Sunday, 15 November 2026
Trending
CourtsJobs in the Law

The Prosecutor’s Job in New Hampshire: Who Charges You, and Who Answers for It

An illustrated call for fairness, transparency, and ethical prosecution in New Hampshire.
Independent New Hampshire Journalism · Northfield, NH
Jobs in the Law · Courts & Prosecution
The Prosecutor’s Job in New Hampshire: Who Charges You, and Who Answers for It

One office decides whether you are charged, with what, and whether you are offered a deal. New Hampshire splits that power three ways, and only one of the three answers to voters.

Loading the Elevenlabs Text to Speech AudioNative Player...

Correction, Sept. 22, 2026, 8:07 a.m. EDT: This article said three counties, including Grafton, set no limit on their county attorney’s private practice. RSA 7:34-h, effective June 5, 2026, bars it in Grafton; only Hillsborough and Merrimack have no limit. Text and row 18 corrected.

The most consequential decision in a criminal case is made before any judge reads the file. Someone opens a police report and decides whether you get charged, what you get charged with, and what will be offered to make it go away. The New Hampshire Supreme Court has put that bluntly: prosecutors, it held in State v. Smith in 2020, “possess the sole authority to decide whether and whom to charge.” No judge signs off first. No jury reviews it. The charge exists because a prosecutor decided it should.

New Hampshire runs that power through three tiers. The Attorney General’s office takes murder and supervises everything else. Ten elected county attorneys take every other felony. And in the circuit courts, where most Granite Staters meet the criminal system for the first time, the prosecutor is frequently a police officer who never went to law school.

County attorney was on the filing sheet at the State House in June, alongside sheriff and county commissioner. The 2026 primary was September 8 and the general election November 3. Most voters fill in that oval, or leave it blank, without ever being told what the job is. So here is the job.

The attorney general takes the worst cases — and watches the rest

RSA 7:6 gives the attorney general two distinct powers. The first is direct: the office prosecutes people accused of crimes punishable by death or life imprisonment. In practice that means homicide. County websites across the state say the same thing in the same words, that murder cases belong to the attorney general alone.

The second power is supervisory, and it is the one nobody campaigns on. The same section gives the attorney general general supervision of criminal cases pending in the superior and supreme courts, and says the state’s criminal laws are enforced by the attorney general with the aid of the county attorneys. RSA 7:11 finishes the thought: any officer enforcing criminal law is subject to the attorney general’s control whenever the attorney general chooses to exercise it.

RSA 7:6, 7:33 and 7:34 — the prosecution chain. RSA 7:6 assigns the attorney general capital and life-imprisonment prosecutions plus general supervision of criminal cases in the superior and supreme courts. RSA 7:33 requires each county to elect a county attorney who is a member of the New Hampshire bar. RSA 7:34 places every county attorney under the direction of the attorney general. Read RSA chapter 7 →

Inside the Department of Justice, the work sits in the Criminal Justice Bureau. Its Homicide Prosecution Unit picks up murder cases from the first call about a suspicious death and carries them through trial and appeal. Its Public Integrity Unit prosecutes criminal wrongdoing by state officials, including state law enforcement officers. Bureau attorneys also assist in investigations of police use of deadly force. The bureau runs the state Drug Task Force and handles financial crime, cybercrime and Medicaid fraud.

Read that list again. The office that reviews police shootings, prosecutes state officials, and decides which homicides get charged is appointed, not elected. The attorney general is nominated by the governor and confirmed by the Executive Council for a four-year term under RSA 21-M:3. John Formella was confirmed to a second term in September 2025. Nobody voted.

Ten county attorneys, elected and supervised at the same time

RSA 7:33 requires a county attorney in each of New Hampshire’s ten counties, elected biennially, who must be a member of the New Hampshire bar. Two counties are on a longer cycle: Rockingham moved to a four-year term beginning with the 2022 election, and Coos moved to a four-year term beginning with 2024.

