision late Friday after stations closed their books; call to Channel 9 general manager David Zamatch to reopen them | ATTRIBUTED | John H. Sununu Oral History, Miller Center, University of Virginia, June 8 and 9, 2000 (his recollection) |
| 9 | Feb. 16, 1988 Republican results with 99 percent in: Bush 38 percent, 54,915; Dole 29, 41,746; Kemp 13; du Pont 10; Robertson 10. Democratic: Dukakis 37 percent; Hart 4 percent, 4,549 votes, seventh of seven named | ATTRIBUTED | The Associated Press, in The Harvard Crimson, Feb. 17, 1988 |
| 10 | “Stop lying about my record”; Bush’s Mark Twain line about reports of his death | ATTRIBUTED | Matthew C. Quinn, UPI, Feb. 16, 1988 |
| 11 | Dukakis won New Hampshire and the nomination; Bush captured the Republican nomination; Hart returned to the race in December 1987; Bush, Dole and Haig were among the participants in the Jan. 16, 1988 Republican debate at Dartmouth | ATTRIBUTED | Dartmouth College, “1988: Presidency in the 200th Year of the Constitution” |
| 12 | Bush’s margin of about 13,000 votes (54,915 minus 41,746 is 13,169); the four candidates behind Carter combined for 56.9 percent (22.7 + 15.2 + 10.8 + 8.2) | VERIFIED | Arithmetic on rows 3 and 9 |
| 13 | RSA 664:14: all political advertising must be signed; TV and internet ads must identify the paying candidate aurally and visually, in letters at least 12 percent of picture height, for at least four seconds at the end; source note from 1979 through 2024, effective Jan. 1, 2025 | VERIFIED | gc.nh.gov, RSA 664:14 |
| 14 | Featured photograph: a steam train on the Mount Washington Cog Railway, Carol M. Highsmith, LC-DIG-highsm-15567, no known restrictions | VERIFIED | Library of Congress catalog record 2011633760 |
| 15 | Robert Greene’s Law 28 is “Enter Action with Boldness,” from The 48 Laws of Power, Viking, 1998; summary: act decisively and correct errors with more boldness | VERIFIED | Published table of contents; Shortform summary |
| 16 | GSR Power Index scores for Laws 1 through 28 | EDITORIAL | Granite State Report’s own rating, not a measurement. Method stated in the chart |
Your voice
Poll. What should matter most when you size up a New Hampshire primary candidate?
How early and often they show up in person · How hard they draw contrasts with rivals · Their record and plans · Who is working for them here
Survey: the candidate who came to you. Five questions: your town; whether you have met a presidential candidate in person in New Hampshire; who and about what year; where it happened; and whether it changed your vote. Granite State Report asks before using your name or story.
Discuss. Is a late attack ad a bold move or a cheap one when the other side has no time to answer? And does New Hampshire still reward the candidate who comes early and often, or has television and the internet ended that?
Verified New Hampshire residents vote and answer at granitestatereport.com. Or write to granitestatereport@gmail.com with your town in the subject line.
Granite State Report wants to hear from volunteers, staff and voters on any side of any New Hampshire primary. granitestatereport@gmail.com, 603-931-9264. Confidentiality on request.
Editor’s note: Commentary and analysis, not legal advice. The statute was read directly. Accounts of both campaigns come from contemporary and later reporting and from Sununu’s own recollection, and are attributed. Time and Sununu describe the ad decision in slightly different terms; the piece uses each for what it reports. The Secretary of State’s results database could not be read for this piece. The GSR Power Index is editorial, not data.