These are the workhorse offices. In Belknap County, the office prosecutes felonies in superior court, runs the grand jury, handles misdemeanor and juvenile appeals from circuit court, advises and trains police departments on criminal investigations, and serves as the county’s civil lawyer under the direction of the commissioners. Multiply that by ten and you have most of the criminal prosecution in this state.

Here is the structural oddity. A county attorney is elected by the county’s voters, then placed by RSA 7:34 under the direction of the attorney general, who is appointed by the governor. The Supreme Court settled what that means in 1958 in Wyman v. Danais, reading RSA 7:6, 7:11 and 7:34 together to place ultimate responsibility for criminal law enforcement with the attorney general and to give that office power to control and direct the county attorneys where it sees a public interest in doing so.

It goes further than supervision. Under RSA 7:33-f, a county attorney cannot hire an assistant county attorney without the approval of both the county commissioners and the attorney general. An elected officer cannot staff their own office without a sign-off from an unelected one.

You elect a county attorney. The governor appoints the person who can overrule that county attorney, and who has to approve the hires.

In circuit court, your prosecutor might be a police officer

Felonies go to superior court. Violations and misdemeanors go to the circuit court’s district division, and that is where the overwhelming majority of criminal cases live: simple assault, shoplifting, driving while intoxicated, disorderly conduct, motor vehicle violations. A class A misdemeanor carries up to a year in jail.

Rule 42(a) of the New Hampshire Rules of Criminal Procedure says New Hampshire certified police officers who are not members of the state bar “may prosecute misdemeanors and violation offenses on behalf of the State” in the circuit court’s district division. The Judicial Branch’s own plain-language guide for defendants tells them the prosecutor may be an attorney or a police officer, and only rules out the officer who made the arrest.

Some departments hire lawyers for the work. In Laconia, Attorney James Sawyer serves as the police department’s prosecutor, handling misdemeanor and violation cases in the 4th Circuit district division and assisting the Belknap County Attorney’s Office and the attorney general on felonies arising in the city. Plenty of smaller departments use a sworn officer instead. Either way, the person across the courtroom from a defendant who cannot afford counsel is often employed by the same department that arrested them.

New Hampshire draws one line here, and it is worth knowing: the state does not permit private citizens to prosecute offenses punishable by imprisonment. That authority is public, and it is exclusive.

What the job requires after the charge

Charging is the start. A felony requires an indictment, which means presenting the case to a grand jury. Then comes discovery, plea negotiation, motions, trial, a sentencing recommendation, and the appeal. Rule 3.8 of the New Hampshire Rules of Professional Conduct opens by forbidding a prosecutor from pursuing a charge the prosecutor knows is not supported by probable cause.

The heaviest duty is disclosure. Under Brady v. Maryland and the state’s own 1995 decision in State v. Laurie, a prosecutor must hand over evidence favorable to the accused, including material that damages the credibility of a police witness. RSA 105:13-b requires that exculpatory evidence in the personnel file of an officer testifying in a criminal case be disclosed to the defendant, and makes that an ongoing duty that survives a guilty verdict.

The Exculpatory Evidence Schedule, the list most people still call the Laurie List, exists because that duty failed. Carl Laurie’s murder conviction was overturned after prosecutors did not turn over what was in a detective’s employment file. In 2020, in New Hampshire Center for Public Interest Journalism v. New Hampshire Department of Justice, the state Supreme Court held that the schedule is neither confidential under RSA 105:13-b nor shielded as an internal personnel practice. Every prosecutor in this state carries a disclosure obligation that the system had to be sued to make visible.

The caseload nobody wants to fund

The pay is public and the math is grim. Grafton County advertised an assistant county attorney position in October 2025 at $76,876.80 to $105,851.20, requiring a law degree and New Hampshire bar membership. That is the going rate for a lawyer who decides whether a neighbor goes to prison.

The workload is worse. In 2021, Belknap County Attorney Andrew Livernois told county commissioners his five attorneys were each carrying well over a hundred cases, one of them 164, against what he described as a state attorney general recommendation of 75 to 100. He put it plainly to the commissioners: “We’re not in a crisis … but we’re having to cut corners.” The delegation eventually funded one additional attorney, not the two he asked for.

Cutting corners in a prosecutor’s office is not an abstraction. It is a discovery obligation reviewed quickly, a plea offered because there is no time to try the case, or a file that sits until a witness stops answering the phone.

The hole the statute left open

Now the part that should be on a ballot question and never is.

RSA 7:6-d bars the attorney general, the deputy, and every attorney employed by the Department of Justice from private practice. Clean rule, one line, statewide.

County attorneys get no such uniform rule. Instead the legislature wrote eight separate sections, county by county, from 1977 to 2026. RSA 7:34-a prohibits private practice in Rockingham. RSA 7:34-b does it in Cheshire, 7:34-d in Sullivan, 7:34-e in Strafford, 7:34-f in Carroll, 7:34-g in Coos, and, since June 5, 2026, 7:34-h in Grafton. RSA 7:34-c restricts Belknap only from the private practice of criminal law and expressly permits private civil practice.

Count the counties. That leaves Hillsborough and Merrimack with no statutory restriction on their county attorney’s private practice at all — including Hillsborough, the state’s largest county, and Merrimack, which contains the State House, the Department of Justice, and the superior court where much of the state’s public business is litigated.

That is not an accusation against anyone currently holding those offices. It is a defect in the statute. The same job, with the same charging power, operates under three different conflict-of-interest regimes depending on which county delegation happened to ask the legislature for a bill. A rule that applies in Ossipee and not in Nashua is not a standard. It is an accident that nobody has bothered to fix, and fixing it would take a single sentence.

What to ask before November

If a candidate knocks on your door, or more likely if you have to go find them, three questions get you further than any mailer.

First: what is your diversion policy, who qualifies, and who gets turned down? That single policy decides whether a first offense becomes a record. Second: when an officer on the Exculpatory Evidence Schedule is a witness, what does your office disclose, and when? Third: how many open cases does each of your attorneys carry right now, and what will you ask the county delegation to fund?

A candidate who cannot answer those has not thought about the job. A candidate who will not answer them has, and would rather you did not know. Either way you have learned something the ballot will not tell you.

— Dexter Dow, Granite State Report

Your Turn

You tell me: Have you been through circuit court in New Hampshire? Who prosecuted your case, a lawyer or an officer? granitestatereport@gmail.com

Fact check

#ClaimStatusSource
1NH prosecutors hold sole authority to decide whether and whom to charge.VERIFIEDState v. Smith, 173 N.H. 115 (2020), as quoted in the NH Law Library guide to private prosecutions
2RSA 7:6 assigns the AG capital and life-imprisonment prosecutions and general supervision of criminal cases in the superior and supreme courts.VERIFIEDRSA 7:6, full text, NH General Court (gc.nh.gov)
3RSA 7:11 subjects any officer enforcing criminal law to the AG’s control at the AG’s discretion.VERIFIEDRSA 7:11, full text, NH General Court
4The Criminal Justice Bureau runs the Homicide Prosecution Unit and Public Integrity Unit and assists in police deadly-force investigations.VERIFIEDNH Department of Justice, Criminal Justice Bureau page
5The AG is appointed to a four-year term under RSA 21-M:3; John Formella was confirmed to a second term in September 2025.VERIFIEDRSA 21-M:3; Office of the Governor announcement, Sept. 17, 2025
6RSA 7:33 requires an NH bar member elected biennially as county attorney in each county; Rockingham moved to four-year terms from 2022 and Coos from 2024.VERIFIEDRSA 7:33, full text, NH General Court (2022, 283:1; 2024, 128:1)
7RSA 7:34 places county attorneys under the direction of the attorney general.VERIFIEDRSA 7:34, full text, NH General Court
8Wyman v. Danais, 101 N.H. 487 (1958), read RSA 7:6, 7:11 and 7:34 to place ultimate criminal-enforcement responsibility with the AG.VERIFIEDWyman v. Danais, 101 N.H. 487, 490 (1958)
9RSA 7:33-f requires AG and county commissioner approval for assistant county attorney appointments.VERIFIEDRSA 7:33-f, full text, NH General Court
10Non-lawyer certified police officers may prosecute misdemeanors and violations in the Circuit Court–District Division.VERIFIEDN.H. R. Crim. P. 42(a), NH Judicial Branch
11The Judicial Branch tells defendants the prosecutor may be an attorney or an officer, but not the arresting officer.VERIFIEDNH Judicial Branch, Circuit Court District Division criminal definitions page
12Attorney James Sawyer is the Laconia Police Department prosecutor and assists the Belknap County Attorney and the AG on felonies.VERIFIEDCity of Laconia, Prosecutor’s Office page
13Belknap County Attorney’s Office duties include felonies, grand jury, misdemeanor and juvenile appeals, police training, and county civil counsel.VERIFIEDBelknap County, County Attorney page
14RSA 105:13-b requires disclosure of exculpatory evidence in a testifying officer’s personnel file, as an ongoing duty past a guilty finding.VERIFIEDRSA 105:13-b, I, as quoted in the NH Supreme Court’s 2020 EES opinion
15The Supreme Court held in 2020 that the EES is neither confidential under RSA 105:13-b nor an internal personnel practice.VERIFIEDN.H. Center for Public Interest Journalism v. N.H. DOJ, 173 N.H. 648 (2020)
16Grafton County advertised an assistant county attorney position in Oct. 2025 at $76,876.80–$105,851.20.VERIFIEDGrafton County Attorney’s Office job posting, published Oct. 4, 2025
17In 2021 Belknap’s five prosecutors each carried well over 100 cases, one 164, against a stated AG recommendation of 75–100.ATTRIBUTEDLaconia Daily Sun reporting, Oct. and Dec. 2021, quoting County Attorney Andrew Livernois
18RSA 7:6-d bars private practice by the AG, deputy and all DOJ attorneys; RSA 7:34-a through 7:34-h cover eight counties, leaving Hillsborough and Merrimack unrestricted.VERIFIEDRSA 7:6-d and RSA 7:34-a to 7:34-h, full text, NH General Court
19NH candidate filing ran June 3–12, 2026 and included county attorney; primary Sept. 8, general Nov. 3.VERIFIEDNew Hampshire Public Radio, June 8, 2026 (updated June 12)
Have a document, a tip, or a correction?
Reach the editor directly — confidentiality respected where possible.
granitestatereport@gmail.com · (603) 931-9264
Sources. New Hampshire General Court, RSA chapter 7 (RSA 7:6, 7:6-d, 7:11, 7:33, 7:33-f, 7:34, 7:34-a through 7:34-h). New Hampshire Department of Justice, Criminal Justice Bureau. New Hampshire Public Radio, candidate filing period coverage, June 8, 2026. Also consulted: New Hampshire Judicial Branch, Rule 42 of the Rules of Criminal Procedure, Rule 3.8 of the Rules of Professional Conduct, and the Circuit Court district division criminal definitions page; the New Hampshire Law Library research guides on private prosecutions and the Exculpatory Evidence Schedule; New Hampshire Center for Public Interest Journalism v. New Hampshire Department of Justice, 173 N.H. 648 (2020); City of Laconia Prosecutor’s Office; Belknap County Attorney’s Office; Grafton County Attorney’s Office hiring notice; The Laconia Daily Sun; and the Secretary of State’s 2026 election details page. Earlier entries in the Jobs in the Law series covered the judge and the attorney general.

Editor’s note. Every factual claim above was checked against a primary source before publication; see the fact-check table. One row is marked ATTRIBUTED: the 2021 Belknap County caseload figures come from Laconia Daily Sun reporting and describe conditions in 2021, not today. Corrections: Granite State Report corrects verified errors promptly and appends a dated note identifying what changed and when. The corrections policy and the corrections register are public, and correction notes are never removed.

Granite State Report · Northfield, New Hampshire · granitestatereport.com
Board